A
apbtmom76
Please write the Mayor of Brampton Ontario
[email protected]
> Brampton Guardian
>
> Rambo on death row as city, owners battle over breeding Rambo on death row
> as city, owners battle over breeding
> Friday January 29 2010
> By PAM DOUGLAS
>
> Rambo wasn't hurting anyone.
> No one had complained about the young dog, he hadn't escaped 75-year-old
> Maria Gaspar's Vodden Street yard, and he had never bitten anyone.
>
> But Rambo and his sister, Brittany, are on death row at the City of
> Brampton's Animal Shelter right now while their owners are embroiled in a
> battle to get their beloved pets back before they are euthanized. The
> deadline- Feb. 5.
>
> Both dogs were seized from separate homes on Jan. 13 by city animal
> control
> officials who said they believed the dogs to be pitbulls.
>
> Their owners say that's not true, and both say they have proof from
> veterinarians tracing their backgrounds as boxers/American bulldogs.
>
> The city's veterinarian has a conflicting opinion, according to a letter
> sent to the Branco family, who own Brittany.
>
> Gaspar is heartbroken. The senior citizen can't understand why Rambo was
> seized. She said the confusing part is, the city has licensed Rambo as a
> boxer/American bulldog cross for the past two years. His vaccination
> certificate from North Town Veterinary Hospital classifies his breed as a
> boxer cross. And, no one who has seen the dog has ever thought he was a
> pitbull, according to the distraught Gaspar.
>
> The city told Gaspar that no one had complained about Rambo. He had not
> escaped the back yard. If anything, he made passersby laugh the way he
> would
> jump up onto the roof of his dog house to look over the fence, she said.
>
> But it was that quirky little habit that led to him being removed from his
> home and held by the city under threat of euthanasia.
>
> A passing animal control officer spotted Rambo on his perch in December,
> looking over the six-foot fence, and told Maria Gaspar she had to move the
> doghouse because Rambo could escape. Gaspar agreed, but then the issue of
> Rambo's breed came up. She was told to get a letter from her veterinarian
> attesting to the dog's breed, and to have him neutered. Gaspar said she
> got
> the required letter, and an estimate for neutering, and gave both to the
> city.
>
> In response, the city sent a letter telling Gaspar there is no completed
> certificate from a veterinarian, and that "Rambo has been confirmed to be
> a
> pitbull by his parentage as well as the characteristics as defined in the
> City of Brampton Dog By-law..."
>
> The bylaw defines a pitbull as a pitbull terrier, Staffordshire bull
> terrier, American Staffordshire bull terrier, American pitbull terrier, or
> "a dog that has an appearance and physical characteristics that are
> substantially similar to those dogs."
>
> "It's not, it's not pitbull," said Gaspar emphatically, struggling for the
> English words to describe her upset. She can't talk about Rambo without
> crying.
>
> "This problem is like a son problem," she said, emphasizing how important
> Rambo is to her. "Now, I no have dog, I no have money, I no have
> nothing...
> It's not fair."
>
> They can't fight the city because her family doesn't have any money for a
> lawyer, she said, but Rui Branco is taking on the fight for both dogs.
>
> His family owns Brittany, and they are in a similar predicament. Like
> Rambo,
> there were no complaints or allegations of biting against Brittany. The
> licence for Brittany's father, Tyson, was due for renewal, and an animal
> control officer went to the Branco's house to collect the $20. She was
> told
> Tyson was given away to a friend, but that's when the issue of Brittany's
> lineage arouse, according to Branco.
>
> He has hired a lawyer who is preparing to file a motion in court to get
> the
> dogs back.
>
> "This is an injustice," Branco said, pointing out how ironic it is that he
> will not only have to pay a lawyer to fight for his family's dog, but, as
> a
> resident of Brampton, he will also contribute to the cost of defending the
> city.
>
> Tyson, also Rambo's father, was also licensed by the city at one time,
> although Branco said the family did not realize the city had classified
> him
> as a pitbull, especially since he was born in December 2005, one full
> month
> after the grace period for owning a pitbull. If he was a pitbull, Branco
> said, the city should not have issued a licence to him at all. But, he
> says,
> the real mistake was labeling him a pitbull in the first place.
>
> He has the microchip paperwork for Tyson, and a veterinarian' s letter,
> stating, "He is in my opinion a healthy and well-socialized pet and is a
> cross between an American Bulldog and a Boxer."
>
> A second veterinarian, Dr. David Kirkham of the Cheltenham Veterinary
> Centre, has added a letter stating Brittany's mother, Jersey, is
> "unquestionably a purebred boxer."
>
> "I don't understand why they are fighting me so hard on this," he said.
> "Brittany doesn't look anything like a pitbull."
>
> The Branco's said the city did not have a warrant to seize Brittany when
> they arrived on Jan. 13, and Rui's brother, John, confronted the city
> worker, who then called for backup. Several police officers and other city
> animal control officials arrived, and, ultimately, the dog was handed
> over.
> However, the Branco's argue they were intimidated into willingly turning
> over their pet and feel proper procedure (a warrant) was not followed.
>
> For their part, the city is considering four charges against the Branco
> family- owning a pitbull born after Nov. 29, 2005 in relation to Brittany
> and in relation to Tyson, failing to licence a pitbull, transferring a
> pitbull without consent of the poundkeeper and permitting a pitbull to
> breed.
