Gots me another...

I'm sorry, but that's a very irresponsible attitude. Some dogs just ARE dog aggressive. They can learn to be respectful of other dogs out in public, as long as there is some distance. But, especially in the Doberman breed, having the idea that they "just have to learn to be ok" is a recipe for disaster. This attitude may lead to a fatal dog fight. I, too, am shocked that a rescue would place a dog that's shown aggression to another dog in a home that has a dog of the same sex. That's completely irresponsible. Our rescue does have a few homes that are very experienced, and have very laid back males, and we occasionally will place a male in those homes. We would NEVER do that with someone inexperienced, and definitely not with a foster that has been dog aggressive. I sincerely hope this does not end in tragedy.

It won't. Cody definitely isn't aggressive. He was showing dominance. After a few corrections, Cody stopped growling and snarling at Linus and puts up with him (if he's on a leash). I spoke to my trainer and she recommended a muzzle for now, one so he can still drink, breath, etc. But he won't be able to bite myself or Linus. He will keep this muzzle on until I'm comfortable enough to have him around Linus without killing him.

I had some help last night, while we worked both Linus and Cody into recognizing each other and understanding the presence of each other. We leashed Linus and Cody and would walk Linus around Cody and everytime Cody showed teeth, we would correct him with a stern "no". After a few times, he understood it. He stopped showing his teeth towards Linus. But we're still working on it.

And irresponsible? I don't believe so. They're in my house, and it's much better than being in a pound. They have to learn to live together and i have to help them get there. With enough training and help, I can turn Cody into a dog friendly dog. I don't think he wants to be aggressive. If he did, he could've killed Linus or severely injured him when he had him on the ground. But he did not.

Two males together with a not so experienced guy ? Sorry but what kind of rescue is that ? I'm very surprised about that. Good luck to you, you will need it
The rescue has no where else to put him. Some volunteers have 2 fosters in their homes, along with their own pack. No one else would step up to the plate, so it was either my house or a shelter. I don't blame the rescue at all.
 
It won't. Cody definitely isn't aggressive. He was showing dominance. After a few corrections, Cody stopped growling and snarling at Linus and puts up with him (if he's on a leash). I spoke to my trainer and she recommended a muzzle for now, one so he can still drink, breath, etc. But he won't be able to bite myself or Linus. He will keep this muzzle on until I'm comfortable enough to have him around Linus without killing him.

I had some help last night, while we worked both Linus and Cody into recognizing each other and understanding the presence of each other. We leashed Linus and Cody and would walk Linus around Cody and everytime Cody showed teeth, we would correct him with a stern "no". After a few times, he understood it. He stopped showing his teeth towards Linus. But we're still working on it.

And irresponsible? I don't believe so. They're in my house, and it's much better than being in a pound. They have to learn to live together and i have to help them get there. With enough training and help, I can turn Cody into a dog friendly dog. I don't think he wants to be aggressive. If he did, he could've killed Linus or severely injured him when he had him on the ground. But he did not.

Often, correcting warning signals (raised lip, growl, etc.) leads to the dog giving no warning before escalating to a bite. Does your trainer know anything about same-sex aggression in the breed?

If you truly believe you can train this out of him you have not done enough reading on this topic. People who have been in the breed forever, who are amazing trainers, who work with "hard" dogs, agree that this is not a training issue.

All I can say is that I hope, for the sake of both dogs, you reconsider this plan. Given your inexperience in the breed and the lack of a good trainer, you are putting both dogs at risk, as well as whomever will be present when they get into a real fight.
 
Often, correcting warning signals (raised lip, growl, etc.) leads to the dog giving no warning before escalating to a bite. Does your trainer know anything about same-sex aggression in the breed?

If you truly believe you can train this out of him you have not done enough reading on this topic. People who have been in the breed forever, who are amazing trainers, who work with "hard" dogs, agree that this is not a training issue.

