• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

First post and need some advice please

01a4man

Novitiate
Hello everyone,

I would like to seek your advice on what I should do in my current situation. I have a 13 y/o Dobie who has been diagnosed with cancer. The vet has given him approximately 3-6 months to live. His hips are giving out and my family (who are taking care of him for me while I am in Afghanistan) says he whines sometimes when getting up. I know he is in pain at times because he never whines unless he cannot get to me.

On a positive note, my family tells me that he still plays sometimes and still likes to go for walks, although he does not have too much energy and tires very easily. I will be home next month on vacation and need to make one of the most difficult decisions. I am unsure at this point if I should put him down to avoid the pain he will most certainly be going through soon, or let my family do it when the time comes.

He has been the greatest pup I have ever had and have watched him grow from him being smaller than my size 12 shoe to a 110lbs. big baby. I cannot help to feel that I should be the one to do it as I feel I owe him that. He chose me as a puppy and we have been together ever since. I also feel that I should let him live on for as long as he seems happy. To say I am torn on this subject would be the biggest understatement of my life. Either way, I know this will be the last time I see him and the sadness of me knowing that, overwhelming.

My apologies for making this first post so long. Any advice provided would be appreciated more than you know while I figure out what to do. I do not want him to suffer but will miss him more than my feeble words will ever be able to express.

Chris
 
Chris - let me say first God bless you for serving this country. May God keep you safe and bring you home soon.

Unfortunatly you are the only one that can decide what is right and when it is right. I can feel the love you guys shared and I know how heart wrenching this must be for you. Regardless of you decision we stand behind you and wish I could be there to help. How horrible to be faced with this after you have so selflessly served to protect freedom around the world.

I agree with you that if he is doing OK there is nothing wrong with wanting to be there with him if possible. It will also help give you closure but this is really about him. From what you say I would take it one day at a time.
 
Hello Chris and welcome to Doberman-Chat even though it's on such a sad note. I'm so sorry to hear about your boys cancer diagnosis and we're here to talk or for a shoulder to lean on if you need it. We've been there and totally understand.

Wow, 13 years is fantastic, even though no amount of time is enough for us, but I think ultimately it's up to you what you want to do when you're home. I think he'll tell you the answer in his eyes when you're together whether he wants to run free over the bridge and be with you when he goes, or if he's still feeling good enough to carry on until he's no longer enjoying his quality of life. You're doing the brave thing and being responsible for weighing the options and asking opinions, and you know that we'll all be here for you regardless of what you decide. It sounds like you'll do what's best for him, and he'll always be with you even after he's gone over the bridge.

Please keep us posted and like I said, we all understand how hard it is, so no matter what you might want to talk about, we're here.
 
Chris,
Thank you for your service. Let me ask you something. Who are you really keeping the Dobe around for? Is it for you because you aren't ready to let go or because you really believe that he has some quality life left to live? This is one of those times where we have to put our feelings aside and make the decision that is best for them. I'm sorry you've come to this point and hope that whatever decision you make brings you peace. Good luck and stay safe over there.
 
Chris,
Thank-you for your service to our country. I'm so sorry to hear about your Dobe's diagnosis. Being a pet owner is so hard sometimes. I can tell you how I made a decision to put my horse down 4 years ago. She was 30 year old but still in good shape and happy. She foundered which is a painful ailment of the hoof. We treated her with pain meds until the vet could come and evaluate. He offered some options but when I asked what he would do if it was his horse the answer was to let her go. I realized that anything else would be only for me and not in her best interest and as her best friend I needed to make the decision to end her pain. Your dog has had a wonderful life full of love. I understand that you want to be by his side and as long as he is not suffering that is what you should do. If and when he becomes debilitated, in pain, not eating, etc, you will know in your heart that the time is right to allow him to cross over the rainbow bridge.
I was "fortunate" in that my 1st dobe died of a heart attack at my feet, sudden and shocking but no decisions. He was only 6. Good luck and know I at least understand the pain and hard decision this will be.
 
The only way I can give yo advice on this, is to tell you what I chose to do when it was my old mans time to go.
I loved him so very much and at 12 years old he just couldnt get around well and would sometimes just lay around to avoid the pain, though some days he would play and seem his old puppy self. It was then that I had to decide, do I want him to suffer, and then put him down, or do I want to let him go before he is miserable and in so much pain that his quality of life is non existent.
I decided on the first, we spent a day together hanging out going for a walk, doing all the things we love to do together, and the next morning, I loaded him up in the truck, He LOVED going for rides, and we went to the vet. I held him and talked to him and petted him as the vet did his thing, he left this world in my arms listening to the sound of my voice and looking into my eyes.

You are going to have to decide for yourself what is best for you and your dog, but remember, its more for us sometimes that we keep them around past the time for them to go. But to let them go when its best, shows how much we truly love them.
 
Hi Chris and welcome to the forum.