>
> The Gaspar family faces one charge of owning a pitbull.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Brampton Guardian
>
> Groundswell of support for two dogs on death row Groundswell of support
> for
> two dogs on death row
> Tuesday February 2 2010
> By PAM DOUGLAS
>
> There has been a groundswell of support for two Brampton families whose
> dogs
> were seized by the city and labelled as illegal pitbulls.
>
> A Facebook page calling for Rambo and Brittany to be released was started
> by
> those opposed to Ontario's pitbull ban soon after The Guardian broke the
> news of the dogs' plight Friday. The page has attracted close to 2,000
> members, and an online petition is closing in on 3,000 signatures.
>
> Bloggers are weighing in on the controversy, too, along with residents
> across Ontario and as far away as Texas. The vast majority are critical of
> the city's handling of the situation, as well as the pitbull ban, which
> they
> say leads to the 'misidentification' of many dogs. Some are focusing their
> anger at animal control officers, saying they did not have to seize the
> dogs, while others are urging them not to blame the city employees, saying
> they had no choice.
>
> Meanwhile, the Feb. 5 deadline for the Brampton dogs to be euthanized has
> been extended as the lawyer representing owners Rui Branco and his family
> prepares to take the fight to court to get the pets returned.
>
> Both were seized from separate homes Jan. 13. The city's veterinarian has
> declared they are pitbulls under the city's bylaw, while the families say
> they are not, and have produced some documents identifying them as
> boxer/American bulldog mixes.
>
> The two dogs are brother and sister, and for the past two years, Rambo has
> been licensed by the city as a boxer/American bulldog cross.
>
> But when a passing animal control officer spotted Rambo sitting on top of
> his doghouse in 75-year-old Maria Gaspar's backyard in December, the
> senior
> citizen was questioned about his breeding.
>
> The Gaspars and Brancos have been told there were no complaints about
> their
> dogs, and no accusations of aggressive behaviour, running loose or biting.
> Similar to what happened to Rambo, an animal control officer who went to
> collect a licence fee from the Branco home spotted Brittany and started
> asking questions about her lineage.
>
> Both dogs were seized, and have been held at the city's animal shelter
> ever
> since.
>
> A dog doesn't have to be a pitbull to be labelled as one under the city's
> bylaw. It defines a pitbull as a pitbull terrier, Staffordshire bull
> terrier, American Staffordshire bull terrior, American pitbull terrier, or
> "a dog that has an appearance and physical characteristics that are
> substantially similar to those dogs."
>
> Both families are distraught about the seizure of their pets. The issue is
> in the hands of the city's legal department, so city officials would not
> comment on the specific cases.
>
> The two families are holding a press conference Wednesday morning.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Toronto Sun
>
> Seized dogs aren't pit bulls: Owners
> By JENNY YUEN, Toronto Sun
>
> Last Updated: 3rd February 2010, 10:25pm
>
> BRAMPTON - Rambo and Brittany may end up on doggie death row unless their
> owners quickly prove the canines aren't pit bulls.
>
> Maria Gaspar and Joseph Branco having been fearing the worst since
> Brampton
> Animal Services seized siblings Rambo and Brittany from different
> residences
> on Jan. 13 for violating the province's pit bull ban.
>
> The owners argued Wednesday that the two-year-old dogs are actually 75%
> boxer and 25% American bulldog and the city had no right to snatch them.
>
> "We stand by the fact that the dogs are boxer mixes," said Rui Branco, 42,
> whose brother owns Brittany and her parents, Jersey and Tyson.
>
> "There was no warrant, no complaints or abuse complaints. The city has
> been
> stonewalling us. We got a letter a day ago from the city ... certifying
> Brittany as a pit bull."
>
> Gaspar, 75, was in tears as she expressed concern for her beloved dog,
> Rambo.
>
> "I just want my dog back," she said. "He didn't do anything to anybody."
>
> But Animal Services said that Joseph Branco had registered Tyson as a
> restricted pit bull in a 2008 licensing document, which means it's against
> the law for Tyson to have puppies.
>
> "The father of these dogs from two different litters was registered as a
> restricted pit bull," city spokesman Mariam Mesbah said. "You have to have
> the dog neutered and microchipped, which was done, but we've since
> discovered the two dogs."
>
> Pit bulls were banned from the province as of Nov. 29, 2005.
>
> Rambo and Brittany's owners faced a Friday deadline to send the dogs to a
> province that accepts pit bulls. The city since has offered the owners an
> extension, Mesbah said.
>
> "In light of the fact they've been granted an extension, (euthanasia of
> the
> dogs) wouldn't happen," Mesbah said.
>
> Branco says the city has dismissed a document from the Campbell Veterinary
> Hospital in Brampton saying Tyson is an American bulldog and a boxer.
>
> Branco said his lawyer is trying to get more documentation from the city
> that proves Tyson is a pit bull.
>
> "I have no idea how the city registered Tyson, the father, as a pit bull
> and
> I have no idea what led them here," Branco said. "Their excuse for being
> at
> our door was to collect the licence fee. The bylaw officer said, 'I'm
> going
> to hunt (Tyson's pups) down, one by one,'"
>
> A Facebook group, "Injustice Brampton Dogs on Death Row - Free Them Now,"
> urging the release of the dogs has had more than 2,600 members sign a
> petition.
>
> [email protected]
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Toronto Star
>
> Seized dogs are pit bulls, Brampton says
> February 02, 2010
>
> Jim Wilkes
>
> Two Brampton dogs may face a date with the executioner unless their owners
> can prove they are not pit bulls.
>
> The dogs, 2-year-olds from the same litter, were seized from separate
> homes
> last month by animal services officers who told the owners they had
> characteristics of the banned dogs.
