• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

11 month puppy super reactive to cars very suspicious of strangers

Josette

New Member
We had a Doberman before. We got her when she was an adult and she was pretty chill right from the beginning. I also grew up with Dobermans in our family but I don't remember any specifics about their training. A year after our sweet Stella passed away from DCM (she was 11 1\2, we had her 10 years) we got a Doberman puppy. Daisy's temperament is nothing like our easygoing Stella. In fact, reading through some of these threads, I think she might be kin to @Ravenbird's Asha 🤣 Our Stella was very protective but she took her cues from us. When we greeted someone warmly and clearly trusted them, she relaxed. Daisy is super suspicious of everyone. Thankfully, when she was young, I took her with me when I kept my young grandchildren 3 days per week, because she is fine(neutral) with them. Any person that comes in our house she acts like she wants to eat them. We did not have people over or take her out as much as I wish we could have when she was at the age that I've ready is really important for socialization. I'm hoping we haven't missed the boat on that and that she will improve with age and training. We tried different advice, and what has worked best when someone comes in our home is for the person to completely ignore her until she initiates or some time has passed and she is less attentive to them. Even then, if they suddenly stand or come from another room she is on high alert again. She is also suspicious of strangers when I walk her in our neighborhood or any other environment we have taken her to. Not everyone though feels comfortable to come in with her barking at them and semi-lunging with hair standing up on her neck.

She is also very reactive to cars. She is super anxious about them and acts like she want to run to or chase them. I got a prong collar and that is the only thing keeping her from dragging her and me both into into the street. I can control her ability to run to them because of it but she is still barking and acting a fool. I take her for walks on our street and we go to the end of the street where traffic crosses and stand back a ways and work on her being less reactive. When she doesn't react she immediately turns to me for a treat knowing she did what I want. She has a long way to go but has made some progress. But heaven forbid if a car comes down our street while we are walking. When I hear a car from a distance, I move into the nearest yard a few feet off the street and get her to sit. She can never remain calm when the car is on our street though. She pulls and carries on and then yelps when the prong collar is pinching her. I realize the cars are just too close for her anxiety but I can't control the distance when the car is coming down our street. I told my husband I think we need to sit in the front yard in our chairs far enough back for her not to flip out and just watch cars go by.

Daisy didn't come from an established breeder. The people we got her from wanted to breed their male dog to keep a puppy because the male had belonged to their deceased son. Daisy is 1/2 European and 1/2 American. I'm really wondering if some of what we're dealing with is partly genetics. She's gotten some better after doing some basic obedience training, but is very stubborn (so much more than our Stella ever was). She's just 11 months old and since we've never gone through this stage before with our previous Dobie I don't know if some of this is something she will mature out of or if this is in great part, her temperament.

I welcome any suggestions from anyone who has dealt with similar issues.
Having said all that, I love this crazy dog as much as anyone can love a dog. She is such a sweet and loving velcro dog as well as a psycho 🤣
 
I'm really wondering if some of what we're dealing with is partly genetics.
Yes

I don't know if some of this is something she will mature out of
Yes, to a point

I told my husband I think we need to sit in the front yard in our chairs far enough back for her not to flip out and just watch cars go by.
A good place to start!

I love this crazy dog as much as anyone can love a dog.
Yup, I get it!

