• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Ecollar Use & Positive vs Negative Training

Drogon

Hot Topics Subscriber
** Moderator Edit: This is a discussion pulled from this thread. There seems to be a discussion here so I moved all OT posts to continue this discussion. :) **

r @Drogon I know for a fact use them regularly and could explain the way it's used better. I only really understand the invisible fence lol
You can think of the ecollar as an invisible leash. We mostly used it for recall (return on command). Just like the fence sets a hard boundary, you use your remote to set loose boundaries. They get "too far" away or "too close" to something and he doesn't respond to your command you can use the remote to give a correction. On our hikes there's barbed wire, a river, and some pretty difficult terrain. He gets too close to the barb wire or the river and I give a correction. He also gets a correction when he tries to eat goose poop. Honestly I rarely use it anymore. Only a few corrections and he knows not to eat the poop or go too close to the river. I don't think he knows where the barbed wire is yet so I still use it there.
It isn't an electrical shock. It isn't a shock in that sense. It is a shock like a surprise like he is shocked that I can still give a correction from 1/2 mile away (not that I let him get that far). The collar I bought has tone, vibration, and stimulation. I used all three when appropriate. Getting too close to the river - got a tone. Ignored the tone and kept going - vibration. Too close for safety - stimulation. Now I just have to hit the tone and he responds because he knows what is coming next if he doesn't. The stimulation feels like the same thing a chiropractor used on my back. It felt odd and uncomfortable but it didn't hurt even though my leg was shaking.
It is certainly possible that the original ecollars were actually giving an electric shock similar to a taser I don't really know. I just know they're not like that now.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Thanks @Drogon. I knew you could explain it better! I have a cheap one but it works. It also has tone, vibration and stim. We both also "shocked" ourselves with it before putting it on the dogs and I have to agree, it's not really a shock. Its enough to grab attention but it doesn't hurt... The stim from the chriro is a good example! I recently had that done on my shoulder and you're right, it feels very similar! Mischa very rarely needs the stim (we still only use it inside, even with the collar I don't trust her off leash outside yet) but she doesn't care about the tone. We always have to go to vibration- which is also why I'm scared to try outside. If she's not respecting it for boundaries indoors how can I expect her to respect it outdoors?

Sent from my LG-H900 using Tapatalk
 
The tone can also be trained as a reward marker. Every time the dog correctly follows your command you can praise them and give the tone at the same time, or give a treat and the tone at the same time. This way you can use it as a positive marker when off leash training and the dog is still away from you. But if you are using it as a pre-correction then it would confuse the dog as a positive marker.
 
The tone can also be trained as a reward marker. Every time the dog correctly follows your command you can praise them and give the tone at the same time, or give a treat and the tone at the same time. This way you can use it as a positive marker when off leash training and the dog is still away from you. But if you are using it as a pre-correction then it would confuse the dog as a positive marker.
The collar we currently have had a bird chirp as the tone... So I took that as a positive marker. She typically gets a verbal warning, then vibration if she doesn't listen. Id say she's about 40% will listen to verbal (depending on why she's stretching the boundaries in the first place) but 99% of the time will respond with vibration.

Sent from my LG-H900 using Tapatalk
 
I'm a little late here since now it's clarified but I took it as he meant the cone of shame too lol... My vet refers to that as an e collar.

@kevn when you say youd never use an electric collar, may I ask why? I absolutely love the fact that we have an invisible fence and can let the dogs run and play off leash. Theres extensive training involved in it and there's a warning before the shock stimulation. 9 out of 10 times our dog backs up when he hears the beep and I think he's gotten the shock maybe once in the last year. I plan to use a remote electric collar in the future as well, which is a similar idea. @AresMyDobie or @Drogon I know for a fact use them regularly and could explain the way it's used better. I only really understand the invisible fence lol

Sent from my LG-H900 using Tapatalk
I would like to avoid negative reinforcement as much as possible. I'm not being judgmental, I just don't like it.
 
I would like to avoid negative reinforcement as much as possible. I'm not being judgmental, I just don't like it.
It's not negative. Trust me. It's no different then a poke to the neck or other body parts to snap them out of it. As stated its like an invisible leash . A correction is not negative but a hey pay attention. They are necessary to train a dog properly. I always correct then reward so they know what they should be doing.
 
I'm glad everything went well and she'll be recovered faster than you think - then the hard part is keeping her quiet until she's healed.

I've heard the elizabethan collar referred to as an e-collar way before the electronic collar, so I knew what you meant right away. It used to be e-collar for the cone, and shock collar for the other but I think the shock collar was softened up to be called an e-collar because people thought it was so cruel.
 
I would like to avoid negative reinforcement as much as possible. I'm not being judgmental, I just don't like it.
Fair enough, I dont think you need to justify your opinion on such a controversial topic.. What's most important is that we use what works best for our individual personalities.. I can tell you i really messed up one of my past dogs by trying advice giving on forums, and ditching my old proven tried and true methods.. Go with what ya Know, I say..

