• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

When discipline is actually a relief

Ravenbird

Moderator
$ Forum Donor $
I know better than to say our dogs are like humans, but this is a good comparison for explanatory reasons, of our puppies - in the long run - wanting/craving to be told what to do. To have authority (to them) is a relief, they just don't know it yet. The burden of responsibility is off their back, they can learn to enjoy life.

This article has nothing to do with dogs, it's just an example of a teen trying to take on all the world because they think they have to, but really they don't, if they have responsible parents. And they shouldn't have to. Just imagine this teenager to be your Doberteen pup, trying to keep all the boogiemen away, all the ducks in a row, and not being able to rest because he thinks he is pack leader and no one else seems to be alert to what he perceives as his responsibility.

Story from a blogpost I ran across today, that reminded me of my own almost teen Dobe and her independence and wanting to take control and her big heart that I never want to break and her temper with eyes that throw me the middle finger when I take control... but I have to keep reminding her that she is still a PUPPY and I will take care of things so she doesn't think she has to:


My daughter is 16 and like all teens deals with social drama and ups and downs. I want her to have a cell phone for safety, but last year I began to realize that she was using it for much more than that. She was staying up late at night texting and on social media, and the beautiful daughter I know and love was, quite frankly, becoming awful to live with.

After investigating her hours of late night phone use (which for a technology challenged mom like myself was no easy task), my husband and I decided it was time for us to start putting her device in our room at bedtime. I honestly had no idea how much this decision would impact her. After she blew up in anger, she began sobbing and puddled on the floor. As I held her, I just listened. Listened to all the worries and fears of fitting in and keeping up, but there was something even more alarming keeping her up at night…My daughter had been counseling another teen late at night who was suicidal. Her huge heart had been on high alert. She HAD to stay up and be available at all times “in case” her friend needed her.

We were able to talk, really talk, (well, she talked and I held my breath hoping that it wouldn’t stop). She shared all her social circle drama, the comments on social media she had to keep up with, the sleep overs and parties she saw that she knew she wasn’t invited to, and most importantly how she was single handedly owning responsibility for her friend’s life. My teen was relieved when we talked through how to break the silence and get her friend help, real help, and that it wasn’t my daughter’s responsibility to carry that burden, especially not alone. Together we came up with a plan to involve adults who can support her friend and break the silence over suicidal thoughts.

After the dust settled and we stuck to our new “no phone at bedtime” rule, I was amazed at the changes we saw. I could tell that my girl was so relieved! Much like setting limits with a curfew, she needed that structure from us to take the pressure off. Also, while initially it was an adjustment for all of us at bedtime to take the phone (not going to lie, some days were harder than others depending on what was going on socially), after awhile it became routine. She began to use our limits to protect herself too, telling peers her mom and dad were taking the phone (we gave her permission to blame us for any lame-ness). She got sleep, she was less irritable and I saw my beautiful girl come back.

Navigating this technology thing is not fun, for parents or our teens. But I will fight for our daughter’s health, and am happy to report that this battle was worth it.

Allison, START Parent, Overland Park, KS

I have no idea if this will resonate with any of you regarding dogs & training, especially puppies, but I thought I'd share. Food for thought.
 
no idea if this will resonate with any of you regarding dogs & training,

Resonate...yep...I'm thinking about reading it out load to Bam so maybe he will understand I am not all of the sudden being a hateful mom......what seems like mom throwing "I am so unhappy/disappointed in you" drama at him the last few weeks..is Mom trying to take a load off him.
 
You will succeed with Bam, just reading your posts here, I know you know what to do and how to go about it. But it does take time. And patience - which some days I run low on and have to take big deep breaths and remind myself that it will all work out. Ye gads, I start thanking my lucky stars the puppyhood days are leaving me and then remember the Doberteens are coming next!
 
I know better than to say our dogs are like humans, but this is a good comparison for explanatory reasons, of our puppies - in the long run - wanting/craving to be told what to do. To have authority (to them) is a relief, they just don't know it yet. The burden of responsibility is off their back, they can learn to enjoy life.

This article has nothing to do with dogs, it's just an example of a teen trying to take on all the world because they think they have to, but really they don't, if they have responsible parents. And they shouldn't have to. Just imagine this teenager to be your Doberteen pup, trying to keep all the boogiemen away, all the ducks in a row, and not being able to rest because he thinks he is pack leader and no one else seems to be alert to what he perceives as his responsibility.

