Brampton,Ontario,Canada - NGHTMARE - *LONG Story*

  • Thread starter Thread starter apbtmom76
  • Start date Start date

A

apbtmom76

Please write the Mayor of Brampton Ontario

[email protected]

> Brampton Guardian
>
> Rambo on death row as city, owners battle over breeding Rambo on death row
> as city, owners battle over breeding
> Friday January 29 2010

> By PAM DOUGLAS
>
> Rambo wasn't hurting anyone.
> No one had complained about the young dog, he hadn't escaped 75-year-old
> Maria Gaspar's Vodden Street yard, and he had never bitten anyone.
>
> But Rambo and his sister, Brittany, are on death row at the City of
> Brampton's Animal Shelter right now while their owners are embroiled in a
> battle to get their beloved pets back before they are euthanized. The
> deadline- Feb. 5.
>
> Both dogs were seized from separate homes on Jan. 13 by city animal
> control
> officials who said they believed the dogs to be pitbulls.
>
> Their owners say that's not true, and both say they have proof from
> veterinarians tracing their backgrounds as boxers/American bulldogs.
>
> The city's veterinarian has a conflicting opinion, according to a letter
> sent to the Branco family, who own Brittany.
>
> Gaspar is heartbroken. The senior citizen can't understand why Rambo was
> seized. She said the confusing part is, the city has licensed Rambo as a
> boxer/American bulldog cross for the past two years. His vaccination
> certificate from North Town Veterinary Hospital classifies his breed as a
> boxer cross. And, no one who has seen the dog has ever thought he was a
> pitbull, according to the distraught Gaspar.
>
> The city told Gaspar that no one had complained about Rambo. He had not
> escaped the back yard. If anything, he made passersby laugh the way he
> would
> jump up onto the roof of his dog house to look over the fence, she said.
>
> But it was that quirky little habit that led to him being removed from his
> home and held by the city under threat of euthanasia.
>
> A passing animal control officer spotted Rambo on his perch in December,
> looking over the six-foot fence, and told Maria Gaspar she had to move the
> doghouse because Rambo could escape. Gaspar agreed, but then the issue of
> Rambo's breed came up. She was told to get a letter from her veterinarian
> attesting to the dog's breed, and to have him neutered. Gaspar said she
> got
> the required letter, and an estimate for neutering, and gave both to the
> city.
>
> In response, the city sent a letter telling Gaspar there is no completed
> certificate from a veterinarian, and that "Rambo has been confirmed to be
> a
> pitbull by his parentage as well as the characteristics as defined in the
> City of Brampton Dog By-law..."
>
> The bylaw defines a pitbull as a pitbull terrier, Staffordshire bull
> terrier, American Staffordshire bull terrier, American pitbull terrier, or
> "a dog that has an appearance and physical characteristics that are
> substantially similar to those dogs."
>
> "It's not, it's not pitbull," said Gaspar emphatically, struggling for the
> English words to describe her upset. She can't talk about Rambo without
> crying.
>
> "This problem is like a son problem," she said, emphasizing how important
> Rambo is to her. "Now, I no have dog, I no have money, I no have
> nothing...
> It's not fair."
>
> They can't fight the city because her family doesn't have any money for a
> lawyer, she said, but Rui Branco is taking on the fight for both dogs.
>
> His family owns Brittany, and they are in a similar predicament. Like
> Rambo,
> there were no complaints or allegations of biting against Brittany. The
> licence for Brittany's father, Tyson, was due for renewal, and an animal
> control officer went to the Branco's house to collect the $20. She was
> told
> Tyson was given away to a friend, but that's when the issue of Brittany's
> lineage arouse, according to Branco.
>
> He has hired a lawyer who is preparing to file a motion in court to get
> the
> dogs back.
>
> "This is an injustice," Branco said, pointing out how ironic it is that he
> will not only have to pay a lawyer to fight for his family's dog, but, as
> a
> resident of Brampton, he will also contribute to the cost of defending the
> city.
>
> Tyson, also Rambo's father, was also licensed by the city at one time,
> although Branco said the family did not realize the city had classified
> him
> as a pitbull, especially since he was born in December 2005, one full
> month
> after the grace period for owning a pitbull. If he was a pitbull, Branco
> said, the city should not have issued a licence to him at all. But, he
> says,
> the real mistake was labeling him a pitbull in the first place.
>
> He has the microchip paperwork for Tyson, and a veterinarian' s letter,
> stating, "He is in my opinion a healthy and well-socialized pet and is a
> cross between an American Bulldog and a Boxer."
>
> A second veterinarian, Dr. David Kirkham of the Cheltenham Veterinary
> Centre, has added a letter stating Brittany's mother, Jersey, is
> "unquestionably a purebred boxer."
>
> "I don't understand why they are fighting me so hard on this," he said.
> "Brittany doesn't look anything like a pitbull."
>
> The Branco's said the city did not have a warrant to seize Brittany when
> they arrived on Jan. 13, and Rui's brother, John, confronted the city
> worker, who then called for backup. Several police officers and other city
> animal control officials arrived, and, ultimately, the dog was handed
> over.
> However, the Branco's argue they were intimidated into willingly turning
> over their pet and feel proper procedure (a warrant) was not followed.
>
> For their part, the city is considering four charges against the Branco
> family- owning a pitbull born after Nov. 29, 2005 in relation to Brittany
> and in relation to Tyson, failing to licence a pitbull, transferring a
> pitbull without consent of the poundkeeper and permitting a pitbull to
> breed.
>
> The Gaspar family faces one charge of owning a pitbull.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Brampton Guardian
>
> Groundswell of support for two dogs on death row Groundswell of support
> for
> two dogs on death row
> Tuesday February 2 2010

