When your puppy doesn't seem to like a family member

If Gypsy bites your daughter, your girl could be traumatized for life and Gypsy would have to be re-homed, which is 99% impossible because most shelters or rescues cannot/should not rehome a known bite case dog, due to liabilities, so you're looking at a death sentence for Gypsy.

I understand that. And I am doing all I can to prevent that from happening. At this time, my daughter is forbidden to walk into Gypsy's pen to pet her. She's been really good the past few days about listening to me when I tell her enough interaction. I am really paying attention to her body language and teaching my daughter what I am looking for. My daughter (surprisingly) is not afraid of Gypsy. She wants to play with her and be around her even after all these scares.

After that incident, I kept them separated altogether for about 2 days. My daughter was not allowed to even look at Gypsy. And the past 4 days or so we started with interactions again, my daughter finally understands about the importance of respecting Gypsy's space and not constantly trying to interact with her. I think we are in the right direction here. My daughter is now in charge of Gypsy's dinner. Gypsy sees her preparing it, and waits calmly. Once the food is ready, my daughter tells her to sit. Once she sits, my daughter puts her food down and tells her to wait. She steps away and releases Gypsy with Ok. During breakfast, my daughter throws treats in the kitchen area where Gypsy is blocked in, and tells her to go find it. She played with some toys too, for just a few minutes before Gypsy had a chance to become too excited.

When we got back home this afternoon, Gypsy was super excited to see me, but clearly didn't want anything to do with my daughter. My daughter stepped aside before I even told her to. We started playing and Gypsy warmed up to her and seemed to seek interaction with my daughter.

I am committed to doing all I can to ensure both of them are safe. I am looking for a trainer that is not the same as our first trainer. met 2 people already, and they both have the same approach as the first. The last one though, does a little more than just ignore bad behavior. She uses time outs and space claiming. Still not different enough for our needs. Will keep looking!
 
Over excitement does not always equal happiness as you’ve sadly found out. She’s showing signs of being highly aroused (level of excitement and mental control) and outwardly very excited.

Yes! I actually learned about that on an episode of a popular dog trainer. I was searching for games to stimulate her mind and came across this video. He hid his pitbull's favorite ball in a room and let him go in to look for it. Once he found it he was excited, and the trainer talked about the importance of stopping the game after a few minutes because that dog would become over stimulated and lose control and start destroying the room. I thought that was good info.

Gypsy lost her self control that evening and you are right, she may have been over her threshold. The last consultation I had with a trainer, she said Gypsy has a low threshold and we should work on increasing that. During her time here, Gypsy was jumping on her almost the entire time and one thing she said was that Gypsy couldn't use her restraint at that point. She needed to calm down first. I am really paying attention to that and the moment I feel she's getting too aroused I stop the game and leave her alone.

I have also upped the number of training sessions I do in a day with her. I feel like I am constantly training her now! hahaha! I am looking for things that make her think.
 
My daughter is now in charge of Gypsy's dinner. Gypsy sees her preparing it, and waits calmly. Once the food is ready, my daughter tells her to sit. Once she sits, my daughter puts her food down and tells her to wait. She steps away and releases Gypsy with Ok.
I think this is great! You are doing an awesome job going about this safely and learning from your experiences. That paired with watching her arousal state is excellent. You can teach excited dogs to learn to cap their arousal too. Asking her to go to spot that is a fair distance away, while it will be hard in the beginning, she will learn to follow command even when shes rearing to go. More tiny training sessions like you are doing will help her too. Anything to make her brain work will tire her out far more than physical exercise. She'll learn good behavior and to follow direction at the same time.

At 8 your daughter is plenty old enough to take part in training so I'm so glad you are teaching her these things young! Here we have a youth program called 4H, dog club is a part of it and 8 is the youngest you can join. Kids do obedience, showmanship, costume class, agility and more with their dogs! Its amazing the leadership skills and responsibilities kids are capable of even at 8. :)

I have also upped the number of training sessions I do in a day with her. I feel like I am constantly training her now! hahaha! I am looking for things that make her think.

If you want to have some fun and maybe even earn a title while doing it, check out AKC's trick dog program. Theres a good list of tricks you can pull from and teach them on the side of the obedience skills. It helps change things up, challenges you, and your dog to trying out something fun! Right now until 2022 you can send your video in virtually to be evaluated. Even if you don't want to be evaluated, theres some decent videos to learn how to train some of the tricks just for fun too.

AKC Trick Dog – American Kennel Club
 
I hope I am not overstepping and please know this is coming from a place of concern for the dynamics of your household.

Gypsy should be crated and must wait while you put a leash on her to come out of her crate and then taken outside to potty, train, play with you etc. then put back in the crate until the next session of potty, training, play.
She needs to learn respect for your rules, your home and the people in it. This also teaches her to appreciate her time out of her crate.