All I can say is that I hope, for the sake of both dogs, you reconsider this plan. Given your inexperience in the breed and the lack of a good trainer, you are putting both dogs at risk, as well as whomever will be present when they get into a real fight.

Like I said, it wasn't a fight. If he really wanted to kill or harm Linus, he was in a good position to do so. But he did not. So, there's hope for him. He's not aggressive, just dominant.
 
Often, correcting warning signals (raised lip, growl, etc.) leads to the dog giving no warning before escalating to a bite. Does your trainer know anything about same-sex aggression in the breed?

I think that the things MeadowCat is saying here are important. Is your trainer experienced with Dobermans? Are you sure you aren't just correcting the warnings out of Cody? I'm sorry if it seems like we're jumping all over you, that would definitely make me feel very defensive, but from what we hear, and from past stories from other households (not yours!), this situation can be very alarming.

I would definitely educate yourself on how to properly break up a dog fight. I do see you're getting a muzzle for Cody; be sure to properly and positively acclimate him to it, and not just strap it on and make him "deal with it". Considering Cody has tagged other dogs before Linus, I would hesitate to have him around dogs at all without other people there, such as a behaviorist and trainer who is familiar with Dobermans, dog aggression, and/or same sex aggression. Good to hear that he seems to be okay around people, though! "Dominance" is not a more positive label than "Aggression" to hang on a dog, and I would hesitate to do so without him having a board certified behaviorist evaluate the dog and come up with a game plan.
 
I definitely agree, it's all viable advice. But I strongly believe he's not aggressive, he either has to get to know a dog, or be taught how to act around other dogs.
 
I definitely agree, it's all viable advice. But I strongly believe he's not aggressive, he either has to get to know a dog, or be taught how to act around other dogs.


I hear that. Elka, with as much as I've done with her, has never known other dogs since leaving her litter. My BIG mistake. So, she kind of acts like a freak around other dogs; never lets them touch her, darts in, darts away, etc. Fear/play looking behavior, she just does not know how to handle things. And then sometimes she's completely calm and acts like a "normal" dog.

So, take it slow with Cody and with Linus! Make sure lots of treats are involved for both of them, so it's positive (well, unless you've seen resource guarding issues as well, don't want to exacerbate that) and do please contact a behavioralist. It'll definitely help you and the rescue get a handle on this dog's needs, and what his future home will need to be! I am very glad that you're helping a rescue.
 
same sex aggression is a big deal and very dangerous. I have two females that can not be together or they will try to kill each other.
I agree, that same sex aggression can very rarely ever be trained out of a dog, while dog aggression can be controlled through training, it will always there,and this must be understood, and always be carefully controlled.
 
Thank you Dale! I appreciate it.

I don't think it's same-sex aggression. After evaluation of them both today during our walks, Cody doesn't mind Linus. He just can't stand how hyper Linus is and how Linus jumps on him and wants to play so much. He's ok with a little playing, but Linus is simply too much. So I'm training Linus to not be so hyper around Cody!
 
I'm sorry, but that's a very irresponsible attitude. Some dogs just ARE dog aggressive. They can learn to be respectful of other dogs out in public, as long as there is some distance. But, especially in the Doberman breed, having the idea that they "just have to learn to be ok" is a recipe for disaster. This attitude may lead to a fatal dog fight. I, too, am shocked that a rescue would place a dog that's shown aggression to another dog in a home that has a dog of the same sex. That's completely irresponsible. Our rescue does have a few homes that are very experienced, and have very laid back males, and we occasionally will place a male in those homes. We would NEVER do that with someone inexperienced, and definitely not with a foster that has been dog aggressive. I sincerely hope this does not end in tragedy.


Thank you, couldn't have said it better. Sorry Nick, but i think, you arent the right home for this forster at all, you have zero experience and you have no idea, about male to male agression, that situation right now in your house, calls for a big disaster and you far away for being ready for that situation.
 
Nick is that the Trainer from Petsmart, the one you took Linus for his puppyclass ???
I think you get some great advice and warnings here, but you need to start to listen to the experienced people on here and not just brush it off, like you always do.