> By PAM DOUGLAS
>
> There has been a groundswell of support for two Brampton families whose
> dogs
> were seized by the city and labelled as illegal pitbulls.
>
> A Facebook page calling for Rambo and Brittany to be released was started
> by
> those opposed to Ontario's pitbull ban soon after The Guardian broke the
> news of the dogs' plight Friday. The page has attracted close to 2,000
> members, and an online petition is closing in on 3,000 signatures.
>
> Bloggers are weighing in on the controversy, too, along with residents
> across Ontario and as far away as Texas. The vast majority are critical of
> the city's handling of the situation, as well as the pitbull ban, which
> they
> say leads to the 'misidentification' of many dogs. Some are focusing their
> anger at animal control officers, saying they did not have to seize the
> dogs, while others are urging them not to blame the city employees, saying
> they had no choice.
>
> Meanwhile, the Feb. 5 deadline for the Brampton dogs to be euthanized has
> been extended as the lawyer representing owners Rui Branco and his family
> prepares to take the fight to court to get the pets returned.
>
> Both were seized from separate homes Jan. 13. The city's veterinarian has
> declared they are pitbulls under the city's bylaw, while the families say
> they are not, and have produced some documents identifying them as
> boxer/American bulldog mixes.
>
> The two dogs are brother and sister, and for the past two years, Rambo has
> been licensed by the city as a boxer/American bulldog cross.
>
> But when a passing animal control officer spotted Rambo sitting on top of
> his doghouse in 75-year-old Maria Gaspar's backyard in December, the
> senior
> citizen was questioned about his breeding.
>
> The Gaspars and Brancos have been told there were no complaints about
> their
> dogs, and no accusations of aggressive behaviour, running loose or biting.
> Similar to what happened to Rambo, an animal control officer who went to
> collect a licence fee from the Branco home spotted Brittany and started
> asking questions about her lineage.
>
> Both dogs were seized, and have been held at the city's animal shelter
> ever
> since.
>
> A dog doesn't have to be a pitbull to be labelled as one under the city's
> bylaw. It defines a pitbull as a pitbull terrier, Staffordshire bull
> terrier, American Staffordshire bull terrior, American pitbull terrier, or
> "a dog that has an appearance and physical characteristics that are
> substantially similar to those dogs."
>
> Both families are distraught about the seizure of their pets. The issue is
> in the hands of the city's legal department, so city officials would not
> comment on the specific cases.
>
> The two families are holding a press conference Wednesday morning.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Toronto Sun
>
> Seized dogs aren't pit bulls: Owners

