Allow Dobe to Sleep in Child's Room at Night?

Have Oji start sharing a bedroom with our young daughter?


  • Total voters
    8

Oh Little Oji

Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
Against my better judgement I am going to ask a question of the forum:

We are considering a change-up in room arrangements in our house. An idea/option is to move our young daughter to a different bedroom and have Oji sleep in that room with her. The room in question is the room in which Oji currently sleeps (on his bed which is in the closet).

Oji has not been allowed in our daughter's room to this point. He has rarely been in there. I just wanted to make it clear that he does not have dominion over her territory. I also wanted to keep his hair and dirt out of there.

I adhere to the policy that states that you should (pretty much) never leave a child alone with a dog.

Oji has been great with our child. He has not shown one instance of looking like he was going to get aggressive with, or dangerously reactive with her. He seems very reliable. She is able to hug him around the neck for instance. I do discourage her from getting face-to-face with him. Part of what makes him so tolerant with her, I believe, is that he is such a "slut" for touch.

So, (in terms of safety especially) how many of you would make the change to having Oji sleep in our daughter's room – with my wife and me sleeping in the next room over? How many of you would not? Why?
 
How old is your girl again?

Are there toys and things he may eat?

I assume this is the room that you always slept in with him. And he always slept in the closet? I'm just wondering if you change it up if he'll sneak to sleep on the bed with her? Would that be okay with you? She may not be as dominant as you to make him go lay in his own bed. I mean, I don't know if there's anything wrong with it except you may not like the hair on her bed. Or is he crated?

And I assume that perhaps The Change-Up is so you can finally sleep in your room room! I don't think there is anything wrong with it. Oji is not making much of a change since he is the one that slept in this room from day one. I guess the only iffy part is that they would be alone. Sleeping is one thing but when both of them are out of your sight, one never knows what's happening in there.
 
To me, it would depend on how confident and can she handle him. Ragnar can be a sweet wiggle butt to all three of my daughters but he gets the wild eye every now and then. You just have to know what to look for and what to do.

My oldest (18) trains Ragnar with me and handles him well. We do this training together right before feeding when he is more suceptible to following commands. Just amazing what he will do and how much easier it is right before feeding. My oldest also got a job this summer working at Camp BowWow and she understands why training and being in control of the situation is important.

My middle one (16) is a firecracker and a joker. Nope, wouldn’t let it happen with her.

My little one (13), Ragnar is really sweet on and she prob could but she does not actively train with us.

Ragnar has never shown any negative aggression to my girls and displays protective tendencies with them but unless they show the ability to turn him off when he gets the wild eye, not gonna happen.

Reading your post again.... Oji being in his same room would definitely help but I just can’t help to to think that children don’t understand that dogs don’t understand things the way we do. A situation may arise when they are alone in which you/I would see that it’s time to stop this behavior, but a child might think it’s funny and antagonize it more. Then something happens and it’s really not the dogs fault, he’s just being a Doberman.....

And then there’s toys, socks and undies!!! Believe me, you don’t want an obstruction surgery to deal with or pay for.

I don’t know man, Oji may bond with her more and it really could go well. Tough choice because you know you want to but is it the smartest thing?

She would definitely have to know what to look for and start doing some kind of training with us for me to consider it.
 
Sounds like maybe he doesn't sleep in a crate at night? I forget?

You know your family dynamics better than anyone so if you're questioning it, is it the right thing?

If he's not in a crate and she were to get up in the middle of the night and accidentally kick or step on him on the floor, would he react? Moose jumped on Rubie while she was sleeping the other day and she was NOT pleased and let him know.
 
I would allow it, if both kid and dog seemed capable.

I started training our first dobe when I was 4. As in, my mom would be sitting somewhere far away or outside while I went through obedience class with our full grown dobe. After we got through obedience, the trainer suggested we do agility. So we did. It was my responsibility, my mom just drove us.

So yeah, a kid is definitely capable. Sam hadn't even been raised by us. We got her as a 2 year old and she was a bigggg female.
 
She is 7.

Actually, one area where Oji shines is that he has never shown a propensity to be an inappropriate chewer! In fact, the closet where his bed is also houses lots of our girl's toys! Stuffed animals and all! Now, used underwear? Yes, he at least wants to lick that, and one never knows what day a dog will up and swallow something – no matter how trustworthy they are. So picking up laundry would be a must.

