What is the difference in these 2 types of Harness? Is one "better" for the dog? Luca has the style on the right. But i see alot of the style on the left too. Just curious.
I don't know if one is "better" than the other. I have a similar style to the one on the left for Archer. Faustus has the one on the right. I now prefer Archer's harness.
I'm not a harness user but am just curious about why you are considering one for your dobe. The general consensus is that harnesses are for pulling without putting pressure on the dog's trachea. You see dobermans wearing harnesses for tracking, protection work and even dog sledding but for general walking on leash not so much.
I'm not a harness user at all either, but to me it looks like the one on the right would stay in place much better when it has the strap that runs between the front legs. Have you checked out the ones that Katja sells? Dog Harnesses
It is mainly a matter of preference, which style you like the best. The one on the left is called the Scandinavian style harness and the on on the right is a Y-harness, named that due to it's shape. The Scandinavian modle is most popular in Scandinavia, and the Y-harness is the most popular shape in the rest of Europe. Not sure how the popularity devices in the rest of the world.
The Y-harness gives more shoulder freedom and all the pressure is on the sternum where the other one has the pressure across the chest. I think the one on the left is used a lot in tracking and pulling where the Y-harness is used more for walking.
I have also gotten feedback that the Y-harness is great for hard-to-fit dogs.
I want Luca to be comfortable and used to wearing them as well as collar / leash combo. I had an experience as a child that had me heart broken. Our family boarded our dog with the same place we always did and s on a walk something happened and her collar came off during her walk. She was never found. Had she been on a harness that wouldn't have happened. Anyways, I like them and i already have one. I was just curious what the difference was really. Thanks for the feedback.
Also that style of harness is not so good for dobes because of their deep chests, movements like sitting can be a bit restrictive when the harness is tightly fitted. IMO
My Dobies use a Y harness do very well with them on. I've said this in a previous post the my dogs are rarely on a lead attached to their collars. I use their collars just for a place for ID tags. It's just my preference.
I use a half check for indi, however now she's getting the hang of recall and heel walking im thinking of getting her a harness to use with a long lead or flexi. I would buy a y shaped harness.
I use a half check for Alvin also for road walking and a harness for flexi etc when walking in nicer places so he can sniff about, his harness is a sporn harness where he steps into it, with a padded chest piece and padded bits for under his arms. I doubt id use one of those for a dobe though
I want Luca to be comfortable and used to wearing them as well as collar / leash combo. I had an experience as a child that had me heart broken. Our family boarded our dog with the same place we always did and s on a walk something happened and her collar came off during her walk. She was never found. Had she been on a harness that wouldn't have happened. Anyways, I like them and i already have one. I was just curious what the difference was really. Thanks for the feedback.
Alvin has a small head and has slipped his collar from time to time. I usually have a harness on him, his lead attached to a double ended chain with one on his collar and one end on his harness for safety, or you can buy short.little chains to connect harness to collar so if the collar comes off it's still attached to the harness.
I use the Ray Allen Patrol Harness-Heavy Duty, with a chest pad (making it a Y style harness). It can be a little tight, my harness has a stomach adjustment that makes it easier for the dog to move around. I'd post the links but I don't have enough posts.
I want Luca to be comfortable and used to wearing them as well as collar / leash combo. I had an experience as a child that had me heart broken. Our family boarded our dog with the same place we always did and s on a walk something happened and her collar came off during her walk. She was never found. Had she been on a harness that wouldn't have happened. Anyways, I like them and i already have one. I was just curious what the difference was really. Thanks for the feedback.
You may want to check out the No Pull Freedom Harness. It has a front ring and a top ring. I use the front ring rather than the top ring so that she does not pull quite as much.
Hello Guest!
We are glad you found us, if you find anything useful here please consider registering to see more content and get involved with our great community members, it takes less than a minute!
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.