• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?

The way I see it, if people want a specific breed, i.e., a purebred Doberman, then it should be all inclusive; which includes cropping and docking.

You don't buy a Vette and ask for a Prius engine, right? Lol.
It would be silly to change the heart of the car, if thats why you bought it... but its nice to know you have a choice of different rims. ;) It's still a Vet.
 
Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?
Yes because its getting harder and harder to find a vet who even knows how to perform the procedures.. I suppose if i had to by law leave my dogs uncropped i could live with that , but those tails are a different story.. I personally feel messing with these laws is dangerous because there is a black market for anything and everything.. Id hate to see cropping and docking included in that list and then you have the real problem of butchers performing these procedures in unsterile environments.. I believe these ban can and will cause more harm then good and frankly thats what i really oppose.
 
The way I see it, if people want a specific breed, i.e., a purebred Doberman, then it should be all inclusive; which includes cropping and docking.

You don't buy a Vette and ask for a Prius engine, right? Lol.

What has a full tail and dropped ears got to do with the character and working ability of a Dobermann? (the Vette/Prius thing)

Using your analogy I guess this guy below, my Ozzy is not a purebred Dobermann after all... just a wanabe Dobe? half a Dobe? I will break his heart tomorrow and explain to him that his pedigree is a lie and he's not a full blown Dobermann... he's just a poor imitation because the UK government stuck their unwelcome noses in quite a few years ago... using your 'analogy' there are no purebred Dobermanns in the UK or in fact much of Europe?

03Mar2012-46-L.jpg


Now I realise that this thread is about what's happening in the US but I'm sorry, offhand comments like this that put down all natural Dobermanns, (Dobermanns who through no fault of their own, their breeders or owners are born into a country where d&c is banned) even if said in jest have started to slightly annoy and offend me, it must be an age thing...
 
We talk so much about ears. Some goes too far... They tell me not to buy a Doberman if I don't want cropped ears.
I want to ask Doberdor if you know what traits the Doberman was bred for? Is your dog a Doberman or she just has cropped ears?

A Doberman is considered to be a working dog. The dog was originally bred to be fearless and willing to defend its owner but obedient and restrained to only do it on command. These traits served a Doberman as a personal protection, police or war dog. Most NA Dobermans lost the traits... but they keep cropped ears :tap: Hmmm... chicken or egg?:scratch:

I don't mean your dogs Susan. You work hard to breed a complete Doberman.
 
You make a great point, DV. I think that with all the talk about ears and tails, docking and cropping, what people are really passionate about here is the standard. We need to encourage breeders to breed for the whole Doberman and stick to the standard. That covers conformation, temperament, and dock/crop here in the US and in several other countries. We also need to be careful to not let governments step in where they have no business. The debate of c/d should be left to those that know the facts, the breed clubs. When they start outlawing this we get what Doom was talking about, underground butchers trying to c/d. Think about that article we discussed a few months back about people shipping their pregnant bitches to a country that allows c/d to whelp.
What it boils down to in the c/d debate is that the creator of the breed called for it and so does today's standard in several countries. If you have the whole Doberman, one that is truly working, the c/d is done for a reason. Having ears and a tail doesn't make the dog less of a Doberman but it does go against what the breed was intended to look like. That is just the facts of it.
 
Using your analogy I guess this guy below, my Ozzy is not a purebred Dobermann after all... just a wanabe Dobe? half a Dobe? I will break his heart tomorrow and explain to him that his pedigree is a lie and he's not a full blown Dobermann... he's just a poor imitation because the UK government stuck their unwelcome noses in quite a few years ago... using your 'analogy' there are no purebred Dobermanns in the UK or in fact much of Europe?

No one said any of this - but it is true that the standard - the original standard and the creater of the breed and his vision has been compromised. Can the dog still work of course, But is it not the complete example as it was in the beginning. If a dog lacks Breed type which is set by specific physical traits then part of the standard is lost. The doberman was to be cropped and docked.

Please don't turn it into a crying session about how poor our dog is - it is about loosing YOUR rights to uphold a standard as per the breed club guidlines. That is pure and simple. I am personally sorry for every single country that lost that right because it was one of the early first steps that we werenot even real aware of of the AR groups to start chipping away at purebred dogs. The choice was lost to choose to leave the dog as intened or not. Now you don't have a choice.
 
Please don't turn it into a crying session about how poor our dog is - it is about loosing YOUR rights to uphold a standard as per the breed club guidlines. That is pure and simple. I am personally sorry for every single country that lost that right because it was one of the early first steps that we werenot even real aware of of the AR groups to start chipping away at purebred dogs. The choice was lost to choose to leave the dog as intened or not. Now you don't have a choice.

