Dealing With Guests

Oh Little Oji

Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
Hi all,

The title is somewhat tongue-in-cheek, but the question is serious:

I am especially asking those of you who have Dobes from Schutzhund, protection or other working-oriented lines.

I know I have asked already about whether Schutzhund Dobes can be reliable around family. The answer is of course yes – they should be and are supposed to be. But I had one that wasn't. That topic can hopefully be searched on the forum if anyone wants to read those exhanges.

But specifically, what are your experiences, and what are your routines, if any, surrounding dealing with guests entering and being at your home?

Do you simply introduce your Dobe to them and then it's all good from there? Or do you have to be strict and always in control of every situation, maybe commanding your Dobe to go to their spot and remain there?

I read of this technique years ago in a book (Maybe called The Home and Family Protection Dog?) where they have their dogs go to their spot and remain there instead of being allowed to socialize with the guests.

My Dobe i had prior to this last one did find with being introduced at the door with my okay command, then he could be allowed to just dwell and do whatever around the guests – even sidle up to them for rubs and scratches.

My most recent Dobe (Schutzhund breeding) couldn't be trusted. He might be able to accept a guest if I had him outside playing fetch, and the guest came out (escorted) and stood there and slowly got discovered. But later in the house, my boy would unpredictably "attack". He never bit anyone thank God, but he would launch at them very aggressively, going for their face.

I imagine he was just of unstable temperament. It seemed like he would freak and lash out.

So what are your experiences? I am seeking my next Dobe from a Schutzhund source and he must be safe and reliable around guests and of course all family!

Yes, I do train and, I believe, do a pretty good job of it.

Thanks!
 
HavIng a dog trained in schutzhund or other bite sports means that the dog has had extensive training in obedience. If trained and socialized properly these dogs are the most stable and reliable. It is the untrained dog that is the one to be worried about. Most of these dogs will bite out of fear or being unsure of a situation. Dogs with aggression issues are not typically the best choice for doing bite sports or protection. If you are buying from a breeder who trains schutzhund and has dogs with a stable temperament then the rest is up to you. Socialization at an early age and training is key, whether you want a working dog or just a well adjusted family pet. Litters can vary with the amount of actual working prospects produced so just because both parents may carry titles does not mean that all there offspring will be able to compete in the sport. Talk with you breeder to determine what puppy will best fit your needs.
 
It depends on the dog and the visitor. I know my two are friendly and can be trusted. When the movers were delivering our household goods they were wandering in and out of the house and yard (both strange men and our dogs) and no one had any problems at all. If the person is comfortable and calm then the dogs are made to sit while I open the door and allowed to greet the visitors once they are inside. This isn't always as controlled as it sounds but we try to keep it calm and controlled. After that one of four things happen, they are allowed to roam and visit, they are told to go to their bed in the living room and expected to stay there, they are put away in their crates, or they are put outside. It all depends on the situation. All of this takes time and training to get them to behave as you want in this highly exciting circumstance. If I had a dog that was not stable I would either crate them or put them outside because you still have to keep them and your visitors safe.
 
Great, keep it coming! Thanks for the good thoughts.

BTW, this is going to be a pup, not a trained adult. So I am asking about Dobes with this type of breeding. The issue of training is a given. He or she will be trained well (not to say I am a perfect trainer of course!)

My wife is understandably worried. My previous Dobe lashed out at her three separate times separated by months and years, and came close to doing the same to our 2 yr. old daughter. The main training problem I see that was definitely in place was that my wife never did much training with him and he very clearly did not respect her or feel he had to obey her. I imagine he saw himself as above her in the pack. I still feel the problem involved more than this though.

Wife says she wants a dog that will allow our daughter to have friends over with now worries. I feel this is a bit too much to ask. Of course I would hope a decently bred and trained Dobe would not get aggressive with a child unless the child/ren was torturing it a bit. But I also feel that this is not a Cavalier King Charles we are talking about here. It is a very special dog and carried with is some special considerations.

