kaloric
Well-Known Member
I saw this on Neatorama earlier today, it seems relevant to this board.
http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/thoughtful-animal/2012/05/31/do-dogs-feel-guilty/
I do have anecdotes, though, which are more entertaining than "competent research" though.
Kira registers no guilt whatsoever when she has done something like performed a shredding on something she wasn't supposed to. However, when she's had an accident in the house while I was away, it's really easy to tell.
I know if she's done that before I can even smell or find the mess. If she's had a good day, she is a super excited happy puppy, zooming around the house. If she has had an accident, she usually is a lot more calm, sometimes she just makes herself a little scarce until I find and clean-up the mess, then it's time for zoomies because the problem is gone, and it's like it never even happened. "A mess in the house? I don't remember any mess in the house!"
I'm not really sure what's up with that behavior even, while I sometimes grumble a little under my breath or gag while cleaning things up, it's never directed at her because I don't want her to associate me getting home with me being grouchy. Coming home is happy time, after all! It just seems to be pure guilt and the lack of the ability to make the evidence of a slightly fouled den vanish that is bothering her, not an expectation of being scolded for any reason.
I wish I had photos of doggy guilt to share. It's so cute even when it means there's bound to be a headache lurking right around the corner.
http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/thoughtful-animal/2012/05/31/do-dogs-feel-guilty/
I do have anecdotes, though, which are more entertaining than "competent research" though.
Kira registers no guilt whatsoever when she has done something like performed a shredding on something she wasn't supposed to. However, when she's had an accident in the house while I was away, it's really easy to tell.
I know if she's done that before I can even smell or find the mess. If she's had a good day, she is a super excited happy puppy, zooming around the house. If she has had an accident, she usually is a lot more calm, sometimes she just makes herself a little scarce until I find and clean-up the mess, then it's time for zoomies because the problem is gone, and it's like it never even happened. "A mess in the house? I don't remember any mess in the house!"
I'm not really sure what's up with that behavior even, while I sometimes grumble a little under my breath or gag while cleaning things up, it's never directed at her because I don't want her to associate me getting home with me being grouchy. Coming home is happy time, after all! It just seems to be pure guilt and the lack of the ability to make the evidence of a slightly fouled den vanish that is bothering her, not an expectation of being scolded for any reason.
I wish I had photos of doggy guilt to share. It's so cute even when it means there's bound to be a headache lurking right around the corner.



No wonder she was in her bed. She knew she did bad and she was staying away from me. Guilt? I'm thinking!