I am so sorry to hear about your boy. I have been in the same situation as you with our Goldie. She was 10 years old when diagnosed with Lymphoma. We tried chemo but she didn't tolerate it. Her hips also starting going down hill fast due to the puppy jumping on her. She had a hard time getting up after sleeping. Both dogs went with me to the barn every day. 6 months after diagnosis all her glands were swollen, she was panting all the time and would just lay outside the stall while I was cleaning it. She would normally potter around the barn checking everything out. We knew that the cancer would be much worse on the inside than what we could see on the outside. She was a very stoic girl and would never whine. I did not want her to suffer and it was so hard to see her not feeling well. The day we had the appointment at the vet she was having a good day. She was running around the barn in the rain begging carrots off the groom and being her normal self. Many people would probably have canceled the appointment and waited, but I knew that it was just one good day and the next would be not so good. I was happy that her last day was one where she didn't feel so sick and that she got to do what she loved the most.

I think it would be great for both you and your boy if you are there when he goes. 13 years is a great age and he has been your buddy for that long, he will want you there at the end.

Sorry you have to go through this. We are all here to support you.
 
Oh, a heartbreaking position that so many of us have been in! I'm so sorry! Both my Dobes developed cancer at 10 years old. Nothing helped and I carefully watched for signs when I knew it 'was time'. Their eyes will usually tell you if you listen carefully. As Katja said, we knew the cancer was worse on the inside, more than what we can see on the outside, and I didn't want them to suffer any more than they were. If at any time they finally stop eating, that to me is a sign they've had enough. I think when you come home you will have to make an evaluation on his condition. Every dog I've ever loved over the last 40 years I've taken to the Vet myself. And as Dale did, I held them in my arms and talked to them so that they were comforted being with me and that my voice/face/love was the last thing they knew. I wish you Peace in your decision.
 
dear Chris ,
i must thank you for your service over there we have lots of troops over there also [UK] and we are all proud of what you are doing for your countries.
I like all the others have also been in your boots, and have had to make the hardest decisions , if i were you i would leave him to you come home unless he deteriorates quickly , you can spend a great couple of days with him like you used to and then make that decision, you would not want him to go without giving him the last hug and kiss , and it would give you closure he will be in your heart forever and a part of you for life evermore, god bless and stay safe :sorrow:
 
Chris,
I, like everyone else wish to thank you for your service to our country. This situation is just one example of the sacrafices you have to make to keep us safe and free.
I feel your pain, and I pray your boy can be comfortable until your return.
As a dog owner, I have this poem that I read when I know I may be facing this personally. I'd like to share it with you, in hopes it helps you.

The Last Battle


If it should be that I grow frail and weak
And pain should keep me from my sleep,
Then will you do what must be done,
For this -- the last battle -- can't be won.
You will be sad I understand,
But don't let grief then stay your hand,
For on this day, more than the rest,
Your love and friendship must stand the test.
We have had so many happy years,
You wouldn't want me to suffer so.
When the time comes, please, let me go.
Take me to where to my needs they'll tend,
Only, stay with me till the end
And hold me firm and speak to me
Until my eyes no longer see.
I know in time you will agree
It is a kindness you do to me.
Although my tail its last has waved,
From pain and suffering I have been saved.
Don't grieve that it must be you
Who has to decide this thing to do;
We've been so close -- we two -- these years,
Don't let your heart hold any tears.

-- Unknown

May prayers are with you.
 
Chris,
My heartfelt prayers go out to you and your big boy. No one can tell you when to let go... only you can make the decision. I lost my baby girl, Karsie, 3 yrs ago to cancer. I remember the day she was brought home as a birthday gift to my mom, who had been pining for a dog. I also remember the day she crossed the rainbow bridge. And I remember her face as she left. That sudden feeling of relief they experience at the end. She was having a hard time moving around, eating, playing, so we knew it was time to let go. I hope you get the chance to be with him one more time before he's called back home, but even if you don't, just remember that love is the only thing remembered after death... and he will always remember you and the love you have given, and you will always remember his.
♥♥♥ Live, Love, Never Forget. ♥♥♥
Joelle
 
Chris,
as everyone else has said, I too would like to thank you for your service to our Country, God Bless you for that. You have a good heart, as you are giving of yourself to others, selflessly, and it also reflects in your love for your dobe as well. When we lost our girl, Mysti, she made the decision to let go, taking that out of our hands, in some ways we were lucky, and in some ways I wish she had not done so. The only advice I can give you is that when you come home, and you spend time with your boy, he will let you know what you should do. Spend time with him, love him, if he is happy, and pain free, and he wants to live, he will let you know, just give him all the love you can and cherish those moments always. I know your family will understand if you choose to allow him the time once you return to duty. They will be compassionate when it is his time to go and they will be with him and his eternal rest will be peaceful. If he lets you know that it is his time while you are home, then be with him and know you have given him the best life possible, full of love and happiness, and that he will wait for you to join him at the Rainbow Bridge when it is time. If you ever need an ear, please feel free to message anyone here, as well all understand what you are going through, its tough, and we are glad to help you through it.
God Bless you, and your big baby boy, and may God keep you in his shelter while you are serving our Country.
 
