Part of an email I received from Dr. Becker.
FDA sheepishly admits: DCM and grain free pet food? No link.
Oops. Mistake, all mine/ours |
Susan Thixton points out that the FDA very stealthily admitted recently that they cannot pin the rash of heart disease in dogs on “grain free” (or “designer”) foods after trying for years to prove the connection.
You may recall the brouhaha that arose a few years back…
DCM (dilated cardiomyopathy, the commonest form of heart disease in dogs) was all over the news, in part thanks to the FDA’s inflammatory press release in July 2018:
We are concerned about reports of canine heart disease, known as dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM), in dogs that ate certain pet foods containing peas, lentils, other legumes or potatoes as their main ingredients. These reports are highly unusual as they are occurring in breeds not typically genetically prone to the disease,” said Martine Hartogensis, D.V.M., deputy director of the FDA’s Center for Veterinary Medicine’s Office of Surveillance and Compliance. “The FDA is investigating the potential link between DCM and these foods. We encourage pet owners and veterinarians to report DCM cases in dogs who are not predisposed to the disease.”
The public was urged to report any cases of DCM along with diet history to the agency.
Several brands were called out as potentially dangerous foods in association with these allegations, as yet unproven. I've heard some went out of business because of being tarred with this assumptive brush.
For a fun, if a bit technical look at the (non-) issue from a board certified animal nutritionist, you might enjoy Ryan Yamka, PhD, saying “
DCM and grain-free pet foods: 3 strikes and you’re out!”
So, it appears the FDA really couldn’t make the case for grain free foods causing DCM, but if there’s a simple take away for me, it’s this:
The further we stray in feeding dogs from what their wild ancestors and current cousins eat, the more likely we are to see problems.
Wolves, coyotes: again, DCM is likely unheard of in these guys.
What do they eat?
Prey, mostly.
Not peas, nor potatoes, nor kibble of any kind, let alone “grain free” or other fad foods.
While DCM has genetic roots in some dog breeds, it’s also one of the many man-made diseases that happen when we let “science” make dietary choices for us instead of following Mom Nature’s simple guidance:
Feed them like their ancestors and wild cousins would eat.
You don’t need 57 ingredients (found in one of the foods studied above) to feed your dog.
But neither is meat alone something a wolf would eat, right?
Find that happy middle ground and you can safely stop worrying about what commercial diets might do to your pet.