• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Dogs in Europe Vs the US - eCollars

LifeofRubie

Moderator
I've been in some interesting and open discussions with a Dobe owner who lives in the UK (I believe) about how dogs are trained in Europe vs the US. Her comments were that she can't believe how many dogs in the US she see's on Instagram with eCollars on because they're hardly used in Europe.

She's not opposed to them, per say, but she thinks people in the US rely too heavily on them instead of putting the time in to actually doing recall training (a general statement).

My opinion is that dogs in Europe grow up used to being off leash in public, for the most part, and are accustomed to being generally ignored where in the US, leash laws are very prevalent so something like meeting other dogs on leash, which can cause most dogs to be very reactive, is always a concern. Also, we're such a dog loving society in the US that I think we do ourselves a disservice by trying to greet every dog we see - Moo and Rubie are the most relaxed in Public when they're being ignored by the people around them.

She actually just got an eCollar to educate herself with and how it's used (which I'm very appreciative of - understand it before you bash it!) and she believes that a training tool, when used correctly, is not a bad thing. I believe she's training to be a dog behavior specialist and is currently training someone else's dog (like a board and train kinda thing) and that the eCollar is for that dog, not her own.

We have people from all over here so I was curious as to what your thoughts were. Is the environment in which dogs are raised in the US vs Europe different enough that we do rely on the eCollar too much or is it a necessity when giving our dogs freedom? I wouldn't call anyone on this forum 'lazy' when it comes to the importance of recall training but I know a lot of us do use eCollars because that's a non-negotiable, safety command. So how do they get by without them in Europe?

She says her Dobe is high prey drive and will listen to recall the first time 99% of the time. Is she being too lax about that 1% when it doesn't work? Is she being over confident in her dog?

I was very adamant that we did not train recall WITH the eCollar but we do use it to reinforce which I think is a very clear distinction of it being used correctly vs not.

Like I said, a very good and open conversation and I know she's generally for positive reinforcement training so I was surprised she got an eCollar and engaged in conversation with her to get a different perspective. I don't think either is right or wrong... but I do find it interesting how different the environments are and can't help but wonder if that has an effect on training.

Disclaimer: there are a lot of generalized statements above because we were talking in generalities based on what people post on the internet and making assumptions
 
Sounds like a very worth while and open discussion.

Here in Australia I think the use of eCollars is often as an anti-bark aid, or as a deterrent to unwanted behaviour of some kind, ie digging, or, in rural areas to stop livestock bothering. I haven't seen many dogs with eCollars on walking with their owners, but am not sure how many people use them as a training aid. Not sure how the off leash thing compares to Britain, but it is a bit unusual to see someone with their dog in a public area unleashed, unless it is a designated area. In fact there is usually a sign somewhere saying dogs on leashes only, and that includes most parks! :(

There is a bias against both eCollars and prong collars here, in the general publics mind anyway.
 
Great topic. My short answer is that the ecollar would cover that 1% chance that the dog fails to recall. Literally a safety measure.

But why does he fail to recall? Because of his intelligence. A thinking dog will always follow his curiosity. Don't we? The saying, "Curiosity killed the cat", dogs are the same, if not worse. Cats don't get themselves killed as easily as dogs.

I think in North America we are way too in love with our dogs and we are a bit over the top with safety measures for that reason. Myself included - don't shoot the messenger! For Dobes in particular I think the fact they run so damn fast is an issue. Being a dominant dog that likes to run up to people and do a bark and hold because they think they own the place, this is a major factor for me. I can't risk that behavior because it might get him into trouble and I don't want that for him or for us. If I had a little fluffy dog, I wouldn't train it beyond basic obedience and I wouldn't even bother with ecollars or the millions of other things this Doberdude requires. Oh and I would totally take it to the dog park! Not that a small dog requires that.

A Doberman is more like an asset. You have to guard your guard dog :dobe: I know :rolleyes:

High prey drive and no ecollar? I suppose it could be possible. Does she work her Doberman or is the dog a pet? I think a pet lifestyle for the dog and the owner is way easier than having the dog work. Working dogs = Committment
 
It comes down to this: that 1% (which lets be real, its probably greater than 1%) is a risk she is willing to take. It is not a risk Im willing to take.

