• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?

Rehash?? People who just give up and stop roaring loose their rights and in this case a breed is at stake - a breed I love dearly. No one forces anyone to choose a cropped an docked breed so please don't force us to loose our rights. If one truly understands the entire concept of PUREBRED then you have to respect and uphold a standard.

I just got a PM about the # of people on here asking about getting their puppy cropped - THANK GOODNESS but where or where are the true good breeders who do it right???
 
Rehash?? People who just give up and stop roaring loose their rights and in this case a breed is at stake - a breed I love dearly. No one forces anyone to choose a cropped an docked breed so please don't force us to loose our rights. If one truly understands the entire concept of PUREBRED then you have to respect and uphold a standard.

I just got a PM about the # of people on here asking about getting their puppy cropped - THANK GOODNESS but where or where are the true good breeders who do it right???

I'm just referring to this particular thread. The previous responses show how hardcore it got.

You know I'm all for the crop/dock debate, and where I stand.
 
Rehash?? People who just give up and stop roaring loose their rights and in this case a breed is at stake - a breed I love dearly. No one forces anyone to choose a cropped an docked breed so please don't force us to loose our rights. If one truly understands the entire concept of PUREBRED then you have to respect and uphold a standard.

I just got a PM about the # of people on here asking about getting their puppy cropped - THANK GOODNESS but where or where are the true good breeders who do it right???

The breeders who do it right are few and far between. It's a sad fact, but it's an ongoing battle.

That also does that help with those against cropping and docking. Seeing more and more byb's using poor cropping and docking methods is just fuel to a already blazing fire. Pets with potential is a good example of this. When those who are unaware of the fight see a dog with his ears sown together they automatically jump on to the AR bandwagon.
 
Well i am on my Way to the USA in November with long Ears and long Tail. No Problem for me, BUT if i do breed her again then i guess i have to go with AKC Style. I can imagine, maybe i am wrong, that if i would go to shows with Natural Ears and Tails that i wouldnt stand a Chance. But maybe i am wrong.
 
The breeders who do it right are few and far between. It's a sad fact, but it's an ongoing battle.

That also does that help with those against cropping and docking. Seeing more and more byb's using poor cropping and docking methods is just fuel to a already blazing fire. Pets with potential is a good example of this. When those who are unaware of the fight see a dog with his ears sown together they automatically jump on to the AR bandwagon.

I have to agree with CRD on this. If you go to her FB page and see the pitiful pictures, it looks Frankensteinish......... easy for the PETA-type folks to jump in and say how cruel and inhumane C/D is.
 
Gloria - how awesome that you are coming here. Yes an uncropped undocked dog from any cropped and docked breed would be penalized for the deviation from the standard. It is not an AKC thing -however, the Doberman was always a cropped and docked breed. When we destroy that image the rest will follow and the standards of all purebred dogs will be lost.

So if we all just breed what we want and like what kind of Dobermans will we have in the future - Will they all be recognized as the Doberman breed. I think not! It is the standard that guides, molds, shapes and maintains a breed standard. Can a McDonalds franchise do whatever they like if it deviates from the Corp headqtrs??? I think not. Where would McDonalds be if each franchise did whatever they wanted BANKRUPT!!
 
Gloria - how awesome that you are coming here. Yes an uncropped undocked dog from any cropped and docked breed would be penalized for the deviation from the standard. It is not an AKC thing -however, the Doberman was always a cropped and docked breed. When we destroy that image the rest will follow and the standards of all purebred dogs will be lost.

So if we all just breed what we want and like what kind of Dobermans will we have in the future - Will they all be recognized as the Doberman breed. I think not! It is the standard that guides, molds, shapes and maintains a breed standard. Can a McDonalds franchise do whatever they like if it deviates from the Corp headqtrs??? I think not. Where would McDonalds be if each franchise did whatever they wanted BANKRUPT!!
I'm not argueing with what you say,but the McD's annalogy isn't quite right.There are indeed differences in the menu based on demographics.Go to Hawaii,there you will find an Egg McMuffin with portagese sausage option(it's rather good I might add)(for Mickey D's anyway).It's something you will not find here in Ca.,and I'm sure not what you would find at the one down the street from you.Then check out the menu of a store in China,....Noodles?
Now don't bite my head off Tiger girl,just pointing it out.
 
