When your puppy doesn't seem to like a family member

CrisK

Jr Member
Last December I posted about my 5 month old puppy thinking my daughter was a toy. (My 5 month old thinks my daughter is a toy)

Time has passed, Gypsy just turned 7 months yesterday, lots of training has happened, and lots of learning on our end as well. I started to pay attention at Gypsy's body language around my daughter. I am starting to think she has some sort of discomfort or fear of my daughter. When I get close to her, I am greeted with play bows, licks and a wagging tail. When my daughter gets close she looks away, or turns around to go in the other direction.

I taught my daughter about body language and that she should respect Gypsy's space. This morning was testament that something other than wanting to play hard with my daughter is at play here.

My daughter went into her pen area to give her a pet. As soon as my daughter touched her chin, Gypsy turned around and walked away from her. I told my daughter to pay attention to that and just leave the pen. She didn't. Gypsy turned around, lunged and nipped at her pants. I was right there and was able to prevent something more serious.

To me, it looks like there is something about my daughter that makes Gypsy uncomfortable to the point that she needs to react - to her benefit this time, she was telling my D. she didn't want to interact with her at that time but my daughter disrespected her space.

In other occasions she wants to play with my daughter, she brings her a toy and they play nicely. Other times she will start to stare at my daughter, and suddenly lunge without warning to nip her. It's a very odd situation. The lunging without warning has been getting fewer and far between and we are always vigilant. The moment a stare begins, we try to distract her. If that doesn't work she is removed into the other room.

Has anyone here been able to resolve a situation like this? We have been working with my daughter and gypsy together. My daughter has been helping with the training, we play games that stimulate her mind, my daughter plays fetch with her ( usually behind a barrier just to be safe). It's odd.

We are hopeful things will turn around. Thank you for your help!
 
I am starting to think she has some sort of discomfort or fear of my daughter. When I get close to her, I am greeted with play bows, licks and a wagging tail. When my daughter gets close she looks away, or turns around to go in the other direction.
Seems like the dog is avoiding her because she knows she will get into trouble over her. This seems like a good thing to me. The dog is consciously choosing to avoid trouble so this means, to me, that the dog understands to leave the child alone.
My daughter went into her pen area to give her a pet. As soon as my daughter touched her chin, Gypsy turned around and walked away from her. I told my daughter to pay attention to that and just leave the pen. She didn't. Gypsy turned around, lunged and nipped at her pants.
This part makes me think it was territorial. As soon as I read that she went into the pen...I held my breath for what came next. The fact that she nipped the pants (and not higher up or anything at eye level) tells me it's another conscious decision the dog is making to avoid getting into trouble, but also wanting to defend her own turf, here, it seems animal instincts kicked in, but the dog was still restrained in her response.

Will be interesting to see how others interpret these interactions. Maybe there has been good progress between the child and dog, but it needs to continue so that the daughter can be more of a consistent leader, maybe it just takes more time? Two months may feel like a lot of time, especially if you're constantly watching for this, it can be exhausting, but I would say to stick with it. The previous thread had tons of great advice which I would stick to through the Doberteen phase.
 
I would very much so encourage your daughter to feed/water Gypsy.

Give special snacks like yogurt or sardines?- daughter.

Gathers the dog food?- daughter.

Let’s Gypsy out of crate?- daughter.

I would initially supervise to make sure Gypsy does not try to dominate and over power her to get what she wants and then, if it looks good, have daughter initiate it without you in room.

Establishing that really good things not only come from you but from daughter.

My wife often gets angry at me because she washes clothes and I always have a pocket full of kibble or treats. Anytime, my two do something good or nice, I give them a treat.- daughter.
 
As soon as I read that she went into the pen...I held my breath for what came next.
I was feeling the same.

I would have your daughter ignore her and not try to engage her in play.
How old is your daughter again?

Also it may be time to let your daughter start preparing Gypsy’s food and be the one to feed her. (Under your supervision) of course.
Gypsy will soon learn she is beneath your daughter in the pack and her behavior won’t be tolerated.
I also would not allow your daughter to ever go into Gypsy’s pen or personal space. Do not allow Gypsy on any furniture either.
There may be a situation you did not notice between your daughter and Gypsy, while Gypsy was going through a fear period. Those impressions stick with them and cause further anxiety until it is resolved through training.
 
