Advice? Dog Fights!!

  • Thread starter Thread starter FredC
  • Start date Start date

F

FredC

Ugh i really have no idea where to start regarding this problem that seems to be getting worse and worse every month..

I have one Male (Lord Mars and two Females (Kali and Demi) Kali is Demi's mother.. Anyways Kali has always been dog aggressive from day one. But she never really had issues with dogs within her own pack.. However over the last few months that has been changing and its only getting worse.. It doesnt take anything to set her off, it could be something as a simply bumping into each other.. A cpl weeks ago Demi jumped on the couch where Kali was sleeping and laid on top of Kali and like lightning it was on that quick.. Kali is always the aggressor, Niehter Mars or Demi have ever started a fight in this house but we have had several over the years and each and every time its been Kali who instigates this..

Another interesting fact is that until today Kali has never been hurt in these fights but she always manages to inflict some damage on one of the others.. As things sit right now Demi has a 2 inch cut on her front leg that managed to cut completely through the skin to the tendons.. It was closing up on its own until Kali reopened it back up this morning..

Fact #2 There has only been one fight started in my presence.. I broke it up (took everything i had then some to break them up on my own) and made sure it never happened again.. But they still scrap when others (GF) are watching them.. At the rate of about one a week.. I just dont know how to get Kali to respect my GF's authority..

The reason for the post is im really starting to worry that one of them is going to eventually get seriously hurt. Today was the first time ever Kali has suffered anything more then a scratch.. At the moment she has a cpl holes in her ears and blood has been draining into the drum. I cant clean it because it hurts her to bad..

We will be on our way to the vets with both Kali and Demi this afternoon when he opens but thats not going to solve this problem..

I know one of the solutions is simply to keep Kali separate from the others but thats not really a solution im fond of.. Im almost sure it boils down to respect since Kristi deals with this all the time and its only ever happened once in my presence. Fortunately for my GF is that im always close when it does happen just never in the same room.

HELP!! I cant remember the last time i actually reached out to the community here for tips and suggestions but im flat out of ideas.
 
Hmmmmmm. I know you don't want to separate, but to keep the dogs safe (and your GF sane) it may be best to do so at least while Kristi is watching them. I am obviously a novice with dogs, but...

1) What generally causes the fights? Do they only happen when Kali is awakened suddenly? Is she protective over toys/bones/food/bed? I guess if you knew more about the circumstances under which the fights start, then you might be able to look at how to address the issue. ?

2) There must be ways to demonstrate to them that Kristi is a leader, such as having her be the one to feed them using NILIF tactics? I don't know Kristi, or her interactions with the dogs, but does she behave like the leader? Firm voice, commands, corrections, etc. I am sure others will be able to provide suggestions on how Kristi can be seen as a leader of the dogs.

Just my $.02. I am sure you will get a lot of great suggestions. Hope you can get this resolved quickly... and then tell us what worked!
 
Did you check her thyroid? Sometimes it causes odd behaviour.

I would keep Kali separated and let her play with other dogs under my supervision only.
Asha may get too much involved in tough games. Usually I distract her by throwing a tug to play with. They both are tug addicts.
Asha is not aggressive... she just likes tough games.
 
I'll be interested in what others say. I would start removing the things they get in fights over, like Liz mentioned. If Kali is having a 'tude, she loses the couch. Obviously the couch has become her place and in her mind she claims it. Well, with her snapping at one of the others she's lost that privilege. I actually would just go ahead and remove all of them off of any furniture until you can get this fixed.

Does your GF feed the dogs routinely? Who is the one that lets them outside? Maybe start having her doing those things including practicing NILIF and you should see a change. Have her make them sit at the door before going out, (say the command once), sit/wait while she places food bowls down then give the command to eat their food, no pushing past her while she's trying to walk around, etc. And, if they get on the couch without being invited, then your GF must make them get down with a command. Help teach her dog body language so she can be on the look out for signals.
 
Damn, sorry to hear that. It sounds like it's pretty much an all out fight too, so that has to be hard. I really don't have any experience with it (KOW), but it does almost sound like separating them with a gate or something when Kris is watching them might be the safest option for all of them. I'm thinking that perhaps since Demi is sort of Kristie's girl there's some jealousy that could trigger it?

I hope your vet visit goes well and that both of the girls are okay!
 
