Am I overexercising my puppy?

Hoos99

New Member
My lad turns 7 months old this week and I have recently increased the amount of time that we exercise per day in an attempt to curb destructive behaviours that were, evidently, arising through a surplus of energy.

I was scared of 'overdoing' the exercise with him at first as I had a vet tell me that he should only be doing 1 hour maximum of activity per day whilst he is still growing because it would impact his skeletal development. This should apparently continue until at least 18 months. He would chew absolutely everything in the house when I was sticking to this advice; his was much more anxious; he would never settle in his crate without making a fuss.

I have recently been doing 1-to-1 training sessions with a trainer who has a vast level of experience with protection dogs, primarily Dobermanns and GSDs. When bringing this up to him, he initially did not want to contradict the vet as he said it wasn't his place to. As we got more comfortable with each other I brought the topic up again and he said that in his 25+ years of experience and ownership of 6 Dobes that overexercising as a puppy had never resulted in long-term health issues.

I now walk him off-lead down by the river near where I live and there is so much for him to do: birds to chase, water to swim in, branches to wrestle with and occasionally other dogs for him to play with. He flits between doing those things and playing fetch with me with a ball. I will do this with him for 45 mins to an hour in the morning and then 1.5-2hrs at night. We also do obedience 3-4 times a day @ 10mins per session, have a 10min on-lead walk to/from the river twice a day and we play at home a lot too.

The difference in his behaviour is genuinely night and day. He has been an absolute dream since changing to this routine and our bond is deeper than ever.

This is my first Dobermann (my first dog, in fact) and I wanted to hear what some of you more knowledgeable and much more experienced folk than me had to say on the matter.

Pics of the big fella below.
 

Attachments

  • N1.webp
    N1.webp
    1.3 MB · Views: 17
  • N2.webp
    N2.webp
    1.1 MB · Views: 17
  • N3.webp
    N3.webp
    275.2 KB · Views: 17
I was scared of 'overdoing' the exercise with him at first as I had a vet tell me that he should only be doing 1 hour maximum of activity per day whilst he is still growing because it would impact his skeletal development.
The vet isn't wrong but it's forced physical exercise that's not good for them. Regular training and mental exercise is something they need and crave and that's not going to hurt them like forced exercise.

Welcome!
 
The vet isn't wrong but it's forced physical exercise that's not good for them. Regular training and mental exercise is something they need and crave and that's not going to hurt them like forced exercise.

Welcome!
Thank you for your reply. I hadn’t heard of forced exercise until you mentioned it but I’ve just read into it a little.

He would run after a ball all day long even if he was tired. Would it be classed as forced exercise then if fetch continued past the point of him becoming visibly tired? What about if I left him to his own devices for a while chasing birds that are in flight or rabbits?
 
He would run after a ball all day long even if he was tired. Would it be classed as forced exercise then if fetch continued past the point of him becoming visibly tired? What about if I left him to his own devices for a while chasing birds that are in flight or rabbits?
I don't worry about them running off leash to their hearts content on soft surfaces like grass. It's things like forcing them to run with you on pavement or having them jump before their growth plates are formed that can cause permanent damage.

image-jpg.55560
 
All that fun outdoor activity is a Dobermans dream! If they are off leash they will rest themselves. Regarding physical activity they can go all day long if you let them and this will build their endurance like an athlete. I’d focus more on mental stimulation to curb the destructive behaviours though.
 
It's things like forcing them to run with you on pavement or having them jump before their growth plates are formed that can cause permanent damage.

Noted, thanks. I have made him jump a few times on grass when he is chasing a toy, I will knock this on the head until he has finished growing. Thank you for the useful pic too.

All that fun outdoor activity is a Dobermans dream! If they are off leash they will rest themselves. Regarding physical activity they can go all day long if you let them and this will build their endurance like an athlete. I’d focus more on mental stimulation to curb the destructive behaviours though.

He is noticeably happier now that he’s getting all of this and I am so glad. I will continue with the obedience training and look into some more activities that are mentally stimulating. Do you have some favourites that you use?
 
The power of mental stimulation can tire them out without any of the stress on their bones and joints. Whether that’s new training, puzzle toys, snuffle mats or different things that make them really think (example hide and seek, cup game etc)
We’ve all been there, trust me. At that age they really don't know when to stop. They can be hyper so the temptation to 'wear them out' with long walks & too much exercise is pretty tempting but not the correct way, IMO. Playing some ball (with breaks) a game of 'find it!' Or a short obedience session will help mentally challenge him as well as give him adequate exercise.
No forced exercise - running, excessive ball/stick/frisbee chasing, constant jumping..... (exercise that is defined as "anything beyond what the dog would engage in with dogs of the same age.") until they're about 18 months, or until their growth plates are closed. That doesn't mean they don't need exercise and lots of stimulation but it needs to be limited while on leash.
This will allow you to enjoy many more years of exercising him by allowing adequate skeletal development.
I always come back to this X-Ray…

B0A143E8-1C9C-4A52-A550-B5543BF38325.webp
 
Common sense rules - at his age he should self regulate at free roaming play & exploring. I would not throw the ball excessively - as @Rits said, high drive will take over and the puppy won't quit because you are encouraging him. I also agree that mental stimulation and problem solving is especially exhausting - any time you can't go out due to weather or time constraints, do some challenges at home. Nose work is my favorite: put him in another room while you hide some treats in different places in the kitchen. Let him out and excitedly tell him to "find it!" - when he finds the treat, jump for joy like he'd found a diamond, hand feed another treat and tell him to "find another!". Once you do this several times he will understand the game and you can start making the hides harder. This is just one example of many to make them work mentally without having to be in training with you telling them what to do.
 