I have a 10 yr old son and a 2 yr old dobe. I was having issues with Skynyrd growling at my son. This always happened on the sofa. I got great advice from everyone here on this issue. Everyone said to get Skynyrd off the furniture. No problems ever since!! Really take all the advice you get here and try to apply it. They all know what they are talking about!!!! It should get better with time and following the advice
 
My wife often gets angry at me because she washes clothes and I always have a pocket full of kibble or treats. Anytime, my two do something good or nice, I give them a treat.- daughter.
Yep, this ^^^. I now have a treat bag that has a magnetic closure and has a strap to go around my waist eliminating the need to stuff my pockets with treats. Of course I wear tactical pants a lot so I sometimes forget to check a pocket and find unused poop bags in the washer. Lol
You can’t walk 15’ in my house without finding a stash of biodegradable poop bags. All my vehicles have several rolls in each along with contractor bags for collecting garbage on our hikes.
 
I gotta get those treat "kits" around here too, and maybe get us some better pants with those big side pockets for the entire family.

Last night we had an even worse occurrence in the living room! Daughter was sitting on the couch next to my husband, Gypsy was bringing him a ball, and he would throw it. She came back and dropped the ball on the couch - she was blocked by a table and the only way to get to my daughter was by jumping over my husband. My daughter picked up the ball and Gypsy took but in the action accidentally got my daughter's finger too, nothing really happened it was just a little light nip that didn't even make her finger red. But, my daughter screamed bloody murder. Gypsy immediately jumped over my husband's lap to try to grab my daughter, husband pushed Gypsy off, at this point I was already at my daughter's side checking on her, Gypsy ran around the table to jump at her from the other side (which I had been blocking before). It was a very dramatic scene with myself holding her up in the air, while my daughter is screaming under me (I would put a "shaking my head" emoji here but I don't know how use them on this platform :) ). Husband comes to the rescue, picking up Gypsy and carrying her into the kitchen where her pen is. In the process, Gypsy peed. I think she was just so scared. I felt horribly for both of them. Nobody yelled at her, but I think my daughter's reaction was too much for her.

Today, I am not letting my daughter pet her. Getting into the penned area is no longer an option for her at this time. I am taking a break between them today. Tomorrow we will go back to having my daughter participate in training and games again. I may have her prepare Gypsy's dinner tonight, but not deliver it yet. And Gypsy is willing to work for her, she always has. I think there is some hope there, but until Gypsy feels confident and trusts my daughter we have to be extremely careful.
 
I have a 10 yr old son and a 2 yr old dobe. I was having issues with Skynyrd growling at my son. This always happened on the sofa. I got great advice from everyone here on this issue. Everyone said to get Skynyrd off the furniture. No problems ever since!! Really take all the advice you get here and try to apply it. They all know what they are talking about!!!! It should get better with time and following the advice

We are teaching her to stay off. She jumps on it to try to get something off the side table or when she is trying to get our attention. She jumps off the couch the moment we say "off". I think maybe we need to be harder on this one and give her time out when she jumps on the couch so she understands she should even try. Thank you for the advice! Did you get your dobe as a puppy? Seem like Gypsy and my Daughter are around the same age as are your son and Skynyrd.
 
I gotta get those treat "kits" around here too, and maybe get us some better pants with those big side pockets for the entire family.

Last night we had an even worse occurrence in the living room! Daughter was sitting on the couch next to my husband, Gypsy was bringing him a ball, and he would throw it. She came back and dropped the ball on the couch - she was blocked by a table and the only way to get to my daughter was by jumping over my husband. My daughter picked up the ball and Gypsy took but in the action accidentally got my daughter's finger too, nothing really happened it was just a little light nip that didn't even make her finger red. But, my daughter screamed bloody murder. Gypsy immediately jumped over my husband's lap to try to grab my daughter, husband pushed Gypsy off, at this point I was already at my daughter's side checking on her, Gypsy ran around the table to jump at her from the other side (which I had been blocking before). It was a very dramatic scene with myself holding her up in the air, while my daughter is screaming under me (I would put a "shaking my head" emoji here but I don't know how use them on this platform :) ). Husband comes to the rescue, picking up Gypsy and carrying her into the kitchen where her pen is. In the process, Gypsy peed. I think she was just so scared. I felt horribly for both of them. Nobody yelled at her, but I think my daughter's reaction was too much for her.

