How do you feel about this guys opinion on the modern Doberman?

Cferg

Notable member

I came across these series of videos from “The jaded dog trainer” on Ray Allen’s YouTube page.
To boil it down the content creator feels the Doberman has been watered down from a real ass eater.
To a “sleek,muscular,ottoman”. What do you guys think?
 
He is 100% correct, you do not see many Dobermans these days that are breed correctly. It is sad but it is all about what he explains, people want the look but don’t want to do the work or training it takes to own one. Many Conformation breeders don’t want the crazy because it makes them more difficult to show in the ring. They put to much emphasis on looks and breed away from proper temperament. There are still a few that try to balance work and conformation but not many these days. Sad
 
Many Conformation breeders don’t want the crazy because it makes them more difficult to show in the ring.
Not saying I disagree with the general statement that the Doberman is different today than what it was in the past but I think it may be important to define what "crazy" means. I read crazy as nerve bag. A dog that is "spicy", strong willed, and has a lot of confidence is a huge part in what makes a great show dog (besides the conformation) and many look for those qualities when picking their show picks. There are people that try and drag the ones that don't want to be there along and you can see it in their behavior in the short time they are in the ring. I don't think judges are paying enough attention to behavior like they should. If a doberman is ever fearful, cowering, pissing at the presence of the judge (yes I've seen it), then it 100% needs to be excused. If you can see that kind of behavior in the limited amount of time they need to tolerate the ring that speaks a lot on their behavior. I believe it was Peggy Adamson who started excusing Dobermans from the ring who would not let her judge them.

A large issue I see is, it costs a lot of money to show. Talking thousands and thousands of dollars, way more than the dog was purchased for. You'll never make your money back with the first litter, probably not even in the second. I'm guessing it costs equal if not more money to train and trial in protection sports. Now add in time to do both. Years for an IGP1? Years for CH? If you're lucky, you could finish that CH before the age of 2 but it isn't the norm, 2-3 is the ideal sweet spot but I do see many in the 3-4 range, especially for a bitch. I think there are so few people that have AKC CH and IGP titled dobermans because not everyone has that kind of money or time!! It truly is a unicorn of a person to have both of those things. I think the next best thing we can do for ourselves is to work together and breed to those that offer what we don't have. Working people breeding their stock to show and vice versa. I'm afraid there is a stigma that comes with making the effort to do that though, from both sides. Neither want to touch the other in fear of it watering their looks or their working ability. So we continue to make the divide between the two even greater. Its a damn shame.

They put to much emphasis on looks and breed away from proper temperament.
And the opposite could be said about some working breeders. Too much emphasis on creating a dog that will pass an IGP trial (which I get, is the best we have but it wasn't created for a doberman) and not enough on conformation. Some conformation breeders put too much emphasis on breeding what wins and not breeding to standard. I agree but I think there are issues on both sides of the coin!
 
99% of the people that me and Stassi have interactions with out and about(if they are under say 40 years old). Is generally something like “I know someone who has a Doberman and they are so sweet and love everyone.” And I would say the 45-65 year old people give her a wide berth and don’t say anything and are afraid. And then for the 65-80 year old people, I believe their is a bit of nostalgia and they usually make the remark “you don’t see many dobies anymore” and then give her and me a compliment. I definitely can feel the respect they have for a Doberman.
I believe the older group of people grew up in a time where it was acceptable for a dog to have some aggression. And were probably told just to leave that dog alone by their parents.
 
I totally agree. With the video, with @Doberman Gang & with @Rits .

I can't remember what dog it was, back in the 1950's, GCH show dog & he bit several people, and I think a judge. Really set the show standards rallying to do something about the sharpness of our breed.

I think @Rits has an excellent point that each type now seems to be exclusive of each other. Hard to find a show dog with good hard nerve and hard to find a good hard nerved dog that allows a stranger to walk up and feel it's entire body including the testicles. And the hardest thing of all is to find a owner/handler who can train a dog to do & be both and a breeder who aims for that goal. So here we are.

