How do you feel about this guys opinion on the modern Doberman?

At 2:03, comparing the IRS to why Louis Dobermann created the breed: "He made a dog to come get your shit" :spit:

Re the original breed being so monstrous that "you'd wear them to the hospital" :rofl: I can totally see it lol.

I love the "About the Breed" text that he read near the beginning - recognized it right away - it's from Animal Watch when they did a video on Dobermans, "...one of dogkind's noblemen..." just beautifully written, but if you hear the host say that out loud, even more impressive:

Our pup is a long way from being a sleek footstool, but she hasn’t eaten a neighbor yet.
:rofl:
This is the 'edge' that I think most modern pet homes are not interested in dealing with.
You are so right! But I think they still have too much edge for most tastes. When Kaiser was at Rally class and he would bark, people with their own dogs would look scared and step away 😦 And this was just Kaiser as a young pup - under 2 years old, so he was big in size, but still a pup. Unless you're in any dog sport that calls for barking, I'd say that most people don't even want a dog that barks at all - it's almost like saying the F word in polite company - a dog's bark can be THAT offensive.
Really, though, it might just be that infamous handsluttery that Dobes do so well. He LOVES to be touched.
Did Oji meet a lot of people as a young pup? We did that with Kaiser and I always figured that is why he loved schmoozing so much. In the past few years, we have significantly reduced his interactions with strangers and that has helped make him more aloof in public, but that may also be related to maturity. With a new pup, I would definitely not 'socialize' the same way that we did with K. I personally prefer the more aloof Doberman and I have seen/met some like that, so it is possible.
He's never quite understood wanting to do much more than a basic obedience class with a puppy and that's fine! That is most average dog owners, I think.
Right again. I wouldn't have guessed a dog would need anything more than just potty training and some basic commands 🙃 but then I got a Doberman and now here I am :pokeeyes:
 
Did Oji meet a lot of people as a young pup? We did that with Kaiser and I always figured that is why he loved schmoozing so much. In the past few years, we have significantly reduced his interactions with strangers and that has helped make him more aloof in public, but that may also be related to maturity. With a new pup, I would definitely not 'socialize' the same way that we did with K. I personally prefer the more aloof Doberman and I have seen/met some like that, so it is possible.
Good question. We socialized him to a fair extent when young. My policy has always been to let people pet him if they ask. That is the prevailing wisdom – to teach your dog to be friendly with people in non-threatening public situations, and in the home, so they won't get into fear biting (if that is in the individual dog's genetic makeup), and it also serves to make them confident.

Of course, the second half of the picture is training them in how to respond to threats. I unfortunately haven't had the resources to do that second half. So, as all of the people who I have introduced Oji to, or who have come over to our house, have been friendly, he would probably falter in an emergency as he lacks training and experience in what to do. Given his breed and his breeding, would his natural protective, defensive instincts kick in and save the day? That's the big question.

As for the handsluttery specifically, I'm happy that Dobes don't tend to get all wiggly and goofy in meeting people, but they sure love to be pet. So, Oji doesn't physically seek to go up to people in public, which is fantastic! But once I say the word indicating he is to physically interact with them, he makes contact. Then, he usually leans on them, but annoyingly, he almost always takes things too far and becomes a hyper pest, failing to repress that strong urge to jump up on people. He paws their legs/body and if unchecked it seems its culmination would be humping.
 
Then, he usually leans on them, but annoyingly, he almost always takes things too far and becomes a hyper pest,
Ugh, Kaiser does this too. He'll force the person to keep petting and when they keep giving in he will eventually lean into them until they lose their balance lol. The Dober lean applies a lot more pressure than anyone might expect! :rofl:
 
When I got my first 2 Dobies in 1984/5 the breed came with a reputation on both sides of the Atlantic. Some clients from the USA preferred not visit my London home for meetings because of their presence & when I walked the 2 together I regularly got anxious looks & the odd comment (“I bet you feel safe”..from a burley builder). Allegedly when they were originally being shown in the U.K. there were issues because of their reactivity & uk breeders deliberately worked to eliminate this. The response for the last decade has been more along the line of admiring glances & comments & “you don’t see many of those these days”. I suspect that this is largely because their reputation has been surpassed in more recent decades by other breeds & the fact that when tail docking was banned many U.K. breeders stopped breeding Dobermans, so there were in fact not so many around.(I was told a 50% reduction in KennelClub registrations). Theres also been a move towards smaller, more manageable breeds in the past couple of decade.
In the U.K. I don’t think that there‘s generally been a distinction made between show, & working lines & over the many years I’ve kept them, I havn‘t noticed any any great difference in mine other than those to be expected between individuals. All have shown the positive expected breed characteristic traits & my suspicion is that had I wanted any of them to be trained beyond their natural protective instincts, all would have responded well to it. Inside or out & about, their presence has alway made me feel safer. They have always responded as I’d expect to unannounced visitors to my property & also on the very rare occasions that they’ve thought to be threatening when out walking. Forty years on I still stand by the belief that …“it’d be fooish to pick a fight with someone on the other end of a leash from a Doberman”. :smile:
 

Back
Top