You are dead right there this is about rights to uphold your standard in your country however it's really starting to annoy me to no end the amount of so called Dobermann lovers who only look at what the dog look like on the outside. If it has a tail or floppy ears its not a purebred Dobermann?? give me a break....

What are all these so called Dobermann lovers going to do if there should be a d&c ban in their state/country? throw their recently born pups who can no longer be c&d into a shelter because they don't look right because they no longer looks like a Dobermann?

We have lost our rights here and we have what we have, so what are we to do, live with the new standard or move on to another breed? What will you do? what will you all do?
 
All anyone is saying here is we love the doberman and want to keep it as it was intended. Do you really think that anyone here would give up on the breed if we lose our right to crop and dock? NO! we won't but we will fight tooth and nail not to have a right taken away. I am sure if you thought back to when you lost your right you would remember that the same thing happened in your country.
My parents are from another country and sacraficed plenty to get here so their childern could enjoy the true meaning of freedom. I will not let those saraficed be in vain!
When you start letting freedoms slip away, before you know it they are all gone!
 
Some things to consider: Crossposted This is a discussion we are having among some long time DPCA members and breeds - And what will I do - I will Fight for our rights the rights of breed clubs and purebred dogs everywhere.

Yes, erect ears have a better range of hearing. Besides the shape of the ear directing sound into the ear; the air in an erect ear reduces fluid hence better overall hearing. I have been told by Dr. Al Stinson DVM, that a dropped ear retains a higher level of fluid. Dr. Stinson taught canine behavior and anatomy at Michigan State University . He and the late Dr. George Padgett DVM founded the "Purebred Endowment Fund" at Michigan State University .

Each type of ear aids in performing a particular task. A dropped ear helps close off sound to encourage the dog to use other senses. The longer the ear, the less distracting the sound, the more the dog will use scent. A long ear will pull loose skin over a domed skull to close the eyes when a hound is scenting, further encouraging work to be performed by the nose. These types of canines perform tasks entirely on scent alone. Some breeds have shorter ears that can be tightly flapped back to close off sound, aid in speed and encourage the use of sight. How a dog will work depends more on how the ear combines with the rest of the standard than how the ear works alone. As Peggy Adamson would say, "Breed type emerges from the WHOLE standard".


If hearing is essential to the task the dog is to perform then an erect ear is correct.. However, it must work in combination with the rest of the standard for optimal performance. It is the shape of the skull, the length of the muzzle and tight skin that directs sound into the erect ear of the Doberman. A correct Doberman can catch a scent from the air or ground. He will lift his head high, prick his ears to find sound in the direction of the scent and scan the terrain with his eyes. It is length of neck and angulation of shoulder that encourages the Doberman to hold it's head high optimizing the use of sound, sight and scent while running at full stride.


I think to truly appreciate our standard one must appreciate the standards of all purebreds. There is much to learn especially from the hounds and the sporting groups. It is there we learn not only the importance of ears but how they work with each breed. It is that history which describes how the smallest changes in ears changes how each breed works. Some of this history can easily be found in the AKC'S Complete Dog Book. There are many good OLD hunting books that describe selective breeding, structure and function in detail. I really like Delmar Smith.

Concerning a description of natural ears in other countries who have banned cropping and docking it is often said that the European Doberman is different from ours. This is probably true for many reasons as well as the fact that they do breed for ears and now tails. There have been discussions in the past concerning the American Doberman Pinscher standard, that it should be a standard of it's own. This is also why Frank Grover called the A.D.P.E.F. the AMERICAN DOBERMAN PINSCHER EDUCATIONAL FOUNDATION. The title was to celebrate what made our Dobermans different. Frank was never ashamed to stand up for our standard. The sad truth is as we allow the erosion of excellence so too shall we erode the unique working abilities of this breed.


Once we begin breeding for ears and tails the Doberman will change both in structure and in temperament. Due to the fact we do not have large kennels with intense breeding programs the change will be slow. In fifteen to twenty years the breed will have changed and sadly the faces of the breed will have changed also. There will be no one left who will remember the uniqueness of this breed. The fact is once it is lost we will NEVER get it back. No one will ever breed with such intensity again and no one will know how amazing the Doberman really was unless we work to preserve it. This is why it is necessary to disband the crop and dock committee and put cropping and docking back into our standard.

"Breed type emerges from the whole standard".

Thanks again for your thoughtful post, they are very cathartic for me!
CinDe Byer
 
If you have the whole Doberman, one that is truly working, the c/d is done for a reason. Having ears and a tail doesn't make the dog less of a Doberman but it does go against what the breed was intended to look like. That is just the facts of it.

Jess having ears in my country doesn't go against the standard. Also it's not banned here and people have a choice.
The forum is international. That's not a fair statement to tell people the natural Doberman is not what breed was intended to look like.... ACK standard is not international.
 