Today, I am not letting my daughter pet her. Getting into the penned area is no longer an option for her at this time. I am taking a break between them today. Tomorrow we will go back to having my daughter participate in training and games again. I may have her prepare Gypsy's dinner tonight, but not deliver it yet. And Gypsy is willing to work for her, she always has. I think there is some hope there, but until Gypsy feels confident and trusts my daughter we have to be extremely careful.
Look at the Tactical 5.11 Stryker pants. They are awesome with plenty of pockets. I have been using these for a while now and my old fatigues.
Plenty of pockets inside of pockets and room for ball/rope toys etc.
 
We are teaching her to stay off. She jumps on it to try to get something off the side table or when she is trying to get our attention. She jumps off the couch the moment we say "off". I think maybe we need to be harder on this one and give her time out when she jumps on the couch so she understands she should even try. Thank you for the advice! Did you get your dobe as a puppy? Seem like Gypsy and my Daughter are around the same age as are your son and Skynyrd.
We got Skynyrd when he was 5 month's old. We have had other dogs before so my son knew the basics about how to behave around dogs. Probably within the first month was the first growling incident. It was always when both Skynyrd and Wyatt were on sofa together. The first couple times it happened I didnt see it. Wyatt would say "Skynyrd growled at me" and I was like " what did you do to him?" When I finally saw witnessed it myself I wasnt sure what was going on. Wyatt would just be sitting next to him and it was like out of nowhere Skynyrd would growl. I was afraid to leave them alone together after that. I talked to my dog trainer about it and then when I found this forum i asked for advice. They all said the same thing in regards to no furniture and get Wyatt involved in feeding and training. It has definitely gotten better. It hasnt happened for a few months.
 
I gotta get those treat "kits" around here too, and maybe get us some better pants with those big side pockets for the entire family.

Last night we had an even worse occurrence in the living room! Daughter was sitting on the couch next to my husband, Gypsy was bringing him a ball, and he would throw it. She came back and dropped the ball on the couch - she was blocked by a table and the only way to get to my daughter was by jumping over my husband. My daughter picked up the ball and Gypsy took but in the action accidentally got my daughter's finger too, nothing really happened it was just a little light nip that didn't even make her finger red. But, my daughter screamed bloody murder. Gypsy immediately jumped over my husband's lap to try to grab my daughter, husband pushed Gypsy off, at this point I was already at my daughter's side checking on her, Gypsy ran around the table to jump at her from the other side (which I had been blocking before). It was a very dramatic scene with myself holding her up in the air, while my daughter is screaming under me (I would put a "shaking my head" emoji here but I don't know how use them on this platform :) ). Husband comes to the rescue, picking up Gypsy and carrying her into the kitchen where her pen is. In the process, Gypsy peed. I think she was just so scared. I felt horribly for both of them. Nobody yelled at her, but I think my daughter's reaction was too much for her.

Today, I am not letting my daughter pet her. Getting into the penned area is no longer an option for her at this time. I am taking a break between them today. Tomorrow we will go back to having my daughter participate in training and games again. I may have her prepare Gypsy's dinner tonight, but not deliver it yet. And Gypsy is willing to work for her, she always has. I think there is some hope there, but until Gypsy feels confident and trusts my daughter we have to be extremely careful.
Whenever my son and I are playing around and wrestling or whatever, Skynyrd always goes after him. It is in a playing way but it usually ends with my son being "pinned" down or accidently clawed in the face or something. Once Skynyrd gets going it is hard to calm him. He is just playing but he is rough. I just always watch them when they are playing together or really any interaction. It has definitely gotten better and we hardly ever have anymore incidents.
 
