Christmas "Surprises!"

DD4MSpock

Hot Topics Subscriber
So, did anyone give or get a puppy for this holiday season? I ask, because it seems the latest thing that's trending on my Youtube "suggestions" list are all these "Christmas Puppy Surprise" videos, where either the parents or Santa give a puppy to their children for Christmas, birthday, etc. Sadly, no dobies given/received, as of yet, but... They even go so far as to put the puppy in a box the children can open (I assume ASAP). Some trends from watching these videos....

1) Almost all the children (of either gender and all ages) have burst into tears (or scream) immediately upon opening the box or discovering the puppy. I dunno... I get the emotions involved, but I'd be afraid I'd be scaring the puppy... I'd want that first few moments of contact to leave a "pleasant" impression on the dog. Just like when approaching an infant for the first time... you want to smile a lot and not frown or look ugly. I also probably wouldn't want my parents to post videos of me crying all over YouTube! :mad: :D

2) Most kids need to learn how to hold a puppy, so that they don't crush it. Delecate and young bones, and all that. Sort of like my fears about those "Dog Loves Baby" videos where the infants/toddlers don't know yet how to interact with the animal and try to pull on its ears, tongue, etc. I have seen some where the parents caution the kids to be very gentle, though. That's a good thing.

3) Overall, I think it's a good thing for kids to have pets at a reasonably young age... this, to learn how to care for and accept responsibility for a living thing. Good training for learning to raise kids, themselves. Although none of the videos, so far, have had the parents explain what that means (i.e. "you must learn to take care of it, feed it, walk it, clean up the errant poop, etc. etc.").

Still, it's interesting to watch all the reactions... Now, let's give some dobie pups for Christmas!
 
Almost all the children (of either gender and all ages) have burst into tears (or scream) immediately upon opening the box or discovering the puppy. I dunno... I get the emotions involved, but I'd be afraid I'd be scaring the puppy... I'd want that first few moments of contact to leave a "pleasant" impression on the dog.
I totally agree. A puppy is already confused enough going to new surroundings and people so it should be as calm as possible.

I personally don't think giving any pet as a gift is a good idea since it needs to be better planned out than that keeping everyone involved.
That said, I did get my first pony for Christmas when I was a kid but I had already met him and dreamed of owning him one day. I'll never forget that morning when they told me to go check in the barn and the pony of my dreams was in there...
 
That said, I did get my first pony for Christmas when I was a kid but I had already met him and dreamed of owning him one day. I'll never forget that morning when they told me to go check in the barn and the pony of my dreams was in there...

Funny you mention that... (i.e. pony for Christmas), as I came across this video...


and this one.....


and others like it....
 
The boys got gerbils for Christmas.... But had been asking for them, and my oldest now has a job and bought his own. We went over all the ground rules and taking care of them etc, and know worst case, my oldest will take over and he'll just end up with more than 1 gerbil! (He's already hoping!! Lol) I would never do a puppy or kitten for Christmas though, unless it was a whole family pet that hubby and I had agreed on!
 
I am bumping this thread only because I am seeing the push for pets as gifts on holidays.
I am the sour puss here. I don’t think any animal should be given as a gift on any holidays.
Most of them wind up in the shelter.
Why not go to the shelter and take pictures of the pets you think would be suitable for your child. Print out the pictures and place in a small album and wrap that up to give to kids that want a pet. Then when they see the pictures they can choose which pet they really like and schedule a trip to the shelter so the kids can interact with the ones they like and only then allow them to adopt. Holiday festivities are just too loud, busy and temptation is high to feed all the wrong foods as treats resulting in a sick animal. Make getting a pet a gentle, quiet and safe environment for the new member. Get the child to read, understand and know ALL that is involved with caring for their pet. Have them sign their pet agreement and be prepared to remind them of what they agreed to in order to get the pet.
I don’t feel like new pets are suitable for very young children. Having pets in the home is great and they can learn how to be responsible, respectful and gentle with them before getting one of their very own. JMHO
 
Funny you should bump it, because I'm seeing an "uptick" in the "Puppy Surprise" videos on YouTube... the reason why I wrote it, initially. I was just reviewing it when you bumped it. :eek: :D

I definitely don't want to see pets of any kind wrapped up in boxes, no matter how "easy access" they are or how much air support they have. It's the "claustrophobic darkness" that's detrimental.