That said, I do want to be able to have the Dobe loose in the house/yard with guests be they adults or children.

More thoughts?

Much appreciated as we tackle this most important issue.
 
Not sure if this helps.

I start by saying my girl isn't Schutz trained.She's a simple family dog.

She's peculiar in that,some people for what ever reason she just doesn't like.
Early on I thought it had to do with size.She seems to be much less fond of men.Single male visitors especially.
But I threw out the size idea.First guy she just didn't like was 6'4" and about 300 lbs.So it led me to the above assumption.
A good friend of mine is 6'6" and about 290lbs.When he came to visit I thought she wasn't going to like him.As it turned out she welcomed him warmly.
Another guy I know is about 5'6" and might weigh 130lbs if I hosed him down first.He came to the door and she wanted his blood,growls,barks,teeth display,the works.Took about half an hour before I was(and my visitor) comfortable enough to take her off leash.
She's always been welcoming to kids,but toddlers scare the bejesus out of her.Knowing this I take a proactive attitude when one comes to visit.
Back to the size thing.A couple came to visit with a new baby.Lets just say they are both "large" people.She was very welcoming and very curious about the baby.You could see a shift in her,taking very soft steps and cautious that mama might not approve of her sniffing around.What's really cool was the fact that several months earlier they came to visit.She welcomed them,sniffing all over.She stuck her nose right in this woman's belly button.She was pregnant.Daisy sniffed that belly button,backed up,cocked her head and looked up at the woman and made soft steps when ever she was around her.She knew there was a baby in there!
 
I second Gel in that mine are not Schulz trained either; only family dogs. Having raised one Dobe with my 4 young kids and my current two with no small kids, I believe that if you want a dog that is kid-friendly, you must raise them with kids. My previous Dobe Shandie came home with us into a houseful of kids. It was all she knew. I never ever worried about her with kids of any size. My two girls now, like Gel's girl, are somewhat freaked by my wobbly curious toddler grand kids. They weren't raised with small kids, and just don't know quite what to make of them. Although I never allow them to show any assertive behavior towards the little kids, ( and they never have; but I don't let them bark at the kids or take their toys, etc) I also never take the chance, for the kids and the dogs alike, of leaving them alone together. ( They seem most freaked about little kids "chasing" them; they totally don't know what to make of it.). The difference is, at least for us, the fact that when my dogs were pups, there were no little kids around. If you get your pup and continually expose them to the movements, mannerisms and noise of toddlers and kids, ( i.e. your daughter and her friends), this will just be a part of life as they know it and it won't seem out of the ordinary or a cause for concern. Just my limited personal experience. While I feel I have "trained" my girls how to behave around our small kids, they don't have a natural, easy comfort about it. And because of that missing part of the puzzle, I always make sure the little kids and dogs are supervised. ( I know some will add that you should always supervise a dog and kids, and while I'm not disagreeing with that, I'm talking about the difference of bringing kids into a dog's life versus bringing a dog into your entire family's life.)
 
Thanks. Bear in mind that I am talking about the breeding of the Dobes in addition to the training. When I express concern over a Schutzhund-bred Doberman, it's over his/her breeding. Prior to getting my last Dobe, I wasn't a big believer in how much effect breeding could have on a particular breed. I was proven wrong. Very significant differences between my pet (admittedly backyard-bred) Dobe and my Dobe from a focused Schutzhund/working program.
Yes, I am also questioning whether the protection training aspect of Schutzhund could cause problems in a Dobe's reliability and ability to be harmless to family and friends.
Don't be offended, anyone. I ask questions. It's how I learn.
I still believe the ideal that a well-bred, well-trained Doberman from Schutzhund/working breeding should be rock-solid reliable and safe. I am just asking for your experiences and thoughts.
Thanks!
 
Any reputable breeder, that does health testing and breeds for proper temperament, can provide a great puppy. Are you planning on doing schutzhund with you new Doberman?
 