>
> "They're not pit bulls," said Rui Branco, whose family owns Jersey, the
> purebred boxer who had a litter of nine pups and once owned Tyson, who he
> said is an American bulldog that sired the brood. Their dog Brittany was
> seized on Jan. 13.
>
> "No matter what we say, no matter what documents we show them, they won't
> believe us."
>
> The city says Tyson was registered with Brampton as a pit bull and claims
> a
> veterinary certificate proves it, said spokesperson Miriam Mesbah.
>
> The city initially gave the two families until Friday to decide whether to
> have the dogs euthanized or pay to have them shipped to another province
> that allows pit bulls. But Tuesday the city granted an extension to allow
> Branco's lawyer to challenge the dogs' lineage in court.
>
> "Under the Dog Owners Liability Act we are required to seize those dogs,"
> Mesbah said. "Because we have that evidence, we are not legally allowed to
> release the dogs."
>
> The act took effect Nov. 29, 2005, banning pit bulls from in the province.
>
> In Brampton, a dog is considered to be a pit bull if it is a pit bull
> terrier, a Staffordshire bull terrier, an American Staffordshire bull
> terrier, an American pit bull terrier or any dog "that has an appearance
> and
> physical characteristics that are substantially similar to those...,"
> according to a city bylaw.
>
> Both Branco and Joe Gaspar, whose family pet Rambo was also seized Jan.
> 13,
> say their animals have never been loose or the subject of complaints from
> neighbours.
>
> They have letters from four veterinarians and a company that inserts
> microchips under a dog's skin supporting their claims there is no pit bull
> in either dog.
>
> One Brampton vet wrote that he would stake his 51-year veterinary
> reputation
> that Tyson was an American bulldog/boxer mix.
>
> "There's no pit bull in him at all," said Gaspar, whose Portuguese-born
> mother Maria struggled to find words as tears streamed down her cheeks.
>
> He said the seizures came after an animal services officer saw Rambo
> standing atop its doghouse on a deck in the family's backyard and thought
> it
> looked like a pit bull.
>
> "He's never hurt a soul. Kids come by and pull his ears, play with him all
> the time," Gaspar said. "I don't know what more we can do to prove that
> Rambo isn't a pit bull.
>
> "They say it doesn't matter what we show them. In their eyes, he's a pit
> bull, so these papers mean nothing to them. We've got nothing to hide.
> He's
> just a sweet dog."
>
> Branco said confusion about the dogs' lineage is the result of Tyson being
> wrongly labeled a pit bull when it was licenced by Brampton in 2006.
>
> He said he only later learned of the error and couldn't change it.
>
> "If they thought Tyson was a pit bull, why did they license him in the
> first
> place?" he said. "He was born after the ban was in place. If he was really
> a
> pit bull, they couldn't have done that. It was their mistake."
>
> In 2008, another pit bull, also named Rambo, won a reprieve from doggie
> death row in Mississauga and was shipped to a farm in Nova Scotia after
> its
> owner was convicted of having an illegal dog. It had been captured by an
> animal control officer after escaping from its owner's backyard.
>
> Mesbah said Brampton municipal lawyers are considering charges against the
> two owners for owning an illegal pit bull. Branco said he has been warned
> he
> could also be prosecuted for permitting a pit bull to breed, failing to
> license a pit bull and transferring a pit bull without consent of the city
> poundkeeper.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Toronto Star
>
> Owners' pleas ignored as two 'pit bulls' seized
> February 03, 2010
>
> Jim Wilkes
>
>
> Rambo and smaller Jasmine stand atop a barbecue on the deck of the Gaspar
> family home in Brampton.
>
> SUPPLIED PHOTO
>
> Two Brampton dogs may face a date with the executioner unless their owners
> can prove they are not pit bulls.
>
> The dogs, 2-year-olds from the same litter, were seized from separate
> homes
> last month by animal services officers who told the owners they had
> characteristics of the banned dogs.
>
> "They're not pit bulls," said Rui Branco, whose dog Brittany was one of
> the
> two dogs seized on Jan. 13. "No matter what we say, no matter what
> documents
> we show them, they won't believe us."
>
> The Branco family owns Jersey, the purebred boxer that gave birth to the
> litter of nine pups that included the two seized animals. The family also
> once owned Tyson, the brood's sire, who Branco said is an American
> bulldog.
> The city says Tyson was registered with Brampton as a pit bull and claims
> that a veterinary certificate proves it, said spokeswoman Miriam Mesbah.
>
> But Branco and Joe Gaspar, whose family pet Rambo was also seized Jan. 13,
> have letters from four veterinarians and a company that inserts microchips
> under a dog's skin supporting their claims there is no pit bull in either
> dog.
>
> One Brampton vet wrote that he would stake his 51-year veterinary
> reputation
> that Tyson was an American bulldog-boxer mix.
>
> "There's no pit bull in him at all," said Gaspar, whose Portuguese-born
> mother, Maria, struggled to find words as tears streamed down her cheeks.
>
> The city initially gave the two families until Friday to decide whether to
> have the dogs euthanized or pay to have them shipped to another province
> that allows pit bulls.
>
> On Tuesday, the city granted an extension to allow Branco's lawyer to
> challenge the dogs' lineage in court.
>
> "Under the Dog Owners Liability Act we are required to seize those dogs,"
> Mesbah said. "Because we have that evidence, we are not legally allowed to
> release the dogs."
>
> The act took effect Nov. 29, 2005, banning pit bulls from the province.
