• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Fear stage at 11 months? Or just hormones?

CrisK

Jr Member
Hi Friends,

Gypsy is almost 1 year old now. We have been doing a lot of training and recently joined a group obedience class. The first day at the class, she behaved way better than I had expected. She paid attention to me most of the time. Second time, she seemed a little more interested in the other dogs. Her fourth class though, she was completely insane. She barked at the other dogs, tried to lunge, we ended up secluded in a hallway to prevent her from staring at the other dogs. She was doing really well on walks, and we were able to walk by the neighbor's dogs calmly even when she got barked at by them. That has changed. She has started to react to every dog and person that she sees on our walks. She goes from 0 to 60 in a matter of seconds and it become impossible to get her attention back. On those occasions, I have to physically move her away from the trigger.

My trainer said it could be her hormones, and someone else I know said the same thing. I believe Gypsy just finished going through a false pregnancy - because I haven't seen milk coming out in the past week or so. This is very confusing to me. I was told to keep her home until she gets through this hormonal phase. But I am not sure.

She's becoming super reactive, and I don't want to accidentally encourage that.
 
What kind of collar are you using? Nothing wrong with physically moving her away!!! Do whatever it takes and do it as fast as you can. Gypsy needs to learn that you are always in charge. I know if Asha went off on a dog/person at that age she wouldn't listen to me unless I had the prong or e-collar on. No way could I get her to listen while she had a flat collar or simple choke chain on, the only things allowed when I was at my AKC teachers classes (although now she does let me use a prong to start Rally class then move to an allowed collar). I think one of my worst mistakes was going along with this and Asha got away with a LOT of reactiveness that I couldn't correct instantly in these classes. Plus the teacher was of the mind to "let the puppy settle, then reward". Nope, nope, nope. My worst events were when I was not paying attention and Asha would have locked eyes on another dog or person and in just a few seconds would blow up at them. So, first of all, my fault for letting my attention wander. Next move is on me to instantly correct - usually snap the leash, do an about face and heel (or drag if you have to) away the opposite direction, demanding her attention. If she kept straining around to look or growl at her target, I would correct again and heel away, down, then heel again - quickly, lots of commands in sequence so she had to listen/obey/listen/obey. Only when her attention was on me did I treat her. Do what I had to learn the hard way: Prevention from letting it start. Check on Gypsy and where her attention is constantly throughout your lessons, or anytime in public. If you see her staring or stiffening up at ANYthing, say her name, give a pat, anything to change her focus. Ask everyone in your group to not make eye contact with her - the teacher should also let everyone know that they should not let their dogs stare at other dogs.

I wouldn't blame it on hormones. I think it's a cop-out that so many people want to use. It doesn't matter what her stage is - an intact male is "always in heat" so to speak with driving hormones! The dog has to learn to behave no matter what hormones are surging, otherwise everyone would spend their life on a roller coster according to how the dog is feeling.

You've come a long ways, I think Asha was a little over a year old was when I felt like I was really making progress. 18 months for sure. You're almost there! Yes Asha still explodes when she's in the car or at home, but it's been a long long time since doing that on leash.
 
How do you correct her when she becomes reactive. Hormones are not an excuse to be reactive. It just means more training needs to be done. You need to be the one that gives the picture of what is allowed and what is not. Dogs become fearful from not knowing what is expected in new environments or if they feel there is a lack of leadership, they may feel it is up to them to take charge. Your trainer probably just doesn’t want to deal with the situation or they don’t feel they have time in a class setting to train it. Be firm but fair, but do not tolerate that behavior.
 
I agree with all of the above comments. I also wouldn't blame it on hormones. More training is needed and you need to watch her body language constantly, so that you can stop her before she starts that reactive behavior. When I am teaching a class, I may move someone with a reactive dog a little further apart (maybe an extra foot or so) from the others, but they need to stay within the group and not isolate as that makes things worse when they come back in. You need to use a firm correction as soon as the behavior starts. It may take you a while to spot the signs that she is getting ready to misbehave in someway, but the sooner you can see her energy change, the easier it will be to correct. Snap the leash, do an about turn, say firmly "leave it" or "enough", or whatever word you choose. Do whatever it takes to get her to refocus on you and lower that energy, but don't isolate her. It can be exhausting training a reactive dog, but if you see it through both of you will be happier! You got this!
 