I also think that the working Doberman has such a small gene pool now - even smaller than the dangerously small gene pool of the entire breed - because they try to avoid a "softer" dog in their breeding program - that the "crazy" has snowballed. I see those Devil Dogs in the marines and I have no doubt in my mind that those dogs as puppies did NOT whine, scream, have tantrums that would wake the neighbors etc etc. What happened here to a really good solid nerved dog?
 
Not saying I disagree with the general statement that the Doberman is different today than what it was in the past but I think it may be important to define what "crazy" means. I read crazy as nerve bag. A dog that is "spicy", strong willed, and has a lot of confidence is a huge part in what makes a great show dog (besides the conformation) and many look for those qualities when picking their show picks. There are people that try and drag the ones that don't want to be there along and you can see it in their behavior in the short time they are in the ring. I don't think judges are paying enough attention to behavior like they should. If a doberman is ever fearful, cowering, pissing at the presence of the judge (yes I've seen it), then it 100% needs to be excused. If you can see that kind of behavior in the limited amount of time they need to tolerate the ring that speaks a lot on their behavior. I believe it was Peggy Adamson who started excusing Dobermans from the ring who would not let her judge them.

A large issue I see is, it costs a lot of money to show. Talking thousands and thousands of dollars, way more than the dog was purchased for. You'll never make your money back with the first litter, probably not even in the second. I'm guessing it costs equal if not more money to train and trial in protection sports. Now add in time to do both. Years for an IGP1? Years for CH? If you're lucky, you could finish that CH before the age of 2 but it isn't the norm, 2-3 is the ideal sweet spot but I do see many in the 3-4 range, especially for a bitch. I think there are so few people that have AKC CH and IGP titled dobermans because not everyone has that kind of money or time!! It truly is a unicorn of a person to have both of those things. I think the next best thing we can do for ourselves is to work together and breed to those that offer what we don't have. Working people breeding their stock to show and vice versa. I'm afraid there is a stigma that comes with making the effort to do that though, from both sides. Neither want to touch the other in fear of it watering their looks or their working ability. So we continue to make the divide between the two even greater. Its a damn shame.


And the opposite could be said about some working breeders. Too much emphasis on creating a dog that will pass an IGP trial (which I get, is the best we have but it wasn't created for a doberman) and not enough on conformation. Some conformation breeders put too much emphasis on breeding what wins and not breeding to standard. I agree but I think there are issues on both sides of the coin!
Crazy is just the word some of my conformation friends have used when talking about trying to show a dog with proper drives. I think in the video it is an expression about why the dog was created. It wasn’t created to do IGP or do conformation. The AKC standard didn’t exist. Working breeders try to create dogs that will have the temperament and abilities to work, the AKC structure standard was made for how they believe the dog will look best. It does not create the best for performance, I have owned both and the dogs that I like would never win an AKC conformation title because of how they are built, they have more power, more speed and are more agile. I don’t want to make this about conformation vs. working because they are completely different dogs, the same goes for the dogs in Europe, working dogs there are completely different than the huge show dogs they produce. I think the guy in video was just expressing how the breed has changed from its original design. You can probably say that about most breeds.
 
The remark we hear most often, when out and about with our pup (after “She’s beautiful”) is “You don’t see many Dobermans anymore”. In most animals, the watering down of a breed comes from over breeding for profit or conformation, rather than focusing on the well rounded individual. We saw that in the evolution of the quarter horse. We had beautiful horses that were not able to work, and reining vs racing vs conformation horse gaps grew wider. These things evolve over time, both good and bad. Our pup is a long way from being a sleek footstool, but she hasn’t eaten a neighbor yet. There is always time.😊
 
I totally agree. With the video, with @Doberman Gang & with @Rits .

I can't remember what dog it was, back in the 1950's, GCH show dog & he bit several people, and I think a judge. Really set the show standards rallying to do something about the sharpness of our breed.