> By JENNY YUEN, Toronto Sun
>
> Last Updated: 3rd February 2010, 10:25pm
>
> BRAMPTON - Rambo and Brittany may end up on doggie death row unless their
> owners quickly prove the canines aren't pit bulls.
>
> Maria Gaspar and Joseph Branco having been fearing the worst since
> Brampton
> Animal Services seized siblings Rambo and Brittany from different
> residences
> on Jan. 13 for violating the province's pit bull ban.
>
> The owners argued Wednesday that the two-year-old dogs are actually 75%
> boxer and 25% American bulldog and the city had no right to snatch them.
>
> "We stand by the fact that the dogs are boxer mixes," said Rui Branco, 42,
> whose brother owns Brittany and her parents, Jersey and Tyson.
>
> "There was no warrant, no complaints or abuse complaints. The city has
> been
> stonewalling us. We got a letter a day ago from the city ... certifying
> Brittany as a pit bull."
>
> Gaspar, 75, was in tears as she expressed concern for her beloved dog,
> Rambo.
>
> "I just want my dog back," she said. "He didn't do anything to anybody."
>
> But Animal Services said that Joseph Branco had registered Tyson as a
> restricted pit bull in a 2008 licensing document, which means it's against
> the law for Tyson to have puppies.
>
> "The father of these dogs from two different litters was registered as a
> restricted pit bull," city spokesman Mariam Mesbah said. "You have to have
> the dog neutered and microchipped, which was done, but we've since
> discovered the two dogs."
>
> Pit bulls were banned from the province as of Nov. 29, 2005.
>
> Rambo and Brittany's owners faced a Friday deadline to send the dogs to a
> province that accepts pit bulls. The city since has offered the owners an
> extension, Mesbah said.
>
> "In light of the fact they've been granted an extension, (euthanasia of
> the
> dogs) wouldn't happen," Mesbah said.
>
> Branco says the city has dismissed a document from the Campbell Veterinary
> Hospital in Brampton saying Tyson is an American bulldog and a boxer.
>
> Branco said his lawyer is trying to get more documentation from the city
> that proves Tyson is a pit bull.
>
> "I have no idea how the city registered Tyson, the father, as a pit bull
> and
> I have no idea what led them here," Branco said. "Their excuse for being
> at
> our door was to collect the licence fee. The bylaw officer said, 'I'm
> going
> to hunt (Tyson's pups) down, one by one,'"
>
> A Facebook group, "Injustice Brampton Dogs on Death Row - Free Them Now,"
> urging the release of the dogs has had more than 2,600 members sign a
> petition.
>
> [email protected]
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Toronto Star
>
> Seized dogs are pit bulls, Brampton says
> February 02, 2010

>
> Jim Wilkes
>
> Two Brampton dogs may face a date with the executioner unless their owners
> can prove they are not pit bulls.
>
> The dogs, 2-year-olds from the same litter, were seized from separate
> homes
> last month by animal services officers who told the owners they had
> characteristics of the banned dogs.
>
> "They're not pit bulls," said Rui Branco, whose family owns Jersey, the
> purebred boxer who had a litter of nine pups and once owned Tyson, who he
> said is an American bulldog that sired the brood. Their dog Brittany was
> seized on Jan. 13.
>
> "No matter what we say, no matter what documents we show them, they won't
> believe us."
>
> The city says Tyson was registered with Brampton as a pit bull and claims
> a
> veterinary certificate proves it, said spokesperson Miriam Mesbah.
>
> The city initially gave the two families until Friday to decide whether to
> have the dogs euthanized or pay to have them shipped to another province
> that allows pit bulls. But Tuesday the city granted an extension to allow
> Branco's lawyer to challenge the dogs' lineage in court.
>
> "Under the Dog Owners Liability Act we are required to seize those dogs,"
> Mesbah said. "Because we have that evidence, we are not legally allowed to
> release the dogs."
>
> The act took effect Nov. 29, 2005, banning pit bulls from in the province.
>
> In Brampton, a dog is considered to be a pit bull if it is a pit bull
> terrier, a Staffordshire bull terrier, an American Staffordshire bull
> terrier, an American pit bull terrier or any dog "that has an appearance
> and
> physical characteristics that are substantially similar to those...,"
> according to a city bylaw.
>
> Both Branco and Joe Gaspar, whose family pet Rambo was also seized Jan.
> 13,
> say their animals have never been loose or the subject of complaints from
> neighbours.
>
> They have letters from four veterinarians and a company that inserts
> microchips under a dog's skin supporting their claims there is no pit bull
> in either dog.
>
> One Brampton vet wrote that he would stake his 51-year veterinary
> reputation
> that Tyson was an American bulldog/boxer mix.
>
> "There's no pit bull in him at all," said Gaspar, whose Portuguese-born
> mother Maria struggled to find words as tears streamed down her cheeks.
>
> He said the seizures came after an animal services officer saw Rambo
> standing atop its doghouse on a deck in the family's backyard and thought
> it
> looked like a pit bull.
>
> "He's never hurt a soul. Kids come by and pull his ears, play with him all
> the time," Gaspar said. "I don't know what more we can do to prove that
> Rambo isn't a pit bull.
>
> "They say it doesn't matter what we show them. In their eyes, he's a pit
> bull, so these papers mean nothing to them. We've got nothing to hide.
> He's
> just a sweet dog."
>
> Branco said confusion about the dogs' lineage is the result of Tyson being
> wrongly labeled a pit bull when it was licenced by Brampton in 2006.
>
> He said he only later learned of the error and couldn't change it.
>
> "If they thought Tyson was a pit bull, why did they license him in the
> first
> place?" he said. "He was born after the ban was in place. If he was really
> a
> pit bull, they couldn't have done that. It was their mistake."
>
> In 2008, another pit bull, also named Rambo, won a reprieve from doggie
> death row in Mississauga and was shipped to a farm in Nova Scotia after
> its
> owner was convicted of having an illegal dog. It had been captured by an
> animal control officer after escaping from its owner's backyard.
>
> Mesbah said Brampton municipal lawyers are considering charges against the
> two owners for owning an illegal pit bull. Branco said he has been warned
> he
> could also be prosecuted for permitting a pit bull to breed, failing to
> license a pit bull and transferring a pit bull without consent of the city
> poundkeeper.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Toronto Star
>
> Owners' pleas ignored as two 'pit bulls' seized
> February 03, 2010