I use a martingale collar. I don't do any corrections per se, aside from pulling her around the moment she starts barking. On walks she is always scanning the environment with her ears pointed forward. I do several things with her on walks to get her attention - like back-aways, sits, walking to heel, touch and 1-2-3 games. But, I feel that's not enough and her attention drifts a lot to the environment. She's constantly watching these days.

I have to look into the prong collar. My trainer is not opposed to it, but she thinks Gypsy is reacting out of fear and a prong collar could make things worse (she said). This new trainer is better than our previous one, she trains search and rescue dogs and she seems to be really good at what she does.

I find it really hard to get her attention outdoors. She's been getting better and better at loose leash walking, she responds to leash pressure much better than to my voice. It's only when a "threat" is around she's mentally gone. She saw a couple walking across the street from us and she panicked - her fur was all standing and she was barking at them. And that happens when they are walking. They stopped to chat with me from across the street and Gypsy hid behind my legs. Once they started walked, she started barking at them again. I pulled her the opposite direction they were going and she kept trying to look back at them.

It's insane!
 
And that happens when they are walking. They stopped to chat with me from across the street and Gypsy hid behind my legs. Once they started walked, she started barking at them again. I pulled her the opposite direction they were going and she kept trying to look back at them.
I have to say that wanting to hide behind you when the couple is no longer moving and "might" come toward you is something I never had to deal with. I did have a thread on here about company and the big nasty show that Asha would put on, but as soon as I accepted the company Asha was totally cool with it. The hackles can be a sign of fear or just stress. If you had called the couple over to chat on your side of the street what do you think Gypsy would have done? Or you take Gypsy and approach them? Always say Gypsy is learning and please no talk, no touch, no eye contact. The couple talks to YOU, and ignores the dog, then you walk away from them. As we've said so many times, socialization isn't about making friends, it's just exposure to new people, dogs, places and things, but nothing bad ever happens, you take charge of all the calls so your pup learns that you make all the decisions from when to stop & chat, when to walk away, when barking is not allowed and when the praise & treats come out. It's a ton of work for both of you, but I promise it gets better.
 
I had a reactive dog in the past....it is a lot of work; but worth it once they mature and rely on you for guidence. I would try the prong collar, there are videos on the proper way to use one, and it won't have to be forever....I personally don't feel you can get a good correction with a martingale, and you want to be able to nip this in the bud. I think she just needs to know you have all the situations you guys are in, under control....and working with her the way you are will reinforce that. It took me 2 years to train my reactive boy to be in public, and in the ring, without letting everyone know he was there...but I finally got a CD on him! I was so proud he could sit in a group of dogs with me across the ring! Keep up the good work! It's gratifying when you can work through this with them, and creates a strong bond.
 
I had a reactive dog in the past....it is a lot of work; but worth it once they mature and rely on you for guidence. I would try the prong collar, there are videos on the proper way to use one, and it won't have to be forever....I personally don't feel you can get a good correction with a martingale, and you want to be able to nip this in the bud. I think she just needs to know you have all the situations you guys are in, under control....and working with her the way you are will reinforce that. It took me 2 years to train my reactive boy to be in public, and in the ring, without letting everyone know he was there...but I finally got a CD on him! I was so proud he could sit in a group of dogs with me across the ring! Keep up the good work! It's gratifying when you can work through this with them, and creates a strong bond.
Thank you! I am going to start working with a trainer who is a retired cop and has a vast experience training dogs for the police, service and guard dogs as well. I hope this is the person we need after going through 4 other trainers. He told me his current dog is a rescue that people said was hopeless. That dog was the most behaved dog in the group and totally trusted his master.

I am very interested in agility training and I hope I can get Gypsy to a point where she is ok around other dogs and people in a situation like that. Sounds like you were able to turn your dog around for competition! That gives me hope :)
 