I think @Rits has an excellent point that each type now seems to be exclusive of each other. Hard to find a show dog with good hard nerve and hard to find a good hard nerved dog that allows a stranger to walk up and feel it's entire body including the testicles. And the hardest thing of all is to find a owner/handler who can train a dog to do & be both and a breeder who aims for that goal. So here we are.

I also think that the working Doberman has such a small gene pool now - even smaller than the dangerously small gene pool of the entire breed - because they try to avoid a "softer" dog in their breeding program - that the "crazy" has snowballed. I see those Devil Dogs in the marines and I have no doubt in my mind that those dogs as puppies did NOT whine, scream, have tantrums that would wake the neighbors etc etc. What happened here to a really good solid nerved dog?
I agree, part of the problem in the gene pool is any time a dog wins a big event, every breeder wants to breed to that dog, it’s bragging rights and what makes puppies more valuable.
 
I can understand what this guy is saying in the video…to a point. Times change and the world evolves to accommodate the needs and wants. That version of the Doberman is no longer needed/required in this world beyond the select that want to train it. Then you have to have the expertise, the skill, the time and the money to train it. Really reminds me of old school muscle car mechanics that can diagnose a Holley 850 double pumper carb just by listening to it- both expertise and wisdom are very hard to find.

My wife and I was just having this conversation of the necessity and purpose from Herr Doberman. We were talking about the contrasting characteristics of Freyja and Ragnar and what either one of them retained in their genes?.?….
- definitely the velcro
- the way they will check back on you with a nose bump to make sure you are okay
- the constant state of alertness
- the versatility
- the loyalty
- etc….

but neither definitely does not show the honed aggression or “monster” this video talks about…. its not needed in the common household. And if you did have this “monster” is a common household/neighborhood, it would be difficult to contain it.

I am glad the Doberman was “watered down” for if not, no way I would have the privilege of having one.
 
I can understand what this guy is saying in the video…to a point. Times change and the world evolves to accommodate the needs and wants. That version of the Doberman is no longer needed/required in this world beyond the select that want to train it. Then you have to have the expertise, the skill, the time and the money to train it. Really reminds me of old school muscle car mechanics that can diagnose a Holley 850 double pumper carb just by listening to it- both expertise and wisdom are very hard to find.

My wife and I was just having this conversation of the necessity and purpose from Herr Doberman. We were talking about the contrasting characteristics of Freyja and Ragnar and what either one of them retained in their genes?.?….
- definitely the velcro
- the way they will check back on you with a nose bump to make sure you are okay
- the constant state of alertness
- the versatility
- the loyalty
- etc….

but neither definitely does not show the honed aggression or “monster” this video talks about…. its not needed in the common household. And if you did have this “monster” is a common household/neighborhood, it would be difficult to contain it.

I am glad the Doberman was “watered down” for if not, no way I would have the privilege of having one.
I personally look at it this way: The doberman is the only dog bred as a personal protector. It does no good to be that if this dog can't live and function in the house with and beside the family.
 
I will try to watch the vid later, but going off your summary:

Certainly in the early days of the breed, like the early 20th century, the Dobermann tended to be what would be called "vicious" today. Skipping forward 1/2 century, I'd say the Dobe in America was still a sharper, dog more capable of its intended work than the Dobe in America today. Yes, the American confo. breeder, as well as the general public has softened down the Dobe quite a bit. As I've read it described in a number of books, the Doberman needs to be this way to exist in modern society (at least Western culture, and the U.S.)

This is why I have gone with a working-line Doberman for my last two. Going with a confo. breeder (and yes, certainly there are some fiery, capable cofo.-line Dobes) you stand a much greater chance of winding up with a Dobe that is just too soft and lacks courage. One more thing is the bite. Again, with exceptions, I say that most modern American Dobes have had the ability to full-mouth bite bred out of them. My first Dobe was a good example. I could not train him to full mouth bite. I tried pretty hard. Then, take my 2nd Dobe from working lines. He had that capability as a birthright. No training or encouragement needed. He would just launch forward and wedge his jaws around the article every time. It was an eye opener.