Doberman Gang, I may do Schutzhund training, yes. The biggest obstacle to my doing that is the driving involved, which is true of any dog-related pursuit except training at home. Gas prices, you know?
I did a little bit with my prior Dobe, but the cost of working with the club, in addition to the miles of travel got to be too much.
If I find the right situation, I very well may pursue Schutzhund with this one, yes.
Regardless, I am seeking the type of working Dobe that I believe the breed was meant to be – not a show ring dog.
He/she will be highly trained in obedience if nothing else.
Why do you ask?
 
Schutzhund is a hard sport - meaning it takes a tremendous amount of time if done correctly. A good club is all around - Tracking, obedience and Schutzhund. I know clubs that just do the PP part and their dogs are not as socialble unless they are given the obedience other places. If a dog is not allowed to greet people but made to go to a place then they tend to be more suspicious. By meeting the people and being taught the proper way to meet people they are not a problem. If you open the door and let them in - just be sure the stop and let the dog smell first at the door then say ok come on in and bring them in the dog should be fine with it. I do agree with Jess always have the dog sit before you open the door. A dog can not become social that is not allowed to meet and greet.

If a dog does not have a stable temperament then all the training in the world will not make them 100% reliable. That is why a club that trains all phases of Schutzhund is better than one that only does PP work. The dog also learns to go from on phase to the next. I think the dog that only does PP work when the go out thinks that is all it is about so are always on the lookout for semething. They need to learn balance. A good breeder should be able to evaluate the puppies and know if there are unstable temperaments in the group and should guide you accordingly.
 
Doberman Gang, I may do Schutzhund training, yes. The biggest obstacle to my doing that is the driving involved, which is true of any dog-related pursuit except training at home. Gas prices, you
I did a little bit with my prior Dobe, but the cost of working with the club, in addition to the miles of travel got to be too much.
If I find the right situation, I very well may pursue Schutzhund with this on yes.
Regardless, I am seeking the type of working Dobe that I believe the breed was meant to be – not a show ring dog.


He/she will be highly trained in obedience if nothing else.
Why do you ask?

Just interested why you were looking at breeders with an IPO background vs other reputable working breeders. I figured you must have been interested in the sport, that's all.
 
My wife is understandably worried. My previous Dobe lashed out at her three separate times separated by months and years, and came close to doing the same to our 2 yr. old daughter. The main training problem I see that was definitely in place was that my wife never did much training with him and he very clearly did not respect her or feel he had to obey her. I imagine he saw himself as above her in the pack


This is a key statement that can not be overlooked. Your wife wasn't confident and in charge with your previous Doberman. Are you sure you can create a different outcome this time? Some people may live with dogs but still not 100% confident and comfortable around them...and their dog isn't properly trained or a dog wouldn't challenge them once, let alone several times that you know about.

Does your wife really want to get a Doberman and from Schutzhund training no less? She may say yes knowing how set you are, but would she go out and get another Doberman without prompting? What would the family do differently in training this dog to prevent the problems you had previously?

it's a very serious thing when a dog frightens their owner and challenges them. The experience doesn't fade away in the person's mind because a new dog is present. There is no worry when the dog is a pup but when they're an adult, people will react the same way they did with the other adult dog.

My mom had some dog fears that she tried really hard not to let anyone see. I didn't get how big it was for my mom when she asked me to make the dog do things as a kid (10 or 12 maybe).

Just concerned about safety here...
 
Thank you, dhorner8.

I'd be lying if I said I was sure I will be able to create a different situation this time. But I will try hard, and my wife is on board with trying harder this time.

No, my wife would not choose a Doberman on her own. But that's a pretty stringent requirement to insist that both husband and wife desire the same breed and type of dog. I bet a very small percentage of dog-owning families agree on which breed to get.

We will do our best, have learned from experiences, and as for me, I'm fairly experienced in dog training. My question is more about the temperament of these Dobes, and whether a Dobe from serious working breeding will always require special caution around family and guests. I will give you an example of what I'm talking about:

I consulted a dog trainer back when we were in the thick of our problem with Dax our male Dobie. This trainer was a woman with whom I had worked some in the Schutzhund club. She is very good and competes with her German Shepherd, in addition to running a dog training business. She said that it's a basic principle that you should never let your dog be between you and somebody else (in terms of physical position). Otherwise the problem can occur that we were having – the dog protects his prized asset – access to his owner, the alpha.

