• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

The good and bad of crate training

  • Pros:
  • Self soothing
  • Easier time at the vet
  • Potty training
  • Safe place
  • Easy and safe traveling
  • Better if you need a dog sitter
  • Keeps them safe.


Cons
  • Sleepless nights
 
I remember when I covered Buddy's crate with a blanket and I woke to half the blanket pulled into the crate through the wire! :wideyed:

This happened to us too. It also happened when we put the crate on top of a comforter to protect our wood floors (cause yanno, she scoots the crate too) after she pulled the blanket from under the crate, I put plexiglass around the bottom so she couldn't get it. She ate (chewed, not literally ate) that too! Now she's in a travel crate, not wire lol
 
We are really pushing crate traning with Hades, and my word he whines and howls the whole apparent, I'm concerned that the nabors will complain as the walls we have are crap, so we invested in a bark collar so hopefully that stops him, if not I will sit in his crate with him and cry as I need to have him sorted before I go back to work next week. :machinegun:
 
Remember, the crate should only be big enough for them to just stand and turn around. If the crate is to big it defeats the purpose and may not give you dog the feeling of security they need. Covering multiple sides of the crate can also help.
 
We are really pushing crate traning with Hades, and my word he whines and howls the whole apparent, I'm concerned that the nabors will complain as the walls we have are crap, so we invested in a bark collar so hopefully that stops him, if not I will sit in his crate with him and cry as I need to have him sorted before I go back to work next week. :machinegun:
Oye, barky pups! Use this time wisely! Have him in there for a few minutes periodically during the day. The moment he is quiet, let him out. And yes, it will be a mere moment so you have to be quick to reward that behavior. :D Don't need to talk to him, the reward is being let out. Rinse and repeat throughout the day. He'll get it that quiet = I get to come out. Lengthen the time over the next few days of being in there and the amount of time he must be quiet.

Once out, wait til he settles (lays down or sits still for a moment) outside the crate to interact with him. That is another good way to reward calm behavior and helps with crate training. :)

Since I will be doing this multiple times a day, I make sure I have the crate in a common room that I will be in. They learn to deal with people moving around them.
 
Try crate games too, they helped us with Nero. We didnt use the clicker since we don't clicker train, but the general idea was helpful.
 
Since I will be doing this multiple times a day, I make sure I have the crate in a common room that I will be in. They learn to deal with people moving around them.



This is really important! We happen to have 2 crates for each dog. One in the bedroom for when we go to bed and one in the family room for when a certain little stinker can't be watched. They are right in the middle of the room where people walk by and the dogs can see us when we get home. They don't come out until they are calm. I think being where there are lots of distractions helps them because they feel they are still part of what's going on.
 
I had some great success with crate training her sometimes she goes in for nap and comes out by herself.
However this morning she freaked out.
I brought her out after 15- 20 min she got quiet when I came home. I took the garbage was buying tea and short step to grocery store. Got home she was still barking crazy.
In the afternoon some days she stayed there for 2 hours no problem and no accident.
It is an issue when she freaks out as you can hear her in both corridors so all the neighbours think of me as an evil person. By law if I get a warning and she brass more than 15 min in 11 weeks the dog has to be removed from the building.
If I leave she barks 3 times makes a fuss and goes upstairs sleeps behind the gate of my bedrooms! Barking continues in crate.
So there are no concerns.
I am very strict with her sitting lie down before petting etc so they look at me all with the eyes! She responds to my calls even outside video soon.
If I am vacuuming or in shower, cleaning she will stay there no problem but as soon as I lock the door different story.
Also how manytime a night 12-13 weeks old needs to do number one average? She pees like a horse almost every 2 hours. I take her out at 9 then I sleep at 10 as I wake up 6 by then she peed on all news papers pooped twice! I don't put her in crate at night for noise reason and also her and her crate are downstairs from were I sleep and I am not capable of up and downstairs when I am not fully awake. I slipped before.
She is not allowed upstairs as they all carpet and lots wires minus when I bath her.
Thinking to move her and crate upstairs so as long as she is in crate she can stay with me for the night then let her downstairs when she needs to go. Don't really no.
 
Last edited:
Last night a loud noise came around 4 am I came downstairs to check she was sleep in crate! ( door open) Noise was from outside. Still there is hope.
Something I find out when she is tired she goes there.
 