Last, I go with working-line because I have a great concern that I might wind up with not just a soft Dobe otherwise, but one that is verifiably shy or skittish. I can't have that.

This is not to say that working Dobe breeders are getting everything right. They are not. Just one aspect is the appearance of the Dobes that are bred for maximum performance on the field. They don't fit the standard, and are often rather ugly and not impressive looking.
 
Yeah, it's a hard discussion because we are all correct.

The GSD has a pet/show type, they have a working type and even a service dog type. And as mentioned, the Quarter Horse breed has a halter type (conformation), roping/cow/working type, and a flat-track racehorse type. Very, very few can do anything outside their specialty.

The breeds biggest problem is that the gene pool is so small that breeding leans mostly to an even smaller number of Grand Champion sires or IGP3 sires and is making that show pool and working pool tighter yet. But again, most people who want a couch ornament couldn't handle the spitfire of the working lines and the working dog people have already laughed way too many interested handlers out of the game because their dog wouldn't work.
 
The breeds biggest problem is that the gene pool is so small that breeding leans mostly to an even smaller number of Grand Champion sires or IGP3 sires and is making that show pool and working pool tighter yet. But again, most people who want a couch ornament couldn't handle the spitfire of the working lines and the working dog people have already laughed way too many interested handlers out of the game because their dog wouldn't work.

Sometimes we are our own worst enemy.
 
I've marinated on this a bit...

I will say my first two Dobermans were rescues and not from a Doberman specific rescue or anything; ASPCA (which I will never use again) and then another, smaller organization run by a woman and her husband using pet finder.

Neither of those dogs were 'well bred' in the sense that the Doberman standard and temperament was not the 'breeders' goal. No doubt, money was.

Rubie, my specifically and thoughtfully and intentionally bred Doberman, is VERY different than my first two rescues. She has an 'edge' that I would say I wasn't necessarily prepared for based on my previous two Dobermans. This is the 'edge' that I think most modern pet homes are not interested in dealing with. Do we, specifically, need a Doberman with edge for guarding purposes? Definitely not. Am I glad that we can give her everything she needs? Absolutely.

We've discussed whether we would get another Doberman in the future. Rubie is not 'easy' in some ways and we do have to accommodate that. I am always happy to make sure she's living her best life and set-up for success but, of course, it is more work. Is it then fair for me to go to a Doberman breeder and say "I want a Moose in a Rubie body?" because there are aspects about Dobermans that I absolutely love? Of course not.

I would assume it's a complicated consideration for breeders of many dog breeds in which the original purpose of the breed isn't what people of today need. To keep the breed going, more dogs must be bred (and of course, I'm talking about reputable breeders and their sparse litters) and homed. Should Doberman puppies go only to tax collectors, Daschund's to badger hunters, Huskies to people who live in the artic circle with a sled, Great Pyrenees to shepherds, etc.? Are people still using those dogs for those purposes; of course! But a very passionate few, considering, I would venture. Of course the irony... is that field and working Labs and Dobermans, respectively, are very different than conformation Labs and Dobermans (my example cuz that's what I know)!

Seems like a very philosophical discussion :D
 
I spent so much time trying to be accurate with my thoughts and missed something!

When I say Rubie's 'edge,' I mean the Doberman specific intent to: guard, not trust strangers, be suspicious, act first and ask questions later, be loud and confident, and a general lack of self preservation. :rolleyes:
 
I would assume it's a complicated consideration for breeders of many dog breeds in which the original purpose of the breed isn't what people of today need. To keep the breed going, more dogs must be bred (and of course, I'm talking about reputable breeders and their sparse litters) and homed. Should Doberman puppies go only to tax collectors, Daschund's to badger hunters, Huskies to people who live in the artic circle with a sled, Great Pyrenees to shepherds, etc.? Are people still using those dogs for those purposes; of course! But a very passionate few, considering, I would venture. Of course the irony... is that field and working Labs and Dobermans, respectively, are very different than conformation Labs and Dobermans (my example cuz that's what I know)!
Your entire comment was great, but I'm quoting just this paragraph because I have something to say about the two main ideas in them.