Jess having ears in my country doesn't go against the standard. Also it's not banned here and people have a choice.
The forum is international. That's not a fair statement to tell people the natural Doberman is not what breed was intended to look like.... ACK standard is not international.
This thread was about the US, check the title. And, as far as I know, all countries DID have the c/d in their standard until recent years when it was changed. Herr Doberman made it quite clear that he wanted the breed to have the pricked ear and the nub tail so yes it is what the breed was intended to look like.
 
All anyone is saying here is we love the doberman and want to keep it as it was intended. Do you really think that anyone here would give up on the breed if we lose our right to crop and dock? NO!

YES! they will... It's happened everywhere there has been a ban put in place eg in Europe - Germany, the UK and many other Euro countrys, also in Australia etc. It sorts out those who's primary attraction to the breed is just its looks. All those that love the breed for it's character, for whats inside the Dobermann, what makes it tick, will stick with the breed and refuse to see it die which is good yes? The only way the breed will die is if everyone walks away after a ban and thankfully that has not been the case, the Dobermann lives on even in countries that have the ban...

we won't but we will fight tooth and nail not to have a right taken away. I am sure if you thought back to when you lost your right you would remember that the same thing happened in your country.
My parents are from another country and sacraficed plenty to get here so their childern could enjoy the true meaning of freedom. I will not let those saraficed be in vain!
When you start letting freedoms slip away, before you know it they are all gone!

Good for you and I truely hope you and others like you succeed in stemming the tide.

Now I'm going to duck out of this thread because whats got my hackles up is not what this thread is all about and I'm sending out the wrong signals and diverting the topic. For those that haven't grasped it yet my complaint is against those individuals that see non cropped/docked Dobermanns as inferior, not the real deal, and some people do before anyone tells me they don't. So thats it, thats my sole complaint...
 
I think the thread has gone far enough with the same things we've gone over again and again. While I love what the standards are supposed to be, I love the breed itself for what they are and their beauty. As I've stated a million times before, I do believe in trying to maintain our rights before they try to yank more and more of them away, but it doesn't mean I don't think each and every one of the totally natural dogs here or anywhere else aren't every bit (and sometimes more) beautiful than the c/d dogs. We all have our preferences and I totally respect and applaud that, and the fact that we do have the choice either way in many countries yet. Heck, like I brought up before, there are a few countries or local counties who are forcing sterilization of our pets and that's another terrible loss of choice, which is along the same lines as far as I'm concerned. They want to rule our lives in one way or another and if they get by with one thing they're going to keep pushing for more and more until we barely own our dogs anymore.

That said, there isn't a single natural Doberman here that I can think of that I wouldn't be proud to own myself because they are beautiful examples of the breed. And please do not let this often brought up topic insult or hurt any of your feelings because you're all very valuable members here (as are your dogs) and I know that the passion with this topic can really get right down to the last emotional nerve for many people (on both sides), even though we are of like minds with nearly everything else breed related.
 
Jess having ears in my country doesn't go against the standard. Also it's not banned here and people have a choice.
The forum is international. That's not a fair statement to tell people the natural Doberman is not what breed was intended to look like.... ACK standard is not international

It is a fair statement because from the humble beginning in Germany at the feet of Herr Dobermann they were cropped and docked do please don't try to sell the AR agenda here. I have been in this breed too long to be fooled by newcommers who can't remember back to when The standards WAS international and still is for some parts of Europe. The best example of the breed is to show it as it was intended - cropped and docked.

For those that want choice you had it right up untl the Governement made that decision for some and took away thier right so now even if they wanted to follow the standard they can't. They lost the right to choose. Now they are stuck with uncropped ans soon Canada AR groups will win and many will be sorry they did not stand up for the standard.
 
What has a full tail and dropped ears got to do with the character and working ability of a Dobermann? (the Vette/Prius thing)

Using your analogy I guess this guy below, my Ozzy is not a purebred Dobermann after all... just a wanabe Dobe? half a Dobe? I will break his heart tomorrow and explain to him that his pedigree is a lie and he's not a full blown Dobermann... he's just a poor imitation because the UK government stuck their unwelcome noses in quite a few years ago... using your 'analogy' there are no purebred Dobermanns in the UK or in fact much of Europe?

03Mar2012-46-L.jpg


Now I realise that this thread is about what's happening in the US but I'm sorry, offhand comments like this that put down all natural Dobermanns, (Dobermanns who through no fault of their own, their breeders or owners are born into a country where d&c is banned) even if said in jest have started to slightly annoy and offend me, it must be an age thing...
I am German and know all about the history of the German Doberman. I live in Florida and just purchased my Pure Bred Doberman from Germany from a Top Breeder without d/c. It was my choice and preference.....
Your Dogs are beautiful and I think you right with your Statement, thank you
 

Back
Top