Whenever my son and I are playing around and wrestling or whatever, Skynyrd always goes after him. It is in a playing way but it usually ends with my son being "pinned" down or accidently clawed in the face or something. Once Skynyrd gets going it is hard to calm him. He is just playing but he is rough. I just always watch them when they are playing together or really any interaction. It has definitely gotten better and we hardly ever have anymore incidents.

We got Gypsy at 2 months old. The first month or so she was pretty good around my daughter, just doing the regular nipping which we managed. I wonder if the games my daughter played with her then, resulted in this. My daughter liked to have the small gypsy run after her, she would get on the swing and Gypsy would get super excited and run in and out of her way. I always told her not to do that, but every once in a while she wouldn't listen. Suddenly we noticed Gypsy would just run after her even when she was just standing and nip her hard. I feel like these incidents are happening further and further apart, but the intensity is getting bigger because she's getting bigger fast.

I am very happy with this forum! I have learned tons! And got great advice that I have been using. I have a feeling my trainers don't really know what to do with this issue. I have little confidence they can help. I am still searching for someone who can give me better direction and not look puzzled when I explain what's happening. :) In our case, I don't think Gypsy is just trying to play rough. I think she's trying to bite her, I can't take a chance to find out. There was one time I brought her home and she saw my daughter on the couch. She went towards her and started licking her face, but then I noticed she changed and was going to nip her arm. It's odd.

Thank you for sharing your experience with me! There is always something I learn from these.
 
We got Gypsy at 2 months old. The first month or so she was pretty good around my daughter, just doing the regular nipping which we managed. I wonder if the games my daughter played with her then, resulted in this. My daughter liked to have the small gypsy run after her, she would get on the swing and Gypsy would get super excited and run in and out of her way. I always told her not to do that, but every once in a while she wouldn't listen. Suddenly we noticed Gypsy would just run after her even when she was just standing and nip her hard. I feel like these incidents are happening further and further apart, but the intensity is getting bigger because she's getting bigger fast.

I am very happy with this forum! I have learned tons! And got great advice that I have been using. I have a feeling my trainers don't really know what to do with this issue. I have little confidence they can help. I am still searching for someone who can give me better direction and not look puzzled when I explain what's happening. :) In our case, I don't think Gypsy is just trying to play rough. I think she's trying to bite her, I can't take a chance to find out. There was one time I brought her home and she saw my daughter on the couch. She went towards her and started licking her face, but then I noticed she changed and was going to nip her arm. It's odd.

Thank you for sharing your experience with me! There is always something I learn from these.
I know it's a hard situation and stressful. You always have to be watching and on alert. Hopefully it will get better and the incidents will become less and less. Somebody on here will probably be able to give you some practical advice that you can begin applying throughout the day. Wish I could help more!
 
It sounds a lot to me like a similar situation to what we have in our household with Oji.

It is not that he dislikes our youngest, just turned 2 y.o., daughter. He would love nothing more than to romp with her, but of course that would be very problematic.

Oji, thankfully, despite being unwilling in most areas of obedience does show that he sees me as Alpha in that when he is near our daughters (or even like this morning when my wife was standing there giving him pets and loves) he looks to me with eyes that say "Am I doing anything wrong? Do you approve?"

So, when my younger daughter approaches where he is, he jumps up and moves away from her.

Now, this also gets mixed in with an irritation factor on his part. Often, dogs don't like to move when they are relaxing and occupying a spot. When Oji gets up to move away from daughter, it's with a quick jerk that indicates his displeasure.

Here's the scary thing: On three occasions, Oji has snapped toward her. At least two of these instances have been when he has been laying in a sunbeam in the house (comfortable, prized spot for a dog). One time I thankfully happened to peer around the wall and see this as it unfolded. Our toddler toddled up toward him and he jumped up and I actually saw his jaws go around her tiny forearm but not touch the skin. Needless to say, I was freaked out and angry, and thinking we had to get rid of him.

When your daughter went to your Dobe's pen area, she invaded the dog's space. I would have your daughter not do this. When she did not leave, that was a mistake!
 