But come on! This is totally impractical and is bound to fail – especially if you have a child who wanders about (and should be allowed to!). What's more, it runs contrary to the claims I see all over the place that these serious working dogs are of stable temperament and make great family dogs.

So you see my confusion?

Thanks
 
Thanks, Dobes4ever.

Yes, this is about how I want it to work, and how it did work for me in the past with my Magnum (2 Dobes ago). We had a set structured way of allowing people into the house and I had a command that indicated to my boy that the person was to be trusted. I also used this command when meeting someone in public.

You wrote:
By meeting the people and being taught the proper way to meet people they are not a problem. If you open the door and let them in - just be sure the stop and let the dog smell first at the door then say ok come on in and bring them in the dog should be fine with it. I do agree with Jess always have the dog sit before you open the door. A dog can not become social that is not allowed to meet and greet.
 
Just had to mention what hits me hard as a super scary big red flag. You may not agree on a breed but the reasons for the disagreement matter. If you wife wants a dog that plays fetch more like a lab instead of a dobi, then it's just a matter of compromise. We all have to do that.

If your wife is afraid of Dobermans; that's a serious possible deal breaker due to safety. You can only try so hard to overcome your fears and you have to be innately ready to do it. Trying in order to please someone else rarely works. It's no different than trying to overcome your fear of heights to please someone who likes climbing. Only in this case the "heights" can follow you around 24/7 to challenge and bite you and your kids at every turn if they aren't properly trained. It also makes a huge difference if your wife is home with the kids and the one spending most of their time with the dog. Your kids would very likely pick up your wife's fear and start having their own issues with big dogs. Or even worse, they may try to help their mother with the dog and be very unlucky.

You can not go on the principle that one person is an alpha and the dog is beta with any breed of dog, as your trainer seemed to suggest must happen. You understood that even if you didn't know how to train your dog for basic family safety, so why didn't you go to a different trainer/behavior expert? When you get info that makes no sense; you know you need to find a true expert. Good in everything except for basic safety of the family and children is not good for anything, IMO. You can try harder but if you don't know what you did wrong, trying harder isn't likely to produce a different result...or things would have been different on the first go.

You also may be great with some training issues but you have to accept that you had a dog that showed serious aggression to family members big and small at least 4 times (and undoubtedly numerous smaller incidents) that you could not fully train for basic safety of your family or with guests. That isn't remotely trivial. That is a huge training problem and family + guest safety must come before everything else.

The temperament of various lines of Dobermans means nothing if they aren't trained to respect the people around them. Any line will produce a biter, aggression or behavior issues if they aren't properly trained, don't have confident calm leaders or aren't thoroughly, routinely exercised. We moved past the thinking that it's the dog's fault long ago for a reason.

Attacks aren't unpredictable. There are always signals, although sometimes they may not obvious. After the very first undesirable incident you should have been looking for the signs and contacting an expert when you couldn't see the signs.

I appreciate that you're very eager to go buy a new puppy and that is a lot of fun but you are glossing over really basic and severe training issues. It scare me and I work retraining dogs no one else will touch pretty routinely. I would find a real expert trainer who works with "aggression" issues routinely to help you train you, your wife and your new dog together. Some things in the training and living arrangements went horribly wrong last time and you can't chance your family and your guest's safety like that again. You were very lucky last time.
 
Allright, Dhorner8. You've made yourself clear, though I don't think you know as much about my situation as you may think. If I believe you, I'm a pretty lousy dog owner and fairly stupid.

It's a pretty big conclusion jump to say that I'm "very eager to go buy a new puppy and that is a lot of fun."

Anyone else have input?

I'm just looking for folks' opinions and experiences on how suitable a Schutzhund-bred Doberman is for a family situation.