Anyway, if you're going to do the puppy thing for holidays, birthday, etc., PLEASE do a video of you and the animal and then show it ti the intended recipient. Let them get the emotion out of their system. Then go visit the animal or, otherwise, allow them the initial contact. You want that to be as pleasant as is possible. Pleasant for the dog, and for you.
 
So, did anyone give or get a puppy for this holiday season? I ask, because it seems the latest thing that's trending on my Youtube "suggestions" list are all these "Christmas Puppy Surprise" videos, where either the parents or Santa give a puppy to their children for Christmas, birthday, etc. Sadly, no dobies given/received, as of yet, but... They even go so far as to put the puppy in a box the children can open (I assume ASAP). Some trends from watching these videos....

1) Almost all the children (of either gender and all ages) have burst into tears (or scream) immediately upon opening the box or discovering the puppy. I dunno... I get the emotions involved, but I'd be afraid I'd be scaring the puppy... I'd want that first few moments of contact to leave a "pleasant" impression on the dog. Just like when approaching an infant for the first time... you want to smile a lot and not frown or look ugly. I also probably wouldn't want my parents to post videos of me crying all over YouTube! :mad: :D

2) Most kids need to learn how to hold a puppy, so that they don't crush it. Delecate and young bones, and all that. Sort of like my fears about those "Dog Loves Baby" videos where the infants/toddlers don't know yet how to interact with the animal and try to pull on its ears, tongue, etc. I have seen some where the parents caution the kids to be very gentle, though. That's a good thing.

3) Overall, I think it's a good thing for kids to have pets at a reasonably young age... this, to learn how to care for and accept responsibility for a living thing. Good training for learning to raise kids, themselves. Although none of the videos, so far, have had the parents explain what that means (i.e. "you must learn to take care of it, feed it, walk it, clean up the errant poop, etc. etc.").

Still, it's interesting to watch all the reactions... Now, let's give some dobie pups for Christmas!

Happy Thanksgiving, all!

I am bumping my original thread once again for two reasons. First, as a reminder of what @Tropicalbri's and I have been advocating... that gifts of pets should be a bit more properly planned, and that no animal should be "boxed" up like a present for the recipient to open up and react by screeming or crying. It scares the crap out of the pet..... sometimes "literally..." :eek: The better approach is to give, say, the "collar" or something like that to the new recipient as an icon of the pet they're about to be gifted. Then, once they've chilled down, take them to see the pet live. That first impression is so important.

Second reason.... I've come upon a new trend in my more recent travels through these "Puppy surprise" videos. It gobsmacks me... the number of people (especially teens and adults) who, upon being introduced to their new puppy, ask, "Is it a boy or a girl?"

I mean, seriously.... can't you pick up the animal and have a look for yourself???? It's pretty obvious, ya know.... :mad::mad::mad:

:D
 
Sorry to bump this old thread again, but I'm starting to get close to the point where I can't watch these "Pet Surprise" videos anymore. Waaaaaaayyyy too much screaming at all ages. It's truly harmful to the pet. And I mean totally loud, shrill screaming! Ugghh.

One good thing, though. I'm starting to see more parents caution their children to stop screaming/acting out for fear they'll scare the pet. I'm even seeing a few more videos where the recipients (mostly kids) are reacting a lot more calmly. That's good, but it's not enough. I think it's pretty obvious that most of the surprise videos are on YT because of the screaming reactions.... Makes good YT content. Frightened Puppy? Ahhh, they'll get over it... :mad: :mad: :mad:

One other thing to mention. Kids still aren't learning how to hold a smaller pet properly. Even if they are very gentle with the pet, I don't know that I'd want to hold a pet in a "snuggling" way... makes the pet think they're being restrained.... entrapped... and it scares them as well. What I'd do is I'd either lie supine on a couch or reclined significantly in a chair and let the animal come to my face and give me kisses. I can still pet the animal, but it's not like I've 'clamped on" to them and are holding them "hostage." And kissing....that's the other thing. Smaller kids tend to turn away from the pet when it tries to kiss them (i.e. lick their face). They should let it kiss them. They can wash their faces later.

Hopefully it will get a little better. At least I'm now starting to see comments in the YT videos comment section from people complaining about the screaming.

Maybe it is getting better.
 

Back
Top