LifeofRubie
Moderator
I've been in some interesting and open discussions with a Dobe owner who lives in the UK (I believe) about how dogs are trained in Europe vs the US. Her comments were that she can't believe how many dogs in the US she see's on Instagram with eCollars on because they're hardly used in Europe.
She's not opposed to them, per say, but she thinks people in the US rely too heavily on them instead of putting the time in to actually doing recall training (a general statement).
My opinion is that dogs in Europe grow up used to being off leash in public, for the most part, and are accustomed to being generally ignored where in the US, leash laws are very prevalent so something like meeting other dogs on leash, which can cause most dogs to be very reactive, is always a concern. Also, we're such a dog loving society in the US that I think we do ourselves a disservice by trying to greet every dog we see - Moo and Rubie are the most relaxed in Public when they're being ignored by the people around them.
She actually just got an eCollar to educate herself with and how it's used (which I'm very appreciative of - understand it before you bash it!) and she believes that a training tool, when used correctly, is not a bad thing. I believe she's training to be a dog behavior specialist and is currently training someone else's dog (like a board and train kinda thing) and that the eCollar is for that dog, not her own.
We have people from all over here so I was curious as to what your thoughts were. Is the environment in which dogs are raised in the US vs Europe different enough that we do rely on the eCollar too much or is it a necessity when giving our dogs freedom? I wouldn't call anyone on this forum 'lazy' when it comes to the importance of recall training but I know a lot of us do use eCollars because that's a non-negotiable, safety command. So how do they get by without them in Europe?
She says her Dobe is high prey drive and will listen to recall the first time 99% of the time. Is she being too lax about that 1% when it doesn't work? Is she being over confident in her dog?
I was very adamant that we did not train recall WITH the eCollar but we do use it to reinforce which I think is a very clear distinction of it being used correctly vs not.
Like I said, a very good and open conversation and I know she's generally for positive reinforcement training so I was surprised she got an eCollar and engaged in conversation with her to get a different perspective. I don't think either is right or wrong... but I do find it interesting how different the environments are and can't help but wonder if that has an effect on training.
Disclaimer: there are a lot of generalized statements above because we were talking in generalities based on what people post on the internet and making assumptions
She's not opposed to them, per say, but she thinks people in the US rely too heavily on them instead of putting the time in to actually doing recall training (a general statement).
My opinion is that dogs in Europe grow up used to being off leash in public, for the most part, and are accustomed to being generally ignored where in the US, leash laws are very prevalent so something like meeting other dogs on leash, which can cause most dogs to be very reactive, is always a concern. Also, we're such a dog loving society in the US that I think we do ourselves a disservice by trying to greet every dog we see - Moo and Rubie are the most relaxed in Public when they're being ignored by the people around them.
She actually just got an eCollar to educate herself with and how it's used (which I'm very appreciative of - understand it before you bash it!) and she believes that a training tool, when used correctly, is not a bad thing. I believe she's training to be a dog behavior specialist and is currently training someone else's dog (like a board and train kinda thing) and that the eCollar is for that dog, not her own.
We have people from all over here so I was curious as to what your thoughts were. Is the environment in which dogs are raised in the US vs Europe different enough that we do rely on the eCollar too much or is it a necessity when giving our dogs freedom? I wouldn't call anyone on this forum 'lazy' when it comes to the importance of recall training but I know a lot of us do use eCollars because that's a non-negotiable, safety command. So how do they get by without them in Europe?
She says her Dobe is high prey drive and will listen to recall the first time 99% of the time. Is she being too lax about that 1% when it doesn't work? Is she being over confident in her dog?
I was very adamant that we did not train recall WITH the eCollar but we do use it to reinforce which I think is a very clear distinction of it being used correctly vs not.
Like I said, a very good and open conversation and I know she's generally for positive reinforcement training so I was surprised she got an eCollar and engaged in conversation with her to get a different perspective. I don't think either is right or wrong... but I do find it interesting how different the environments are and can't help but wonder if that has an effect on training.
Disclaimer: there are a lot of generalized statements above because we were talking in generalities based on what people post on the internet and making assumptions


you'd be hard-pressed to find a large area that is free of humans, traffic, other dogs, etc that it would be safe to have your dog offleash, where I am. And I'm quite rural ATM.