>
> In Brampton, a dog is considered to be a pit bull if it is a pit bull
> terrier, a Staffordshire bull terrier, an American Staffordshire bull
> terrier, an American pit bull terrier or any dog "that has an appearance
> and
> physical characteristics that are substantially similar to those ..."
> according to a city bylaw.
>
> Both Branco and Joe Gaspar said their animals have never been loose, nor
> the
> subject of complaints from neighbours.
>
> Gaspar said the seizures came after an animal services officer saw Rambo
> standing atop its doghouse on a deck in the family's backyard and thought
> it
> looked like a pit bull.
>
> "He's never hurt a soul. Kids come by and pull his ears, play with him all
> the time," Gaspar said. "I don't know what more we can do to prove that
> Rambo isn't a pit bull.
>
> "They say it doesn't matter what we show them. In their eyes, he's a pit
> bull, so these papers mean nothing to them. We've got nothing to hide.
> He's
> just a sweet dog."
>
> Branco said confusion about the dogs' lineage is the result of Tyson being
> wrongly labelled a pit bull when it was licensed by Brampton in 2006.
>
> He said he only later learned of the error and couldn't change it.
>
> "If they thought Tyson was a pit bull, why did they license him in the
> first
> place?" he said. "He was born after the ban was in place. If he was really
> a
> pit bull, they couldn't have done that. It was their mistake."
>
> Mesbah said Brampton municipal lawyers are considering charges against the
> two owners for owning an illegal pit bull. Branco said he has been warned
> he
> could also be prosecuted for permitting a pit bull to breed, failing to
> license a pit bull and transferring a pit bull without consent of the city
> poundkeeper.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Globe and Mail
>
> Dog fight
> Boxer mixes caught up in pit bull controversy
>
> Timothy Appleby
>
> Toronto - From Wednesday's Globe and Mail
> Published on Wednesday, Feb. 03, 2010 12:37AM EST
>
> Last updated on Wednesday, Feb. 03, 2010 3:47AM EST
>
> One veterinarian' s boxer is another vet's pit bull.
>
> As a result, Rambo and his sister Brittany are languishing behind bars at
> the City of Brampton's animal shelter, possibly headed for the death
> chamber.
>
> Their aggrieved owners, meanwhile, complain that whatever the city may
> say,
> neither beast is a pit bull at all.
>
> Pit bulls are a type of dog rather than a breed and have garnered numerous
> headlines and a couple of high-profile court hearings since an amendment
> to
> Ontario's Dog Owners' Liability Act took effect four years ago.
>
> Under the new rules, pit bull terriers, Staffordshire bull terriers,
> American Staffordshire bull terriers and American pit bull terriers are
> outlawed; those already here were allowed to remain, providing they be
> muzzled and leashed.
>
> Straightforward enough. However, the legislation also contains a clause
> banning any dog "that has the appearance and physical characteristics
> substantially similar to" those specified.
>
> For Rambo and Brittany, born in separate litters to the same parents, that
> inclusiveness has spelled bad news and their future looks bleak: If homes
> are not found for them outside Ontario they may be euthanized, though no
> execution date has been set.
>
> Rambo belongs to 75-year-old Maria Gaspar. Brittany's home is across town
> with the Branco family.
>
> Both were seized Jan. 13 by city animal control officials who said they
> believed the dogs were pit bulls.
>
> Not so, says Rui Branco, who will host a press conference outside his
> Reeve
> Road home Wednesday morning in efforts to highlight the plight of the two
> siblings, neither of which is known to have attacked or threatened anyone.
>
> Rather, their perceived sin rests with their lineage.
>
> The dogs' mother was Jersey, a purebred boxer. No problem there.
>
> But their dad was Tyson, born shortly after the pit bull law took effect
> in
> late November, 2005, and a survivor of the ban, apparently through an
> oversight. He was, nonetheless, classified as a pit bull, although Tyson's
> family vet disagrees, calling him "a healthy and well-socialized pet . a
> cross between an American bulldog and a boxer."
>
> Either way, Tyson's label as a pit bull means his offspring are deemed pit
> bulls, too.
>
> "Animal Services has documentary and veterinary evidence that (Rambo and
> Brittany) are pit bulls," city spokeswoman Mariam Mesbah said.
>
> "The bottom line is that if the mother or the father is a pit bull and
> documented as such, any of their brood would be considered pit bulls. We
> are
> required by law to follow the legislation. "
>
> Lawyer Megan Burkett, acting for the Brancos, is preparing a court motion
> to
> get both dogs back on grounds they were improperly seized, and says the
> law
> casts too wide a net.
>
> "Tyson is an American bulldog and a boxer and if they wanted boxer to be
> in
> the legislation, it should have said boxer," she said.
>
> "That's what's causing the problem. Our position is that he looks like a
> boxer. A lot of breeds are being caught up in this that shouldn't be."
>
> Rambo's troubles began when he was spotted atop his doghouse in his fenced
> yard, and his detention left his elderly owner, Ms. Gaspar, distraught.
>
> For the previous two years the city had licensed him as a boxer/American
> bulldog cross, she told a local newspaper, and his vaccination certificate
> states that.
>
> Brittany was picked up later the same day. And her vet, Dr. David Kirkham,
> voices the same complaint of mistaken identity. "I don't understand why
> (city officials) are fighting me so hard on this," he said.
>
> "Brittany doesn't look anything like a pit bull."
>
> Last June, the Supreme Court of Canada declined to consider whether the
> four-year-old law is unconstitutional.
