• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Ecollar Use & Positive vs Negative Training

I guess i wasn't clear.. I don't disapprove of your training methods in the slightest, i just have a higher rate of success sticking with what i know and 100% positive reinforcement training is completely out of my realm of understanding.. Frankly i wish i had better success with it but im just old school and don't understand how or when to praise a dog when it pees on the floor. 50/50 is what works for me.. Scold and Praise when warranted.. For example going so far as to rub their noses in their own excrement on the other hand is plain abuse. I think my line is a reasonable one and pretty much how i raised my kids..
Understood, thank you for your opinion.
 
I look at it this way....
You know the bratty kids at the restaurant that won’t listen to their parents and disrupt the entire place? That's how positive reinforcement worked me.
Sure we start off positive, but once the dog knows what is expected, he's gonna know I'm not happy when he doesn't do it. Dogs are alot like kids and will test the boundaries every chance they get until they learn you are not going to put up with that crap.
 
Anyone who uses a prong or choke collar is also using negative training / corrective / punishment. I agree with @paintinsthegame to start out positive and only use corrective once they know what is expected of them.
To me the ecollar muscle stimulation at an appropriate setting isn't much different than a correction from a prong collar. Many ecollars have the ability to adjust the strength on the fly with either a dial or a 'boost' or both. Allowing the owner to give a softer correction and a harder correction. Just like one would with a prong collar. As an extreme example if your dog is in danger - say from getting hit by a car as you are walking, you'll give a very strong prong collar correction. Similarly if your dog is off lead on an ecollar and is about to run into danger, you give a very strong correction.
 
Even using a simple leash correction is negative training...

I look at ecollars, prongs, chokes, slip leads, etc. as a tool. Any tool can be used improperly. I never use a tool without using it on myself first. I know exactly what and how much I'm using on my dogs. I'm a chicken for shocks (yes even static electricity makes me cringe a little, lol) or pain of any kind so if I can handle it, I know my dog...who is usually in a high energy state of mind (speaking solely offleash training here)... can handle it.

I don't really use the e-collar for anything other than recall because recall to me is a life or death command that I cannot risk relying solely on my dog's obedience and hope she's obedient the one time I need her to be. It would be too late to observe and say "Woops, looks like I need a better recall" when my dog is chasing prey and runs into the road... Breaking a dog out of that state of mind is extremely hard to do...like a horse running with blinders on. It is in their instinct...if something runs fast...they chase!



I also like others always train using positive first. I teach the skill first by encouraging with rewards and building them up for success. Once they know a skill with great success, I discourage any disobedience by using correction. There are consequences for disobeying, just like there would be for a child who disobeyed their parent. I do this to build a healthy balance between positive and negative, and to be very clear in my communication with my dogs.

I think positive training is a great thing but 100% positive training only, to me, appears to be something that would take an extreme amount of effort and a lot of time to get the same results as using a healthy mix of styles of training. Time or risks that people honestly cannot take (such as offleash training through purely positive...). I've even joined training groups that promote "force and pain free motivational methods for sport/working dogs" to understand it more. It's certainly possible...but those people put in a lot of work to get to a fairly average level of training.

There is a reason there are very few positive only trainers that have reached a high level in titles. It takes an extreme amount of time, effort, energy and most likely takes the right kind of dog to perform at that level of training with absolutely no negative corrections.
 
Even using a simple leash correction is negative training...

I look at ecollars, prongs, chokes, slip leads, etc. as a tool. Any tool can be used improperly. I never use a tool without using it on myself first. I know exactly what and how much I'm using on my dogs. I'm a chicken for shocks (yes even static electricity makes me cringe a little, lol) or pain of any kind so if I can handle it, I know my dog...who is usually in a high energy state of mind (speaking solely offleash training here)... can handle it.

I don't really use the e-collar for anything other than recall because recall to me is a life or death command that I cannot risk relying solely on my dog's obedience and hope she's obedient the one time I need her to be. It would be too late to observe and say "Woops, looks like I need a better recall" when my dog is chasing prey and runs into the road... Breaking a dog out of that state of mind is extremely hard to do...like a horse running with blinders on. It is in their instinct...if something runs fast...they chase!