Wow,

Thank you all for the kind words and advice. I can honestly say that I am blown away by all of your responses. Your words have truely made my day and have given me much to think about. While I understand what many of you have said about him letting me know when it is time, but I cannot help but feel that it is my responsibility to do this. I will never forget the day he picked me, the first night together and many more memories he has given me during our short time together. I will not re-deploy home again for some time, therefore I think it is best that we spend some time together before I send him on and will at least take comfort in the fact that he spent his last moments with me; where he belongs. Thank you again to everyone, your words and support are appreciated more than you know.
 
Wow,

Thank you all for the kind words and advice. I can honestly say that I am blown away by all of your responses. Your words have truely made my day and have given me much to think about. While I understand what many of you have said about him letting me know when it is time, but I cannot help but feel that it is my responsibility to do this. I will never forget the day he picked me, the first night together and many more memories he has given me during our short time together. I will not re-deploy home again for some time, therefore I think it is best that we spend some time together before I send him on and will at least take comfort in the fact that he spent his last moments with me; where he belongs. Thank you again to everyone, your words and support are appreciated more than you know.
god bless Chris
 
Hello Chris,
I am so sorry that you are going through this. Several years ago I had a rottie mix that developed bone cancer. I took him to specialists and spent a lot of time talking to my vet. My dog was not a candidate for amputation as the cancer had quickly spread to his lungs. We talked about chemotherapy and what it would do to his quality of life. We tried several different pain medications, all with awful side effects. I asked my vet when I should begin to consider putting him down. My vet told me to start keeping track of his good days versus his bad days. That helped me visually see when his quality of life was truly decreasing. Could I have waited another month or two - sure - but would I have been doing it to keep him around for me? We never know if our timing is perfect, but I do know that they appreciate that we love them enough to make difficult decisions and to think of their pain and suffering before our own. Even as I write this I tear up, so I think we all know what a difficult process you are going through.

PS. Thank you for serving our country and for all the sacrifices you make for us.
 
Chris:
what kind of cancer is it? there are some cancers that cause a wasting away and some that are extremely painful... Bone cancer is extremely painful for the patient and dogs cannot communicate their pain.
SO it would be very good to know what kind of cancer it is as it should help you make your choice.
My last Neapolitan mastiff was 10 years old and I found out he had bone cancer about 3 months before we had to put him down... but during that 3 months I met an Oncologist whom I was talking to about my dog and I told him he had bone cancer and what should I do? his answer was swift and cogent.. "If it were my dog" he said "I would put him down now".... I asked him why and he said "Because he is in intense pain and suffering and he cannot and will not let you know"...
How true his words are to me now after the fact. Amadeus suffered that entire 3 months and finally he could barely stand and he fell one day and in trying to get him up, he attacked me savagely and My arm was very badly punctured and I had to be hospitalized over it. He was in such agonizing pain that my trying to move him sent him over the edge and he just attacked in pain...
I just say this because I realize now I could have eased his suffering by letting him go earlier and not selfishly trying to keep him as long as we could... I say that directed ENTIRELY at MYSELF.. not you... but say it because I know now that I should have let him go as soon as I found out and as soon as that Doctor told me that, but it was about another 6 weeks before this incident happened and I could have avoided it entirely.
Blessings on you and your beloved boy... 13 years is awesome and even if it were 23 or 33 or 53 its NEVER enough time....
so blessings on you both and if its bone cancer.. just consider my story... namaste'
:sorrow:
 
Denissov43 - so sorry to hear of your loss, too. Bone cancer is rough. My rottie mix only displayed a minor amount of pain, limping occasionally on the affected leg. The tumor was in a joint and it was imperative that I restrict his movement, as the bone could have split. I agree that they hide their pain very well, I like to think they are trying to make it easier on us :) After my dogs diagnosis that the cancer had spread to his chest it was about 2 months before I had the courage to put him down. My Baxter wagged his tail til the very end. Even though it broke my heart I have to be confident that I made the right decision, at the right time. I have heard of dogs becoming violent when the pain becomes that intense, it's a shame that they have no other way to let us know just how much they are dealing with.
 
true Lori... they are really masters of managing pain and ignoring it unless it is really severe. My mastiff was waging his tail till the last day as well, but he was in so much pain... first photo is him about a year before, and a year later at 10 years old, he was down from 165 in this photo down to 110 lbs.... the pain in his face and I just did not want to see it, because it pained me to let go and it pained me to see him suffer.
we love them so!!
shusha waiting for treat.webp
 

Back
Top