[email protected]
> Brampton Guardian
>
> Rambo on death row as city, owners battle over breeding Rambo on death row
> as city, owners battle over breeding
> Friday January 29 2010
> By PAM DOUGLAS
>
> Rambo wasn't hurting anyone.
> No one had complained about the young dog, he hadn't escaped 75-year-old
> Maria Gaspar's Vodden Street yard, and he had never bitten anyone.
>
> But Rambo and his sister, Brittany, are on death row at the City of
> Brampton's Animal Shelter right now while their owners are embroiled in a
> battle to get their beloved pets back before they are euthanized. The
> deadline- Feb. 5.
>
> Both dogs were seized from separate homes on Jan. 13 by city animal
> control
> officials who said they believed the dogs to be pitbulls.
>
> Their owners say that's not true, and both say they have proof from
> veterinarians tracing their backgrounds as boxers/American bulldogs.
>
> The city's veterinarian has a conflicting opinion, according to a letter
> sent to the Branco family, who own Brittany.
>
> Gaspar is heartbroken. The senior citizen can't understand why Rambo was
> seized. She said the confusing part is, the city has licensed Rambo as a
> boxer/American bulldog cross for the past two years. His vaccination
> certificate from North Town Veterinary Hospital classifies his breed as a
> boxer cross. And, no one who has seen the dog has ever thought he was a
> pitbull, according to the distraught Gaspar.
>
> The city told Gaspar that no one had complained about Rambo. He had not
> escaped the back yard. If anything, he made passersby laugh the way he
> would
> jump up onto the roof of his dog house to look over the fence, she said.
>
> But it was that quirky little habit that led to him being removed from his
> home and held by the city under threat of euthanasia.
>
> A passing animal control officer spotted Rambo on his perch in December,
> looking over the six-foot fence, and told Maria Gaspar she had to move the
> doghouse because Rambo could escape. Gaspar agreed, but then the issue of
> Rambo's breed came up. She was told to get a letter from her veterinarian
> attesting to the dog's breed, and to have him neutered. Gaspar said she
> got
> the required letter, and an estimate for neutering, and gave both to the
> city.
>
> In response, the city sent a letter telling Gaspar there is no completed
> certificate from a veterinarian, and that "Rambo has been confirmed to be
> a
> pitbull by his parentage as well as the characteristics as defined in the
> City of Brampton Dog By-law..."
>
> The bylaw defines a pitbull as a pitbull terrier, Staffordshire bull
> terrier, American Staffordshire bull terrier, American pitbull terrier, or
> "a dog that has an appearance and physical characteristics that are
> substantially similar to those dogs."
>
> "It's not, it's not pitbull," said Gaspar emphatically, struggling for the
> English words to describe her upset. She can't talk about Rambo without
> crying.
>
> "This problem is like a son problem," she said, emphasizing how important
> Rambo is to her. "Now, I no have dog, I no have money, I no have
> nothing...
> It's not fair."
>
> They can't fight the city because her family doesn't have any money for a
> lawyer, she said, but Rui Branco is taking on the fight for both dogs.
>
> His family owns Brittany, and they are in a similar predicament. Like
> Rambo,
> there were no complaints or allegations of biting against Brittany. The
> licence for Brittany's father, Tyson, was due for renewal, and an animal
> control officer went to the Branco's house to collect the $20. She was
> told
> Tyson was given away to a friend, but that's when the issue of Brittany's
> lineage arouse, according to Branco.
>
> He has hired a lawyer who is preparing to file a motion in court to get
> the
> dogs back.
>
> "This is an injustice," Branco said, pointing out how ironic it is that he
> will not only have to pay a lawyer to fight for his family's dog, but, as
> a
> resident of Brampton, he will also contribute to the cost of defending the
> city.
>
> Tyson, also Rambo's father, was also licensed by the city at one time,
> although Branco said the family did not realize the city had classified
> him
> as a pitbull, especially since he was born in December 2005, one full
> month
> after the grace period for owning a pitbull. If he was a pitbull, Branco
> said, the city should not have issued a licence to him at all. But, he
> says,
> the real mistake was labeling him a pitbull in the first place.
>
> He has the microchip paperwork for Tyson, and a veterinarian' s letter,
> stating, "He is in my opinion a healthy and well-socialized pet and is a
> cross between an American Bulldog and a Boxer."
>
> A second veterinarian, Dr. David Kirkham of the Cheltenham Veterinary
> Centre, has added a letter stating Brittany's mother, Jersey, is
> "unquestionably a purebred boxer."
>
> "I don't understand why they are fighting me so hard on this," he said.
> "Brittany doesn't look anything like a pitbull."
>
> The Branco's said the city did not have a warrant to seize Brittany when
> they arrived on Jan. 13, and Rui's brother, John, confronted the city
> worker, who then called for backup. Several police officers and other city
> animal control officials arrived, and, ultimately, the dog was handed
> over.
> However, the Branco's argue they were intimidated into willingly turning
> over their pet and feel proper procedure (a warrant) was not followed.
>
> For their part, the city is considering four charges against the Branco
> family- owning a pitbull born after Nov. 29, 2005 in relation to Brittany
> and in relation to Tyson, failing to licence a pitbull, transferring a
> pitbull without consent of the poundkeeper and permitting a pitbull to
> breed.
