• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

newbie prong collar questions

PandoraB

Hot Topics Subscriber
So I finally broke down and tried a prong collar for the first time today. I have been having a lot of pain in my arm which I think is coming from Luna's ridiculously strong pulling every time I have her on the leash and I'd finally had enough after trying everything else.

The pulling was quite a bit better with the prong but far from perfect. I actually borrowed a collar from a friend and had to take a couple of links out but I think the size is pretty good now.

The prongs have the black rubber caps on them. Does it make much of a difference if I take them off? Will she pull even less?

My goal is to use the prong to get the pulling under control and hopefully switch back to a regular collar when walking. I really want to be able to do a 10 km power walk with Luna a couple of times a week without getting my arm yanked off. She's still only 1 year old so I'm hoping part of her "enthusiasm" is due to her youthful exuberance.

Any other tips to avoid mistakes when you have never used a prong before would be greatly appreciated.

And shhhhhhhhhhhhh my trainer is very anti-prong so don't tell! lol
 
I've never used a prong with rubber caps on them. Sounds like something that they would ship in that you should take off. You can walk with both collars if you're coordinated enough, or you can link them together. Have the flat in one hand and the prong in the other, or tie/carbiner the flat to you so that if the prong comes apart, you have a collar on her.

Make sure it's up high and right at the top of her neck and doesn't slide down. For photos on fit try here: Leerburg Dog Training | How to Fit a Prong Collar

I personally like the smaller links as you get a better fit with them even on large dogs. My prong collar is old so doesn't have the center plate in the front, so I likely will be updating it.

When you correct give her a sharp pop (take and immediate release) to correct the behavior. The first couple times you use is, you should use the dead ring, then go to the live ring where you will find a more immediate response. Otherwise the leash should be loose. Change direction both ways, practice sitting and starting, and in general keep her mind going while you walk.

Don't use a flexi lead. Always use a regular 4-6' lead.

I'm not sure going back to a flat will necessarily be a good idea and you may not want to. Eventually you should be able to get to off lead with zero corrections. Even offlead when I took my dogs for walks (they had a short 12" leash attached) they wore their prong.

Also I found this:
 
Hey, me again with more evidence that we apparently own clones (but different gender...??)
We've never used those little prong covers (it kind of seems like it would defeat the purpose a bit)...I do have to think that they send a stronger message without them. The tips of the actual prongs are rounded anyway (on most) so it's not like it's really sharp.
Jax's prong collar constantly slips down his neck, so I stop a million times to move it up, but I still love it.
The smaller links are much easier to fit...I'm waiting on one now...still using the larger ones in the meantime.
My goal is to get Jax doing well on a flat collar as well, and we've made some (very tiny) progress in the last few weeks since we've been back at the trainer.
If you decide that you do want to go with that, tons of people recommend the Herm Sprenger (sp?).
 
The collar was slipping down her neck the whole time for me too @bomary. Maybe I need to take another link out? I will take off the rubber caps tomorrow and maybe try it with one less link too. Maybe I should also look at getting a collar with the smaller links.

Thanks! :)
 
The rubber tips have a use... I just forget what. My trainer suggested buying a set to use with my prong, since mine didn't come with them. I think it gives a little less of a bute, but also absolutely helps keep it in place, so it doesn't slide down the neck. I have the same problem with Mischa, but if I take another link out its way too tight. @AresMyDobie is my go to gal for prong questions lol
 
I never even thought of them holding it up better...I'll have to look into that, I guess. But I kind of think I'll be happier with the smaller prongs.
@MischasMomma ...same with Jax....either slipping or with another link out, too tight. Frustrating. I'll be happy to get my new one.
 
We have the small prong too lol it still slips. I'm pretty sure that's why my trainer suggested me buying the rubber tips
 
Doberman necks are hard to keep one up on so it's a matter of keeping the collar up manually from time to time. It's true that the smaller links are easier to adjust and fit to size, but the smallest HS I know of is 2.25 mm and that's what we have. You can get a micro-prong, but they can be harsher if you need more corrections.
 
That's what I ordered...the 2.25. I don't really have any problems with the larger one except for the slipping down. It's just that with this recall issue we are having, I want one that will stay up a bit better (maybe??) so that he can get far away from me on a long lead and not have it slip down every time.
I did look at the micro prong, but that doesn't look like something Jax would need. We will try this and see how it goes.
Once it slips just a bit down on that elegant "little" neck, it is gonna go all the way down!
 
