A Dog's Purpose

I'm not ready to hang anyone just yet. Keep in mind we saw a few seconds of what was probably hours of filming. Watching that clip I would agree it was not done correctly. But we have to remember who was behind this campaign, the AR activist. In my experience I have learned not to trust them and think of most of them as crazy extremist. Call me any name you want for saying that, but I have been stalked, physically attacked and nearly arrested for what came down to the fact that I own an intact dog.
I am going to withhold any judgement until we have more facts.
A good editor given a film can tell any story that want. The makers of this film could be wrong and I may end up boycotting this. I just am not ready to make that decision yet.
 
Yeaaa............about 8 minutes in, it gets a little, um, weird. Smellavision? :spit:

LOL I'll admit I didn't watch the entire clip so if there is more to it, woops...Haha. but I liked what he had to say and how there were some more facts and sources presented. I'll admit I was upset by the video initially but I can see now how this could be a totally different day in training. I still think they could of had a ramp to introduce the dog into the water vs lowering him in like they did and I still think there probably is a better dog out there suited to what they wanted to do.
 
Oh I'm not ready to boycott the movie at all, this was one clip and I hope they learned from the experience. I assume the dog is okay and they went back and either used that shot or trained the dog better or used a different dog. Which is why there is one clip vs multiple.
 
A statement from the Author of the book the movie is based on came out today.
Source: Bruce Cameron

"First I want to thank everyone—and there have been literally thousands of you—who have written to express support. Your words and thoughts mean the world to us.

I found the video we’ve all seen to be shocking because when I was on set, the ethic of everyone was the safety and comfort of the dogs.

If the people who shot and edited the video thought something was wrong, why did they wait fifteen months to do anything about it, instead of immediately going to the authorities?

I have since viewed footage taken of the day in question, when I wasn’t there, and it paints an entirely different picture.

The written commentary accompanying the edited video mischaracterizes what happened. The dog was not terrified and not thrown in the water—I’ve seen footage of Hercules earlier that day joyfully jumping in the pool. When he was asked to perform the stunt from the other side of the pool, which was not how he had been doing it all day, he balked. The mistake was trying to dip the dog in the water to show him it was okay—the water wasn’t his issue, it was the location that was the issue, and the dog happily did the stunt when he was allowed to return to his original spot.

I also didn’t like it when Hercules’s head briefly went under water, but there was a scuba diver and a trainer in the pool to protect him. He loves the water, wasn’t in danger, and wasn’t upset.

On a movie where the mantra was the safety and comfort of the dogs, mistakes were made, and everything needs to be done to make sure those errors are not repeated. But the reason American Humane certifies that no animals were harmed during the making of the film is that no animals were harmed during the making of the film.

I celebrate animal rescue and am proud of the values that show up in A Dog’s Purpose. -- Bruce"
 
I knew there was something off about that clip... obviously the voice was afterwards since the water wasn't louder than the voice which sounded like a normal speaking voice. Then the obvious clip to the end.

I believe the director in this.
 
Has anyone seen the movie yet? I've heard it's great.




I did see the movie. I highly recommend everyone that has ever owned a dog see it too. Will you cry? Absolutely, but in the end you are left very comforted. Kind of hard to explain without giving too much away.
Only one disappointing part for me. The role of the GSD, the AR wackcos had their say there. Definitely a subtle message about working dogs. Still a good movie overall.
 
I did see the movie. I highly recommend everyone that has ever owned a dog see it too. Will you cry? Absolutely, but in the end you are left very comforted. Kind of hard to explain without giving too much away.
Only one disappointing part for me. The role of the GSD, the AR wackcos had their say there. Definitely a subtle message about working dogs. Still a good movie overall.
Unfortunately, all movies and TV shows have underlying messages they're trying to push. It's the chief reason I hardly watch any.
 
My 12 year-old nieces told me that even though it's a "happy cry" a lot of the time, they don't recommend that I watch it!!...They know I get HIGHLY emotional, and they definitely did not want to see it in the theatre with me!!...I think they feared I would embarrass them!!
 
