Training styles

ksirr

New Member
Hello all! I am really liking the information from this site! Everyone is very helpful and so far from what I have seen, everyone is able to discuss different opinions without things going sour which I very much appreciate!
So my question is, what are some training styles have been effective for you guys? My current dogs are border collies and require a bit of a harsher voice when they are not listening. How is it with Dobermans?

Thanks!
 
Routine for sure.

They are highly intelligent so their training must be kept interesting and varied to keep them on their toes and to keep them concentrated.

Leadership, consistency (repetition) and patience are a must.

They are eager to please but you need to start training from an early age.
 
Deflection of voice shouldn’t matter, it is a learned behavior thru our training mistakes. Consistency and following thru is the most important. Giving a clear picture, you only need to be firm. Your commands can be given soft as long as they are given in a firm way. You must be prepared to reinforce the command and not continuously give the command while changing the deflection of your voice. They will quickly only learn to conform when they her your frustration knowing that is the sound that's followed by reinforcement.
 
Firm, Consistent, and Fair.

Just like any dog, the more you set them up to make decisions and reinforce the right decision, the smarter they are, if that makes sense? I'm sure you've experienced that with BCs.

I personally use everything from clicker training to eCollar training, depending on the situation. My dogs respect me but they don't fear me.
 
Firm, Consistent, and Fair.

Just like any dog, the more you set them up to make decisions and reinforce the right decision, the smarter they are, if that makes sense? I'm sure you've experienced that with BCs.

I personally use everything from clicker training to eCollar training, depending on the situation. My dogs respect me but they don't fear me.


I definitely have experienced this. My current training with the BC's is strictly voice and toys. No treats, no clicker, no ecollar. Praise with voice and toys and corrections with voice (growly deep voice - I try not to yell :)) . I want to make sure this way will be effective with my future Doberman. Border Collies brains are intense and focused and when trained to think properly they are very good at finding solutions to problems (including how to please you). I have not found that clicker/treat training is any more effective than what I do.
 
I definitely have experienced this. My current training with the BC's is strictly voice and toys. No treats, no clicker, no ecollar. Praise with voice and toys and corrections with voice (growly deep voice - I try not to yell :)) . I want to make sure this way will be effective with my future Doberman. Border Collies brains are intense and focused and when trained to think properly they are very good at finding solutions to problems (including how to please you). I have not found that clicker/treat training is any more effective than what I do.
Doubt that training will be effective on a Doberman. Possibly one with lower drive or a soft temperament but a higher drive, hard dog will own you if that is how you train.
 
Ok, what do you suggest instead?
When they are young puppies I shape behavior with food and marker system. Once they hit the teenage stage they will start to test you so you have to have some form of negative reinforcement. Verbal correction will most likely not be enough. There has to be a consequence for bad or wrong behavior. Using a negative marker then reinforcing that with some form of correction will help create a verbal correction that will work in the future. Just as giving a verbal marker followed by a reward with create a positive reinforcer that can be used when removing rewards slowly from training. Then you can continue with random reinforcement training to up your training sessions. If you do your work when they are young to build focus and engagement with you, a correct will not shut your dog down but actually build your dog up and improve there abilities.
 
When they are young puppies I shape behavior with food and marker system. Once they hit the teenage stage they will start to test you so you have to have some form of negative reinforcement. Verbal correction will most likely not be enough. There has to be a consequence for bad or wrong behavior. Using a negative marker then reinforcing that with some form of correction will help create a verbal correction that will work in the future. Just as giving a verbal marker followed by a reward with create a positive reinforcer that can be used when removing rewards slowly from training. Then you can continue with random reinforcement training to up your training sessions. If you do your work when they are young to build focus and engagement with you, a correct will not shut your dog down but actually build your dog up and improve there abilities.

Thank you for this. I will keep this in mind. I love getting feedback and information, Especially from trainers. Border Collies are much more sensitive then most breeds. At least when they are at home. When on the field they are much more stubborn. Haha :biggrin:
 
They learn quickly and show you they can do a certain thing, but often proceed to throw in their own twist – especially if you give them too much repetition. It's like they are thinking: You have told me to do this a few times already and I have done it. Maybe I am not doing what you want. How about this variation?

Keep training sessions pretty short.

They can be hard headed and dominant, yet they are sensitive. As with any dog, tailor your training to the individual.

There will be times when you need to use a loud, stern voice, but not often, and not when teaching them something new or when they are quite young. In fact, I like to speak quietly. I feel it causes them to listen better (and, being a private, antisocial person I don't like to draw attention to myself in public).

Speaking of which, I don't train in English. Bonus here is you get to stand back and laugh to yourself if a stranger tells your Dobe to sit.
 
They learn quickly and show you they can do a certain thing, but often proceed to throw in their own twist – especially if you give them too much repetition. It's like they are thinking: You have told me to do this a few times already and I have done it. Maybe I am not doing what you want. How about this variation?

Keep training sessions pretty short.

They can be hard headed and dominant, yet they are sensitive. As with any dog, tailor your training to the individual.

There will be times when you need to use a loud, stern voice, but not often, and not when teaching them something new or when they are quite young. In fact, I like to speak quietly. I feel it causes them to listen better (and, being a private, antisocial person I don't like to draw attention to myself in public).

Speaking of which, I don't train in English. Bonus here is you get to stand back and laugh to yourself if a stranger tells your Dobe to sit.
I'm not planning to train in english. I want to do latin.
 
I'm not planning to train in english. I want to do latin.
Love it!

Yeah, there was one time a rather presumptuous woman came into the front office of the vet as we were standing in there paying. She right away started telling Oji to sit. :cus: :nono: :cool:
 

Back
Top