• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Melanistic doberman

MischasMomma

Site Sponsor
Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
Sorry if this isn't the right category... Couldnt decide where would be best!

I'm in a few doberman groups on facebook, and recently melanistic dogs have come up. I never heard of this before, and actually had some good discussions. So, have any of you ever had or seen one in person? My understanding is theyre basically the opposite of albino dobes, and also should not be bred. If thats the case (and I don't disagree, dogs who fit the standard are the ones who should be bred, by color, size, temperament, and health) why are melanistic dogs not tracked, similar to the Z for albino lines? Your thoughts? Lets Discuss. :biggrin:
 
I seem to recall a member having one at one time?
I don't think melanistism was continued through inbreeding the way albinism was and I don't think it has many associated health issues the way albinism does. No real evidence to base that on
Completely agree.

I'm sort of surprised we haven't seen more? I understand it isn't that uncommon.
The local land developer around here in our area swears he's seen a melanistic mountain lion in the area several times. :eek:
 
ME. My first dobie Max was melanistic, course back in 1994 we had no clue. Seems to be a new "fad" starting, seeing more lately. Melanistic is not black, the "tan" markings are a dark chocolate color that blend in at a distance. Max came from a BYB. As far as health, he lived to be 13 yrs. Never any health issues other than knee surgery for a tear (probably cause I had him fixed young). I've had better bred dogs but NONE lived as long as him!! I'll post some pic if I can find them.
 
I've had a discussion with Archer about this. I was trying to understand her explanation of how melanism is not that the hairs that are normally tan are semi-black, but that the hairs that are normally tan have black hairs in their place. Get it? :scratch:

One of my questions is: You see varying degrees of what I take to be melanism. My previous Dobe had what I described as a "black wash" over the rust muzzle markings and the rust chest markings. I loved it, and I still do love that look. Oji has a bit of it, and you do see it to varying degrees especially in some Euros.

Yes, I've seen the Dobermans that essentially look all black, and I too am surprised there is not more of a trend to try to breed for that. I agree that it should NOT be bred for; but then I also am of the belief that breeding for any particular color other than black should not be done.

But yes, one has to wonder if a Dobe that carries the gene(s) to make it mostly or all black might also carry some problematic health genes or qualities. It's an unknown we should avoid, it seems to me. Or, if someone can educate me more on it, and show why it is not a problem, please do!
 
I also find it interesting that some Dobes have more black markings than others. I'm talking about the "pencil marks" on the toes, and the "thumbprints" on the top of the paws. Some of Oji's littermates have a lot more black markings like this, and also along the sides of the feet/hocks.
 
and recently melanistic dogs have come up.



I saw that and have been following it. I always find some of the opinions anywhere from interesting to ridiculous. I am of the mindset that there is a reason for a standard. It's sort of a template to get what you want. My biggest concern when something different comes along it is just an opportunity for greeders. IMHO, when you start breeding for something like color, other important things are forgotten. The doberman has enough problems, we don't need to add to or create more.



So, have any of you ever had or seen one in person?





I have. He was dumped at a local rescue because he had tumors related to the heavy pigmentation. His owner got tired of paying to have them removed. He did have some rust on his face but the rest of his marking could only be seen in bright light like in the sun.
 
I think of the black Jaguar. If the sunlight shines on it, you can see the Jaguar spots in there. Some dark/black brindle dogs are like this too, I believe.

So, are these examples considered melanism?

From my understanding yes... As it was explained to me, it is the result of having too much pigment, and can be seen in nature as well, ie tigers or leopards end up being solid black. I assume it would apply to any animal that SHOULD have markings, but end up being a solid color (I saw examples of solid blue, fawn and red doberman too)
 
Here is another thread in which it is discussed:

dark doberman muzzle

By the way, I am not at all trying to be like: There's already a thread on this. I'm just trying to sort of consolidate information on this, as it is a topic of interest to me.

I do rememeber that thread now!! Mischa actually has a very dark muzzle... However the rest of her markings are "normal"?

I also have to agree with @GennyB i feel like once a certain color is being bred for, other important aspects are lost when the focus is on color.
 
I do rememeber that thread now!! Mischa actually has a very dark muzzle... However the rest of her markings are "normal"?

I also have to agree with @GennyB i feel like once a certain color is being bred for, other important aspects are lost when the focus is on color.
Yes, I recall Mischa does have a darker muzzle.
 
and also along the sides of the feet/hocks.
I saw a totally natural Doberman with very light tan markings. The tan went all the way up the hind legs and into the tail. Like a wishbone. That made me unsure if it was a full Dobe. She was not the nicest to Kaiser either and they were working on skittishness issues...at a pet smart puppy class :rolleyes: The owner said it was nice to meet us as "you don't see them around anymore".
 
I saw a totally natural Doberman with very light tan markings. The tan went all the way up the hind legs and into the tail. Like a wishbone. That made me unsure if it was a full Dobe. She was not the nicest to Kaiser either and they were working on skittishness issues...at a pet smart puppy class :rolleyes: The owner said it was nice to meet us as "you don't see them around anymore".
Yes, you sometimes also see the chest markings that are quite large like a big bow tie or butterfly. This is always in conjunction with lighter, tan markings not rich rust markings in my experience. Just observations. Not trying to offend anyone.
 
Breeding for a specific color, to me, is the wrong way of doing things. Breeding for health and temperament is the most important thing. Melanistic Dobermans do not carry the health problems you will see in the z-factor dogs. They can be produced from two normal marked black Dobermans. Black Dobermans can vary in marking color from light tan to a rich dark mahagony color. This darker color can almost look black from a distance. There are always people in it for the money, whether they are breeding z-factor dogs, purposely trying to produce blues and fawns, trying to produce oversized Dobermans or trying to produce an all black dog. These are novalty breeders that do not care about the breed as much as they do selling dogs.
 
I think of the black Jaguar. If the sunlight shines on it, you can see the Jaguar spots in there. Some dark/black brindle dogs are like this too, I believe.

So, are these examples considered melanism?
Actually yes the black jaguar is melanistic, they are also healthier because of it then the normal leopards interesting isn’t it ?
 

Back
Top