Im the more intelligent creature. My dog doesn't understand that if it chases prey across a road that it may get hit by a car and die. My dog is a being that can make mistakes and wrong choices. Its my job to protect them. Dont judge me for protecting my dog because its not what you would do.

I do think theres more room for freedom here but with more risks. I see Judiths (UK member) pics of her two offleash and its wide open sheep fields and no danger of traffic anywhere. So now while you may have only a 1% chance of your well trained dog ignoring you but even less of a chance of any real danger.
 
I should have added that I am for both the prong collar and the eCollar as training tools. The prong collar has proved itself to me and the eCollar has made a huge difference to Jazzies attentiveness and general obedience even with just the initial very basic conditioning, with no trauma and very little confusion, all on very low stim. Personally I don't think it really matters if a Doberman is a pet or a working dog, if there is a way for them to safely have more freedom, why not use it?
 
Locally, I see very very few dogs with training collars. Even fewer that are actually under control. So I wish *more* people would use them, if it meant more trained dogs. I've lost count of how many times a dog has run up on us because it was either off leash (with no control from the owner what so ever), slipped it's regular collar or just plain pulled away from them. Just last night we had a guy with two bullies have one get loose. Fortunately, we did not have our dogs at the time and she was a sweetheart, but we were a mere 20 feet from a busy road. These two dogs were dragging him! And he was not a tiny guy. But they were good sized, strong dogs. What if we hadn't been there to intercept? What if she had run up on someone armed and scared of her (not far fetched considering the breed ... Nothing against pits, she really was sweet, but we know how ignorant the general public can be in regards to certain breeds). There are SO many ways that could have gone terribly wrong and it would have been preventable had these dogs been trained and under better control.

Within reason, I don't care *how* someone trains, so long as they actually DO it.

The UK is also vastly different than the majority of the US in a lot of ways in regards to dogs. Not better, not worse ... Just different. It's like comparing apples to oranges, imo. Like stated above, most pictures I see of offleash dogs in the UK, there's no signs of other people, traffic, etc anywhere nearby. Most of us in the US don't get that luxury :) you'd be hard-pressed to find a large area that is free of humans, traffic, other dogs, etc that it would be safe to have your dog offleash, where I am. And I'm quite rural ATM.
 
Hmmm.....

Is it law to wear seatbelts in Europe? Because I really like the seatbelt analogy in this situation.

I can’t help but to think how much easier and safer it is to train mine with the ECollar.

I was just discussing this with my eldest daughter last night. We went to the soccer fields and Ragnar did great!! (Gosh, he is getting sooo much better).

She asks, if he is better, than why do you still have the ECollar on him? I told her that it is insurance.

There is just no guarantee, at this time, that he will not go disrupting a soccer game AGAIN chasing their soccer ball or see another dog and aggressively run to it, wanting to play. So, either tied down to me by a leash or use an ECollar with some directed restrictions governed?? He and I would much rather use the ECollar. And, it’s gotten to the point in which I hardly use it anymore....kinda like the seat belt, have it on just in case.
 
She asks, if he is better, than why do you still have the ECollar on him? I told her that it is insurance.
Although he's pretty reliable with his recall, letting the dog off leash always requires a lot of analysis of the situation. My hb just thought with time and training K would be able to go without an ecollar, but now that he is a more serious dog and less tolerant of other dogs, I would add that "reducing human stress" is another reason to use this collar. The play bowing donkey boy seems to be changing his tune in public. From this vantage point, it would have been better to get him collared up about a year ago. A young dog needs it to cap his youthful exuberance, a mature dog needs it to cap his confidence. Seeing this helps me understand why so many better trained dogs are still using ecollars.
 
Great topic. My short answer is that the ecollar would cover that 1% chance that the dog fails to recall. Literally a safety measure.

But why does he fail to recall? Because of his intelligence. A thinking dog will always follow his curiosity. Don't we? The saying, "Curiosity killed the cat", dogs are the same, if not worse. Cats don't get themselves killed as easily as dogs.