>
> The Gaspar family faces one charge of owning a pitbull.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Brampton Guardian
>
> Groundswell of support for two dogs on death row Groundswell of support
> for
> two dogs on death row
> Tuesday February 2 2010
> By PAM DOUGLAS
>
> There has been a groundswell of support for two Brampton families whose
> dogs
> were seized by the city and labelled as illegal pitbulls.
>
> A Facebook page calling for Rambo and Brittany to be released was started
> by
> those opposed to Ontario's pitbull ban soon after The Guardian broke the
> news of the dogs' plight Friday. The page has attracted close to 2,000
> members, and an online petition is closing in on 3,000 signatures.
>
> Bloggers are weighing in on the controversy, too, along with residents
> across Ontario and as far away as Texas. The vast majority are critical of
> the city's handling of the situation, as well as the pitbull ban, which
> they
> say leads to the 'misidentification' of many dogs. Some are focusing their
> anger at animal control officers, saying they did not have to seize the
> dogs, while others are urging them not to blame the city employees, saying
> they had no choice.
>
> Meanwhile, the Feb. 5 deadline for the Brampton dogs to be euthanized has
> been extended as the lawyer representing owners Rui Branco and his family
> prepares to take the fight to court to get the pets returned.
>
> Both were seized from separate homes Jan. 13. The city's veterinarian has
> declared they are pitbulls under the city's bylaw, while the families say
> they are not, and have produced some documents identifying them as
> boxer/American bulldog mixes.
>
> The two dogs are brother and sister, and for the past two years, Rambo has
> been licensed by the city as a boxer/American bulldog cross.
>
> But when a passing animal control officer spotted Rambo sitting on top of
> his doghouse in 75-year-old Maria Gaspar's backyard in December, the
> senior
> citizen was questioned about his breeding.
>
> The Gaspars and Brancos have been told there were no complaints about
> their
> dogs, and no accusations of aggressive behaviour, running loose or biting.
> Similar to what happened to Rambo, an animal control officer who went to
> collect a licence fee from the Branco home spotted Brittany and started
> asking questions about her lineage.
>
> Both dogs were seized, and have been held at the city's animal shelter
> ever
> since.
>
> A dog doesn't have to be a pitbull to be labelled as one under the city's
> bylaw. It defines a pitbull as a pitbull terrier, Staffordshire bull
> terrier, American Staffordshire bull terrior, American pitbull terrier, or
> "a dog that has an appearance and physical characteristics that are
> substantially similar to those dogs."
>
> Both families are distraught about the seizure of their pets. The issue is
> in the hands of the city's legal department, so city officials would not
> comment on the specific cases.
>
> The two families are holding a press conference Wednesday morning.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Toronto Sun
>
> Seized dogs aren't pit bulls: Owners
> By JENNY YUEN, Toronto Sun
>
> Last Updated: 3rd February 2010, 10:25pm
>
> BRAMPTON - Rambo and Brittany may end up on doggie death row unless their
> owners quickly prove the canines aren't pit bulls.
>
> Maria Gaspar and Joseph Branco having been fearing the worst since
> Brampton
> Animal Services seized siblings Rambo and Brittany from different
> residences
> on Jan. 13 for violating the province's pit bull ban.
>
> The owners argued Wednesday that the two-year-old dogs are actually 75%
> boxer and 25% American bulldog and the city had no right to snatch them.
>
> "We stand by the fact that the dogs are boxer mixes," said Rui Branco, 42,
> whose brother owns Brittany and her parents, Jersey and Tyson.
>
> "There was no warrant, no complaints or abuse complaints. The city has
> been
> stonewalling us. We got a letter a day ago from the city ... certifying
> Brittany as a pit bull."
>
> Gaspar, 75, was in tears as she expressed concern for her beloved dog,
> Rambo.
>
> "I just want my dog back," she said. "He didn't do anything to anybody."
>
> But Animal Services said that Joseph Branco had registered Tyson as a
> restricted pit bull in a 2008 licensing document, which means it's against
> the law for Tyson to have puppies.
>
> "The father of these dogs from two different litters was registered as a
> restricted pit bull," city spokesman Mariam Mesbah said. "You have to have
> the dog neutered and microchipped, which was done, but we've since
> discovered the two dogs."
>
> Pit bulls were banned from the province as of Nov. 29, 2005.
>
> Rambo and Brittany's owners faced a Friday deadline to send the dogs to a
> province that accepts pit bulls. The city since has offered the owners an
> extension, Mesbah said.
>
> "In light of the fact they've been granted an extension, (euthanasia of
> the
> dogs) wouldn't happen," Mesbah said.
>
> Branco says the city has dismissed a document from the Campbell Veterinary
> Hospital in Brampton saying Tyson is an American bulldog and a boxer.
>
> Branco said his lawyer is trying to get more documentation from the city
> that proves Tyson is a pit bull.
>
> "I have no idea how the city registered Tyson, the father, as a pit bull
> and
> I have no idea what led them here," Branco said. "Their excuse for being
> at
> our door was to collect the licence fee. The bylaw officer said, 'I'm
> going
> to hunt (Tyson's pups) down, one by one,'"
>
> A Facebook group, "Injustice Brampton Dogs on Death Row - Free Them Now,"
> urging the release of the dogs has had more than 2,600 members sign a
> petition.
>
> [email protected]
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Toronto Star
>
> Seized dogs are pit bulls, Brampton says
> February 02, 2010
>
> Jim Wilkes
>
> Two Brampton dogs may face a date with the executioner unless their owners
> can prove they are not pit bulls.
>
> The dogs, 2-year-olds from the same litter, were seized from separate
> homes
> last month by animal services officers who told the owners they had
> characteristics of the banned dogs.
