• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Buying a holter monitor

JanS

DCF Owner
Administrative Staff
Moderator
Hot Topics Subscriber
I got an early Christmas present (or at least that's what I'll call it) and bought a holter monitor. Both of these dogs are young and I don't want to rent or borrow one every year and be responsible for it if it's someone else's.
New holter Oct  31 24.webp

I rented one a while ago and they sent a vest that was too small so I never did get a reading after 4 tries and they said there were 2 memory cards in there when there was only 1 so I wound up paying an extra $35 to replace it, not to mention shipping it back insured was almost $40. Now we have our own and don't have to worry about that stuff...
 
I'm sure curious what test that was! Maybe a 48 hour Holter + Echo?
I would have to ask Katyusha's mom's owner, it could have been, but I didn't remember her talking about an echo at the time. Xena (Katyusha's mom) went to the cardiology center there before her second litter. I am sure it was a comprehensive visit. What are the rest of you paying for a 48 hour holter around the country?
 
I paid $189 just for the holter a year ago....but it was because I was there for an echo...so I think it was cheaper because I didn't have to pay another office visit fee.
Echos went up $100. here....they are now $600 for first time visit...$400 for returning visit.
 
I would have to ask Katyusha's mom's owner, it could have been, but I didn't remember her talking about an echo at the time. Xena (Katyusha's mom) went to the cardiology center there before her second litter. I am sure it was a comprehensive visit. What are the rest of you paying for a 48 hour holter around the country?
Probably best to start a new thread on this since there is interest, it would be informative for all. @Ravenbird mind moving the echo/holter related posts?
 
My breeder lends hers to her puppy owners, so I've just paid shipping both ways for the Holter and Albas fee for the 24 hour one. I can't find an Echo without driving 4 - 6 hours one way and they want $800 for that. Keep trying to find a health fair, but nope, not in my area.
 
I can't find an Echo without driving 4 - 6 hours one way and they want $800 for that.
Wow it would have been close to 4 hours for us to the U but they started having health clinics in Superior, WI and it only cost us $305 for Elroy's echo with a cardiologist so that's not bad considering it's only 1.5 hours away.
My breeder lends hers to her puppy owners, so I've just paid shipping both ways for the Holter and Albas fee for the 24 hour one.
Our breeder has one that she will loan out to puppy buyers but it's tied up much of the time so I just figured it would be easier to get our own and keep it here.
 
I can't find an Echo without driving 4 - 6 hours one way and they want $800 for that.
Yeah, that's far away and quite expensive! I can get an echo about an hour away for what my local, referring clinic tells me is $400 ish. The manager of the echo capable clinic lives less than a block from me, If I asked nice enough, he might just take Katyusha to work one day and bring her home? Katyusha's vet wants her to have the echo done within the next year or two, then every year after that, to compare against the first baseline one. The local vets seem much more interested in echo results than holter, but I gather here that both are important.

If anyone wants to, I would love the "explain it to me like I am two years old" version of how the echo and Holter differ in their measurements and prediction/detection of DCM. In my uneducated brain, I figure that "dilated" would mean enlarged, which an echo would pick up really easily, but maybe the Holter has results that I don't know their predictive capability?
Our breeder has one that she will loan out to puppy buyers but it's tied up much of the time so I just figured it would be easier to get our own and keep it here.
This would be my mentality. Just own one for my two, then it's mine and always available, and also could be lent as I see fit, to some of the other local Doberman owners who have, and their dogs have, become dear to me.
 
I can't find an Echo without driving 4 - 6 hours one way
I know that one show where you got Asha's CD is about that far but do they hold heart clinics? I wonder if there is enough interest in your area to host a heart clinic?

I'll look for my receipts of typical echo costs I've paid. I've done them only at heart clinics at dog shows for 3 years now. I borrow my breeder's holter and send the results to alba for $60?, then upload both of those results to OFA. I'll likely be investing in our own holter monitor soon, as I have my own puppy owners to lend it out to.
 