Unfortunately, all movies and TV shows have underlying messages they're trying to push. It's the chief reason I hardly watch any.

I don't worry about the "underlying messages" as I suspect they'll be there, anyway. It is "Hollyweird," after all, no? :D I pride myself on being able to ferret out that message ASAP.

I rarely go watch movies in theaters now, for "safety" reasons. I'll await the DVD... unless it's something I absolutely have to see immediately. With one exception, the only movies that merited that treatment recently were the Harry Potter series, and only because I was taking my niece to see them.
 
My 12 year-old nieces told me that even though it's a "happy cry" a lot of the time, they don't recommend that I watch it!!...They know I get HIGHLY emotional, and they definitely did not want to see it in the theatre with me!!...I think they feared I would embarrass them!!

I know all about HIGHLY emotional! lol I would like to see it but really hesitant. I usually get all my movies on Netflex (DVD mailed to me) so one day I'll order it. But as it is, I had a free movie channel a while back and I recorded MAX. I've yet to watch it!! :confused-alt: I'm so hesitant. Gotta be in the right frame of mind, no one home and lots of tissue!!
 
I know all about HIGHLY emotional! lol I would like to see it but really hesitant. I usually get all my movies on Netflex (DVD mailed to me) so one day I'll order it. But as it is, I had a free movie channel a while back and I recorded MAX. I've yet to watch it!! :confused-alt: I'm so hesitant. Gotta be in the right frame of mind, no one home and lots of tissue!!

I'm with ya 100%!
 
Unfortunately, all movies and TV shows have underlying messages they're trying to push. It's the chief reason I hardly watch any.



It seems everybody has an agenda. :rolleyes:

I don't worry about the "underlying messages" as I suspect they'll be there, anyway. It is "Hollyweird," after all, no? :D I pride myself on being able to ferret out that message ASAP.




I try not to worry but I wonder if I am supporting the crap sometimes. Sooo tired of people thinking only their ideals are right and having them forced down my throat.


As far as the movie goes, I'm happy I saw it. After a year I still struggle with the loss of my Goober. I have had countless dogs in my life. Loved them all but there was just something about Greta. She nursed me through breast cancer, kept me distracted when my Dad died, saved my life when a presumed carjacker wanted my car....we lived and shared a life together. I never had the pleasure of a dog like her. As silly as it sounds, this movie helped me understand our journey isn't over. Maybe it's just the way I interpreted it, don't know, I do know it helped.
 
I try not to worry but I wonder if I am supporting the crap sometimes. Sooo tired of people thinking only their ideals are right and having them forced down my throat.

Well, if it's obvious enough for me to ferret it out before having to spend money on it, that's the best. For example, that Jessica Chastain movie "Miss Slone" where she played the lobbyist in favor of gun control. That I figured out in advance, and would not watch that. But if it's subtle enough, I might give it a look.

As far as the movie goes, I'm happy I saw it. After a year I still struggle with the loss of my Goober. I have had countless dogs in my life. Loved them all but there was just something about Greta. She nursed me through breast cancer, kept me distracted when my Dad died, saved my life when a presumed carjacker wanted my car....we lived and shared a life together. I never had the pleasure of a dog like her. As silly as it sounds, this movie helped me understand our journey isn't over. Maybe it's just the way I interpreted it, don't know, I do know it helped.

Then it was certainly worth it to watch. I will also, when it comes out on DVD.
 
As far as the movie goes, I'm happy I saw it. After a year I still struggle with the loss of my Goober. I have had countless dogs in my life. Loved them all but there was just something about Greta. She nursed me through breast cancer, kept me distracted when my Dad died, saved my life when a presumed carjacker wanted my car....we lived and shared a life together. I never had the pleasure of a dog like her. As silly as it sounds, this movie helped me understand our journey isn't over. Maybe it's just the way I interpreted it, don't know, I do know it helped.
I'm still on the fence about seeing it.
Coming up on 7 months, post Daisy.
I'm not sure I can handle the emotional roller coaster?
I fear that film may be a short fuse to an emotional setback, if I could even sit through it all.
 

Back
Top