Thanks Guys.. They really dont fight over anything.. They share their food and eat out of the same bowl they respect each other regarding toys and never fight over those things.. The couch isnt an issue the three of them sleep on it together regularly. They are never allowed to free feed on bones because that would certainly cause a fight. (You know the other bone is always better) The trigger is sometimes over excitement.. Which i never personally allow indoors our out..

I wasnt in the room when the fight this morning started but what i was told is that Kris let Demi all the dogs out of their crates for their morning potty kali ran out of her to the end of the hall turned and charged demi who was 10 15 feet away in another room.. So no trigger there as far as i can tell.. And of course since im never around when it happens its difficult for me to know the cause.. I think if i could see it i could fix it.. Like i said they did this once with me and never again.. I set them all straight from the word go..

I dont mean this in a bad way but i do blame the GF probably more then i should but its so frustrating knowing no dogs respect her.. (remember Daemon who took a cpl shoots at her a cpl years ago.) But before someone suggests it i want to be clear that my GF doesnt have a mean bone in her body and would never hurt the dogs so thats out of the question.

Here is my only theory.. When Kali was about 16 weeks she had a traumatic experience with a half dozen GSP's.. When we first met Kalis handler we of course brought Kali along.. We went into the kennel area (not the kennels themselves) to see her facility and where Kali would be staying on show weekends.. When we got inside the GSP where barking so crazy loud the poor little girl had a panic attack and just backed herself in a corner and squealed for her life.. The GSP's where kenneled and we were in the common area so she was never in harms way but it was a traumatic experience for her and she has never from that day forward been dog friendly.. However she was all about her pack and never fought her own.. I think she was about a year before she got in her first fight with Mars ( the first fight that kali got into was actually between Mars and Daemon she of course picked a side and went ap crazy helping Daemon in attacking Mars) at that time we averaged a cpl fights a year now we average about two or three a month.. Its getting old and i just dont know how to fix it short of separating them, which i only believe will cause more problems down the road.. Separating the dogs seems like a bad option because it only puts a bandaid on the problem and doesn't fix it in any way shape or form.. (of course i understand its about their safety to but id perfer to solve this problem then to avoid it by just keeping them apart.
 
Wow, been there done that and I know your pain. Is it just the two females that are fighting? We've never had a problem with opposite sexes fighting, in fact all the males are very respectful of our girl Leia.

Our males on the other hand have been a problem particularly our foster boy Jake. We have tried everything with him from making him lay down in front of the others crates and treating him to keep him calm, but once he started on one of our boys he won't let it go. Just recently in the care of our local pet lodge when we were out of town, he got excited with all the other dogs barking and went after our one year old puppy when they inadvertently let them both out at the same time for a walk, 5 stitches in each of the puppies legs. Because of that and the difficulty in now having to keep him separated from the other dogs at all times, as much as it hurts us for the safety of our other dogs we have decided to finally find him a better home without other male dogs.

I'm not sure if there is a solution once they start fighting other than to keep them separated, I hope it turns out ok and let us know if you find a solution that works.
 
Wow, been there done that and I know your pain. Is it just the two females that are fighting? We've never had a problem with opposite sexes fighting, in fact all the males are very respectful of our girl Leia.

Our males on the other hand have been a problem particularly our foster boy Jake. We have tried everything with him from making him lay down in front of the others crates and treating him to keep him calm, but once he started on one of our boys he won't let it go. Just recently in the care of our local pet lodge when we were out of town, he got excited with all the other dogs barking and went after our one year old puppy when they inadvertently let them both out at the same time for a walk, 5 stitches in each of the puppies legs. Because of that and the difficulty in now having to keep him separated from the other dogs at all times, as much as it hurts us for the safety of our other dogs we have decided to finally find him a better home without other male dogs.

I'm not sure if there is a solution once they start fighting other than to keep them separated, I hope it turns out ok and let us know if you find a solution that works.
Thanks for that.. In Kalis Case she isnt prejudice at all Male or Female. Mars Could tear her up but hes so chill that he goes out of his way to avoid her.. Demi on the other hand is carefree and has no problem getting on her mothers nerves.. So ultimately Demi kind of starts them but Kali is always the initial aggressor.

I think it can be fixed in my case because they respect me.. I just need to figure out how to teach the GF to be assertive enough for them to understand she is in charge so they respect her to.. The big difference between me and her is im physically involved in their interactions where the GF is kind of oblivious until its to late. I think she fears them to a degree and i also think they know it.. But if thats the case its going to be a long haul.. as she was pretty viciously attacked a cpl years ago by Daemon. That kind of fear just doesnt go away even if she doesnt show it..
 
