good temperament?

lovedobe

Notable member
What's a good/ bad temperament for a Doberman?

A friend's Doberman doesn't let anyone in the house and very violent even to some family members plays very rough and bites (no serious bite history) ... to me that dog doesn't have a good temperament while my friend says Niko (3.5 Dobermans ) is a good and protective dog... What do you thing ?
 
Doberman doesn't let anyone in the house and very violent even to some family members plays very rough and bites (no serious bite history
I totally agree with @JanS but I'm wondering, have you seen this dog in action, or are you just listening to your friends description? What is "very violent" and bites, but "no serious bite history"? It would be one or the other. Also, temperament is born, not trained. Dobermans can have very soft, easy going temperaments and be spoiled or have no boundaries in the house and they'll end up growling or biting or resource guarding their food or the bed or whatever. They can be born with a very sharp temperament and be well trained to down-stay while a guest comes over and has dinner with the owners.

Your description of this dog sounds like a nightmare to live with, also sounds like the owner likes him just how he is, but this is training or lack of training rather than temperament.
 
I totally agree with @JanS but I'm wondering, have you seen this dog in action, or are you just listening to your friends description? What is "very violent" and bites, but "no serious bite history"? It would be one or the other. Also, temperament is born, not trained. Dobermans can have very soft, easy going temperaments and be spoiled or have no boundaries in the house and they'll end up growling or biting or resource guarding their food or the bed or whatever. They can be born with a very sharp temperament and be well trained to down-stay while a guest comes over and has dinner with the owners.

Your description of this dog sounds like a nightmare to live with, also sounds like the owner likes him just how he is, but this is training or lack of training rather than temperament.
Yes I want to learn more about the doberman temperament that was a real life example i have seen!


By no serious bite history i mean Niko has never broke the skin but sees people as a chew toy!
He keeps jumping on people in the beginnings it is so cute and fun but after 10 mins it gets so annoying that u wanna leave the house! The owner my friend of course very biased doesnt even lock him up in a room or somewhere.


So my exact question is, it that a temperment a dog born with ? Or as u mentioned lack of training? Or a little bit of both?? There second Doberman in the same household is so sweet and never bothers anyone! So i just wanna understand why the hell 2 dogs at the same household act to different? I am sure they got the same amount of traning and they are very close in age!
 
By no serious bite history i mean Niko has never broke the skin but sees people as a chew toy!
He keeps jumping on people in the beginnings it is so cute and fun but after 10 mins it gets so annoying that u wanna leave the house!
That is 100% lack of training. And rude to guests.

So my exact question is, it that a temperment a dog born with ? Or as u mentioned lack of training? Or a little bit of both??
I'd say both. Some Dobes have much higher drive and energy levels and you have to train them accordingly. I wouldn't call it a bad temperament, just higher drive than his other dog. You can see the same thing in human families - they have 2 kids and one is quiet and polite and the other is loud and demanding, both raised under the same roof, but they will always have their own personalities. Loud & demanding needs a little more structured training on how to behave.
 
Agree that your friends one dobe is doing whatever he pleases, and the owners are fine with that....in my opinion, that could end up being a very dangerous situation...dobermans need limitations, and be told what to do. That jumping up and biting is something you would experience if you were to get a dobe pup, but it needs to be corrected, consistently, then they don't become an adult with no manners.
 
I'm now going back over this thread. Excellent answers above, so there you go!

I would just say that the description of very violent threw me, and I didn't square it with the other statement that the dog does not break the skin. What strikes me now is that that is probably how my boy Oji would be if I had not worked hard on his training from the start.

Oji, to this day, still will not fully comply with my commands to not put his paws on houseguests. Yes, I could keep him on a place command or even a stay, and I often do for a period of time at the beginning of the visit, but most people want to interact with my Dobe. Worse, some people think it's mean, or even cruel :rolleyes: to make the dog be away from them. So, when the time comes to let Oji greet the guests, I am standing right there and commanding him to not put his paws up. (Pawing at the person is the toned down version of jumping up on them, which would be the toned down version of jumping up on them and biting at them).

My wife's parents have gotten to the point of just accepting, unspoken, that Oji will be put away in his crate while they visit. I guess some people, when they get older, start to have skin that scratches easily; and my wife's dad received enough scratches over time from Oji's paw swipes.

I do know that Oji will break the skin with biting if allowed. There was a big, burly guy who worked at a local brewery taproom and he invited me to let Oji just get hyper and rough with him. This escalated to Oji biting the guy's forearm repeatedly (obviously not that hard, as it was all in play) but blood was drawn in several spots. The guy had this inane notion that all you had to do to defend against a biting dog was shove your arm forward into its mouth. Um, okay.

Anyway. Oji has a good temperament, and is not a "bad" dog. He is just very high energy and is very excited by people who he does not live with. He can't control himself or be controlled fully if given the freedom to meet the people. Now, if Oji acted anywhere close to this badly with his family members (my wife and kids) it would be, well, that would just not happen. No way. When they come back from a trip, he still may elevate onto his hind legs and get face to face with the person, but 99% of the time, he holds his paws back and does not let the paws make contact.

So yeah. Training.
 
That behavior is unacceptable but before the dog gets more/better training the owner should... not meant to be disrespectful but real.
 

Back
Top