I know you were stating things succinctly when you wrote "tax collectors," and I understand what you mean; but I'd say the pool of buyers/owners who want a Dobe with sufficient hardness, drive and sharpness to be an effective guard is decently broad. I am in that pool. I want a Dobe that has what it takes upstairs to face an aggressive intruder or attacker wielding a weapon. I want the dog to not have had an effective bite bred out of him. I hope that at least 1/2 of Dobe owners and seekers want the dog to actually protect. I know there are, unfortunately, many who want a Dobe to just be a sweet friendly dog though, and don't want it to be a guard dog. I hope I don't offend you by saying that, as I see you said you don't need a protective dog.

So what do we have here? I'd say that many Dobes are presenting a fairly good package, really. Take Oji. He seems to possess the necessary hardness and courage and sharpness to effectively protect; yet he also possesses that almost universal Doberman sweetness and actual affection for people. Really, though, it might just be that infamous handsluttery that Dobes do so well. He LOVES to be touched. So, he has a pretty nice on/off switch. If I had actually extensively protection trained him, I think he'd be great at it. As it is, he alerts in stellar fashion like almost all Dobes do, and he has it in him to go not back down.

I think I am rambling a bit here as I'm quickly typing out thoughts before I need to go up and tuck in daughter; but if we could somehow breed out of the Doberman the excessive whining, and in Oji's case, the extreme obsession with animals and the extreme barking that comes along with it, I'd say we're getting it pretty right with him. Oh, and we could get rid of the separation anxiety and thunder storm anxiety - please!

As for conformation: Yes! That is a glaring point I've realized for a long time now, how the ones from performance lines don't measure up to the conformational standard!

(I'm not going to proofread this)
 
Of course the irony... is that field and working Labs and Dobermans, respectively, are very different than conformation Labs and Dobermans (my example cuz that's what I know)!
Love everything you mentioned and I'm going to add on to this comment: Until recently I never even knew about a working Lab and omg, they are nothing like the popular "Moos" that I've known. I love Moo, so don't take that wrong! Just that I was so surprised to see the opposite of the couch potato Lab. These dogs were quick, active to a fault, athletic, skinny, and movers & shakers. First I had to ask what breed it was, then I said out loud: "I didn't know they made Labs like that" :rofl: So yeah, same breed but in name only. There's a 17 mo. old working lab in our SAR obedience and this little pup gives every working dog in the club a run for their money. She bites a tug back to her tonsils and has no quit. If you want an athlete with boundless energy but no suspicion or defensive behavior you'd love a working lab! I totally agree, it's a pain to constantly manage the "edge" when in public.

Since it's pretty much already been decided by the last 50 years of breeding, I'd say it's going to have to be OK to have two types of Dobermans - because we obviously do. Show/pet lines and working lines. I think the biggest problem is the idea of the ideal dog, is not ideal for everyone! Wanting a true hard dog, I did lots of research and didn't compromise when searching for what I wanted in a Doberman. I got way more than I bargained for, but in the end Asha was everything I wanted, but I'd not recommend her type to many people at all. On the other hand you and @Rits, just for example, have good kind dogs with that edge that everyone thinks they want, but solid training and management has made Rubie and Ripley stellar companions. How would they have turned out in pet homes with little training and even less discipline? Just thoughts. To me they are perfect examples of what a good Doberman is, in the right hands, but possibly still too much for some pet homes?
 
