• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?

Thanks for answering so quickly D4E. I really thought the answer would include more. Let me explain what I mean by that. My pups Sire is called Ozzy, his breeders said this about him "Ozzy gained his Stud Book number at Paignton July 2007...." so I was thinking that other than the obvious as you mentioned, there must be some other significance perhaps from the showing side of things? that maybe it's something to be won somehow as the Ozzy and Paignton reference may infer?

Are all stud dogs in this studbook? what about the male Dobermann advertised for stud in the local paper, would he be in it, should he be in it? Do dogs need to reach a certain standard in confirmation showing before being included in the book? hmmm many questions...
 
Sorry - I tend to be just direct and too the point and forget that some explanation is more helpful.

The AKC Stud Book Register, published monthly, contains the sire and dam of the dog that has been involved in a litter for the first time along with the names of the breeders, registration numbers, date of whelping, and coat colors.
It has nothing to do with showing. Every purebred dog reg (dog) refererng to the male gender is entered into the stud book when it's first litter is registered. The date entered in the stud book has nothing to do with showing or DOB. It is a record kept for all AKC approved breeds that documents it purebred status and qualificaitons to produce an AKC reg litter.

The American Kennel Club "Stud Book" is the basic registry from which all pedigrees are constructed. When a dog or bitch is first registered as the sire or dam of a litter, they are entered in the stud book. The stud book is a public document and can be examined at the AKC offices. The entry includes the following information:
  • Name, gender, AKC number, color, date of birth
  • Sire name and AKC number and date of first entry into stud book
  • Dam name and AKC number and date of first entry into stud book
  • Owner name; breeder name
It does track the # of dogs that are OFA certified, have obtained AKC CH etc -

Hope this helps
 
If we don't stand up for our rights we are quickly heading to a police state mentality. Look what happened in Denver several years ago on the PitBull ban - The actually invaded homes and took peoples loving pets just because of the breed.. Many of these dogs were trained, did not run loose, where not a nusiance to the neighborhood, had never bitten anyone and loved and played with kids.

We have a situation now where a disabled Veteran moved from Chicago to Iowa and had to remove his service dog because it's a mixed-breed pit bull. While I definitely understand why some communities ban the breed, I think it's a knee-jerk reaction and also these communities are not using common sense. This Veteran is suing for violation of the Federal ADA act, and they are going to have to go through a lot of legal fees and spend lots of money for what I hope is a losing battle for them.

http://www.mnn.com/family/pets/stor...forces-veteran-cop-to-give-up-his-service-dog

I do think some breeds can be dangerous in the wrong hands, and I wish we could/would legislate some common sense laws - like in order to legally own any large-breed dog or animal, an owner has to qualify to own one (i.e. no criminal convictions, no child or animal abuse priors, no drug dealing priors, etc.) It is not the fault of any animal that they are trained to be vicious, and people need to be certified to own them and prevented from owning them if they're likely to turn them into vicious animals.
 
Quee - the problem with your theory while good on the surface is what if then the governement decides YOU are not worthy to own one. Anytime you relinquish the right to anything then they can change it at will and the very next step is to eliminate the dogs all together.

This country was hard won - lives were lost, but freedom rang. Now everyone wants laws for everything and you are so right you can't legislate morality. Every single person needs to READ the consitution of the UNITED States of AMERICA and the Bill of RIGHTS understand that our forefathers came here to excape oppressing government. Now we want them to regulate everything and they are slowly strangling us to death.

The government is not the answer - the government is the problem. Their mind siet is greedy and self indulgent. I can tell you one thing were I president I would eliminate taxes and only have taxes on things as you bought them and paid for them Not on your money before you get it then again as you spend it.

EVERY single politician would be put on a frozen salary after a 30% reduction and they would have to join SS just like we have to. Continued salaries would be based on 40% of earnings not 100%. How stupid is government??? Don't even ask me. ALL illegal aliens would be thrown out of SS - If you don't contribute and are not a US citizen you don't qualify.

Guess what ALL breeds can be dangerous in the wrong hands. ALL not some = that is buying right into the AR agenda - Believe you me if we loose ONE breed we are destined to loose them all. They are whittling away at our rights for their own self serving agenda. When they solve poverty, joblessness, child abuse, crime and the economy then they might have better sense to help with our dogs until then I just prefer that they go jump off a cliff. I personally think the above should be their priority not legislating themselves more money for doing nothing productive.