A well fitted flat can help the collar stay up too. Dobermans do have a long neck and fine coat. I tried my old one on Nero (after taking out like 5 links) and it slid down or feels too tight. That's probably why people notice a prong on them vs on a gsd. I never had anyone say a thing to me about the prong on my gsd, but he had enough coat to hide the darn thing.

I hear you on the "anti-prong" laments too. :complain: Trying to convince my husband that a prong is a better training device and better for the dog than a flat collar is like smacking my head into a wall right now. :banghead: He thinks it'll rub and it's not needed if the dog listens. :wtf2: If the correction is more gentle despite the collar looking harsher, isn't that better? :speechless: I'm totally at a loss how he thinks it'll rub and cause our dog's neck to be rubbed raw. Like completely :censored: baffled. Apparently being more effective is being lazy somehow?! I was also being lazy because I was walking faster so Nero could do his light trot on our walk vs trying to walk, and then getting more keep his 4 month old mind on the job. I have to do more corrections this way just so that you can also walk in front of the dog but you don't want to walk faster? :pullhair:

Sorry off topic... just frustrated. Training a dog or horse or even another person means making it easy for them to figure it out and comply. Then when they figure it out, you can make it harder for them to do. Then the hard is easier. Why the heck would you start on hard setting? It makes zero sense! As my horse instructor in college said "Inch by Inch it's a cinch; Yard by Yard it's very hard."
 
A prong collar is a tool for training, it is not a miracle cure for pulling dogs. It is something that requires training to use. Yes there are some dogs that can have a prong put on and they immediately stop pulling, but not all dogs. Rubber caps on a prong are a waste, take them off. If the collar slips down but is too tight with one less prong than you may have to adjust it up the neck during training occasionally or even frequently. Training is the key, learn how to to use it or find someone who can help show you.
 
Rubber caps on a prong are a waste, take them off. If the collar slips down but is too tight with one less prong than you may have to adjust it up the neck during training occasionally or even frequently.

I just got off the phone with my trainer...you two might have said the EXACT same words!! She knows I've been worried about the fit and the slipping, and she said that the rubber tips are not the answer for that...
Being such a novice, I am gonna go with what's been working and also the word of Jax's trainer who has never steered me wrong (though I might not have as much follow-through as she'd like)!
 
Ive seen dogs pull the crap out of a prong. They get used to it, like any other collar and the owners just pull back. It can injure this way. People have sharpened the prongs and caused injury too. Its how you correct with a prong that makes it effective, but it certaining isnt a miracle cure. The pop allows an immediate correction and release. You may have to pop every step and then praise when theyre finally in the right spot. But the pop or quick jerk is more effective then pulling until they give imho, at least with a prong.
 
image.webp When my two see the prong collar come out they get excited to go out to work and walk. I keep a flat collar on too. I will use the prong for the work aspect before the walk then hook leash to flat collar. They respond well just having the prong on without it being used. They need very little correction unless of course a cat runs by or they see an Egret strolling down the street. Lol
I frequently adjust the prong because of slippage during their training/walks.
They are doing well on their down/stays.
 
Last edited:
Ive seen dogs pull the crap out of a prong. They get used to it, like any other collar and the owners just pull back. It can injure this way. People have sharpened the prongs and caused injury too. Its how you correct with a prong that makes it effective, but it certaining isnt a miracle cure. The pop allows an immediate correction and release. You may have to pop every step and then praise when theyre finally in the right spot. But the pop or quick jerk is more effective then pulling until they give imho, at least with a prong.

This is what has me on the fence with prongs. I've always gotten the same result with a choker. I have "handled" a lot of dogs over the years and with a little training never had a puller, except the GSD who we had to train to get to the front for showing.

Everything is in how you use it, but a quick pop with a choker, timed right has always got the job done. I understand the prong users say they can't cause damage and don't cause the pain a choker can, but I have no objection to a little pain so long as it is done right. It usually is a good deterrent.

Anything in the wrong hands can be brutal, even the softest snaffle.
 
These guys were my first to use a prong collar with and a first for the e collar. Both tools require very little use now. My trainer instructed me on both the prong and e collar uses.

Their useless barking has been curbed by 95% and they are much calmer after using the e collar correctly and I very seldom use it at all now. They wear it but it isn't turned on and they behave very well.
I never thought I could achieve this level of cooperation with a couple uses of the e collar.
Now that I have said this (I put the Goat's Mouth on it) watch them act like little twits. Lol
 
I'm not against a prong, and VERY for ecollars used correctly. I watched some people use one on a Weimaraner, and I was getting rather mad. They were using it for "sit" and the dog kept whining, it was like "sit".... " siiiitttt".... "Sit" zap. Three seconds later repeat. I felt bad for the dog.
 

Back
Top