Welcome to Doberman Chat. Sounds like you're doing lots of things right. Reactivity is just that - reacting to a stimulus without thinking. Becoming neutral is the goal, looking to you for fun, food & confidence is the biggest goal. I think if you can control her from a chair in your yard as cars go by that's an excellent idea. Does she like to tug? Does she have hunt drive? I'm assuming your front yard is not fenced, so safety would be #1, so with the pinch collar on and a sturdy 6' leash, take some kibble (or treats if she is not highly food motivated). Sit and toss one piece in the grass, let her find & eat it, return to you and look at you for another. (this is key - she knows you have the food & wants YOU to act) Repeat repeat repeat. Best if she has to hunt a little for it. As soon as you know a car is coming do this quickly one after another, or a scatter of 10 pieces so she wants to go find them all without looking up. If food is not her thing, or if you want to do different things, try a tug game. Again, she needs to look to YOU for a fun thing. I suggest the activities because being still watching a car go by may be too stimulating for her to stay calm, but then again she might be better in the yard than on a walk, I don't know. So many variables, and it depends on the dog. The idea is that she will have to choose between having fun and interacting with you to dropping your game and lunging toward the passing car. (Choosing self-rewarding behavior over interaction with you) When you become the most important thing, every kind of training will be easier.

Use leash pops if you don't have her attention. I will say and admit right here, my biggest mistake was knowing how hard my dog was and still not correcting strong enough. I preach it a lot, some of these Dobermans are not the ones we remember from years past. A good instructor is valuable if you can find one that understands a strong reactive working type dog.

Hope this helps. Do post some pictures of your new girl and let us know about your progress.
 
I need to add that PREVENTING any barking and lunging at the car is the biggest goal. This is a self-rewarding behavior so it's important to not let the first bark or lunge happen. The car is like the "mail man". Comes to the door, dog barks, mail man leaves, over & over & over the dog thinks it was controlling the situation. Car comes by, dog barks, car leaves. Same thing, the dog believes the behavior is controlling the action. Preventing the action is key to the dog learning that she is NOT controlling the car at all.

Curious too, same reaction to a car coming toward you on the walk as a car coming from behind?
 
I need to add that PREVENTING any barking and lunging at the car is the biggest goal. This is a self-rewarding behavior so it's important to not let the first bark or lunge happen. The car is like the "mail man". Comes to the door, dog barks, mail man leaves, over & over & over the dog thinks it was controlling the situation. Car comes by, dog barks, car leaves. Same thing, the dog believes the behavior is controlling the action. Preventing the action is key to the dog learning that she is NOT controlling the car at all.

Curious too, same reaction to a car coming toward you on the walk as a car coming from behind?
I had not considered that when she barked and lunged she felt she was controlling the situation. That’s helpful to think about.

Yes, she reacts the same no matter what direction the car comes from. My husband happened to leave the house coming toward us while I was out walking Daisy yesterday and she barked and lunged until he stopped the car and spoke and then she ran over tail wagging. She rides in our car nicely (other than barking and growling at people she sees in cars beside us or walking by stopped) and she doesn’t react in any way when we walk by our cars, just when they’re moving.

She has improved in that she can now tolerate (anxious but not reacting) about 7 -8 out of 10 cars passing on the cross street. You can tell it’s hard for her but she can do that now when it used to be reacting every time. She’s practically vibrating she’s so anxious. She will immediately turn to me for her reward. In the house when I give her peanut butter on my finger, I’ll put my whole finger in her mouth and she’s gentle, backs off immediately if she presses too hard…when we’re watching cars she sometimes pinches my palm with her teeth because she’s so anxious and trying to be so fast about it to get back on watch.

I’m giving to try to figure out how to share a picture.
 
We had a Doberman before. We got her when she was an adult and she was pretty chill right from the beginning. I also grew up with Dobermans in our family but I don't remember any specifics about their training. A year after our sweet Stella passed away from DCM (she was 11 1\2, we had her 10 years) we got a Doberman puppy. Daisy's temperament is nothing like our easygoing Stella. In fact, reading through some of these threads, I think she might be kin to @Ravenbird's Asha 🤣 Our Stella was very protective but she took her cues from us. When we greeted someone warmly and clearly trusted them, she relaxed. Daisy is super suspicious of everyone. Thankfully, when she was young, I took her with me when I kept my young grandchildren 3 days per week, because she is fine(neutral) with them. Any person that comes in our house she acts like she wants to eat them. We did not have people over or take her out as much as I wish we could have when she was at the age that I've ready is really important for socialization. I'm hoping we haven't missed the boat on that and that she will improve with age and training. We tried different advice, and what has worked best when someone comes in our home is for the person to completely ignore her until she initiates or some time has passed and she is less attentive to them. Even then, if they suddenly stand or come from another room she is on high alert again. She is also suspicious of strangers when I walk her in our neighborhood or any other environment we have taken her to. Not everyone though feels comfortable to come in with her barking at them and semi-lunging with hair standing up on her neck.