The nipping sounds like prey drive kicking in. I don't think she is being aggressive at all. Then the high pitched squealing sounds just like a prey animal. If an instance like that were to occur again, with your daughter making a high pitched noise, and you see Gypsy run over to her, step into Gypsy to block her. Bump her with your knee and firmly say SIT. Something to snap her mind out of zeroing in on her prey drive and put her into thinking mode.

There also sounds like there is some stress associated with your daughter since she has been corrected for her behavior around her. I would definitely start incorporating positive interactions with the two, supervised of course to build the interactions from negative more towards positive. Have her always feed one of her meals each day. Have her give a sit or down command and reward. Have your pup in her "place" on a bed or rug while your daughter plays nearby. Make it clear to your daughter that she doesn't ever disturb her while she is in her place. You can leave a leash on her tied to a firm table or something else as backup so that she may not be able to break her place command and run to your daughter should she scream.

Having your pup do these positive interactions, of control, with your daughter will help their bond. She will not only see her as a pack leader but will also get used to her noises.
 
Last night we had an even worse occurrence in the living room! Daughter was sitting on the couch next to my husband, Gypsy was bringing him a ball, and he would throw it. She came back and dropped the ball on the couch - she was blocked by a table and the only way to get to my daughter was by jumping over my husband. My daughter picked up the ball and Gypsy took but in the action accidentally got my daughter's finger too, nothing really happened it was just a little light nip that didn't even make her finger red. But, my daughter screamed bloody murder. Gypsy immediately jumped over my husband's lap to try to grab my daughter, husband pushed Gypsy off, at this point I was already at my daughter's side checking on her, Gypsy ran around the table to jump at her from the other side (which I had been blocking before). It was a very dramatic scene with myself holding her up in the air, while my daughter is screaming under me (I would put a "shaking my head" emoji here but I don't know how use them on this platform :) ). Husband comes to the rescue, picking up Gypsy and carrying her into the kitchen where her pen is. In the process, Gypsy peed. I think she was just so scared. I felt horribly for both of them. Nobody yelled at her, but I think my daughter's reaction was too much for her.

This has to be extremely stressful. You also don't want your daughter to become fearful because that would intensify Gypsy's prey drive. You really really really don't want Gypsy to bite her. Sounds like Gypsy is an independent thinker and very much wants to be dominant. My puppy totally dominated the resident 5 year old dog here by the time she was just 4 - 5 months old, because resident dog was well trained and polite and did not get aggressive with the pup and put her in her place, so my puppy just ran all over her. Your daughter is too young to show Gracie she is a leader, since Gracie is obviously not a push-over. Anytime one party (your daughter in this case) is not having fun it's up to you to stop it. You absolutely cannot let another incident like this happen. If Gypsy bites your daughter, your girl could be traumatized for life and Gypsy would have to be re-homed, which is 99% impossible because most shelters or rescues cannot/should not rehome a known bite case dog, due to liabilities, so you're looking at a death sentence for Gypsy. I know I sound harsh and awful, but I've seen this play out and it's just a hard hard situation. I personally would not let any interactions happen with your daughter & Gypsy until you get Gypsy under total control, like 110%. Sit, Down, Off, Stay, Wait, NO, especially NO! Find a trainer who knows working breeds and can work with you on this. Wishing you all the best, it CAN be worked out.
 
Just something else to add to this conversation....

It may be wise to stop the ball play in the house. Leave it for outside where there’s room for Gypsy to run about freely.
Over excitement does not always equal happiness as you’ve sadly found out. She’s showing signs of being highly aroused (level of excitement and mental control) and outwardly very excited. In this state of hyper excitement she can freeze and become fixated
on her stimulus, your daughter.
I truly appreciate and understand the struggles of a lively puppy and a young child, I really do BUT it’s about giving Gypsy balance in her life. A balance between physical exercise outside the house and mental stimulation inside the house, this will help prevent the buildup of stress and help create a calm, healthy, happy mind.


Think and be positive and work with them both. Supervision is an absolute must when it comes to your daughter and Gypsy and is much more than merely being physically present in the same room. Effective supervision involves being actively involved in any interactions between them. This includes monitoring body language, from both of them to ensure interactions remain stress free for everyone.
 

Back
Top