Color = Intimidation factor?

BamMoMoMommy

$ Forum Donor $
(This could probably titled stupid sh!t people say....like the dingbats who have told me they know Mo isn't a Warlock/King...cuz like..they are ALWAYS black and tan...yeah I'm rolling my eyes too.)


Seems gen pop...media influenced...Doberman always means large,muscular, glossy black and tan.
Something @JanS said here:
Compliments
About people asking her if Della was a pure bred dobe....made me think about how often we get that same question. She also mentioned getting asked breeding since she has a male and female. We get asked is we have/plan to breed Mo....and the answers is always...nope....and people make all kinds of odd comments and they always tend to be along the lines of "such waste to not recreate such a beautiful dog."


These are our first reds....all other have been black and tan

DH and I were talking about how people seem more relaxed around these two...then they ever were our black and tans. They don't seem to be as afraid to approach us/these two...and poor Bam.....everyone thinks he is a harmless small mixed bred mutt....or puppy.

Is it my imagination...or has anyone else noticed people don't seem to be as intimated by coat colors outside black and tan?
 
Just seems black dogs in general tend to be a little more intimidating, but I think a big factor is the eyes. With a black/rust, eyes can range from very dark brown to coal black. Where a red's eyes (to me) are more amber to golden.
 
After my first red Dobe, 3 Dobes in, I only wanted reds from then on. So beautiful and yes, there is an intimidation factor with the blacks and the ears up. My last Dobe (puppy pic on my profile) was allowed her natural ears. Absolutely the sweetest and best behaved ever. Yours are gorgeous. Love the picture and the contrasting ears. I am now dogless for the first time since the 70s, and living vicariously through all the photos posted here.
 
Just seems black dogs in general tend to be a little more intimidating

After I dropped the starter post...I thought about something an insurance agent friend said...that most of the dogs bites she handled....came from lighter colored dogs.

And the eyes definitely play a large role in intimidation factor. One thing that struck me the first time I saw Mo.....his eyes seemed softer, friendlier than any of the black and tans we had.

We hear a lot of "WHOA that's a big dog" with Mo...where what we used to hear with our black and tans is "WHOA that a big scary looking dog!"

No doubt the crop on Mo as opposed to the flop on Bam...raises the intimidation factor of Mo.

I only wanted reds from then on

I never thought I would own a red...and now with two..I can't figure out what was wrong with my silly brain thinking I'd never want one.

living vicariously through all the photos posted here.

The photos here are amazing, aren't they. I've lost a "oh holy cow...how did it get that late??"couple of hours...just scrolling thru them.
 
My red had a certain....fire.

Yeah there's that female ginger thing:evilgrin:....being a ginger myself....I get that.:laughing:

@Panama "Hawk"....perfect name for a red dobe.

We've been asked a few times if we see a personality/temperament difference between the black and the red.....always find that an unusual question....but I think it could be people assigning human hair color characteristics to the dogs. All of our guys up til squishy, silly brained Bam...were mellow, not much got them out of sorts....which always amazed me, cuz our life when our kids were young.....always tended to be frenetic -off the walls- crazy.
 
Our first Doberman was Black and Tan and I think more people were intimidated by him. When we got Buddy, I remember a few people didn't even know he was a Doberman! They didn't know they came in a color other than black and tan. :wacky: And I do believe the Reds are somehow more approachable. I think people have a stigma with the black and tan as the "normal", perhaps vicious (Eye roll) Doberman that they remember. Bring in a different color and somehow they are softer toward them. Go figure!
 
My fawn girl was often mistaken for a Weimaraner. People wouldn't hesitate to approach her until I corrected them when they called her a Weim. When I said "she's a doberman", people beat FAST! :sonic:

This always cracks me up.....when we get this kind of reaction to Bam......before the words get out of our mouth "He's a doberman"..like five seconds earlier....the person was about to get on the ground and cuddle him like he was a stuffed animal.....all of the sudden they are backing up so fast I am afraid they are going to injure themselves trying to get away.
 
For me, a black dog is scarier because it’s harder to see their eyes. At least Dobermans have short hair, but longer haired black dogs where I can’t see their eyes...harder to trust them. The pointy ears also add to the overall scary look...Dober Devils!
 
At least Dobermans have short hair, but longer haired black dogs where I can’t see their eyes...harder to trust them

HA..I thought this was a "me thing" in fact my husband ribs me about the fact I steer clear of any dog that I can't see their eyes...no matter what color they are.
 
Yup Albert it black with the deep rust and people are way more leery of him. It might be partly because of size too since he's quite a bit bigger than Della.
 
My first was a Red male. I often got asked if he was a mix – got asked about Pit Bull. He was a big, stocky, thick guy – strayed from breed standard in appearance somewhat. Had a pretty wide head, a snout that appeared shorter than the norm, and a short ear crop.

If he was a Black, I doubt anyone would ask if he was a mix though.

I have long thought that black dogs naturally elicit a more leery response in humans. I think black objects also project a serious feel. Think of weapons, clothing, cars, planes.

A few years back, I opined on this topic, posting pics of the same type of muscle car in black and in white. I also posted pics of two MMA fighters – one black and one white. I asked which imparted a more imposing feel. I had my posts removed, as it was thought they may be considered inappropriate. I meant no offense, of course, but I stand by my assertion.

JaguarBlack.webp
Jaguar.webp
 
Then, there is my all-time favorite picture of a dog

WHOA.....even if that dog was rainbow sparkly....I'd be headed in the opposite direction of him so fast.....I'd leave rut two foot deep...same goes with MMA fighters. I understand your point and do get the psychological aspect of how color affects perception.

DH had Mo out this evening while running errands.....and he got a comment we hear often
"I didn't know dobermans had any other color to them but black with brown."

I don't know enough about the history of the dogs to know when red's started "going main stream", but still seems they are a rare sight to some folks.

I don't think we knew anyone with any color other than black and tan til into the 90's. We knew of the other colors...but that comes from husband's history with them. I've only seen fawns in pictures. I've seen one blue "in the flesh"..and he belonged to a guy who stopped me to compliment Bam!! I wanted to hug him for telling me I had nice looking red dobe pup...not cuz he thought Bam was a nice looking pup..I wanted to hug him cuz HE KNEW Bam was a dobe!!! LOL.
 
I don't know enough about the history of the dogs to know when red's started "going main stream", but still seems they are a rare sight to some folks.
It's surprising what the majority of people don't know, or aren't familiar with.

I go places with my older daughter using a tagalong bike. This is not a rare apparatus by any means, yet I get so many people – children and adults reacting with some wonder and curiosity.

Red Dobes? I understand they showed up not too many years after the breed came to be. Been around almost as long as the breed has.
 
I don't know about black & rust being scarier.... But they sure are harder to see at night in the dark LOL!
Thank god for Maja's light reflecting collar or I wouldn't be able to find her half the times I let her out at night.
MR
 

Back
Top