When I crate, my pups are ready to go in. They have had a long morning run and swim and they chill out from the heat outside.
As they have aged they are not crated as often. Before when they were younger they have destroyed so many things in the house like chewing Sheetrock, couch, linens, baseboards etc. so yes crating was necessary for their safety. As they have aged they can be trusted and are seldom crated except to eat or when they want to go in on their own.
My comment was to crate them when puppies until they are trustworthy being left alone. With my two I will not ever leave them alone together because they will start arguing with each other and I don't want to come home to bleeding dogs should it ever escalate.
That was my point with the puppies being free in the house. Too many things to get into that two puppies will do whereas one may not.
When I have to be gone for any length of time then my female will be in the bedroom with my beagle and female cat and Bogie will be in the living room. We don't have a lot of property down here anywhere that allows them to run free that doesn't have other (untrained) dogs blazing through so I use the ocean and nature trails for their exercise.
I did not crate my prior dobes but have learned with these two that it has made them easier to train and keep your home intact and less medical bills for FBS.
When I am home my front door is always open so they come and go downstairs as they please but because Bogie is a jumper he cannot be trusted with access to the outdoors without me here. (Momma's boy)

Edit here: when I crate it is for their safety not my convenience. But I do agree that many have abused crating dogs. Not in my house, even my birds have free reign outside of their cages.