I think in North America we are way too in love with our dogs and we are a bit over the top with safety measures for that reason. Myself included - don't shoot the messenger! For Dobes in particular I think the fact they run so damn fast is an issue. Being a dominant dog that likes to run up to people and do a bark and hold because they think they own the place, this is a major factor for me. I can't risk that behavior because it might get him into trouble and I don't want that for him or for us. If I had a little fluffy dog, I wouldn't train it beyond basic obedience and I wouldn't even bother with ecollars or the millions of other things this Doberdude requires. Oh and I would totally take it to the dog park! Not that a small dog requires that.

A Doberman is more like an asset. You have to guard your guard dog :dobe: I know :rolleyes:

High prey drive and no ecollar? I suppose it could be possible. Does she work her Doberman or is the dog a pet? I think a pet lifestyle for the dog and the owner is way easier than having the dog work. Working dogs = Committment

Ah, yes, all too familiar with the bark and hold :rolleyes: it's usually only when Rubie is caught off guard that she'll do that but I can always call her away BECAUSE... we train recall AND she's on her eCollar if she's off leash. If she doesn't turn the moment I call, she gets a reminder and snaps to attention. And you're right: we need to guard our dogs.

She 'works' in as far as training and stuff but no competition anything that I'm aware of.

And yes, as far as Moo NOT being a Doberman, I really struggle with his training. I want him to be as good or better than Rubie, but he is a totally different type of dog. He doesn't *need* a CGC title to work in his favor, basic obedience would be plenty enough because he's just so... easy. I do want to compete with him in something at some point so he will get more training above and beyond basic but it's been very interesting seeing just how different he is than Rubie.

It comes down to this: that 1% (which lets be real, its probably greater than 1%) is a risk she is willing to take. It is not a risk Im willing to take.

Im the more intelligent creature. My dog doesn't understand that if it chases prey across a road that it may get hit by a car and die. My dog is a being that can make mistakes and wrong choices. Its my job to protect them. Dont judge me for protecting my dog because its not what you would do.

I do think theres more room for freedom here but with more risks. I see Judiths (UK member) pics of her two offleash and its wide open sheep fields and no danger of traffic anywhere. So now while you may have only a 1% chance of your well trained dog ignoring you but even less of a chance of any real danger.

And that's my thinking, too. I am NOT willing to take that risk and recall is non-negotiable. When she and I were talking, she said that her dog will go after a squirrel here and there and it will take a couple of calls to her to get her back. I have a friend who's dog was impaled in the chest by a stick in the woods when she went after a squirrel and didn't come when called. She's fine now but can you imagine!

And to your point about the actual physical location, you're absolutely right. We have traffic, people, kids on bikes, other dogs, all the things I need to protect my dog from. Even when we're at my parents house and they have tons of room, there are bears, snakes, coyotes, a neighbor with a distaste of dogs and a shotgun, and other creatures that could cause harm. The biggest predator in Ireland is foxes (we found out) which I'm sure could do damage but something I'd be less concerned with, overall.

Locally, I see very very few dogs with training collars. Even fewer that are actually under control. So I wish *more* people would use them, if it meant more trained dogs. I've lost count of how many times a dog has run up on us because it was either off leash (with no control from the owner what so ever), slipped it's regular collar or just plain pulled away from them. Just last night we had a guy with two bullies have one get loose. Fortunately, we did not have our dogs at the time and she was a sweetheart, but we were a mere 20 feet from a busy road. These two dogs were dragging him! And he was not a tiny guy. But they were good sized, strong dogs. What if we hadn't been there to intercept? What if she had run up on someone armed and scared of her (not far fetched considering the breed ... Nothing against pits, she really was sweet, but we know how ignorant the general public can be in regards to certain breeds). There are SO many ways that could have gone terribly wrong and it would have been preventable had these dogs been trained and under better control.

Within reason, I don't care *how* someone trains, so long as they actually DO it.