I've been in poodles since I was 15..... I've had miniature pinschers and viszslas and numerous other breeds. Realized most of the breeds I've owned have had something D/C. We do tails/dewclaws between 3-5 days. Most of the "pain" inflicted was emotional .......... and that was from the brief seperation from mom/siblings! Pluck from whelping box, place on kitchen table. Measure, dock, remove dewclaws......... replace in whelping box. Mom checks over pup and pup contendly nurses. End of story. A poodle w/undocked tail doesn't have the dignity the breed is to have. A vizsla with the extra 1/4 of its tail is a menac e:lmao:. They also often end up needing the injured part removed later..... painful and long recovery. Tail has a purpose, its length has a reason in hunting. Dewclaws removed for a purpose as well, never want to deal with ripped dews....

I raise/show LaMancha dairy goats. All of our goats are disbudded at 5 days of birth. Most of the males are also wethered at this time. We also vaccinate w/tetnus antitoxen at this time. Goes like this....... baby brought out, hair clipped around horn buds (this is just so we don't have to smell the stench of burning hair), vaccinated, boys are wiped banded, immediately they have each horn buds burned for 30 seconds. They are immediately given a bottle of milk and walked back to the kid barn. We band/burn in the early morning so the kids will move and play all day long. Within an hour, the kids are back to butting heads and playing king of the hill. Animal right folks scream cruelty.......... folks, a male goat is fertil by 8 weeks of age......... that is before he is even weaned!!! Also, horned goats can and do cause abortions, become caught and have injured people, both accidently and deliberty. We disbud on average 50 kids a year. In the last 10 years, I've only had 1 kid that developed a scur (regrowth). It was a kid that was disbudded at 3 months of age (I co-owned the doe, the owner didn't believe in early disbudding/wethering). Those 3 kids all took longer to recover, the 2 males moaned and groaned (typical men :rolleyes:) and had a much longer horn cap that took weeks to fall off and of course their testicals were larger and also took longer to "fall off".

LaMancha's have a naturally occuring short ear flap. Our standard calls for 1/4-1/2". My boys are constantly educating folks on this. BUT we still get the fanatics that will come to the barn and try to make a huge scene. GASP! Look, not only did they butcher the poor goats tail and cut off the horns, they cut the ears so short they are deaf. :rofl: :lmao:

:groan::censored:, actually dumb***, goat tails are not docked and these are the ears that the Good Lord gave them. Also, they never had a horn cut off, instead they were prevented from growing.. Then my boys whisper the goat's name as ask if they would like a cookie. Quick as a flash the "deaf" goat is up on the side of the pen, begging for cookies. Then we'll stretch out the ear flap and show them and let them fall in love with the kind, gentle dispostion of the breed. Most are appreciative of the knowledge and walk away with a smile on their face. But there are always the few that refuse to believe and will walk off muttering about cruelty. :weird:

My long-winded point is that in the dairy goat breeds we have "standards". JUST LIKE IN DOGS. All dairy goats are to be dehorned, they work closely with humans and to loose kids from the mother being butter, or to have an udder torn, would be a terrible loss. LaMancha ears are a dominat gene, it takes a minimum of 2 generations to breed out the short ear. They orginated in a cold climate where the shorter ear flap allowed them to stay warm (no heat loss thru the ear) and avoid frostbite. Folks will tell us how they love the high fat content and massive quantity of milk, love the gentle, patient tempermant of the breed, love the moderate size............. but they want longer ears and they think horn-removal is cruel. I always tell them then they need to get a different breed of goat........ for long ears, get a nubian (long-eared, hot climate origin), but you'll get larger frame in both height and length, and a flightier temperment.
Each breed has a STANDARD, that is what makes each breed recongizeable and unique. Once they've been hooked by an adult buck's horn while he is in rut, or have an injury to a doe in milk, then they want to get rid of the animal.. :thumbdown:

If you cross the breeds, you may or may not get the traits you desire. We who love the breeds work dang hard to preserve and improve the breed, so if you don't like it, fine, move on to another breed, but don't try to change it to suit some idea that you have and yet don't understand the reasoning behind the standard. Find the breed, the "look", that you desire, but don't change a breed to fit "you". The standards are in place for a reason!!!

Lady in the pet store this past weekend was kind enough to correct me on my dog's breed. After she had been rubbing all over him and smooching on him, she asks what kind of dog Reno is. I tell her Doberman Pinscher. She proceeds to laugh and tell me that he isn't because they owned one in the past and Reno looks nothing like hers nor the ones she sees, plus dobes are biters. I gave her a VERY quick run-down on the breed's history and about C/D. She walked away and I overheard her telling her companion that I was mistaken as dobes had floppy ears and long tail and untrustworthy. I think that D4E is right to be fearful, the pet population is getting so far away from the standard that the public doesn't recognize the breed when they actually see it.
 