My spoiled boy slept in bed with me from day one. He would curl up close to me and I'd know right away when he'd wake up and have to go out. I got no sleep but I did have a housebroken pup in no time. All of my dogs have slept in bed with me so I wasn't worried about having problems later on crating at night time. He is crate trained but has never liked it, I think he's a little claustrophobic and it makes him anxious. He is good in one if need be but he can be trusted to be left out unsupervised at this point and he is a lot more relaxed as a result.
 
My husband told me the other day that he thought something was wrong with the pups. He lets them out at 4am before he goes to work on the days that I have to overnight pet sit.
He said, I open their crates and they won't come out, they just look at me, normally they always charge out of their crates at full speed. What's wrong with them?
I had to laugh as I explained to him charging out of the crates full speed is NOT allowed anymore. I have been training them to wait until I say they can come out and they must sit once out to get their leash put on. I then walk them individually downstairs. They were used to just barreling out and running downstairs making it dangerous for us as we went down with them.
It has taken 2 days just to teach them this behavior, which I think is pretty quick for them to understand and learn this.
It also prevents them from chasing the cat first thing in the morning.
I love having them crate trained. It teaches them respect for the rules of the house, however they are STILL hooligans. Lol
 
My husband told me the other day that he thought something was wrong with the pups. He lets them out at 4am before he goes to work on the days that I have to overnight pet sit.
He said, I open their crates and they won't come out, they just look at me, normally they always charge out of their crates at full speed. What's wrong with them?
I had to laugh as I explained to him charging out of the crates full speed is NOT allowed anymore. I have been training them to wait until I say they can come out and they must sit once out to get their leash put on. I then walk them individually downstairs. They were used to just barreling out and running downstairs making it dangerous for us as we went down with them.
It has taken 2 days just to teach them this behavior, which I think is pretty quick for them to understand and learn this.
It also prevents them from chasing the cat first thing in the morning.
I love having them crate trained. It teaches them respect for the rules of the house, however they are STILL hooligans. Lol


That's really odd that you should mention that! We always made sure Kobi sat before letting out of the crate but once the bottom bolt was released and the door open he'd fly out, run straight into the kitchen and slid across the floor like a ninja.
Not ideal! (yet I think he found it highly amusing!) So now we close the door to the kitchen. Once that bottom latch is released if it still looks like he wants to bolt we push the crate door shut. He's released when we think he's ready and calm. It feels so good seeing him walk out calmly rather than a whirling Tasmanian devil.

I will try what you have taught them, Bri. Release him from the crate into a sit and then leash him for morning walks :)
 
I took crate upstairs to my bedroom like the idea she sleeps in it all night. I give her a nap time in crate while doing my computer work . One day she stays 3 hours one day 30 min depending how tired she is.
I started this Monday.
About dog sleeping in bed I like the idea but really don't want her get more attached.
My friends wish their dog gets attached even one takes her brand new puppy to showers and bathroom with her. She has two older Schutzhund training dogs both very independent now started with puppy different. She attends shows etc and started training at club from 9 weeks old!
I really don't know none is wrong or right I say.
My only reason for crate is to cut the accidents indoor as well as make sure she well rested and incise needs to spend night in an animal hospital
From first day I started crate ( 10.5 weeks she was)
She is not allowed out of crate and has to wait until I call her name. If she tries I give her the stop sign meaning wait. I like to introduce free command no success yet. I used come but now adding here as well.
 
I remember when I covered Buddy's crate with a blanket and I woke to half the blanket pulled into the crate through the wire! :wideyed:
I would use a heavier, stiffer material that hangs straight. Also, people on Etsy are selling crate covers they've specifically made: Dog crate cover | Etsy

Con: Your dog will not be able to protect your home while locked in a crate.
We're training Ruger to sleep in his crate, yet with the crate door ajar for exactly that reason. He's still young, but he's catching on quickly.
 
Cons
  • Sleepless nights
Sleepless nights for the dog, not for the people... I hope! Although Ruger whined and whimpered and barked during the beginning of crate training we were mostly prepared. Yes, we had some miserable nights at first but then we learned to use all noise barriers that were at our disposal: ear plugs, floor fans, white noise making apps. We are able to shut out the noise of a NUCLEAR BOMB DROP now. We should have employed all that stuff from the start.

Now that we've had him a month he's quiet throughout the night.
 

Back
Top