Sounds promising! After I got his RAE title and his CD, I started doing Agility with him when he was 4 years old. By then he was very intuned to me, and the "watch me" command was invaluable. While we would wait "on deck" to do our run in agility, there were always other dogs warming up. I would have him do tricks like spin, weave through my legs, heel small areas...constantly watching me - never giving him the opportunity to get set off by another dog playing tug or something near us.... then it would be our turn to run our course. I am sure you will be successful with her! Coincidentally, before I did all this, he was terrible at my local obedience club when he was 8 months old, and being a Doberman, people gave me the "look"....like get that dog out of here. I ended up training at a place that trained police dogs, and reactive dogs in paticular. That is when I learned to "calm down" and not pass my energy to my dog...I would get nervous that HE was reacting. We did alot of cool things to give the dogs confidence in unusual situations. The emphasis was having the dog do everything slowly, until you could see they relaxed.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0912.webp
    IMG_0912.webp
    664.7 KB · Views: 9
  • IMG_0910.webp
    IMG_0910.webp
    843.1 KB · Views: 8
  • IMG_2002.webp
    IMG_2002.webp
    458.9 KB · Views: 8
Sounds promising! After I got his RAE title and his CD, I started doing Agility with him when he was 4 years old. By then he was very intuned to me, and the "watch me" command was invaluable. While we would wait "on deck" to do our run in agility, there were always other dogs warming up. I would have him do tricks like spin, weave through my legs, heel small areas...constantly watching me - never giving him the opportunity to get set off by another dog playing tug or something near us.... then it would be our turn to run our course. I am sure you will be successful with her! Coincidentally, before I did all this, he was terrible at my local obedience club when he was 8 months old, and being a Doberman, people gave me the "look"....like get that dog out of here. I ended up training at a place that trained police dogs, and reactive dogs in paticular. That is when I learned to "calm down" and not pass my energy to my dog...I would get nervous that HE was reacting. We did alot of cool things to give the dogs confidence in unusual situations. The emphasis was having the dog do everything slowly, until you could see they relaxed.
What a gorgeous dog! Love the pictures! And again, thanks forswearing your experience. I may be expecting too much too soon from her. These dogs are very intelligent and can learn. I need patience, consistency and calmness. I am putting in the work, looking forward to the results!
 
Just checking in to see if you have looked into a prong collar, or how things are going this week?
 
Not yet. She was spayed today so we will wait at least 2 weeks to do anything. The past couple of days have been interesting. On a walk a few days ago, one of the dogs that barks at her ran towards her and there was a face off. My husband ended up on the ground trying to keep the dogs apart - the other dog is a huge Bernese mountain dog. I tried walking her out again but she’s still on edge. No matter how far we are from that dogs house, she is looking at it.
 
I am at day 14 with Glory....whew, it was a long two weeks! My biggest pet peeves....loose dogs rushing my well behaved dog who is on leash!! I wait for my neighbors to go out of town to walk down my street (we are on a dead end, and one neighbor has pit that roams.). When I see them pull out in their RV I know it is safe to walk, otherwise, I put my two in the car and drive them to the park, fairgrounds or anywhere else to walk every day. Hope gas doesn't go up to $3 a gallon! I will still drive them someplace safe to walk ;). Someone will chime in on how to reintroduce her to your neighborhood...I would avoid it until you have her trained the way you want, and she is more confident and mature.
Keep us posted.
 
Not yet. She was spayed today so we will wait at least 2 weeks to do anything. The past couple of days have been interesting. On a walk a few days ago, one of the dogs that barks at her ran towards her and there was a face off. My husband ended up on the ground trying to keep the dogs apart -
Just a quick story for you to think about: If one dog is in control (yours is the only one you can control so be proactive) the chance of escalating is cut in half. The other day a neighbor wanted to hike with me & Asha with their reactive dog. Their dog reacts to strange dogs like "Act big and bad and barkbarkbark so the strange dog won't attack me". My dog just has to posture up and act like a badass, which I have worked on now for over a year. It's much better & I can cut it off, but she still is reactive if another dog starts in or if a person stares at her. I ALWAYS cut it off, no matter what it takes. I put the e-collar on Asha and we met on a neutral ground - not their house or my house but the road between. Their dog instantly started barking and mine started barking back and hackled up. I said no and tapped her e-collar - very low stimulation - which she totally ignored and the other dog was escalating. I cranked the e-collar up and said NO Leave It, and Asha kept on so I hit the e-collar again and this time it registered. Asha came right to my left knee, looked me in the eye and basically said I WILL BE GOOD FOREVER. And it was over. fullsizeoutput_33c.jpegLike all nastyness gone. The fearful dog knew she hadn't won, but also knew there was no longer any threat, so SHE de-escalated! In just a few more minutes they were totally ignoring each other as we walked (on leash) side by side for about 15 minutes, then I let Asha off leash for the rest of out 2.5 hour hike. The other is still training on recalls so was only off leash for a short time. They got along fine. What I'm saying is, if you can control your dog to not stare, threaten or react to another dogs actions you can also have a good chance of de-escalating the other dog as well. I hope this makes sense. In certain situations I don't think I will ever have a neutral dog, but management is my responsibility and I take it seriously. Two happy calm dogs for a 2.5 hour hike, loose leash on the pup no threats from Asha.fullsizeoutput_33d.webp
 