Our daughter is quite good about knowing how to handle a dog. She is a very well-behaved child! We have had her do some training with Oji. He will sit and lay down and other things for her, if even more slowly than he obeys for me :mad: I'm not saying she never gets silly and crosses the line into a bit of annoying pestering of Oji. I still have the standing rule: Do not get face-to-face with him.

So, really, my struggle is: Do I break that cardinal rule: Never leave a child alone with a dog. ?

Yes, a good point has been raised: What if she steps on him in the night? He does not stay in his bed, or in the closet all night. I've talked about how (especially if he is not sufficiently exercised and if it is warm in the house) he will body slam himself a few times in the night, jolting me awake.
 
The room in question is the room in which Oji currently sleeps (on his bed which is in the closet).
My only concern is that the room is kinda Oji's territory. Sure he's exclusively got the closet but what contains him to the actual closet. If there's a physical barrier, then I'd be pretty comfortable. If the room was new to him that would also be better in my view.

If you're going to do it, I would at least have an introductory phase. First night it's all of you, next night your wife leaves, next night you stay, then half a night. I think this could help you arrive at a decision.
 
I boy hasn’t slept in my daughter’s room but my older son who is 10 I do allow at times for him to move his bed in his room at night for Kodak to sleep near him. My boy just likes to sleep near anyone of us on his bed. My son knows all things have to be picked and cleaned, closets closed, and no socks around. Then Kodak just lays down anyways on cue for bedtime. Throughout the day both kids have to keep the rooms closed just cause they aren’t on top of not leaving undies or a pair of socks out on a regular basis.
 
She is 7.

Actually, one area where Oji shines is that he has never shown a propensity to be an inappropriate chewer! In fact, the closet where his bed is also houses lots of our girl's toys! Stuffed animals and all! Now, used underwear? Yes, he at least wants to lick that, and one never knows what day a dog will up and swallow something – no matter how trustworthy they are. So picking up laundry would be a must.

Our daughter is quite good about knowing how to handle a dog. She is a very well-behaved child! We have had her do some training with Oji. He will sit and lay down and other things for her, if even more slowly than he obeys for me :mad: I'm not saying she never gets silly and crosses the line into a bit of annoying pestering of Oji. I still have the standing rule: Do not get face-to-face with him.

So, really, my struggle is: Do I break that cardinal rule: Never leave a child alone with a dog. ?

Yes, a good point has been raised: What if she steps on him in the night? He does not stay in his bed, or in the closet all night. I've talked about how (especially if he is not sufficiently exercised and if it is warm in the house) he will body slam himself a few times in the night, jolting me awake.
All we can offer is our own anecdotal experiences. Ultimately it is your decision.
My anecdotal experience,
We’ve never contained the dogs at night, mostly because they’ve never given me a reason to. Other than when Daisy was a new pup, and we porta-penned her.

That said, they have all had the freedom to sleep where they like. And not one of them sleeps in the exact same spot all night.
Rocky seems to follow me up to bed most nights, on occasion I tell him I’m going and he looks at me like “I’m pretty comfortable here, man”, so I let him be.
He usually wanders up in a couple hours to his bed in our room.
He’s never shown much interest in sleeping in the kids rooms.

Now Daisy...
She was Velcro to me most of the time, but come bed time? Sometimes in our room. Most of the time just outside of or in our daughters room, sleeping on the very end of her bed, the foot.
My daughter was older than yours, but mental capacity is probably about at your kids 7 year level.
It was never an issue or worry, but we knew her personality pretty well.
Part of her deal was security.
She liked to sleep at the top of our stairs a lot too. Her perfect vantage point.
Clear view of the front door, half the down stairs, both kids rooms to her back, my room to her back, her controlling the only way to those rooms.
That was just who she was.

Maxie, the old girl. She liked to sleep under our beds, didn’t matter who’s.
She was a shorty.:D

Have you ever considered just letting him choose where he’d want to sleep?
Maybe he doesn’t like where he is now? Hence the defiant body slams.
Just a thought.
 
We too let our dogs have the roam of the entire house at night, as well as when we are gone. Our children are grown and gone, but we had our first Dobe, Slayer, when they were 8 & 10. Slayer also had roam of the house, but we did train him to not go into the kids rooms. He never slept in the room with them, always slept in our room or his bed in the living room. I for myself, would only allow it when the kids were older and after they went through classes with the dog. I believe the oldest was 14 when we finally allowed the dog into his room, but Slayer still preferred to sleep with us or in his bed!
 