She is also very reactive to cars. She is super anxious about them and acts like she want to run to or chase them. I got a prong collar and that is the only thing keeping her from dragging her and me both into into the street. I can control her ability to run to them because of it but she is still barking and acting a fool. I take her for walks on our street and we go to the end of the street where traffic crosses and stand back a ways and work on her being less reactive. When she doesn't react she immediately turns to me for a treat knowing she did what I want. She has a long way to go but has made some progress. But heaven forbid if a car comes down our street while we are walking. When I hear a car from a distance, I move into the nearest yard a few feet off the street and get her to sit. She can never remain calm when the car is on our street though. She pulls and carries on and then yelps when the prong collar is pinching her. I realize the cars are just too close for her anxiety but I can't control the distance when the car is coming down our street. I told my husband I think we need to sit in the front yard in our chairs far enough back for her not to flip out and just watch cars go by.

Daisy didn't come from an established breeder. The people we got her from wanted to breed their male dog to keep a puppy because the male had belonged to their deceased son. Daisy is 1/2 European and 1/2 American. I'm really wondering if some of what we're dealing with is partly genetics. She's gotten some better after doing some basic obedience training, but is very stubborn (so much more than our Stella ever was). She's just 11 months old and since we've never gone through this stage before with our previous Dobie I don't know if some of this is something she will mature out of or if this is in great part, her temperament.

I welcome any suggestions from anyone who has dealt with similar issues.
Having said all that, I love this crazy dog as much as anyone can love a dog. She is such a sweet and loving velcro dog as well as a psycho 🤣
 
When she was younger we always said she had crazy eyes (compared to Stella anyway, whose eyes always had such a sweet look in them). We don’t see the crazy eyes as much now that she’s a little older but you can kind of see them here. I think it’s partly the coloring that makes them look that way. Here she is with all her sticks. We just got rid of our firewood we weren’t using because as soon as we would restack it she would carry it around the yard and it always looks such a mess, logs everywhere 🤪
BF16EA63-EB03-44E0-B1A7-4BCDE8662582.webp
 
She is such a sweet and loving velcro dog as well as a psycho 🤣
I couldn't agree more! Psycho is THE word 😜 Yes, the eyes do look a bit crazy, haha, they are full of intensity especially when they want something, which is always lol. The alertness and energy also radiates from the eyes and I think that contributes to the crazy vibe.
She's just 11 months old and since we've never gone through this stage before with our previous Dobie I don't know if some of this is something she will mature out of or if this is in great part, her temperament.
Raising a Doberman puppy to adulthood is really hard work, omg, just thinking about that stage used to make my blood pressure go up LOL. But they do grow out of it with training and exposure. We have a male and they definitely seem to mature late, but it does seem to me that females mature a lot faster, so you may get lucky yet.

I suggest the activities because being still watching a car go by may be too stimulating for her to stay calm
The activities are really important. If you have something fun going on, the dog is more likely to stay focused on your situation rather than investigate the environment which is more than half the battle with these dogs lol.
I preach it a lot, some of these Dobermans are not the ones we remember from years past.
This is such a great point for people who experienced the breed a longer time ago. Reading all the comparisons, the breed sure seems to have changed a lot from the olden days. Does yours whine lol? Does she have a favorite blanket to suck on?
 