The UK is also vastly different than the majority of the US in a lot of ways in regards to dogs. Not better, not worse ... Just different. It's like comparing apples to oranges, imo. Like stated above, most pictures I see of offleash dogs in the UK, there's no signs of other people, traffic, etc anywhere nearby. Most of us in the US don't get that luxury :) you'd be hard-pressed to find a large area that is free of humans, traffic, other dogs, etc that it would be safe to have your dog offleash, where I am. And I'm quite rural ATM.

YES. We see this ALL THE TIME. I've ranted once or twice about how people look at Rubie like she's a rabid werewolf as we walk by nicely and their dogs are at the end of their retractable leases attached to ill-fitting harnesses, on two legs, barking like maniacs. When we're out with them, we get the, "Oh, my dog would NEVER behave this well in this setting!" Well, that's your fault and your fault alone.

It is very different which makes me so interested! The lady I was talking with was like, Well have you trained recall with a long lead? Yes, I've done it all since the day I brought Dingo home. I do it even now in the back yard with both dogs without them even realizing it. I really think she thinks people use it in-lieu of other training and that by putting A LOT of time in with her dog, she's a better human being - as if we haven't all put in hours of training.

I will say, we stayed in Dublin, Cork, and Killarney, all three very large cities with bustling people and traffic and saw off-leash dogs in all three. When we went to Howth and places like Ross Castle, it was less busy with cars but there were people, birds, other off leash dogs, outdoor restaurants and they all ignored everything.

We did see a Chow on leash with a muzzle BUT I think that's because Ireland has laws around certain breeds and that they have to be muzzled when in public (although I don't think Dobes have made that list - yet).

Hmmm.....

Is it law to wear seatbelts in Europe? Because I really like the seatbelt analogy in this situation.

I can’t help but to think how much easier and safer it is to train mine with the ECollar.

I was just discussing this with my eldest daughter last night. We went to the soccer fields and Ragnar did great!! (Gosh, he is getting sooo much better).

She asks, if he is better, than why do you still have the ECollar on him? I told her that it is insurance.

There is just no guarantee, at this time, that he will not go disrupting a soccer game AGAIN chasing their soccer ball or see another dog and aggressively run to it, wanting to play. So, either tied down to me by a leash or use an ECollar with some directed restrictions governed?? He and I would much rather use the ECollar. And, it’s gotten to the point in which I hardly use it anymore....kinda like the seat belt, have it on just in case.

I'm really glad you like that analogy and I'm glad your talking to your daughter about it in an educated way. I'm sure you've told her that a lot of people don't see it the same way and that a difference of opinion is OK when respectfully voiced. And I agree, I WANT Rubie to explore and run and be a dog BUT I want to know that she will always come to me, no matter what the distraction or appeal to go the opposite direction. Train as we do, I cannot guarantee a 100% recall all the time. I'm glad Ragnar is doing so well!

This guy we saw in Howth while we were eating. He was actually more interested in the Chow than us but was sneaking around our table, watching him. I think he and another border collie were actually inside the restaurant but would casually make their way outside now and again to watch what was going on
9RDvzzI1bD8RJEnB8pBf1WllllR5_Vpbfr7vYbapay4UdsUyqG61d2_AAZmY88D989GY8K5go5TrmeoWcB5LR-3YxehlYMJUZtOsR2f8ENiVITeIybuQcnZz6xEXIHhI8BI4ydQC3L9vQPihLvl5QF2Hn92Q3bE3pJv61t-RB5d2kmFPzAmIBRIix-UIOC2k4scAj8roBqPmy5wRPfj6FBz21XMA7qiAKRNkOMgQlo4iXR_y9klVeVQoKnEbPI-gvB2bt6wJ-g1Jyv7pmD_MYO9TbMLSIN7do87eEZeUXzeA35YZ7RkVnnsftX84-rOHH_HrCAS5WhOcle2zs3JfLr67XaDzJXtgjqqvFs4ptzhbWiPYVanadV61Igt5V9dhZiNI229z8_IYQVZTFqnwkf1jYhchQn2B_4THfl6EUKB8cOQdtUctVk8wPoCyr29HmQb4jP91nSC8JtjRkLnf2XR1_62pu4r5qhC5ees7bNfZppKwwZvwwzEgNIQDKZ7VxAJHmcqKx7f1-Er5XtYNzqn0mAZUTJ2MOyAHCLXeCjtwhBkjnhB9XRaI82FRiqKbeNz6VLHpXTOV_txwrdOhRUUAf4kNdxiocdcv-JQyE4b2Y8HAU1elFpchXu-eaooyxGX5T1QgiUtNX18xDcr5IK7T39lGj0g1me6ry3vswhhbxDe2jHq5HIDADA=w987-h740-no