After evaluation of them both today during our walks
How you wanna evaluate them, if you don't have the experience, you can missread the bodylanguage very easily
 
Nick is that the Trainer from Petsmart, the one you took Linus for his puppyclass ???
I think you get some great advice and warnings here, but you need to start to listen to the experienced people on here and not just brush it off, like you always do.


How you wanna evaluate them, if you don't have the experience, you can missread the bodylanguage very easily

I take a lot of advice from this forum but sometimes you can't quite explain the entire situation through a forum. So I explain it to someone in person and I'm able to explain it much better. This forum has helped me raise Linus. It just sucks because no one on the forum lives near me and can accurately tell me what is wrong. But my trainer (who knows Linus very well) and knows Cody from what I've told her, has given me advice for my particular situation with Cody and Linus.

I can read Cody's body language, we got him from standing there and barking/growling to now just standing there. He actually smelt Linus as well tonight. Which means we're making progress!
 
I take a lot of advice from this forum but sometimes you can't quite explain the entire situation through a forum. So I explain it to someone in person and I'm able to explain it much better. This forum has helped me raise Linus. It just sucks because no one on the forum lives near me and can accurately tell me what is wrong. But my trainer (who knows Linus very well) and knows Cody from what I've told her, has given me advice for my particular situation with Cody and Linus.

I can read Cody's body language, we got him from standing there and barking/growling to now just standing there. He actually smelt Linus as well tonight. Which means we're making progress!

Hi Nick,
I feel your pain with regards to having no one living near you to lend a helping hand...it sucks.;)

Cya
 
Nick is that the Trainer from Petsmart, the one you took Linus for his puppyclass ???
I think you get some great advice and warnings here, but you need to start to listen to the experienced people on here and not just brush it off, like you always do.


How you wanna evaluate them, if you don't have the experience, you can missread the bodylanguage very easily
Hello thegang.. would you mind posting an intro thread??? people here like to know what kind of expierance all this advice comes from.
 
The rescue has no where else to put him. Some volunteers have 2 fosters in their homes, along with their own pack. No one else would step up to the plate, so it was either my house or a shelter. I don't blame the rescue at all.


Well I certainly hold the rescue responsible. When a rescue is out of room, they should not place a dog with the first person to step up to the plate. They should contact DAN (doberman assistance network www.dobermanassistance.org ), a place that networks the entire country to find a rescue that does have a qualified foster home. They have a whole group of people that volunteer to drive dogs across country or at least from various points to get them where they are going. Also, there are pilots that will fly them. www.pilotsnpaws.org

You seem to have strong feelings about this. Would you please take a moment to explain why you feel the way you do? I think we all need to see that you truly understand what you have gotten into. You say " I don't think it's same-sex aggression" what do you base that on?

I know you have every confidence in the world in your trainer because she has helped come so far with Linus. I have to say that most of the petsmart/petco trainers I have come across are not the ones I would go to for anything other than basic obedience training. They are hired by the company and take a course and come out thinking they are expert trainers. She may be a very good trainer, but that does not mean she has the experience or knowledge to help with Cody. Would you tell us some about her experience.

I know you are trying to do a good thing here. And kudos to you for that but you only have a few months experience and not much support so it is very concerning for us. Trainers with years of experience sometimes think twice before taking on something like this. You, Cody or Linus could be hurt and at the very least, all the work you have done with Linus could be in vain.
I do hope you take a few minutes and read this thread again and let go of the "but I have too help him" and think about what is best for all three of you.
 
Often, correcting warning signals (raised lip, growl, etc.) leads to the dog giving no warning before escalating to a bite.

I've got to second this. Correcting the warning signals can often lead to a dog giving no warning signals before a bite. I'd much rather be able to read the body language and intervene than to have an unpredictable dog on my hands.
 