It seems Gypsy has a strong willed nature and pushes the envelop to her own tune.
She cannot be allowed to do this.
She reads your body language as you are trying to read hers.

I would not do a lot of talking when training or even play other than marking her positive behavior with a yes or clicker and a treat.
She must learn she has to earn every single thing she gets.

Gypsy does not respect anyone in the house and your role as her leader must be established through crate training, firm but fair corrections and consistent training with the entire family.
She needs to learn and understand her place in the hierarchy of the family and that place is beneath everyone in the family.

I am glad your daughter is taking the lead on preparing Gypsy’s food and teaching to wait until your daughter releases her to eat.

Absolutely no physical play should be allowed in the house, only mental stimulation games.
Environmental training should be started with her so she learns to focus on you and not other distractions around her.
Eventually she will learn and understand the rules for the home through repetition and consistency. This breed learns and thrives on schedules and continuity.

Crates should never be used as punishment but should be utilized in their training structure.
Once they are trained and trustworthy in the home, only then will they be allowed to be free in the home but never on furniture.

Crating, training, established rules, physical and mental exercise will help you get a handle on Gypsy’s errant, willful and attempted dominant behavior.
Also learn to deep breathe and calm your own emotions before working with her.
If you become frustrated while working or playing with her, calmly put her up and start again later when you are relaxed and confident.
They pick up on our emotions easily. I am a high energy person and my dobes pick up on that so I have to tone myself down in order to work with them without the frustration and craziness that comes with that energy.
I’ve learned to do deep breathing exercises before I work with mine and it has helped me tremendously in calming and training them.

Fast movement and high pitched squeals just increases their prey drive as @Ravenbird mentioned earlier and gets them amped up.
Their crate works to calm them down and teaches restraint.

It’s a process but it works and it makes your world less trying and crazy in the home.
 
@CrisK it sounds like it is all coming together! It'll be 24/7 while Gypsy is growing up, but you are clearly doing everything you can and sound determined. I may have come off sounding a bit overpowering in my last post but I think you are handling the situation way better than many do. Thanks for keeping us posted on the progress!
 
It seems Gypsy has a strong willed nature and pushes the envelop to her own tune.

Thank you! She does seem that way for sure!

Absolutely no physical play should be allowed in the house, only mental stimulation games.
Environmental training should be started with her so she learns to focus on you and not other distractions around her.

Do you mean we shouldn't be playing anything aside from mental games like searching? One thing I started enforcing is not letting her initiate anything. If she brings me a toy, I ignore her - we all do. If she forces herself into my space, I push her away without talking or looking at her (she seems to understand that and leaves me alone in the first try).

Also learn to deep breathe and calm your own emotions before working with her.

I will admit, when my daughter is near I tense up. My husband does a better job being relax than I.

This morning we were working on some skills in the closed off area in the kitchen, and she would just turn around and walk away from me after 4 tries. I find that frustrating. What would you do in this case? I think I am doing something wrong in my training approach. She does come back for more, but I feel like I am waiting on her to be ready to train. If I don't talk or be excited during the training, won't that make her less excited too? This is a bit confusing to me. I notice when I am more high energy at training I get more of a response than when I am less energetic.

Gypsy should be crated and must wait while you put a leash on her to come out of her crate

Does a pen work similarly to a crate? We have a crate upstairs for night time. Downstairs it's a pen that we can make bigger when we are hanging out in the kitchen, and smaller when she's on her own. At this time it's impossible to let her roam free around the house. She only allowed in the living when we are there. She will usually chew on a bully stick while we watch TV or hangout. She does invade our space once in a while when we are not expecting. Do you think I should respond in a more drastic manner than simply pushing her away?

I have so many questions! Thank you so much for the help! This forum has been invaluable!
 
@Ravenbird I appreciate your feedback! I am a tough cookie, I can take strong feedback :). Moreover, I see this conversation as a resource for someone else who might encounter a similar situation. So, bring it on! Thank you so much!
 
She only allowed in the living when we are there. She will usually chew on a bully stick while we watch TV or hangout.
She shouldn’t be allowed to just hang out with you watching tv as this gives her the impression that she is equal to everyone in the home. She has to learn that is a privilege that is earned.

If you are training in the house of course you can be animated and give lots of praise when she complies with a command. What I meant was no roughhousing inside with running and bouncing off the walls squealing.
Finding treats around the house is what I consider brain exercise games and yes that is good.

If she shows no interest in training without the excitement and wants to go do her own thing, this is where crate training is beneficial. It teaches them to appreciate her freedom from confinement and they are more willing to work at training.

Outdoors would be for burning up physical energy by using a flirt pole to burn energy or chasing a ball or frisbee.

I just realized you live in cold country but bundle up and get them out to play for 10-15 minutes several times a day.
With her ignoring you and walking away when you try to work with her is her way of controlling you so keep a leash on her while training and praise heavily for complying and always end the session with something she knows how to do. That way the session ends on a positive note.