This was in Cork. We'd actually seen these guys walking around from atop a bell tower and then came across them waiting for their owner who was in the store. The husky looking dog was on leash but the other guy was totally off leash.
ZBBaqPiSa5aUDDcVpqXGPKGs6f-jEVcHuMI_EMLYNzCHN0JTsJBDrsmOUNmtCN9buJ5eQO_pCi5Yf-aXuvldLrN5lrPpsJW4eCPwruw0_mCFSDOCPuSATsY2W-m8v5atEOaE2Q7m7iPyjDwIk6vql6eZY54zOtVYp8zLSAzJ-prsPoPQhhxaJGny3jtDU1Q-PYadyui4hhbcPUoN2nOFp0qhERe3sQCsVASWT-YSJ-dNOmfmnSNsCpnRbxJuW9dvUzI_p6w794mp_RsFVjVClR3lJercz4mhpJHFrLDSwAgHkMOQHuyYwa2PrfEWTx525n-2IfPts9i7FTuxKFRUbftk_5iAqcfwZemanU9dFK_1uvqv6qgOc9pJuxF5fyXxmZifT6gSJaKNvAEW386nWF6VjalKIfjVPro27n2Ny8UyKjCi0af9matm95Z-LGcICqk0VJBPzQieUMGFIBetLLVrDJTOL8Zv89A7JA_Cd80FUFDK0P65jGxER9ug4FHm9QNDy4HUVBEateOao0UhvFwNB0ezSJyh62qjvuYsr9xkqdMBdYWfmDBHdRG9NriHRHaiGMYycNa3rLXMxr0HM6bX2NHVpraO9ZsKCruiY_I5NeYKSkn2vqlibBtMKTlbD_6Tb6aZi9PCNjF9SfsCUBc7N7NXdKQUbzjq2QGjur1yEKLckXZ6Gdgzvw=w987-h740-no


And this was at Ross Castle. Cars. Horses. Other dogs. People everywhere. She could not have cared less. The moment her owner said her name (as she was about to cross a street with cars pulling in), she came right to her.
T4lTaC41lsdDonq1RYbNITgA-uMyDqrKBwjHUW6u8F6Vf_Rn4Eb0J7R5S7Yn7v3GuNcynLJFB_FDqMKbzli3V5zcOX-RGZ1doQYydiFUZ-T_FvAo6di-rwKFr0KB-ilx1SyvVxPquSteGyV6KvAil4nUDMwwOXYJ68aFVDrANpOo0lpaLmBVDRkMjhZRAcL-oR3KGfq-EcuP5Sj2UQnUaX-76ahKxEohgtMVY1g6CadUSWxRaHV6euhnqubftkrJvKKEz7g85MypFeQ4lpOw3BmPZx7YHPPXtQZOblcj4ANAEMWVxEP0Qy355uB3ib_C2Qe-fsPb_uLOpFhtxIkB7dGY9NNhxDeLm7SzXLKh_gQ9Waz05sfmNLZrkHZn24EHbiSjmH1ek4qjJZWOV4QGPoU5_oLNe6VvCpBxpIA9HSp67Xd2eeudIRA3jTKjpbcIWOh-V7uHbY9WCYaI6Lupj-JvAj1oYsoOrhMnbo2KychTjuged414967sCIGm7ToSYHpuhCvPprfh-JiX4Bdxa_EWS2AT9sKlIRP2BSIPkhVXrmAeWTC2hDiyPVFgDSjoaHwSMi4gOiUISFxuRC6fFi93HA8PyB1Ew5_duk1vp2g9rLOJbzBsWC4RljOdDuAl5oV0H4vFrzsc6pTA13-V6EWQa_nmzEFmBgWIyF6oD82uCvfXCyk6fhH0Ig=w987-h740-no



