• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Train like you trial quote

Ravenbird

Moderator
$ Forum Donor $
I know that as I've trained without a local club, without a local instructor who fits what I need to work on, etc. etc. - out here in a remote location with few new distractions, that I find how well things work at home and how fast it falls apart at a new location. Every damn time. Specifically a mock trial a few months ago. Then as a hokey thing for Trick Dog just a few days ago, I thought I'd teach Asha to jump over my propped up leg. She goes over a jump with the word "Hup" backward and forward, just point & go. I've been told and I KNOW that dogs don't generalize. ("Hup" in front of a jump means jump over that, but "Hup" anywhere else without a real jump means nothing) But even after 3 years it didn't sink in. Leg propped up, ball for bait, "Hup", and Asha goes under my leg for the ball (held high). Over & over & over. We got a few jumps over, but it still wasn't solid and I didn't use that for Trick Dog. It reminded me how much I forget to remember about training. What they know at home, doesn't always mean anything to them anywhere else. Without lots and lots of practice, and even then give them yet another environment and back to square one. Then I see this quote from Dave Kroyer and the answer hits home again. Tractor Supply heeling is not like a trial. Period. 💡

"There is no secret. Train like a trial and in the environment like a trial. Train in a ring. With people. Like a trial. In a stadium field. With people . Like a trial. Training means (for me anyway) corrections and rewards. Sometime a lot, sometimes none. Home Depot is not a trial environment. Neither is pet smart. That does not help you as much as you think." Dave Kroyer
 
Unfortunately, not everyone has access to train like a trial in a ring. So you do the next best thing. Proof in as many settings as humanly possible hoping it helps bridge the gap somewhat. It won't be the same, no. But better than staying in the house or your backyard. I'm envious of people that have access to rings to train in.

On the flip side, trial like you train! If you smile and are fun at home, why not smile in the ring? Dog will pick up on that. When you call your dog to come in the ring, at home you make eye contact, in the ring maybe you are watching the judge. Dog will pick up on that.
 
Unfortunately, not everyone has access to train like a trial in a ring. So you do the next best thing. Proof in as many settings as humanly possible hoping it helps bridge the gap somewhat. It won't be the same, no. But better than staying in the house or your backyard. I'm envious of people that have access to rings to train in.
I totally agree. I'm crying and bemoaning how things can be so good, then travel for hours and get the completely untrained dog. Things that I know would not happen if I could visit the club weekly or even twice a week like the other dedicate people do. Or AKC obedience, have a class that has the rings, the white fence, the dogs, the weekly practice, different strangers to touch the dog, other activities and dog stuff going on. Shows or events or matches that I could go to one day and be back in my own bed that night. I guess I'm finally admitting defeat for half my goals, because once Asha gets Tractor Supply, TSC is not that hard. But trips to events are so few & far between, it's always new. 😭 And yes, genetics and less than perfect temperament is part of it, so there's that.
 
Ehhh….forgive me but I think you are being too hard on yourself.

Yes, it is most prob very frustrating to have the great success and then travel for hours only to show up and not meet one’s own expectations.

Regardless of that, I think y’all are doing absolutely remarkable with the environment and situation you are in. I am so impressed with what you do with Asha. It takes a shitload of determination, persistence, patience, time and energy to train a hardheaded asshat.

That is one asshat to another.
15B1FED9-1408-4A31-96A9-F236B97F55B4.webp
 
I totally agree. I'm crying and bemoaning how things can be so good, then travel for hours and get the completely untrained dog. Things that I know would not happen if I could visit the club weekly or even twice a week like the other dedicate people do. Or AKC obedience, have a class that has the rings, the white fence, the dogs, the weekly practice, different strangers to touch the dog, other activities and dog stuff going on. Shows or events or matches that I could go to one day and be back in my own bed that night. I guess I'm finally admitting defeat for half my goals, because once Asha gets Tractor Supply, TSC is not that hard. But trips to events are so few & far between, it's always new. 😭 And yes, genetics and less than perfect temperament is part of it, so there's that.
You know I empathize greatly with you here! 99% of the time if you see us at a class or place that has a ring, I've clawed my way to find something like that and then they don't offer it frequently or it ends all together, definitely not weekly LOL. The distance to anything doesn't help either. I do most of our training on my own, a lot of the time I feel lost doing it on my own. I have someone, while they are trying to be helpful, practically tell me all the things I'm ALREADY doing. I'm trying to tell her that nothing, nothing beats having access to a ring/trial setting. I can do all these things to improve ourselves at home, in a busy parking lot, at the park etc. but if I can't do these things in a ring, it won't matter come trial day when it comes to precision. Why would it, its a completely different picture to my dog! Maybe I need to start taking ring gates to random places :wacky: The other challenge, I've tried to garner interest with my "local" dog friends and not many people are interested in obedience. I can't say I blame them, its the "less fun" thing to do with your dog compared to everything else, but this has always been a dream of mine to see through since my 4H days. Hugs to you my friend, wish we were closer to start our own club :rofl:
 