She doesn’t whine a lot. In just the last few weeks though she has started to act differently about a particular squeeze, squeaky soft rubbery toy. That first day that I noticed it she was whining or whimpering some and I was concerned that she was in pain, thinking she had eaten something I hadn’t seen ( she is constantly after feminine hygiene products, paper towels that have touched food, and anything she can grab from the trash). Later in the day and in the next couple of days I noticed she only made that sound when she was carrying or laying with that toy, like it was a baby. She has slacked off of it, which I’m glad, I was afraid it would become an obsession to be worried about. She had torn up some toys but LOVES rubbery squeakers and doesn’t tear them up. She doesn’t suck a blanket but I think it’s so cute when they do I almost wish she did. Funny story, when she was a young puppy she was terrified if I tried to cover her with a blanket. She would jump up and run. Our other Dobe had loved to be covered up. Anyway, gradually when she would snuggle with me I started covering up just her feet, then working my way up and she loves to be under a blanket with me now. I’m hoping we can achieve similar desensitization with some of her other issues 😅. On our bed she tries to dig to china to get under the covers, but although she has a blanket on top of her dog bed in her kennel (she stays in her kennel when we leave the house and at night) she doesn’t cover up when in the kennel.

I have joked that it’s a full time job keeping her alive. She is so much better as she gets older, she has never torn up anything of ours, but it’s still a struggle for her not to eat from the trash. It has a foot pedal to open and has a TINY hole you can use to lift the lid and she can quickly and easily stick her big brown nose in there. If we have chicken bones etc we have to immediately take out the trash. If anyone has a super stubborn dog they won’t think this cruel (others who haven’t had this experience might) , but I keep a Nerf gun in the kitchen and when she gets in the trash I let her see it. It stings (has plastic not soft tips) and she respects it. Otherwise, it doesn’t matter how many times I tell her no or push her away she would come right back. It’s like she says “ Dang it!” When I get that out and she goes on about her business. I hope one day we won’t require it, but she is sometimes just very determined 😅
 
Later in the day and in the next couple of days I noticed she only made that sound when she was carrying or laying with that toy, like it was a baby.
I wonder if she was going through a false pregnancy, which a lot of females do after a heat and sometimes out of the blue.
 
Last edited:
I wonder if she was going through a false pregnancy, which a lot of females do after a heat and sometimes out of the blue.
I googled when she was acting that way and saw that as an option. It wasn't that recent that she was in heat. She got a new toy a few days ago and alternates which she carries around but hasn't been whimpering or whining anymore and not acting frantic when she doesn't have it so I'm hoping it's nothing to worry about.
 
It wasn't that recent that she was in heat.
The "toy obsession" from false pregnancy is usually about 2 months after their heat ends. Their hormones will do the same rise & fall as if they've been bred, just to a much lesser extent. Sometimes no symptoms, sometimes just slightly, and sometimes full blown with milk in their teats and trying to push the toy to nurse or defending it. I actually removed all toys for that reason and it totally made a difference in me being looked to for fun. I bring out the toy, we play together with tug or ball or I use them for rewards in training, then I put them away. With you wanting to improve Daisys attention on you for behavioral & training reasons, I recommend it.

My husband happened to leave the house coming toward us while I was out walking Daisy yesterday and she barked and lunged until he stopped the car and spoke
Yup. Asha has barked at my housemate when she comes home from town. That's what I mean reactive - not even thinking or recognizing the person or car. Just yesterday we were out on the property and J came up the path to see the work I was doing and Asha goes off barking at her. She stopped after one big bouncing "woo wooo wooo", but still. It's crazy.
 