HELP!! I cant remember the last time i actually reached out to the community here for tips and suggestions but im flat out of ideas.

I have a feeling you already know the solution to your problem but you are hoping someone might suggest a different working fix..
The truth is...you best keep Kali & Demi separated when you are not around to supervise..



by the way..how old are they? (Kali & Demi)
 
I have a feeling you already know the solution to your problem but you are hoping someone might suggest a different working fix..
The truth is...you best keep Kali & Demi separated when you are not around to supervise..



by the way..how old are they? (Kali & Demi)
Kali is four Demi is two.. Kali is Demi's Mother but the way they play you wouldn't be able to tell which one was the pup and which one was the mother.

I respect your opinion iceman i really do, but separating them isn't a solution its a band aid. Although your probably right and and regardless of weather its a solution or a band aid im pretty sure the writing is on the wall and thats the future.
 
I wasnt in the room when the fight this morning started but what i was told is that Kris let Demi all the dogs out of their crates for their morning potty kali ran out of her to the end of the hall turned and charged demi who was 10 15 feet away in another room.. So no trigger there as far as i can tell..
Von, you know I am the LAST person to put my two cents into this! lol Because I have zero experience with dog fights and they scare the bejebbers outta me too! But I love to try and analyze and understand dog behavior. As soon as I read the sentence above, the first thing I thought of was, could jealousy be the trigger? Competition? Kali wanted to beat everyone to the door. So much so that she would turn and 'beat up' (stop) anyone else......especially when there's no one there to control the excitement (GF doesn't seem to count. lol) She's (Kali) the 'mom' and she seems to making sure Demi remembers that by picking on her. And you know sons or males don't cross the queen, ;) but us daughters might be up for the challenge. :evilgrin: lol Not that Kali is doing anything .......except not backing down like Mars. That's what Kali wants. She's being top dog with your GF. With you, it's like the teacher just stepped back in the classroom. :tap:

I just need to figure out how to teach the GF to be assertive enough for them to understand she is in charge.
And I don't have a clue how to 'teach' this to someone, especially one that has been bitten before. Fear is funny thing and difficult to cure. My neighbor down the road loves horses but when she bought her first horse it had reared up and went over backward with her. She now has such a fear that I could not help her. She scared to death to ride outside of a fenced area. When she tries she's terrified even though there is nothing happening to be fearful for. She's got a trainer coming out now to work with her on her horse and the way it's going, I have doubts she'll ever be able to ride down the road with me. It's frustrating to me because I don't know how to help her. How do you create confidence in someone?
 
Von - Having lived with this for a number of years in the past I can tell you I am on sides with Iceman. Dobermans are famous for SAME SEX AGGRESSION. And once it starts it tends to escalate over time. The GF is in danger if Kali does not respect her. Better to set up a separate area for Kali and when she is out Demi is up. I swear I livedi n terror for almost a year worrying I would forget one bitchs was out and accidently let the other out.

They actaully can kill another dog in about 5 seconds so I am not for playing Russian roulette. You have tried to work with it and it is not working. You can handle it this time but what happens when the time comes you can't. They are very powerful and they are strong as an ox. You need to think of keeping eveyrone safe and at peace and separation does the trick. I am not convince even if you tried the fixes that I would believe in them 100% - again what happens when you are not there - the GF can't deal with it for sure as she is already a target.

Does she work with the dogs at all??? Any obedience??? If not she will not ever be respected and at this point might not anyway regardless of what changes you make. Bitches coming into heat or thyroid problems as Rits mentioned might also be playing a role. My advise don't go there - it is just not worth it. Sening you a big hug and specail prayer.
 
We got an appointment to see the vet at 6 tonight..

I would like to thank everyone for taking the time to reply here and ill get back to this after the vet appt.. Right now im just kind of Anxious and having a hard time concentrating.. Demi will probably need several stitches in her leg and Kali has something going on behind her Jaw around the ear canal. :( Ill be sure to update everyone when i have some answers. Demi doesnt seem to even know her leg is cut open but Kali is acting really off and im worried.
 