I'm not argueing with what you say,but the McD's annalogy isn't quite right.There are indeed differences in the menu based on demographics.Go to Hawaii,there you will find an Egg McMuffin with portagese sausage option(it's rather good I might add)(for Mickey D's anyway).It's something you will not find here in Ca.,and I'm sure not what you would find at the one down the street from you.Then check out the menu of a store in China,....Noodles? Now don't bite my head off Tiger girl,just pointing it out.

My dearest Gel - While McDonald's franchises may vary on menu based on the culture they are in you can be sure that the same standards apply to each item on the menu and the same process for buying and preparing the food regardless of the item. How is that??? The standards and quality and how food is prepared is as close to the same as possible. So the menu may vary but from one franchise to another the quality and taste of the foods prepared are standardized by McDonald's.

Sending you a BIG dober HUG.
 
Or we could put it this way. The standards in Doberman are very closely related. You sill see mixed variations in body size, color based on the region the dog is from. When it comes down to it they are still a working breed, with very closely related standards. Taking away the c/d is a huge deviation from the original standard. As well as oversized, albino, ect.

If we have no base standard we have multiple different types of dogs. This is where our downfall is. This is why I believe we have seen Dobermans tank in registration numbers all across Europe.
 
I would rather live my life with a Doberman being natural all ears and tail than to live my life without one no question about that, this argument is always one sided, and I have never been against you all having a choice , we don't and this law came in before I got back into Dobes, I am sure everyone will loose the right one day, for as much as you shout about it and want to keep your choice once the government makes it's mind up they will just walk all over everyone like they have done here and in the rest of Europe.
 
My dearest Gel - While McDonald's franchises may vary on menu based on the culture they are in you can be sure that the same standards apply to each item on the menu and the same process for buying and preparing the food regardless of the item. How is that??? The standards and quality and how food is prepared is as close to the same as possible. So the menu may vary but from one franchise to another the quality and taste of the foods prepared are standardized by McDonald's.

Sending you a BIG dober HUG.
:nono:Calling that slop "food" is a stretch,dontcha think?:DI know what you mean,you are correct.My point was it's not all the same by appearance,nothing more.Thanks for not biting my head all the way off.Besides,with Sosthens head already in there you wouldn't possibly have room for my overinflated head too;)

I like how you started that,My dearest^:D:DYour on fire today,I like it.
 
I didn't know having floppy ears and a long tail prevented a dobermann from doing the job it was bred for. :)

As long as the dobermann stays a working breed, I don't care about the ears and tails... Looks are not important. I like both natural and c/d equally much. I oppose a ban.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I777 using Tapatalk 2
 
I would rather live my life with a Doberman being natural all ears and tail than to live my life without one no question about that, this argument is always one sided, and I have never been against you all having a choice , we don't and this law came in before I got back into Dobes, I am sure everyone will loose the right one day, for as much as you shout about it and want to keep your choice once the government makes it's mind up they will just walk all over everyone like they have done here and in the rest of Europe.
Judith,you are one of my favorite posters here.I feel the need to respond to your post,but need to pick my words proper so as not to offend.I need to think about this some.
 
I didn't know having floppy ears and a long tail prevented a dobermann from doing the job it was bred for. :)

As long as the dobermann stays a working breed, I don't care about the ears and tails... Looks are not important. I like both natural and c/d equally much. I oppose a ban.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I777 using Tapatalk 2
Crop/dock was a big part of the dog doing the job it was bred for from what I have read.Long tail and ears makes spots of vulnerability when fending off those that would do harm to it's master.
 
I didn't know having floppy ears and a long tail prevented a dobermann from doing the job it was bred for. :)

As long as the dobermann stays a working breed, I don't care about the ears and tails... Looks are not important. I like both natural and c/d equally much. I oppose a ban.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I777 using Tapatalk 2


I'm not saying a dog cannot work without being cropped and docked. What I am saying is, if you don't follow the standard and start dropping things off, what's next? Oversized dogs? Eventually you will be left with something nowhere near the Doberman we love and respect today. I always hear lines like this is it, or this is the last time. It won't end with banning c/d it will continue on to things that will eventually destroy the standard, and the breed.
 
We need to keep the government out of our breeders, and our dogs. They can not control and dictate every action. Too much government is never good. A lot of places are already seeing this.
 
I'm not saying a dog cannot work without being cropped and docked. What I am saying is, if you don't follow the standard and start dropping things off, what's next? Oversized dogs? Eventually you will be left with something nowhere near the Doberman we love and respect today. I always hear lines like this is it, or this is the last time. It won't end with banning c/d it will continue on to things that will eventually destroy the standard, and the breed.
Or outright banning the breed.
 

Back
Top