It made me wonder... I'm sure Moo would excel in this environment but would a Dobe like Rubie? If raised in this environment, would their bark and hold dwindle and their recall be totally different? The one trainer who works with our normal trainer is very much a 'make your dog think for themselves and reward them when they make the right decision.' Are these dogs being raised to think for themselves more and CAN be more reliable by default?

This is starting to sound like a child-rearing thread and the difference between being a hands-off, figure-it-out-yourself parents vs a hold your hand, helicopter parent :woot2::woot2: Sorry!
 
I think it is true that some dogs are able to achieve the casual off leash life. My previous dog was a cattle dog cross, and after about 3 years could go anywhere without even a collar. This included being left at home with no yard, no tether, nothing. At the time hubby was still alive and we sometimes needed to be away overnight and dear old Freckles would just stay and wait. There was a lot of training involved to start with, mostly about not chasing cattle and wildlife, the staying with me just sort of happened as we live where there is little to worry us, probably like rural areas in Europe. No way would I have asked her to just hang outside a shop though and when we went to city areas she was always on leash. She would have been fine, but the general public and their dogs tended to be unpredictable.

Now Jazz is a totally different dog. My end goal for her is to be able to be as reliable out in our own environment as my other dog was, but because of her breeding and looks I won't ever be as casual about her freedom. People perceive her very differently, and she attracts much more attention, both in a good way and a bad way. I need to be able to absolutely know that she is where she is meant to be at all times in case of any trouble in the neighbourhood. This also goes for absolutely knowing that I have her under control out in public, we are always under scrutiny, so I'm afraid that it means I have to be a bit of a control freak! :facepalm:
 
People perceive her very differently, and she attracts much more attention, both in a good way and a bad way. I need to be able to absolutely know that she is where she is meant to be at all times in case of any trouble in the neighbourhood. This also goes for absolutely knowing that I have her under control out in public, we are always under scrutiny, so I'm afraid that it means I have to be a bit of a control freak! :facepalm:

It's no accident Dobes are generally very well behaved in public. I think a lot of people share your sentiment.
 
Two of the most famous dog trainers in the world Bart Bellon (Belgium) and Ivan Balabanov (USA) are both advocates of e-collars. Of course they don't train the 'average pet' dogs. They train high level competition dogs.
Personally I rather someone use an e-collar vs the old school 'yank and crank' methods. However like any tool e-collars can be abused. We always start out using motivational methods and only introduce corrections later once the dog has learned the behavior.
 
I really think she thinks people use it in-lieu of other training and that by putting A LOT of time in with her dog, she's a better human being - as if we haven't all put in hours of training.

...

It made me wonder... I'm sure Moo would excel in this environment but would a Dobe like Rubie?

...

This is starting to sound like a child-rearing thread and the difference between being a hands-off, figure-it-out-yourself parents vs a hold your hand, helicopter parent :woot2::woot2: Sorry!

Haha, we are totally in helicopter mode, but if people only knew how much time was being spent training and playing-to-train. It's like full time dogging. And people dare to talk about crazy cat ladies?!

The dogs in the pictures are really out there totally free...no one gets hit by a car, they don't chase bikes? A horse has never been spooked and trampled a dog?

Moo isn't classed as a dangerous breed and his easier nature would make him a way better candidate for that lifestyle vs our breed living an urban lifestyle.
 
It really does boil down to the actual dog. My old husky was never reliable off leash. He wasn't mean, though. He just liked to go greet *everyone* and every animal he saw and would take off after bunnies. I tried everything to get him to a point that he atleast had a recall, it was still really iffy when he passed at 9. So he never got to be offleash outside.