>
> "They're not pit bulls," said Rui Branco, whose family owns Jersey, the
> purebred boxer who had a litter of nine pups and once owned Tyson, who he
> said is an American bulldog that sired the brood. Their dog Brittany was
> seized on Jan. 13.
>
> "No matter what we say, no matter what documents we show them, they won't
> believe us."
>
> The city says Tyson was registered with Brampton as a pit bull and claims
> a
> veterinary certificate proves it, said spokesperson Miriam Mesbah.
>
> The city initially gave the two families until Friday to decide whether to
> have the dogs euthanized or pay to have them shipped to another province
> that allows pit bulls. But Tuesday the city granted an extension to allow
> Branco's lawyer to challenge the dogs' lineage in court.
>
> "Under the Dog Owners Liability Act we are required to seize those dogs,"
> Mesbah said. "Because we have that evidence, we are not legally allowed to
> release the dogs."
>
> The act took effect Nov. 29, 2005, banning pit bulls from in the province.
>
> In Brampton, a dog is considered to be a pit bull if it is a pit bull
> terrier, a Staffordshire bull terrier, an American Staffordshire bull
> terrier, an American pit bull terrier or any dog "that has an appearance
> and
> physical characteristics that are substantially similar to those...,"
> according to a city bylaw.
>
> Both Branco and Joe Gaspar, whose family pet Rambo was also seized Jan.
> 13,
> say their animals have never been loose or the subject of complaints from
> neighbours.
>
> They have letters from four veterinarians and a company that inserts
> microchips under a dog's skin supporting their claims there is no pit bull
> in either dog.
>
> One Brampton vet wrote that he would stake his 51-year veterinary
> reputation
> that Tyson was an American bulldog/boxer mix.
>
> "There's no pit bull in him at all," said Gaspar, whose Portuguese-born
> mother Maria struggled to find words as tears streamed down her cheeks.
>
> He said the seizures came after an animal services officer saw Rambo
> standing atop its doghouse on a deck in the family's backyard and thought
> it
> looked like a pit bull.
>
> "He's never hurt a soul. Kids come by and pull his ears, play with him all
> the time," Gaspar said. "I don't know what more we can do to prove that
> Rambo isn't a pit bull.
>
> "They say it doesn't matter what we show them. In their eyes, he's a pit
> bull, so these papers mean nothing to them. We've got nothing to hide.
> He's
> just a sweet dog."
>
> Branco said confusion about the dogs' lineage is the result of Tyson being
> wrongly labeled a pit bull when it was licenced by Brampton in 2006.
>
> He said he only later learned of the error and couldn't change it.
>
> "If they thought Tyson was a pit bull, why did they license him in the
> first
> place?" he said. "He was born after the ban was in place. If he was really
> a
> pit bull, they couldn't have done that. It was their mistake."
>
> In 2008, another pit bull, also named Rambo, won a reprieve from doggie
> death row in Mississauga and was shipped to a farm in Nova Scotia after
> its
> owner was convicted of having an illegal dog. It had been captured by an
> animal control officer after escaping from its owner's backyard.
>
> Mesbah said Brampton municipal lawyers are considering charges against the
> two owners for owning an illegal pit bull. Branco said he has been warned
> he
> could also be prosecuted for permitting a pit bull to breed, failing to
> license a pit bull and transferring a pit bull without consent of the city
> poundkeeper.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Toronto Star
>
> Owners' pleas ignored as two 'pit bulls' seized
> February 03, 2010
>
> Jim Wilkes
>
>
> Rambo and smaller Jasmine stand atop a barbecue on the deck of the Gaspar
> family home in Brampton.
>
> SUPPLIED PHOTO
>
> Two Brampton dogs may face a date with the executioner unless their owners
> can prove they are not pit bulls.
>
> The dogs, 2-year-olds from the same litter, were seized from separate
> homes
> last month by animal services officers who told the owners they had
> characteristics of the banned dogs.
>
> "They're not pit bulls," said Rui Branco, whose dog Brittany was one of
> the
> two dogs seized on Jan. 13. "No matter what we say, no matter what
> documents
> we show them, they won't believe us."
>
> The Branco family owns Jersey, the purebred boxer that gave birth to the
> litter of nine pups that included the two seized animals. The family also
> once owned Tyson, the brood's sire, who Branco said is an American
> bulldog.
> The city says Tyson was registered with Brampton as a pit bull and claims
> that a veterinary certificate proves it, said spokeswoman Miriam Mesbah.
>
> But Branco and Joe Gaspar, whose family pet Rambo was also seized Jan. 13,
> have letters from four veterinarians and a company that inserts microchips
> under a dog's skin supporting their claims there is no pit bull in either
> dog.
>
> One Brampton vet wrote that he would stake his 51-year veterinary
> reputation
> that Tyson was an American bulldog-boxer mix.
>
> "There's no pit bull in him at all," said Gaspar, whose Portuguese-born
> mother, Maria, struggled to find words as tears streamed down her cheeks.
>
> The city initially gave the two families until Friday to decide whether to
> have the dogs euthanized or pay to have them shipped to another province
> that allows pit bulls.
>
> On Tuesday, the city granted an extension to allow Branco's lawyer to
> challenge the dogs' lineage in court.
>
> "Under the Dog Owners Liability Act we are required to seize those dogs,"
> Mesbah said. "Because we have that evidence, we are not legally allowed to
> release the dogs."
>
> The act took effect Nov. 29, 2005, banning pit bulls from the province.