>
> Jim Wilkes
>
>
> Rambo and smaller Jasmine stand atop a barbecue on the deck of the Gaspar
> family home in Brampton.
>
> SUPPLIED PHOTO
>
> Two Brampton dogs may face a date with the executioner unless their owners
> can prove they are not pit bulls.
>
> The dogs, 2-year-olds from the same litter, were seized from separate
> homes
> last month by animal services officers who told the owners they had
> characteristics of the banned dogs.
>
> "They're not pit bulls," said Rui Branco, whose dog Brittany was one of
> the
> two dogs seized on Jan. 13. "No matter what we say, no matter what
> documents
> we show them, they won't believe us."
>
> The Branco family owns Jersey, the purebred boxer that gave birth to the
> litter of nine pups that included the two seized animals. The family also
> once owned Tyson, the brood's sire, who Branco said is an American
> bulldog.
> The city says Tyson was registered with Brampton as a pit bull and claims
> that a veterinary certificate proves it, said spokeswoman Miriam Mesbah.
>
> But Branco and Joe Gaspar, whose family pet Rambo was also seized Jan. 13,
> have letters from four veterinarians and a company that inserts microchips
> under a dog's skin supporting their claims there is no pit bull in either
> dog.
>
> One Brampton vet wrote that he would stake his 51-year veterinary
> reputation
> that Tyson was an American bulldog-boxer mix.
>
> "There's no pit bull in him at all," said Gaspar, whose Portuguese-born
> mother, Maria, struggled to find words as tears streamed down her cheeks.
>
> The city initially gave the two families until Friday to decide whether to
> have the dogs euthanized or pay to have them shipped to another province
> that allows pit bulls.
>
> On Tuesday, the city granted an extension to allow Branco's lawyer to
> challenge the dogs' lineage in court.
>
> "Under the Dog Owners Liability Act we are required to seize those dogs,"
> Mesbah said. "Because we have that evidence, we are not legally allowed to
> release the dogs."
>
> The act took effect Nov. 29, 2005, banning pit bulls from the province.
>
> In Brampton, a dog is considered to be a pit bull if it is a pit bull
> terrier, a Staffordshire bull terrier, an American Staffordshire bull
> terrier, an American pit bull terrier or any dog "that has an appearance
> and
> physical characteristics that are substantially similar to those ..."
> according to a city bylaw.
>
> Both Branco and Joe Gaspar said their animals have never been loose, nor
> the
> subject of complaints from neighbours.
>
> Gaspar said the seizures came after an animal services officer saw Rambo
> standing atop its doghouse on a deck in the family's backyard and thought
> it
> looked like a pit bull.
>
> "He's never hurt a soul. Kids come by and pull his ears, play with him all
> the time," Gaspar said. "I don't know what more we can do to prove that
> Rambo isn't a pit bull.
>
> "They say it doesn't matter what we show them. In their eyes, he's a pit
> bull, so these papers mean nothing to them. We've got nothing to hide.
> He's
> just a sweet dog."
>
> Branco said confusion about the dogs' lineage is the result of Tyson being
> wrongly labelled a pit bull when it was licensed by Brampton in 2006.
>
> He said he only later learned of the error and couldn't change it.
>
> "If they thought Tyson was a pit bull, why did they license him in the
> first
> place?" he said. "He was born after the ban was in place. If he was really
> a
> pit bull, they couldn't have done that. It was their mistake."
>
> Mesbah said Brampton municipal lawyers are considering charges against the
> two owners for owning an illegal pit bull. Branco said he has been warned
> he
> could also be prosecuted for permitting a pit bull to breed, failing to
> license a pit bull and transferring a pit bull without consent of the city
> poundkeeper.
>
> ------------ --------- --------- --------- --------- --------- -
>
> Globe and Mail
>
> Dog fight
> Boxer mixes caught up in pit bull controversy