Nick, I think your heart is in the right place and I don't want you to feel ganged up on...people are just concerned, understandably. I think you mentioend that the adoption group didnt place the dog with you, but that you and the dogs previous foster made arangements. Has the rescue group been notified of the change? I know a lot of rescues are at their limits now, but if a rescue is stretched, they usually stop taking dogs in. You mentioned the dog would have to go back to the shelter if you hadnt taken him? Who pulled the dog initially... the rescue group? Was he in a shelter previously? Is the rescue looking for another foster home with no dogs, or are you pretty much on your own?
 
Nick - Sometimes it is bliss to have just enough knowledge that you don't have a clue how far over your head you are in this one. I have given warnings bewfore and been told how horrible I am for speaking up and speaking the trueth - but I speak for the dogs =

You have a wonderful heart and I believe you have a great future in dogs but you are still in day care and have not even made kindergarten yet. Dogs test each other and size each other up and each encounter gets worse and worse until one dog says OK I have him sized up and now I will finish him off. You are flirting with disaster and the dogs will pay the ultimate price. Often dogs in this situation will learn to STOP warning you and next time just strike with no signs and no warning. You are not prepared for that.

Please clear up who placed the dog with you??? It would really put any rescue in very bad light if they placed a dog that was known to be dog aggessive in the home of a new person to the breed and one who had a male to boot.
This story is not adding up based on what I know of how hard rescues work to make the right placement plus the screening they do on fosters. So did you really get him from the pound or where exactly????

I do not say thise things to make you feed bad but to protect you and save you from some of the stuff Sophie's Justice suffered when people did not listen to sound advice from poeple who know more than any petsmart trainer will ever know because they don't work with problem dogs and are not equiped to work with them - they train puppy classes for gosh sakes and do manage to get through the basics.
 
Nick,
and anyone else who is curious.
There are lots of people here giving you advice, many of them are just as you were insinuating earlier, your typical breed lovers who heard someone on the internet say something so they take it as gospel and preach it. This does not mean they are wrong or bad people, it just means they only see one perspective of the situation and are therefore biased.

I am a proffessional trainer who has hade well over a decade dealing with high drive high aggression protection breed dogs, you can ask those who know me personally here, such as doberman gang and dobs4ever, they know me on a personal and proffesional level and can attest to my abilities and my credentials.

I am going to put this as honest and forthwright to you as I can.
I understand completely what your trying to do, you want to help the breed, and the dog that would otherwise be put down, you love the breed and are stepping up to the plate to put your money where your mouth is by opening your home to a dog in need, and for this I must commend you, it is a brave and selfless act.

BUT, with that said, what your describing is the start of dog aggression and same sex aggression. You have two males in the same closed in space of your home, one is dominately playing with the other one, hence the jumping over top of him, and putting his feet on his back and head over his back etc, these are all tell tale signs of dominance, and this will lead to a fight, the other dog is showing you that he is uncomfortable in the situation and therefore has not gone all out yet as he is unsure of his place. BUT, If you continue to have these two dogs togethor and allow the play and dominance to continue, you will have a bad dog fight on your hands, where them and you may be hurt. I have been bitten badly several times in breaking up dog fights, and have seen dogs hurt badly, to the point of death.

I again commend you for what your doing as your heart is in the right place, but the trainer your seeing, is not a properly trained trainer who has a true understanding of protection breed dogs, or dog aggression, it is just not taught in any of the standard obedience trainer classes, and a petsmart or any other pet place trainer, go through a simple obedience certification to be able to be called a trainer, trust me, I personally know several of these people, and they are great for simple puppy obedience and socialization, but have no clue whatsoever when it comes to real behavioral issues in dogs, much less in protection breed dogs.

You need to keep them seperate at all times, walking them togethor is fine as long as your in control, but allowing them free roam and play togethor is not a good idea. Trust me, its much better to crate and rotate if your going to do this. If your not willing to take these precautions, then I would find another suitable home for your foster.

I hope this helps you my friend.
 

Back
Top