It's not negative. Trust me. It's no different then a poke to the neck or other body parts to snap them out of it.
I would respectfully disagree.. Its a shock plain and simple, and they are not even remotly pleasant (unless your 50 shades of freaky) :p .. its effective because its has a negative connotation , They don't like it therefore they are deterred form the unwanted behavior.. So i would call it Negative Reinforcement with a positive outcome. ;)
 
I would respectfully disagree.. Its a shock plain and simple, and they are not even remotly pleasant (unless your 50 shades of freaky) [emoji14] .. its effective because its has a negative connotation , They don't like it therefore they are deterred form the unwanted behavior.. So i would call it Negative Reinforcement with a positive outcome. ;)

I just have to say, the collar we personally have, didn't seem to have a shock to it. We both tested it on ourselves before putting it on the dogs and it caught our attention but wasn't a shock like I expected nor was it painful. We have a small TENS unit for my shoulder pain and it felt similar to that. I'm sure every collar is different too though.


Sent from my LG-H900 using Tapatalk
 
lol your talking to a guy who treats a static shock like being hit by a pair of defibrillator paddles. But with that being said i have no problems with the collars as training tools and have used bark collars for several years with great success.. as a matter of fact the batteries have been dead for years.. (don tell any of them that though..) :whistle:
 
lol your talking to a guy who treats a static shock like being hit by a pair of defibrillator paddles.
:spit: LOL I don't like any sort of shock either but it makes me take heed. ;)

I agree that the shock collar is a wonderful training tool when used correctly and it has saved Albert's life a couple times when he was bolting down the driveway after heavy equipment going by. I certainly wouldn't call it positive reinforcement, but very necessary with positive results.

Sorry, I know this has gone way OT. :sign1:
 
Fair enough, I dont think you need to justify your opinion on such a controversial topic.. What's most important is that we use what works best for our individual personalities.. I can tell you i really messed up one of my past dogs by trying advice giving on forums, and ditching my old proven tried and true methods.. Go with what ya Know, I say..


I would respectfully disagree.. Its a shock plain and simple, and they are not even remotly pleasant (unless your 50 shades of freaky) :p .. its effective because its has a negative connotation , They don't like it therefore they are deterred form the unwanted behavior.. So i would call it Negative Reinforcement with a positive outcome. ;)

But positive reinforcement can achieve similar results. I agree with Victoria Stilwell, on "It's Me or the Dog". Shock Collars I have a feeling I'm about to get in trouble on here again....
 
I have a feeling I'm about to get in trouble on here again....
You've never been in trouble here and as stated, we're all entitled to our opinions and should use what works for us. :)
 
I would respectfully disagree.. Its a shock plain and simple, and they are not even remotly pleasant (unless your 50 shades of freaky) :p .. its effective because its has a negative connotation , They don't like it therefore they are deterred form the unwanted behavior.. So i would call it Negative Reinforcement with a positive outcome.

Respectfully it is not a shock, it is a muscle stimulation. Chiropractors use muscle stimulation and the collar is the same. If you've ever had a actual shock from electricity the feeling is much, much different than muscle stimulation. I've had muscle stimulation every few months for my back and I've been shocked by electricity. Even low voltage is very different.
I agree it is negative and unpleasant feeling, but so is a prong collar.
 
But positive reinforcement can achieve similar results. I agree with Victoria Stilwell, on "It's Me or the Dog". Shock Collars I have a feeling I'm about to get in trouble on here again....
I guess i wasn't clear.. I don't disapprove of your training methods in the slightest, i just have a higher rate of success sticking with what i know and 100% positive reinforcement training is completely out of my realm of understanding.. Frankly i wish i had better success with it but im just old school and don't understand how or when to praise a dog when it pees on the floor. 50/50 is what works for me.. Scold and Praise when warranted.. For example going so far as to rub their noses in their own excrement on the other hand is plain abuse. I think my line is a reasonable one and pretty much how i raised my kids..
 
Respectfully it is not a shock, it is a muscle stimulation. Chiropractors use muscle stimulation and the collar is the same. If you've ever had a actual shock from electricity the feeling is much, much different than muscle stimulation. I've had muscle stimulation every few months for my back and I've been shocked by electricity. Even low voltage is very different.
I agree it is negative and unpleasant feeling, but so is a prong collar.
Call it what you will there is nothing even remotely pleasant about it.. It may not cause pain per say but it does hurt and that what makes them so effective.. lol imagine your employer strapping one to your neck and using them to keep their employees awake and productive and calling it a little stimulation..
 
Going way OT now, but speaking of the TENS unit, I had hubby try it for his back and told him to turn it up as high as he could stand it since that's what I do. I had to laugh watching him jump and squirm every time it pulsed so needless to say he turned it down a bit. ;)
 
I had to laugh watching him jump and squirm every time it pulsed
When the chiropractor hooked it up to my back my left leg was twitching and flopping like a fish out of water. It was very uncomfortable but didn't hurt. I called for the doc and asked him if that was normal or should it be turned down - he turned it down so apparently it wasn't normal lol
 
Lol and you have my big bad fiance deciding he'll start on the highest level when we first got it... He uses it on a 3 or 4 now instead of 10 haha... I typically have it set on 4... Sometimes 4.5 depending on the day. For me it's one of those deal with it and it feels better when I'm done... The higher stim I can handle the better I feel so if it's a bad day I try to go a little higher than normal.

Sent from my LG-H900 using Tapatalk
 

Back
Top