The root of the problem (imo) would be dominance. Kali is trying to "control" the behavior/excitement levels of the other dogs that "she" does not approve of. Dobies are known for same sex aggression....that in mind, I would go the separation route when the GF is in charge ((bc in the dogs mind she is clearly NOT in charge)). Dogs with this issue don't have to live the separation/kennel swap life, their "control" and pack status just needs to be altered/taken away from them. If it doesn't happen in your presence it's more than likely bc she understand that you are the boss and when you are around she doesn't have to be.
To play it on the safe side...I would keep them separated when left with the GF. You are the one that has to live with them...GF included ((LOL!!:D)) so try a few things and stick with what makes you comfortable concerning everyone's safety.
 
Kali is four Demi is two.. Kali is Demi's Mother but the way they play you wouldn't be able to tell which one was the pup and which one was the mother.

I agree with others that problem is dominance...as long as Demi was a pup there was no problem... she respected Kali and all was well, but naturally as she started feeling mature enough, she started challenging Kali for the top female position in your pack.
If you had a male pup same problem would happen when he was old enough to challenge your male..this is how hierarchy in canine packs is established and we cant change it.
One of them will have to submit to other for the problem to go away...if they don't ..........they could kill each other!!
 
I can relate on the aspect of having another person in charge of two dogs that could blow up without you around. I worry about that now that I have changed jobs and can't take Hans with me to work anymore. My BF commands very little respect from the dogs, but he's not had an incedent on his watch. Is there any way you can take Kali or Demi to work with you? Keeping one of the girls with you at all times would eliminate the GF's need to keep peace while you are not home.

The excitement factor in the explosion of aggressiveness is also very familiar. Keeping the calm around the house is very important, but you know that.
 
Ugh i really have no idea where to start regarding this problem that seems to be getting worse and worse every month..

I have one Male (Lord Mars and two Females (Kali and Demi) Kali is Demi's mother.. Anyways Kali has always been dog aggressive from day one. But she never really had issues with dogs within her own pack.. However over the last few months that has been changing and its only getting worse.. It doesnt take anything to set her off, it could be something as a simply bumping into each other.. A cpl weeks ago Demi jumped on the couch where Kali was sleeping and laid on top of Kali and like lightning it was on that quick.. Kali is always the aggressor, Niehter Mars or Demi have ever started a fight in this house but we have had several over the years and each and every time its been Kali who instigates this..

Another interesting fact is that until today Kali has never been hurt in these fights but she always manages to inflict some damage on one of the others.. As things sit right now Demi has a 2 inch cut on her front leg that managed to cut completely through the skin to the tendons.. It was closing up on its own until Kali reopened it back up this morning..

Fact #2 There has only been one fight started in my presence.. I broke it up (took everything i had then some to break them up on my own) and made sure it never happened again.. But they still scrap when others (GF) are watching them.. At the rate of about one a week.. I just dont know how to get Kali to respect my GF's authority..

The reason for the post is im really starting to worry that one of them is going to eventually get seriously hurt. Today was the first time ever Kali has suffered anything more then a scratch.. At the moment she has a cpl holes in her ears and blood has been draining into the drum. I cant clean it because it hurts her to bad..

We will be on our way to the vets with both Kali and Demi this afternoon when he opens but thats not going to solve this problem..

I know one of the solutions is simply to keep Kali separate from the others but thats not really a solution im fond of.. Im almost sure it boils down to respect since Kristi deals with this all the time and its only ever happened once in my presence. Fortunately for my GF is that im always close when it does happen just never in the same room.

HELP!! I cant remember the last time i actually reached out to the community here for tips and suggestions but im flat out of ideas.


Doom,
I hate to give you what is most certainly bad news, but I am going to say that you will have to start the crate and rotate method and keep them apart going forward. I have had personally and worked with many dogs that have had these issues, and I currently have my two bitches now (dobe and GSD) that are this way. They got along for years with no issues, and then it started small, a few growls and then small fights, and now they want to kill each other whenever they see each other. There is no amount of training in the world that will correct this. The fact is, that same sex aggression is very common in large breed protection dogs and once it starts, you just cant ever have them together again, without the real risk of someone getting seriously hurt, maimed, or even killed. Right now we simply have a room for the GSD bitch to be in when we are all home, and the other bedroom is for the Dobe Bitch, and the male usually rotates with outside and inside, but I never let the two bitches be together anymore as they would go right into a fight. I can walk them together on leads, and even train on the same field in side by side proximity, but take them off lead and in a normal environment, and the fight is on. Sorry to say this, but it seems your coming up on the same issue, and will have to learn to rotate their time and attention with the family.
 

Back
Top