If anyone wants to, I would love the "explain it to me like I am two years old" version of how the echo and Holter differ in their measurements and prediction/detection of DCM. In my uneducated brain, I figure that "dilated" would mean enlarged, which an echo would pick up really easily, but maybe the Holter has results that I don't know their predictive capability?
@Rits? I've seen you explain it well before.
 
I'll look for my receipts of typical echo costs I've paid. I've done them only at heart clinics at dog shows for 3 years now. I borrow my breeder's holter and send the results to alba for $60?
was a toss-up between informative and like. informative won.
 
If anyone wants to, I would love the "explain it to me like I am two years old" version of how the echo and Holter differ in their measurements and prediction/detection of DCM.
Non-sciency explain is the echo looks at the heart, as you said, and sees it as it's beating and can tell if it's enlarged and see the contractions and expansion and any anomalies. The Holter tracks the heartbeats rhythms and can detect how fast, how slow and if there are skipped beats or extra beats. Think instead of a normal lub-dub it records a" lub___ - ____ -dub" or "lub-dubdub", or no beat at all for two beats worth of time, then continuing as if nothing happened. It's why 24 hours is needed to catch the occasional anomalies.

@Rits, correct me if my quick simple explanation is the right idea.

I know that one show where you got Asha's CD is about that far but do they hold heart clinics? I wonder if there is enough interest in your area to host a heart clinic?
No & no. I find it dis-heartening (no pun intended) all these health clinics you get in the midwest and they have that 5 day cluster with multiple kennel clubs & specialties and no health clinic.
There is a King Charles club in Phoenix that does health clinics and I emailed them to ask about them but they don't do echos, it was some other heart test. I asked one member of the Doberman KC in Tucson and she told me about the cardiologist in Phoenix and said it was about $800.
 
I paid $189 just for the holter a year ago....but it was because I was there for an echo...so I think it was cheaper because I didn't have to pay another office visit fee.
Echos went up $100. here....they are now $600 for first time visit...$400 for returning visit.
Here in SD couty, at SoCalVetthey rent the holter for $500 but return $300 when you bring it back.
They have a traveling cardi scan guy who they schedule on the once a quarter on weekends for I think $175.
 
Non-sciency explain is the echo looks at the heart, as you said, and sees it as it's beating and can tell if it's enlarged and see the contractions and expansion and any anomalies. The Holter tracks the heartbeats rhythms and can detect how fast, how slow and if there are skipped beats or extra beats. Think instead of a normal lub-dub it records a" lub___ - ____ -dub" or "lub-dubdub", or no beat at all for two beats worth of time, then continuing as if nothing happened. It's why 24 hours is needed to catch the occasional anomalies
Thank you for that explanation. But both tests catch indicators of DCM, specifically? Like you definitely want these tests working together, if you can, right?
Here in SD couty, at SoCalVetthey rent the holter for $500 but return $300 when you bring it back.
They have a traveling cardi scan guy who they schedule on the once a quarter on weekends for I think $175.
Good info. Thanks! There is also a traveling echo guy who comes to my local clinic, I should ask more about that and price.
 
There is also a traveling echo guy who comes to my local clinic, I should ask more about that and price.
How far are you from the U of MN?

This is the one who did Elroy but she's only practicing at her own place in Oakdale now, which isn't far from the U.
 
Like you definitely want these tests working together, if you can, right?
I don't think it matters, they are two tests that measure different things. You can have a good Holter and a bad echo or the other way around. If one test is showing problems you'd definitely want to the the other test soon. It seems I read that they are leaning toward reasoning that the the echo showing an enlarged heart is most indicative of true DCM, whereas a Holter with erratic heartbeats that has a normal echo may indicate the sudden death risk. Hypothesis, nothing proven that I know of. It's all a crying shame these dogs have so many health risks. 😢
 

Back
Top