Against my better judgement I am going to ask a question of the forum:

We are considering a change-up in room arrangements in our house. An idea/option is to move our young daughter to a different bedroom and have Oji sleep in that room with her. The room in question is the room in which Oji currently sleeps (on his bed which is in the closet).

Oji has not been allowed in our daughter's room to this point. He has rarely been in there. I just wanted to make it clear that he does not have dominion over her territory. I also wanted to keep his hair and dirt out of there.

I adhere to the policy that states that you should (pretty much) never leave a child alone with a dog.

Oji has been great with our child. He has not shown one instance of looking like he was going to get aggressive with, or dangerously reactive with her. He seems very reliable. She is able to hug him around the neck for instance. I do discourage her from getting face-to-face with him. Part of what makes him so tolerant with her, I believe, is that he is such a "slut" for touch.

So, (in terms of safety especially) how many of you would make the change to having Oji sleep in our daughter's room – with my wife and me sleeping in the next room over? How many of you would not? Why?
Why the change? Does your daughter want him to sleep with her? Has he been sleeping loose in the house with no problems? Only you know your dog and if she has a great relationship I say let him sleep with her.
 
What if she has a nightmare and screams, and Oji rushes to her and scares her. She may develop a fear of him which may disrupt the comfort level she has with him now. Just imagine how much more devilish they look coming out of the shadows of a dark room :screamcat:

Aren't you glad you asked :laughing:
 
The concerns about her startling him or stepping on him or having a nightmare ...

Been there, done that. The kids know that if they startle him, he barks. They talk to him, he shuts up. Stepping on him - my kid rolled off the couch onto Kaizer in his sleep, Kaizer just looked at him and started licking his face face. I guess the nightmare situation is possible, but I'd say pretty unlikely unless you have a kid prone to nightmares.


Remember - Oji has grown up with your daughter. And I'm going to guess that if you still have him, you're not worried he's going to just randomly try to eat her. Yeah, there's always a risk. Always. But you know oji and you know your kid. Kaizer is a million times gentler with the kids. I can't keep Kaizer from sleeping with my youngest. They'll climb up on the couch or love seat and crash. In fact, Kaizer will very gingerly climb up after the kid is asleep and wedge himself around/under the kid.
 
I understand the motto "never leave a child unattended with a dog" BUT for me that is for a certain age. 4 and under I would be most concerned they may play inappropriately with the dog. Maybe it' just me, but with my kids being raised from the start with dogs, by the time they are 5 they have a pretty tight bond with our furry family. I believe my daughter was around 5 yrs old when I would let her play in the privacy fenced back yard alone, as long as she brought a doberman with her. I never worried, but I spent a lot of time setting the ground rules from the day they came home from the hospital. I also know my dogs very well, and if I had any doubts, I wouldn't do it. Sooo...are you having doubts?
 
I understand the motto "never leave a child unattended with a dog" BUT for me that is for a certain age. 4 and under I would be most concerned they may play inappropriately with the dog. Maybe it' just me, but with my kids being raised from the start with dogs, by the time they are 5 they have a pretty tight bond with our furry family. I believe my daughter was around 5 yrs old when I would let her play in the privacy fenced back yard alone, as long as she brought a doberman with her. I never worried, but I spent a lot of time setting the ground rules from the day they came home from the hospital. I also know my dogs very well, and if I had any doubts, I wouldn't do it. Sooo...are you having doubts?
No, no doubts based on Oji's track record. Just doubts based on the fact we can never know what an animal will do, and a moderately sized dog has the physical tools to do horrific things to a small person.
 
No, no doubts based on Oji's track record. Just doubts based on the fact we can never know what an animal will do, and a moderately sized dog has the physical tools to do horrific things to a small person.


Maybe you can observe the first evening.

When I introduced Rex to our bed to sleep, I set alarms (on vibrate not to wake him) every few hours to see where he was on the bed and his positioning awake/chewing on blankets etc. I also put his “pee slip lead” on him and tied it to my body so if he jumped off the bed or moved a significant amount of distance it’d wake me up. I did this on a weekend night since my sleep was going to be affected.

Maybe what you can do is, let him sleep in her room on a Friday night. Check in on them every hour and see what he’s doing in the room. Possibly even put a pet camera so you could observe him more covertly and see how it goes and go from there.
 

Back
Top