but if we could somehow breed out of the Doberman the excessive whining, and in Oji's case, the extreme obsession with animals and the extreme barking that comes along with it, I'd say we're getting it pretty right with him. Oh, and we could get rid of the separation anxiety and thunder storm anxiety - please!
I'm with you on this. The whining especially!!! It's insane. And the super-duper extra heavy Velcro could go too, if I had my way about it. Mine is fine in the house, no destruction or anything when I leave her, but I have no idea how much whining or howling might happen. She does whine & howl if I leave her in the yard and go to the neighbors - but she sees me walk off, so she knows where I'm going. If she explodes or obsesses over a squirrel while in the house I just put her on her mat in a down stay and make her chill, so that's trainable in my opinion. The other stuff I'm afraid is pretty tough to deal with.
 
Love everything you mentioned and I'm going to add on to this comment: Until recently I never even knew about a working Lab and omg, they are nothing like the popular "Moos" that I've known. I love Moo, so don't take that wrong! Just that I was so surprised to see the opposite of the couch potato Lab. These dogs were quick, active to a fault, athletic, skinny, and movers & shakers. First I had to ask what breed it was, then I said out loud: "I didn't know they made Labs like that" :rofl: So yeah, same breed but in name only. There's a 17 mo. old working lab in our SAR obedience and this little pup gives every working dog in the club a run for their money. She bites a tug back to her tonsils and has no quit. If you want an athlete with boundless energy but no suspicion or defensive behavior you'd love a working lab! I totally agree, it's a pain to constantly manage the "edge" when in public.

Not taken wrong at all! I've said it before... I was not excited about getting a Lab because I hadn't really met one that I was impressed with. Any I'd met were usually overweight with minimum training. And I get it, Labs are generally 'good' with little effort which is probably why they're the most popular breed over and over again.

But because Moo was raised with the same expectations, boundaries, and lifestyle as Rubie, he's a delightful and fit (for an English) Lab! He's also got a temperament that allows him to participate in more activities than Rubie and that is not Rubie or our fault; it's just her design.

While I'm not opposed to more of a working style Lab, I think it would be more effort than my husband would want to put in :D He's never quite understood wanting to do much more than a basic obedience class with a puppy and that's fine! That is most average dog owners, I think. There is a lady I've crossed paths with a couple of times at Fast CAT events who has multiple working labs. She is self taught in all things field work and competition and trains all her dogs herself. Those labs run upwards of 26-28 MPH at Fast CAT events! They are a marvel to watch, for sure but they definitely have that look in their eye... the WHAT'S NEXT factor.

Since it's pretty much already been decided by the last 50 years of breeding, I'd say it's going to have to be OK to have two types of Dobermans - because we obviously do. Show/pet lines and working lines. I think the biggest problem is the idea of the ideal dog, is not ideal for everyone! Wanting a true hard dog, I did lots of research and didn't compromise when searching for what I wanted in a Doberman. I got way more than I bargained for, but in the end Asha was everything I wanted, but I'd not recommend her type to many people at all. On the other hand you and @Rits, just for example, have good kind dogs with that edge that everyone thinks they want, but solid training and management has made Rubie and Ripley stellar companions. How would they have turned out in pet homes with little training and even less discipline? Just thoughts. To me they are perfect examples of what a good Doberman is, in the right hands, but possibly still too much for some pet homes?

Aw shucks, you're making me blush! :love: I hope we've done well by Rubie. She's taught us a lot and I would certainly do some things differently if I could do it all over again, but overall, I do think she's a great example of not an ottoman, not a tax collectors guard dog, but somewhere in between. Perhaps, yes, a bit too much for the 'average' pet household but that's not saying that we're much more than that or anything above average. Our options were to learn or to have an out of control dog :)

I think Asha is exactly the dog you didn't know you needed and how lucky for her that you two found each other! The versatility of Dobermans is truly something I adore about the breed and it's demonstrated time and time again with everything people on this forum do with their dogs.
 

Back
Top