she has never torn up anything of ours, but it’s still a struggle for her not to eat from the trash. It has a foot pedal to open and has a TINY hole you can use to lift the lid and she can quickly and easily stick her big brown nose in there. If we have chicken bones etc we have to immediately take out the trash. If anyone has a super stubborn dog they won’t think this cruel (others who haven’t had this experience might) , but I keep a Nerf gun in the kitchen and when she gets in the trash I let her see it. It stings (has plastic not soft tips) and she respects it. Otherwise, it doesn’t matter how many times I tell her no or push her away she would come right back
I would do one of two things. A new trash can that is impossible to get into or put it in a cabinet or pantry, or, e-collar. Again, you have a self-rewarding behavior that can be stopped totally by you. Prevention, where she cannot self-reward or discouragement where the reward is not worth the risk. Otherwise the intermittent reward always wins. "I've gotten food out of there before, so I just have to try one more time". The problem with the Nerf is that it is after the fact and to prevent a behavior it needs to be stopped before it happens.
 
The "toy obsession" from false pregnancy is usually about 2 months after their heat ends. Their hormones will do the same rise & fall as if they've been bred, just to a much lesser extent. Sometimes no symptoms, sometimes just slightly, and sometimes full blown with milk in their teats and trying to push the toy to nurse or defending it. I actually removed all toys for that reason and it totally made a difference in me being looked to for fun. I bring out the toy, we play together with tug or ball or I use them for rewards in training, then I put them away. With you wanting to improve Daisys attention on you for behavioral & training reasons, I recommend it.


Yup. Asha has barked at my housemate when she comes home from town. That's what I mean reactive - not even thinking or recognizing the person or car. Just yesterday we were out on the property and J came up the path to see the work I was doing and Asha goes off barking at her. She stopped after one big bouncing "woo wooo wooo", but still. It's crazy.
That is about the right timing then to be false pregnancy! That's crazy! The article wasn't very detailed and I didn't think to check further. I didn't realize the hormones would continue to rise and fall. I assumed when it was over it was over. I don't know why it didn't occur to me thinking about how humans cycle. She isn't doing those behaviors now but I will watch for them and instead of letting her keep her toy all the time for comfort remove it for a bit. We plan to spay her (I don't think all her genes are ones we want to pass on 🤣) but we want to let her finish growing.

Daisy barked once when my husband came in a room with a different hat on. It was so sudden and loud it scared him. When he spoke she was sorry. She doesn't seem quite as hyper vigilant about such as that in more recent months, thankfully.
 
I would do one of two things. A new trash can that is impossible to get into or put it in a cabinet or pantry, or, e-collar. Again, you have a self-rewarding behavior that can be stopped totally by you. Prevention, where she cannot self-reward or discouragement where the reward is not worth the risk. Otherwise the intermittent reward always wins. "I've gotten food out of there before, so I just have to try one more time". The problem with the Nerf is that it is after the fact and to prevent a behavior it needs to be stopped before it happens.
I don't know that a kitchen trash can exists that she couldn't get into. I don't have a convenient place I could put it to make it impossible for her to get to. I'm going to be thinking on how I might could work this out. I have wondered if an e-collar is something we need to consider I'm just a little scared of it, for one. I didn't think I would consider a prong collar either (just based on how they look) but it has been the best thing for us for sure. She was physically hurting me before in her excitement, pulling and lunging. Do you think with the fear/ anxiety she has it wouldn't cause her to fear me or have any other negative anxiety from it? I don't have anyone I know who has first hand knowledge and reading online has just been confusing. Right now, when we leave the house she is in a crate but we hope she can be free in the house when she is older. Will she still not get in the trash when we aren't home if we use the e-collar? Our previous Dobie would never attempt the trash when we were home but if we forgot to move the can to on top of the washing machine, and there was tempting food in the trash, we would come home to a mess.
 
Absolutely gorgeous dog! Working lines? Are you going to do any sports with her?
Thank you so much! I know I'm super partial, but I tell her everyday how beautiful she is, as though she understands me 🤣

I don't really even know what the options are or what might suit her. And $ is potentially a factor. Where is a good place to look for more information? She does NOT like water. At least not yet. Our other Dobie never did either.
 