I swer if one more person wants the government to solve our problems I will GAG GAG GAG.
 
I agree Dobs4ever that the Government can be hindrance and not a help at times - especially when it goes too far into overriding individual rights. However the Government that we have today is a part the reason that we have more freedoms than we ever had before, and we certainly have more freedoms than other countries. The fairness and success of our government depends on whether people as a whole are able and willing to step up and make their voices and opinions heard, and whether people are willing to vote and lobby for issues they believe in. I don't think anarchy is an acceptable alternative to the government establishing and enforcing standards (laws) that are in the interest of the public good.

Animal ownership is a responsibility that needs to be taken more seriously I think. Too many animals end up abused, abandoned or used for criminal purposes (keep in mind I live in Chicago) and are owned by people who should be locked up in jail or in a psych ward, and not allowed to use and abuse innocent animals. Yes that is a judgment call I am making, but if anyone saw how some of these animals are treated and used, I have no doubt that others would make the same statement.

Defining and applying fair and consistent standards in the form of laws is what the Government is there for. Developing a standard/law that applies to all breeds that states that convicted criminals cannot own dogs over 10 pounds (and no animal ownership whatsoever for criminals convicted of child or animal abuse) for example, seems a reasonable standard that can be consistently applied by governmental units. It may cost all dog owners in the form of additional dog registration fees, but isn't that a reasonable price to pay to avoid a knee-jerk breed ban that affects everyone in an unfair manner?
 
However the Government that we have today is a part the reason that we have more freedoms than we ever had before, and we certainly have more freedoms than other countries.

Quee bless you I could just give you a big hug - I love your spirit HOWEVER, the government we have to day is not the government that gave us our freedoms - that governement is quickly turning into a money hungry, degenerate, low life that is self serving and daily working to steal our money from us.

If the above was the case then why aren't the peopel you speak of in jail??? Because we have gone SOFT on crime and criminals. They have more rights than you and I.

Developing a standard/law that applies to all breeds that states that convicted criminals cannot own dogs over 10 pounds (and no animal ownership whatsoever for criminals convicted of child or animal abuse) for example, seems a reasonable standard that can be consistently applied by governmental units. It may cost all dog owners in the form of additional dog registration fees, but isn't that a reasonable price to pay to avoid a knee-jerk breed ban that affects everyone in an unfair manner?

IT MAY cost us more fees - no it is not reasonable to expect me to pay for those who choose NOT to follow the law. The governments response is always the same - INCREASE taxes and punish the good so the bad can continue on as usual. The Government has gone SOFT on crime and you and I are paying the price so NO it is not OK for them to charge me more because they won't enforce the laws that they already have on the books.
 
Quee bless you I could just give you a big hug - I love your spirit HOWEVER, the government we have to day is not the government that gave us our freedoms - that governement is quickly turning into a money hungry, degenerate, low life that is self serving and daily working to steal our money from us.

If the above was the case then why aren't the peopel you speak of in jail??? Because we have gone SOFT on crime and criminals. They have more rights than you and I.

IT MAY cost us more fees - no it is not reasonable to expect me to pay for those who choose NOT to follow the law. The governments response is always the same - INCREASE taxes and punish the good so the bad can continue on as usual. The Government has gone SOFT on crime and you and I are paying the price so NO it is not OK for them to charge me more because they won't enforce the laws that they already have on the books.


I wish we could get together for a cup of coffee with our Dobies around a nice fireplace and continue our discussion Dobs4ever! While we may not land on the same side of the fence on all issues, you seem like someone I'd enjoy discussing them with!

I agree with you wholeheartedly on our being soft on crime and we're getting softer on it all the time as a country. I think if we were consistent in our arrests, sentencing and incarceration of criminals we wouldn't have so many criminals flouting the law doing as they please. For whatever reasons the majority of Americans must be OK with this, because we keep voting in the soft-shoe politicians who change positions at the drop of a hat, and do their best to avoid rocking the boat so that they can get re-elected - regardless of what is right for the people and society at large.

At any rate - while I don't like the idea of paying extra to enforce laws against criminals, I don't know that any other approach will realistically work. Our fees are relatively low here in Chicago for dog registration $2.50-$5 for spayed/neutered dogs, $5.00-$50.00 for an unneutered/unsterilized dog. Even if I had an unneutered/unsterilized dog I'd be willing to pay say $5.00 more to implement and enforce a law that doesn't allow criminals to have dogs. But that's just me - it may not fly with the rest of the dog-owning population. If I were in Denver though, I'd rather have that than the breed ban they have in place now, which is pretty asinine. Denver has also paid the price for that breed ban through lawsuits for ADA violations, and now they've had to put several exceptions in place which their whole tax base population is paying for.
 