>
> Timothy Appleby
>
> Toronto - From Wednesday's Globe and Mail
> Published on Wednesday, Feb. 03, 2010 12:37AM EST
>
> Last updated on Wednesday, Feb. 03, 2010 3:47AM EST
>
> One veterinarian' s boxer is another vet's pit bull.
>
> As a result, Rambo and his sister Brittany are languishing behind bars at
> the City of Brampton's animal shelter, possibly headed for the death
> chamber.
>
> Their aggrieved owners, meanwhile, complain that whatever the city may
> say,
> neither beast is a pit bull at all.
>
> Pit bulls are a type of dog rather than a breed and have garnered numerous
> headlines and a couple of high-profile court hearings since an amendment
> to
> Ontario's Dog Owners' Liability Act took effect four years ago.
>
> Under the new rules, pit bull terriers, Staffordshire bull terriers,
> American Staffordshire bull terriers and American pit bull terriers are
> outlawed; those already here were allowed to remain, providing they be
> muzzled and leashed.
>
> Straightforward enough. However, the legislation also contains a clause
> banning any dog "that has the appearance and physical characteristics
> substantially similar to" those specified.
>
> For Rambo and Brittany, born in separate litters to the same parents, that
> inclusiveness has spelled bad news and their future looks bleak: If homes
> are not found for them outside Ontario they may be euthanized, though no
> execution date has been set.
>
> Rambo belongs to 75-year-old Maria Gaspar. Brittany's home is across town
> with the Branco family.
>
> Both were seized Jan. 13 by city animal control officials who said they
> believed the dogs were pit bulls.
>
> Not so, says Rui Branco, who will host a press conference outside his
> Reeve
> Road home Wednesday morning in efforts to highlight the plight of the two
> siblings, neither of which is known to have attacked or threatened anyone.
>
> Rather, their perceived sin rests with their lineage.
>
> The dogs' mother was Jersey, a purebred boxer. No problem there.
>
> But their dad was Tyson, born shortly after the pit bull law took effect
> in
> late November, 2005, and a survivor of the ban, apparently through an
> oversight. He was, nonetheless, classified as a pit bull, although Tyson's
> family vet disagrees, calling him "a healthy and well-socialized pet . a
> cross between an American bulldog and a boxer."
>
> Either way, Tyson's label as a pit bull means his offspring are deemed pit
> bulls, too.
>
> "Animal Services has documentary and veterinary evidence that (Rambo and
> Brittany) are pit bulls," city spokeswoman Mariam Mesbah said.
>
> "The bottom line is that if the mother or the father is a pit bull and
> documented as such, any of their brood would be considered pit bulls. We
> are
> required by law to follow the legislation. "
>
> Lawyer Megan Burkett, acting for the Brancos, is preparing a court motion
> to
> get both dogs back on grounds they were improperly seized, and says the
> law
> casts too wide a net.
>
> "Tyson is an American bulldog and a boxer and if they wanted boxer to be
> in
> the legislation, it should have said boxer," she said.
>
> "That's what's causing the problem. Our position is that he looks like a
> boxer. A lot of breeds are being caught up in this that shouldn't be."
>
> Rambo's troubles began when he was spotted atop his doghouse in his fenced
> yard, and his detention left his elderly owner, Ms. Gaspar, distraught.
>
> For the previous two years the city had licensed him as a boxer/American
> bulldog cross, she told a local newspaper, and his vaccination certificate
> states that.
>
> Brittany was picked up later the same day. And her vet, Dr. David Kirkham,
> voices the same complaint of mistaken identity. "I don't understand why
> (city officials) are fighting me so hard on this," he said.
>
> "Brittany doesn't look anything like a pit bull."
>
> Last June, the Supreme Court of Canada declined to consider whether the
> four-year-old law is unconstitutional.
 
it drives me crazy and makes me so upset, if there is prove, that those dogs are no Pit's, why say different and take them anyway.
i'm so sorry for those family's and hope, they will get their dogs back. that poot old Lady, it must break her heart.
those officials are so heartless and brainless, grrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr
 

Back
Top