Wow! @Ravenbird thanks for sharing this story! It totally makes sense! I can’t wait to go through training in this new place. We’ll learn how to use the e-collar. I think this will be game changing for us. The martingale collar is only good for when she’s relaxed. The moment she is triggered she no longer responds to the squeeze. We need a more robust way to communicate with her. I want to be in control, and I do the best I can but I am still not getting through in certain situations. She gets into the red zone too quickly.
 
@Two Dobes - I live in a culdesac, the dog in question lives across the street from us. They have 3 dogs. The husky kept leaving their property with the invisible fence collar on. He didn’t care he got shocked. We were surprised by this dog right in front of our garage one time I was leaving with Gypsy. She lost it, I held her back and the husky just stood there watching Gypsy lose it. I called the town and made a complaint. Over here dogs have to be contained in their yards. After that I haven’t seen the husky roaming anymore. The neighbors are relaxed but I think they want to avoid trouble so they take action when there is a problem. My husband talked to them about what happened. The guy said his wife and children remove the collar from the Bernese mountain dog for some some reason and never put it back on. It’s just a stupid excuse, but I hope they will be more careful about ensuring their dogs stay within their property. I think it’s a good idea to take the dog for a walk somewhere outside the neighborhood. I will be doing that in the future!
 
We have leash laws in TN, but nobody in our small neighborhood follows the law....we are the only one's in our neighborhood with a fence. Our front yard is much larger than our fenced back, (at the end of a dead end) so I take our two out in our front, one at a time to play ball, play games with them where they can really run. (E collar on for insurance) Inevitably, either the schnauzers across the street come flying up to bark at my dog, or the dachshunds a few houses over haul up barking. So I feel you pain! I took this photo to prove they are in our yard if anything ever comes of it.....worse part; neighbors say "well it won't be your fault if something happens". WTF???? Most people shouldnt have dogs.Clarke being a good boy.webpGlory waiting for trouble.webp
 
We have leash laws in TN, but nobody in our small neighborhood follows the law....we are the only one's in our neighborhood with a fence. Our front yard is much larger than our fenced back, (at the end of a dead end) so I take our two out in our front, one at a time to play ball, play games with them where they can really run. (E collar on for insurance) Inevitably, either the schnauzers across the street come flying up to bark at my dog, or the dachshunds a few houses over haul up barking. So I feel you pain! I took this photo to prove they are in our yard if anything ever comes of it.....worse part; neighbors say "well it won't be your fault if something happens". WTF???? Most people shouldnt have dogs.View attachment 119510View attachment 119511
Gosh! Our situation is so similar!! We have a large front yard and a smaller fenced backyard too. We put up the fence because I don’t trust the invisible fence after seeing all these dogs ignoring it. I would feel terrible if my large dog would go running and barking at anyone on the street. I just can’t have that. See 4 dogs out there? I couldn’t believe all these dogs were escaping from 2 or 3 different houses at the same time. It’s insane!
 

Attachments

  • BBB2C9EE-9EB8-44E7-8D31-859AB44602AC.webp
    BBB2C9EE-9EB8-44E7-8D31-859AB44602AC.webp
    141 KB · Views: 6
Invisible fences are worthless! The dog sees something exciting and blows right through it, once it's out, it is "rewarded" by getting to romp around freely. Then on top of that it will get a shock going back through it to get back where he belongs, so essentially punished for going back home.
I can’t wait to go through training in this new place. We’ll learn how to use the e-collar. I think this will be game changing for us. The martingale collar is only good for when she’s relaxed. The moment she is triggered she no longer responds to the squeeze. We need a more robust way to communicate with her. I want to be in control, and I do the best I can but I am still not getting through in certain situations. She gets into the red zone too quickly.
So good you recognize all this. Some dogs just can't seem to learn without extra tools. I'll look forward to hearing how your lessons go from your new trainer. The other thing I've learned is most of these dogs really really like you being in charge and relax more on walks and in training knowing you have their back.
 

Back
Top