Yes the temptation to tire him out through longer walks really is tempting but I will keep these helpful comments in mind going forward and remember not to overdo it. There will eventually be a day when we can explore to our heart's content.

Find it/hide-and-seek sounds fun, I will give that a go tonight at home. I'll add that and the other suggestions to my new list 😎

We had a session last night with the trainer with another Dobe boy who is only a few weeks older along with his owner. They love each other and had several 'play breaks' between some heel work and recall practice, both under distractions. He's OK with both of these things but there's definitely room for improvement. He heels and returns to me perfectly... until something else perks his interest.

Do any of you have any tips on increasing his focus on me when there are distractions around? If something has really intrigued him, I struggle to regain his attention. I can be saying his name, jumping up and down or running around and his attention won't falter in the slightest from whatever it is that he's fixated on. I know that his puppy curiosity will most likely decline as he gets older but it would be good if I could get maximum engagement sorted from an early age or be able to break the fixations at the very least.
 
Do any of you have any tips on increasing his focus on me when there are distractions around? If something has really intrigued him, I struggle to regain his attention.
My first thoughts: Work on focus at home with no distractions first. Be the most fun/important thing your dog knows. This is not easy at his age.

There's a "look at me" game. Hold a tasty treat in each hand, closed fist. Hold your closed hands out for the dog to smell, let him push & nudge and try to get the treat, but keep your fist closed. Eventually he will look at your face to say "WHAT? You're offering it, but not giving it?" The INSTANT he looks at your face say YES! and open one hand so he gets the treat. Repeat repeat repeat. I start this in a sitting position so he doesn't even have to look up, then when he understands, do it from a standing position so he really has to look UP at you. This teaches him that when he wants something he needs to look at you, not at the distraction. This encourages an idea in his head that YOU are the provider of all things fun.

Also the command to "leave it". Put a piece of food like a potato chip on the floor (don't act like you are putting it there for him, or put it there while he's in another room). Then while on leash, when he goes to it say "leave it" and stop him with the leash and offer a treat from your hand to reward him for leaving the distraction and coming to you. Teach him to walk on leash past the distraction from a distance to closer up. Do this inside and outside, plant distractions in advance and then walk by them using the "leave it" command when he looks at it. This eventually comes in very handy on outdoor walks when he might be going toward something he doesn't need to get into, or looking/staring at an unruly dog, or trying to pull you toward something exciting - "Leave it" becomes a term for anything that he's focusing on and you need to break his focus & bring him back to you.

Always start with a quiet environment and add challenges as he understands what's expected of him. Always reward lavishly when he does the right thing (making you the most fun), and understand that as a young dog he will not be perfect for a long time. Short fun sessions/lessons will go a long way!
 
I have a male and a female Doberman.

My male was an absolute asshat beast in his younger years….he was a rehome to me from a richy richy couple that had triplet little girls- I have no idea what they were thinking. He ripped their house to pieces and then rehomed to me. There were times I had to tie him to the couch to get some peace. He was everywhere. Late at night I would tug war with him in the middle of the living room to tire him out for the night. It worked wonderfully at first but his energy tolerance became stronger and he demanded more and more. The couch no longer held him- he pulled it out of place many times. My wife and kids were terrified of him and often asked what did I get myself into.

What I learned from Ragnar to implement on my 2nd Doberman Freyja:
1. Listen to the members on this forum. I was warned about building his tolerance.
2. Mental work tires them more than physical.
3. They must be put in the crate and taught how to “turn off”. An absolute must.
4. They must be put in the crate to take naps during the day. If not, they are like a cranky baby at night.
5. Physical is good at their own pace- let them be a puppy.
6. Hide and seek in the house during rainy days is a lot of fun and can work obedience with fun.
7. Limit their freedom of running around free- use of a leash ALOT. They must understand their place is with you….not being a dog running the fence line for scent and fun. This will be earned and given at a later age when they are more settled. Not saying don’t let them run free and have fun, just saying limit it in order to establish their place is with me not on the fence line.
 
It worked wonderfully at first but his energy tolerance became stronger and he demanded more and more.

I hadn't even thought of this, I'll definitely be reducing the physical activity again so that it won't take a marathon to tire him out!

I love using frozen Kongs

I have a couple of Kongs and it takes him the best part of 2 minutes to get all the treats out. This will prolong another activity, thank you

check out these videos on Youtube - Dobercademy

Wow, that lady deserves a medal for all of that great content. It's the channel I never knew I needed! Thank you.
 
Re: Kongs!

We use plain yogurt and/or plain canned pumpkin, shmear it all around inside the Kong and add food to it (they get a bit of pre-made raw so that works well but you can also use kibble) and really fill it up and then freeze it solid. Keeps them busy for 20+ minutes. If using kibble, might work best to pre-soak it so it's mushy or mix it in with the yogurt/pumpkin and then fill the Kong!

We've also been doing a bit of scatter feeding. I measure out their dinner per usual for their kibble, and then take a handful and literally throw it in to the backyard. They're pretty quick with it but my Dobe is historically not an enthusiastic eater unless she has to work for it. Then it's much more appealing for some reason.

I've been seeing a lot of people on the internet saying their dogs almost never just eat food from a bowl. They make them work for it. cheers!
 

Back
Top