Story from a blogpost I ran across today, that reminded me of my own almost teen Dobe and her independence and wanting to take control and her big heart that I never want to break and her temper with eyes that throw me the middle finger when I take control... but I have to keep reminding her that she is still a PUPPY and I will take care of things so she doesn't think she has to:


My daughter is 16 and like all teens deals with social drama and ups and downs. I want her to have a cell phone for safety, but last year I began to realize that she was using it for much more than that. She was staying up late at night texting and on social media, and the beautiful daughter I know and love was, quite frankly, becoming awful to live with.

After investigating her hours of late night phone use (which for a technology challenged mom like myself was no easy task), my husband and I decided it was time for us to start putting her device in our room at bedtime. I honestly had no idea how much this decision would impact her. After she blew up in anger, she began sobbing and puddled on the floor. As I held her, I just listened. Listened to all the worries and fears of fitting in and keeping up, but there was something even more alarming keeping her up at night…My daughter had been counseling another teen late at night who was suicidal. Her huge heart had been on high alert. She HAD to stay up and be available at all times “in case” her friend needed her.

We were able to talk, really talk, (well, she talked and I held my breath hoping that it wouldn’t stop). She shared all her social circle drama, the comments on social media she had to keep up with, the sleep overs and parties she saw that she knew she wasn’t invited to, and most importantly how she was single handedly owning responsibility for her friend’s life. My teen was relieved when we talked through how to break the silence and get her friend help, real help, and that it wasn’t my daughter’s responsibility to carry that burden, especially not alone. Together we came up with a plan to involve adults who can support her friend and break the silence over suicidal thoughts.

After the dust settled and we stuck to our new “no phone at bedtime” rule, I was amazed at the changes we saw. I could tell that my girl was so relieved! Much like setting limits with a curfew, she needed that structure from us to take the pressure off. Also, while initially it was an adjustment for all of us at bedtime to take the phone (not going to lie, some days were harder than others depending on what was going on socially), after awhile it became routine. She began to use our limits to protect herself too, telling peers her mom and dad were taking the phone (we gave her permission to blame us for any lame-ness). She got sleep, she was less irritable and I saw my beautiful girl come back.

Navigating this technology thing is not fun, for parents or our teens. But I will fight for our daughter’s health, and am happy to report that this battle was worth it.

Allison, START Parent, Overland Park, KS

I have no idea if this will resonate with any of you regarding dogs & training, especially puppies, but I thought I'd share. Food for thought.
As a father of 2 girls, 19 and 23, I can appreciate and relate to all of this.:)
I could tell you some stories:D
Similar but different social media drama, including law enforcement involved, or the 9:35pm “wellness” check from the local Sheriff deputy:rolleyes:
The Sheriff visit was interesting, given the time and uh, :dobe::dobe:;)

Parenting ain’t for sissy’s:D
 
So true. While our dogs are not human they just like our children entirely dependent on us to tech them wrong form right, provide for their needs, take care of them and make them feel loved and safe always.

Over the years many of our friends especially single parents after a divorce were trying to be their children's friend rather than be their parent and then problems that followed. More than once I had them come to me overwhelmed and tell me how lucky I was that my children were such a terrific kids and we have such a great relationship.
I always would tell them it's not luck it's good parenting.
We always made it perfectly clear "We are not your friends we are your parents".
"You will hopefully have many many friends through out your life, but you will only have one mom and one dad." When you grow up and have children of your own will understand just how important that is.
That does't mean we can't play together and have lots of fun. But I am always your parent 1st and foremost."

Not the humanize this but it is the much same with our dogs.
Yes we can play with them, love on them and even spoil them a bit.
But job 1 is to teach them, always keep them safe, and be a leader that they respect, trust & love 100% of the time . If we do they will be happy well adjusted dogs with good manors and a joy to be around for the rest of their life.
All dogs need a leader if there isn't one then the job falls to them and that is wrong.
Quite frankly it is simply not a job they are equipped to do and is the source of most if of not all of the behavior problems folks have with their dogs.
When you see happy dogs that adore their owners.
It is because they haven't a care in the world because they know their leader has everything 100% under control. All they have to do is follow their leader.

Anyway thats my opinion / experience.
MR
 
I always would tell them it's not luck it's good parenting.
I hate hearing the word, luck, with anything. It's not good luck if you have great kids. It's not good luck if you have a good job. It's not good luck if you're financially stable. It's all hard work, good parenting, good choices.
 

Back
Top