>
> In Brampton, a dog is considered to be a pit bull if it is a pit bull
> terrier, a Staffordshire bull terrier, an American Staffordshire bull
> terrier, an American pit bull terrier or any dog "that has an appearance
> and
> physical characteristics that are substantially similar to those ..."
> according to a city bylaw.
>
> Both Branco and Joe Gaspar said their animals have never been loose, nor
> the
> subject of complaints from neighbours.
>
> Gaspar said the seizures came after an animal services officer saw Rambo
> standing atop its doghouse on a deck in the family's backyard and thought
> it
> looked like a pit bull.
>
> "He's never hurt a soul. Kids come by and pull his ears, play with him all
> the time," Gaspar said. "I don't know what more we can do to prove that
> Rambo isn't a pit bull.
>
> "They say it doesn't matter what we show them. In their eyes, he's a pit
> bull, so these papers mean nothing to them. We've got nothing to hide.
> He's
> just a sweet dog."
>
> Branco said confusion about the dogs' lineage is the result of Tyson being
> wrongly labelled a pit bull when it was licensed by Brampton in 2006.
>
> He said he only later learned of the error and couldn't change it.
>
> "If they thought Tyson was a pit bull, why did they license him in the
> first
> place?" he said. "He was born after the ban was in place. If he was really
> a
> pit bull, they couldn't have done that. It was their mistake."
>
> Mesbah said Brampton municipal lawyers are considering charges against the
> two owners for owning an illegal pit bull. Branco said he has been warned
> he
> could also be prosecuted for permitting a pit bull to breed, failing to
> license a pit bull and transferring a pit bull without consent of the city
> poundkeeper.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Globe and Mail
>
> Dog fight
> Boxer mixes caught up in pit bull controversy
>
> Timothy Appleby
>
> Toronto - From Wednesday's Globe and Mail
> Published on Wednesday, Feb. 03, 2010 12:37AM EST
>
> Last updated on Wednesday, Feb. 03, 2010 3:47AM EST
>
> One veterinarian' s boxer is another vet's pit bull.
>
> As a result, Rambo and his sister Brittany are languishing behind bars at
> the City of Brampton's animal shelter, possibly headed for the death
> chamber.
>
> Their aggrieved owners, meanwhile, complain that whatever the city may
> say,
> neither beast is a pit bull at all.
>
> Pit bulls are a type of dog rather than a breed and have garnered numerous
> headlines and a couple of high-profile court hearings since an amendment
> to
> Ontario's Dog Owners' Liability Act took effect four years ago.
>
> Under the new rules, pit bull terriers, Staffordshire bull terriers,
> American Staffordshire bull terriers and American pit bull terriers are
> outlawed; those already here were allowed to remain, providing they be
> muzzled and leashed.
>
> Straightforward enough. However, the legislation also contains a clause
> banning any dog "that has the appearance and physical characteristics
> substantially similar to" those specified.
>
> For Rambo and Brittany, born in separate litters to the same parents, that
> inclusiveness has spelled bad news and their future looks bleak: If homes
> are not found for them outside Ontario they may be euthanized, though no
> execution date has been set.
>
> Rambo belongs to 75-year-old Maria Gaspar. Brittany's home is across town
> with the Branco family.
>
> Both were seized Jan. 13 by city animal control officials who said they
> believed the dogs were pit bulls.
>
> Not so, says Rui Branco, who will host a press conference outside his
> Reeve
> Road home Wednesday morning in efforts to highlight the plight of the two
> siblings, neither of which is known to have attacked or threatened anyone.
>
> Rather, their perceived sin rests with their lineage.
>
> The dogs' mother was Jersey, a purebred boxer. No problem there.
>
> But their dad was Tyson, born shortly after the pit bull law took effect
> in
> late November, 2005, and a survivor of the ban, apparently through an
> oversight. He was, nonetheless, classified as a pit bull, although Tyson's
> family vet disagrees, calling him "a healthy and well-socialized pet . a
> cross between an American bulldog and a boxer."
>
> Either way, Tyson's label as a pit bull means his offspring are deemed pit
> bulls, too.
>
> "Animal Services has documentary and veterinary evidence that (Rambo and
> Brittany) are pit bulls," city spokeswoman Mariam Mesbah said.
>
> "The bottom line is that if the mother or the father is a pit bull and
> documented as such, any of their brood would be considered pit bulls. We
> are
> required by law to follow the legislation. "
>
> Lawyer Megan Burkett, acting for the Brancos, is preparing a court motion
> to
> get both dogs back on grounds they were improperly seized, and says the
> law
> casts too wide a net.
>
> "Tyson is an American bulldog and a boxer and if they wanted boxer to be
> in
> the legislation, it should have said boxer," she said.
>
> "That's what's causing the problem. Our position is that he looks like a
> boxer. A lot of breeds are being caught up in this that shouldn't be."
>
> Rambo's troubles began when he was spotted atop his doghouse in his fenced
> yard, and his detention left his elderly owner, Ms. Gaspar, distraught.
>
> For the previous two years the city had licensed him as a boxer/American
> bulldog cross, she told a local newspaper, and his vaccination certificate
> states that.
>
> Brittany was picked up later the same day. And her vet, Dr. David Kirkham,
> voices the same complaint of mistaken identity. "I don't understand why
> (city officials) are fighting me so hard on this," he said.
>
> "Brittany doesn't look anything like a pit bull."
>
> Last June, the Supreme Court of Canada declined to consider whether the
> four-year-old law is unconstitutional.