Approaching you uninvited would be a situation of where I would have her go to her spot and stay by telling her to leave it in a firm voice and put her on her designated placing rug or mat.
I would not use a physical push. If she doesn’t comply with the leave it or place command then I would grab her leash and calmly place her on her mat, rug, towel or whatever you use.
Just pushing away does not reinforce that you want her to get out of your space and into hers.
It’s a lot of repetition but they eventually understand what you want.

Keep a 4’ - 6’ leash on her in the house. It gives you more control to be able to immediately correct a negative behavior.

I really hope I am not confusing you. :eek:
My last male Bogie and now my male 5mo old Legend was/are very independent and display dominate, willful traits making training more challenging.

It’s always a work in progress but once that light clicks on in Gypsy’s brain you will find yourself with an amazing Dobe.
I don’t think she dislikes your daughter, I think she feels your daughter is her equal and going through her Doberteens on top of that makes the situation frustrating.

Keep going, I know how difficult it can be but in the end when she reaches adulthood you will look back on it and be pretty damn proud you survived the puppy and teenage years. :D
 
Update on Gypsy. She has been so much better the past couple of weeks. Forbidding my daughter from getting into her pen and really paying attention to her body language and level of excitement has done wonders over here. My daughter has been doing the dinner routine, morning mini training session and play in the mornings. Yesterday we were able to have my daughter and gypsy in the same room without any incidents aside from Gypsy bringing a toy to my daughter. I have a good feeling about this. I am still very cautious, and I won't relax for a while but I see us going in the right direction. I have become a better leader too, I don't let Gypsy get away with anything. I know time outs work for her and I use them whenever she gets stubborn. Also, when I notice she's getting too excited, she goes back to her pen to calm down. Friends, it's a lot of work! But, watching her learn is totally worth the effort and I think we will have the dog we always wanted in the future. We saw glimpses of her yesterday and today. We are progressing nicely. Thank you so much for all the advice!
 
Your post makes me smile. So happy for your family and Gypsy. Many different components all coming together to communicate to Gypsy her place and to develop a positive relationship between her and your daughter that will last a lifetime. Great job! We need Gypsy pic updates too :D
 
Everything @Rits said x 2! I ended up with a really tough puppy, challenged me like nothing I ever dreamed of, those glimpses of the future were what kept me going!
 
So very happy to hear her new schedule and NILIF training is working for you and your daughter being involved with feeding and training!

It’s a process but trust me the end results are well worth the journey!
Love the head tilt. They certainly have a way of grabbing your heart.
 
Awesome.
Getting her to understand obedience and discipline will allow you to unlock her potential. Otherwise, you just really have a dog on crack running crazy fulfilling its wants at abandon.

Great job. Mine has made me sooo proud, my wife says that I glow when he is with me in public.
 
So happy to hear you’re getting positive results. Keep up the great work :thumbsup:
She instinctually craves structure and order, and looks for a strong leader. If she detects that you are not strong enough, by instinct she will take over that role. So don’t give her an inch!! You won’t do her any favours by allowing her to flip back and forth between leader and follower, nor are you doing her any favours by allowing her to run your home. It would be very stressful for her to believe she is the leader, yet to not be able to control her followers, and it is equally as stressful for her not to have the stability of a consistent, strong-minded leader.
So stay consistent and make her look up to you for guidance. It’s all in the mind and energy which is being projected! :thumbsup:
 
One more update because I am too excited about this. We have reached yet another milestone! Gypsy now seeks my daughter for love! I am over the moon! Last night we were in the living room and she rested her head on my daughter's lap and was really calm while enjoying some head and neck scratches. When she was done, she walked away calmly. It was such a dramatic shift, that I am still not believing it. We had a deadline at 8 months. If we felt she couldn't be around my daughter safely, we would have to re-home her. We already had support lined up, our day care person has a farm and lots of experience with dobermans, (Gypsy loves that place and the owners) she would either keep her or help us find a family for her. Gypsy turns 8 months on March 1st, and we are so excited to continue to have her in our family. The next challenge: co-exist with our cats!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0344.webp
    IMG_0344.webp
    330.5 KB · Views: 6
Last night we were in the living room and she rested her head on my daughter's lap and was really calm while enjoying some head and neck scratches. When she was done, she walked away calmly.

That’s is the best news ever!! Keep doing what you are doing. They BOTH know the rules now so this will get better as they age.

Cats are a different story....you cannot sit down and explain to cats not to do zoomies in front of a prey driven Doberman.

I have three daughters, two Dobermans and three cats. I couldn’t do anything about the cats. I just had to stay on my Dobermans to “leave it”. I really do not expect to change my older Doberman (3.5yrs), his prey drive is very high. After being corrected 10k times they both kinda get the idea to leave the kitties alone. But then I also know that I will not completely tame a high prey drive Doberman....they are Dobermans, just have to be aware as always.
 

Back
Top