My lab has a recall, but he's not the stereotypical loves everyone, happy go lucky lab that people are accustomed to. He's Mr. I put people in bark holds for wandering into our campsite. Everyone who meets him ends up wondering if he's mixed because his personality is so NOT lab. Not food motivated, doesn't care for strangers, Kaizer retrieves better, etc.

Kaizer has a killer recall. But ... Everyone is terrified of him. Lmao. I get it though, he's around 125 pounds now and that alone is intimidating as hell. I'd be too worried someone would shoot him out of fear.

But our society is so .... Different. If someone left their dog outside a store here, even leashed to something, people would be calling the cops and the dog could very likely be seized. So we don't even have a chance to train our dogs in the same way.

The few people I DO see with off leash dogs .... Well, I wish they WOULD leash them. One instigates fights with other dogs and charges people. And this dog lives a literal block from the only park in town and is often unleashed in the yard, taking off after passerby. Leash, e-collar, tether ... I really don't care, whatever they need to do to keep that dog in it's own yard. You can't even walk on the opposite side of the street without him coming at you. And it's not particularly friendly either, he's yet to bite, but he does run up on you growling with hackles up.

So I dunno. I think I'd still be a dedicated leash user. Just to be extra safe. Any dog can bite. Any dog can run into a person or animal it just doesn't like. And there are too many trigger happy morons in our country.
 
I'm in the UK, and while I don't use the eCollar myself, I don't hate on people that use it either. It can be a good tool, if its used correctly.

My dogs are only really leashed next to roads, mainly for common sense & to give drivers peace of mind - because they don't know anything about my dogs and if they'll jump out in front of them or not.

My dogs recall are 100%, even if they're chasing rabbits, if I call them they'll come straight back.

We generally walk at a heel if other dogs are leashed, and I'll release them once we're passed.


I train dogs in the RAF Police and we don't use training collars for our training.

If something works for you and your dog, then you should continue to use it as a training tool, I wouldn't care about the opinions of others
 
I wasn't sure quite where to post this but I think it ties in with this thread well.

This morning there was an incident, (well actually, there WASN'T an incident, which is the point!), where Jazz and I were walking along a track and suddenly came across someone out with their dog. Jazz was off leash but with her ecollar on, and the other dog was off leash but luckily wasn't interested in coming over. About 75 yards away, and Jazz spotted this dog and wanted to engage in play. The dog looked like her sometimes playmate, but I knew that this was an English Staffie with aggression issues! :shock:

Jazz focused and then made a determined bolt towards them, I called and gave stim, she halted for a moment then another rush, another call and +2stim. Halted again but still didn't look back or come, so another call and stim. She came back 20yards and then looked back to the dog, another stim! It took probably 5 seperate stims to get her to return all the way to me. (All the time the owner of the other dog is calling out "good morning", I was too focused on Jazz to reply until I had her back.) Should just note that I chose not to up the stim level as she was feeling it and responding, upping the pain doesn't help the brain I find!

Now this is exactly what I think an ecollar is for. It wasn't pretty, but I won the round, and the situation could have been very nasty if I hadn't managed to get control of Jazz. This was an extreme test of the ecollar, and an important one to win as next time it is already established that I WILL be obeyed, no matter what.
 
Great job!!

Prevented a dangerous situation and at the same time Jazzie is freely moving about.....
 
Great job!!

Prevented a dangerous situation and at the same time Jazzie is freely moving about.....
Well, she was freely moving about before the incident, then was leashed for a while after the incident. She was hyped up and inclined to be frustrated so there was some settling down to be done. Only in the flat collar so I just asked her for a formal walk and quietly persisted with that until she settled and became compliant again. We went in another direction and as soon as she was relaxed let her off leash and we continued as normal. So not quite as instant as all that but a good lesson anyway! :biggrin:
 
Ugh, I hate these types of encounters because anything can happen, but it’s great to hear you were able to get her back. We need dumber dogs!
 
I don't think we could ever settle for a dumber dog! :rofl:

Realistically I think these sort of encounters are just a part of dog ownership unless you are willing to keep them totally confined all the time. :facepalm:
 

Back
Top