I googled when she was acting that way and saw that as an option. It wasn't that recent that she was in heat. She got a new toy a few days ago and alternates which she carries around but hasn't been whimpering or whining anymore and not acting frantic when she doesn't have it so I'm hoping it's nothing
I wonder if she was going through a false pregnancy, which a lot of females do after a heat and sometimes out of the blue.
I didn't realize it could likely happen that far out from her heat until @Ravenbird clarified. I think you're probably right about that is what was going on. I am learning so much from this group! And I really appreciate it.
 
I couldn't agree more! Psycho is THE word 😜 Yes, the eyes do look a bit crazy, haha, they are full of intensity especially when they want something, which is always lol. The alertness and energy also radiates from the eyes and I think that contributes to the crazy vibe.

Raising a Doberman puppy to adulthood is really hard work, omg, just thinking about that stage used to make my blood pressure go up LOL. But they do grow out of it with training and exposure. We have a male and they definitely seem to mature late, but it does seem to me that females mature a lot faster, so you may get lucky yet.


The activities are really important. If you have something fun going on, the dog is more likely to stay focused on your situation rather than investigate the environment which is more than half the battle with these dogs lol.

This is such a great point for people who experienced the breed a longer time ago. Reading all the comparisons, the breed sure seems to have changed a lot from the olden days. Does yours whine lol? Does she have a favorite blanket to suck on?
So, I only learned today how to reply to a quote so that the reply goes to the right person and makes sense.

YES! So much intensity in the eyes! I do see more and more often the softness I remember from my Stella ❤

It is so much work! I thought I was prepared. And I even prepared mentally for some puppy stubbornness. But Daisy exceeded all my expectations 🤣

We had a good walk today! Only 1 barking reaction and it was quite mild. Was neutral to 10 plus cars at a distance and thankfully no one came down our street. She saw a dog from a distance and easily went the other way AND I spoke to a neighbor a good distance away and she had no reaction. That is a major plus. I think my walks have been very inconsistent for a variety of legitimate reasons but if I can manage to do it almost daily I hope I will continue to see more consistent progress. She has stitches in her leg and isn't allowed to run (2 more days!) and it has kind of forced me to walk her more instead of just letting her run in the back yard.

Funny story...the vet told me how I could take her stitches out so for Diasy's sake and his I wouldn't have to bring her back.
 
Do you think with the fear/ anxiety she has it wouldn't cause her to fear me or have any other negative anxiety from it? I don't have anyone I know who has first hand knowledge and reading online has just been confusing. Right now, when we leave the house she is in a crate but we hope she can be free in the house when she is older. Will she still not get in the trash when we aren't home if we use the e-collar?
e-collar training is not terribly complicated and is not a tool that brings on any anxiety if used correctly. Basically it allows you to communicate with your dog at a distance. One most important issue, if you decide to get one is do NOT get a cheap one! A good one will be over $100 and have at least 100 settings on it. Cheap ones usually only have 5 - 10 settings. This becomes a problem if 4 isn't felt at all and 5 makes them yelp. With 100, you can different settings useful for different occasions. For me it was the only option when we started traveling as Asha would do explosive barks in the motel room every time she heard a voice or a car door slam ALL night long. She learned that this was absolutely unacceptable and the last few times we traveled she was able to sleep naked. A few grumbles but no explosive barking. Because her barking is reactive and not much thinking behind it, I can't seem to prevent it 100%, but she KNOWS that if she does this at a motel, the price is higher than the pleasure of barking and she has made the decision to not do it.

I didn't realize the hormones would continue to rise and fall. I assumed when it was over it was over. I don't know why it didn't occur to me thinking about how humans cycle.
I never knew either, this is the first intact bitch I've had. You are wise not to spay until 2 years old or older. I was totally fascinated by the cycling between heats and sure enough at about a week before "puppies" would be whelped and then for another couple of weeks, Asha is nesting and nesting and nesting some more, sleeps longer, and looks at her crate a lot - like thinking something is missing?
 

Back
Top