I agree Dobs4ever that the Government can be hindrance and not a help at times - especially when it goes too far into overriding individual rights. However the Government that we have today is a part the reason that we have more freedoms than we ever had before, and we certainly have more freedoms than other countries. The fairness and success of our government depends on whether people as a whole are able and willing to step up and make their voices and opinions heard, and whether people are willing to vote and lobby for issues they believe in. I don't think anarchy is an acceptable alternative to the government establishing and enforcing standards (laws) that are in the interest of the public good.
While I agree we have more rights than some other countries,I can't so much on having more freedoms today than ever before.Can't agree so much I have to ask how old are you?
 
I wish we could get together for a cup of coffee with our Dobies around a nice fireplace and continue our discussion Dobs4ever! While we may not land on the same side of the fence on all issues, you seem like someone I'd enjoy discussing them with!

I agree with you wholeheartedly on our being soft on crime and we're getting softer on it all the time as a country. I think if we were consistent in our arrests, sentencing and incarceration of criminals we wouldn't have so many criminals flouting the law doing as they please. For whatever reasons the majority of Americans must be OK with this, because we keep voting in the soft-shoe politicians who change positions at the drop of a hat, and do their best to avoid rocking the boat so that they can get re-elected - regardless of what is right for the people and society at large.

At any rate - while I don't like the idea of paying extra to enforce laws against criminals, I don't know that any other approach will realistically work. Our fees are relatively low here in Chicago for dog registration $2.50-$5 for spayed/neutered dogs, $5.00-$50.00 for an unneutered/unsterilized dog. Even if I had an unneutered/unsterilized dog I'd be willing to pay say $5.00 more to implement and enforce a law that doesn't allow criminals to have dogs. But that's just me - it may not fly with the rest of the dog-owning population. If I were in Denver though, I'd rather have that than the breed ban they have in place now, which is pretty asinine. Denver has also paid the price for that breed ban through lawsuits for ADA violations, and now they've had to put several exceptions in place which their whole tax base population is paying for.
 
Judy - thank you so much for sharing this information. I hope more will visit the DPCA web site and the ADPEF web site to learn the history of the Doberman here in America. You can't know where you are going until you know where you have been and far far too many today are making decisions that affect us all with no understanding or knowledge of our rich rich history. I enjoyed visiting with you on the phone and appreciate your joining in.
 
Here is a great place to go on ADPEF.org Click on the Breed today and then click on State of the breed today.
 
In the US, natural ears seem to be gaining in popularity as more breeders are giving people that choice of cropped or natural, but tails are most often docked at three days of age. I too think the natural tails you are seeing are on the European dogs.

The Tail needs to be docked on the second Day already.
At least this is how they do it in Europe, where it is still allowed.
I am actually facing that Problem when my Bitch have her next Litter in the USA.
I believe and know from a few People, that there are more Doberman Lovers that like the crooped and docked ones.How do you see it ??
 
Gloria - glad you joinein to help shed some personal knowledge of what is going on in Germany. For gosh sakes they are the ones who created some of the finest working dogs and they set standards for reasons then whimped out to the AR agenda thinking it would take the spot light off them How sad IMHO that the mother country of some of the finest working breeds in the world turned out to be whimps.

QUEE
Defining and applying fair and consistent standards in the form of laws is what the Government is there for.

Somehow I missed this statement but wanted to ask how you think it is working out for us????

The Doberman Pinscher is a cropped and docked breed and was done so for a reason. If you read some recent threads that have popped up seems they are having problems with ear infections in their flopped earred Dobes. Gosh I think that is a medical problem and a good reason to crop - I stand by that.
 
@Dobes4ever, i know what you mean.It wasnt my Decision to forbit that, and it wasnt the decision of the Dobermann-Verein. So many good old Breeders stoped for good, when that Law came out. It just the Law now.Well today it is the Way it is, so many say its good, but what other choice do they have than to tell Stories,lol, they dont.They want to stay into breeding, so they go with the flow..........

For me, i am in this Doberman Matter for only 5 Years, still a Newbie and only know they come with long ears and Tails. But now i became a Breeder and have to make a Choice if i do that breeding in the USA.
 

Back
Top