Oh, and all of my Dobes have been excellent retrievers. :)

Thanks
 
I think a dog that would bite a family member has an unstable temperament. A Doberman from a good breeder (whether from show lines or working lines) should have a stable temperament, regardless of whether your wife is involved in training the dog or not. I think the bigger issue is that dogs from working lines are higher drive and may be harder to live with. As long as you do your research and choose an ethical breeder, I would not worry about a dog that would bite your family unprovoked. Your most recent dog sounds like he had an unstable temperament, unless there were other factors you aren't sharing. May I ask what lines he was from?
 
No, my wife would not choose a Doberman on her own. But that's a pretty stringent requirement to insist that both husband and wife desire the same breed and type of dog. I bet a very small percentage of dog-owning families agree on which breed to get.

Well a lot of folks got bitten that way - BITTEN that is by the NOW I LOVE DOBERMAN bug!!!. Those little puppies just have a way of worming their way into your heart. You wife now has more experience and information than she did the first time around so it should go smoother for you guys. The key to successfully raising a Doberman puppy is guidelines and consistent direction - NOT correction but direction. There is a big difference. i agree with Meadow Cat that if you work with a good breeder they will guide you and be there if and when you have a problem and need some guidance yourself.

Dobermans have a STRONG desire to please their owners. Use that against them!!! It makes them marshmallows, willing and compliant. If everyone works together, and is calm and confident the puppy will thrive and grow. I dont' know that I have ever bought all the alpha wolf thing but I do believe that Dobermans above all want to make you happy. If they trust you they will follow your guidance.
 
OH, man it told me it didn't post those replies so I kept hitting the button. Doh.
I think a dog that would bite a family member has an unstable temperament. A Doberman from a good breeder (whether from show lines or working lines) should have a stable temperament, regardless of whether your wife is involved in training the dog or not. I think the bigger issue is that dogs from working lines are higher drive and may be harder to live with. As long as you do your research and choose an ethical breeder, I would not worry about a dog that would bite your family unprovoked. Your most recent dog sounds like he had an unstable temperament, unless there were other factors you aren't sharing. May I ask what lines he was from?
Meadowcat, My late Dax was out of (and I don't want to disrespect anyone) Boris von Rosenhoff x Vanta vom Dynasty. Dax was his call name. Evan was his official name. And thank you for your input!
 
I think a dog that would bite a family member has an unstable temperament. A Doberman from a good breeder (whether from show lines or working lines) should have a stable temperament, regardless of whether your wife is involved in training the dog or not. I think the bigger issue is that dogs from working lines are higher drive and may be harder to live with. As long as you do your research and choose an ethical breeder, I would not worry about a dog that would bite your family unprovoked. Your most recent dog sounds like he had an unstable temperament, unless there were other factors you aren't sharing. May I ask what lines he was from?
You know, I guess I'll reveal something else that I haven't felt at liberty to share. But it may actually help solve this mystery: My late Dax was from a litter of only two. His breeder, at least at the time, liked to breed her bitches at a more advanced age (his Dam was about 8 yrs. old) because this yielded smaller litters she told me.
Dax's brother had to be put down a few years before Dax died (Dax died of bloat like his Sire, Boris). Dax's brother, I was told by his owner (a very intelligent, educated, dog-experienced woman), began suffering from "violent seizures" or "rages" which is why he had to be put down.
Now this does not sound like what would happen with Dax. He didn't get any sort of far-off look in his eyes (in my estimation) prior to or during the incidences when he went after my wife, or when he went after guests. He would just whine for a split second then launch into aggressive barking and snapping toward the person's facial area.
When I was discussing Dax's problem with his breeder, she asked me about this sort of look in the eyes, and held out the possibility that he may be short-circuited in the head, or however exactly she phrased it. Of course she wasn't at all sure, it is just one thing that was discussed.
But I wonder if Dax's brother's fate is at all related to do with Dax's problem. Perhaps he had – at least – an unstable temperament. That is my current best explanation for the problem, though other factors may have contributed.
 

Back
Top