On the flip side, trial like you train! If you smile and are fun at home, why not smile in the ring?
One of the hardest things to instruct owners on is "make your voice the happiest in the building, so your dog responds"! I probably shouldn't say this, but men are the worst when training their dogs. They don't want to sound excited and happy, they just want to be firm all the time. It is true that sometimes you need to be firm when working with your dog, however, when the dog is learning a new behavior they need to hear a happy, excited owner! That happiness in their owner's voice will usually encourage them to do their best! Dogs love to please, and that happiness carries a lot of weight!
 
One of the hardest things to instruct owners on is "make your voice the happiest in the building, so your dog responds"! I probably shouldn't say this, but men are the worst when training their dogs.
That is so true and we're both quiet people but I will talk louder and change my voice when it comes to training; whether it be a happy "good job!" voice or a "knock it off" voice. I get looks from hubby and other people when I work with our dogs so I do a lot of it if I'm by myself.
out here in a remote location with few new distractions, that I find how well things work at home and how fast it falls apart at a new location.
Same here. Our local club that is a few years old will have occasional seminars but no actual regular training. There is one training club about 20 miles from here but they're booked out for years and have a long waiting list. We have a private trainer but some group classes would be nice too.
 
Yes, always train like you are trialing! Especially on a field. This always gives the dog a picture of what a trial will consist of.
 
I relate to this so much ravenbird! Gilly has to do a 5 min down stay without me present off leash for his nsda level 1 and I've literally been stressing over that more than, you know, the actual search work! He can do it at home, our yard, or the same old.parks we always go. But I just need to keep exposing him to new and weird places, and I am not doing great at that. (I just... don't go many places! I am very boring!). Wish we were closer!!! ❤️
 
One of the hardest things to instruct owners on is "make your voice the happiest in the building, so your dog responds"! I probably shouldn't say this, but men are the worst when training their dogs. They don't want to sound excited and happy, they just want to be firm all the time. It is true that sometimes you need to be firm when working with your dog, however, when the dog is learning a new behavior they need to hear a happy, excited owner! That happiness in their owner's voice will usually encourage them to do their best! Dogs love to please, and that happiness carries a lot of weight!

There's some truth to this. I learned dog training from a K9 cop / former USMC Vietnam dog handler. My first dog was very responsive to the type of training I learned. To be fair to myself, it was also the type of training my parents used on me, so I saw nothing wrong with it. My second dog melted down and I had to find a different way of training. I'm one of the few men in my obedience class and my teacher periodically tells the class to be upbeat and to praise our dogs when they're doing good.
 
I relate to this so much ravenbird! Gilly has to do a 5 min down stay without me present off leash for his nsda level 1 and I've literally been stressing over that more than, you know, the actual search work! He can do it at home, our yard, or the same old.parks we always go. But I just need to keep exposing him to new and weird places, and I am not doing great at that. (I just... don't go many places! I am very boring!). Wish we were closer!!! ❤️
We'd have a ton of fun if you were around here, that's for sure!

Gilly will be fine, I just know! Hope you post when you get his nada 1 - with all the stories & pictures to go with!
 
"make your voice the happiest in the building, so your dog responds"
I truly do believe this and it's great advice. It gets crazy though because if I get really happy with a training exercise Asha goes nuts and jumps and spins and can get wild in about 2 seconds. So I try to praise quietly so she doesn't have to be reset with a "no". For the first year or two of training, quiet praise meant nothing, she was almost irritated by it. She finally gets it now, that long quiet strokes are the equivalent of "good job" without a party. I save the party for when we are "all done" or "no mas" or if it's a ring situation, when I'm out of the ring or training area. Again, no instructor to correct me when I did this (party for great training exercise) and I didn't learn to tone it down until it became a bad habit.
 
I'd like to add to this thread that we own one of the most expressive breeds there is. They have ears and tails that tell us what's going on in their heads so we can adjust what we're doing accordingly.

My dog's tail stands straight up when he's happy and motivated. It's tucked down when he's confused or not happy.

His ears are straight up when he's working good. They start lowering when things start going sideways - the lower, the worse things are getting. That's when motivation of some sort is needed, such as happy talk or a play break. Sometimes just one ear will be the expressive one, kind of like Spock raising an eyebrow.

If you're new to training, learn to read your dog because he won't make it a secret. His language is there to read.

Below is AJ with his ears cocked to listen to my movements and commands. Note that they're not flat, but cocked back.

121722_AKC_45039.webp
 

Back
Top