I also like others always train using positive first. I teach the skill first by encouraging with rewards and building them up for success. Once they know a skill with great success, I discourage any disobedience by using correction. There are consequences for disobeying, just like there would be for a child who disobeyed their parent. I do this to build a healthy balance between positive and negative, and to be very clear in my communication with my dogs.

I think positive training is a great thing but 100% positive training only, to me, appears to be something that would take an extreme amount of effort and a lot of time to get the same results as using a healthy mix of styles of training. Time or risks that people honestly cannot take (such as offleash training through purely positive...). I've even joined training groups that promote "force and pain free motivational methods for sport/working dogs" to understand it more. It's certainly possible...but those people put in a lot of work to get to a fairly average level of training.

There is a reason there are very few positive only trainers that have reached a high level in titles. It takes an extreme amount of time, effort, energy and most likely takes the right kind of dog to perform at that level of training with absolutely no negative corrections.

Well said! Not much more to add to that.
 
When the chiropractor hooked it up to my back my left leg was twitching and flopping like a fish out of water. It was very uncomfortable but didn't hurt. I called for the doc and asked him if that was normal or should it be turned down - he turned it down so apparently it wasn't normal lol

I know exactly what you are talking about here. I had the same on my neck and shoulder. It was my first Chiropractor visit and I didn't know what to expect! :bag: When they put that thing on me, it was so weird! She told me she would turn it up until I cried Uncle. LOL No, not really! :p But she did say until I thought it was too much. At first, I didn't like it at all! Then It started to feel good and she actually turned it up. But I know exactly what you mean about the 'fish flop' because one time it was a little too high and it was making a muscle in my face twerk. haha is that twerking?? Sorry, off topic.....lol Anyway, if that's what the e-collar I have feels like, that it not a "shock." It more of a strong vibration. But I have a 'Vibe' setting on their collar, so I'm not sure. All I know it I only use the Vibe anyway. If they were running towards the street or something dangerous, then I would use the other. But really, they are 'collar smart' anyway. :rolleyes:

Now, ask me if I tried the collar on myself.



I tried ...........

but chickened out. :anonymous :
 
Fair enough, I dont think you need to justify your opinion on such a controversial topic.. What's most important is that we use what works best for our individual personalities.. I can tell you i really messed up one of my past dogs by trying advice giving on forums, and ditching my old proven tried and true methods.. Go with what ya Know, I say..


I would respectfully disagree.. Its a shock plain and simple, and they are not even remotly pleasant (unless your 50 shades of freaky) :p .. its effective because its has a negative connotation , They don't like it therefore they are deterred form the unwanted behavior.. So i would call it Negative Reinforcement with a positive outcome. ;)
It's a philosophical question. Does the end justify the means? Or the means justify the end? An electric shock is an electric shock. It hurts. When I was growing up, my adoptive father used a razor strop on me. It did work, but it made me fearful and resentful. He might as well have used an electric collar. I believe that positive reinforcement should be used, and negative reinforcement rarely that doesn't involve pain, like spraying electric cords with bitter spray. I believe that pain should never be used for training. This is my personal opinion.
 
Any type of leash correction can be painful as well....prong, flat, choke....if used improperly. The same is true for the e-collar. Used correctly it is not painful, used incorrectly it can be very painful. But if my dog was running out in the street and not paying attention to my recall, I would use a strong shock to get his attention and save his life. The end would absolutely justify the means!

Positive training can only go so far, especially for the pet owner. I do not think positive training alone can be used to train off leash in the real world. A correction can save your dogs life, and stop many dangerous situations in their tracks. Positive training will not do that for the majority of pet owners.
 
To add to what @Dobie Wan Knobie said, I think it especially holds true for a dominant breed dog. You just have to be a strong leader or the dog will.

@kevn I'm sorry that happened to you as a child. For me, that is a perfect example the wrong way to use correction and the biggest reason people are so opposed to any kind of training with corrections. Our life style demands that my dogs listen to me immediately. I can't have them running off thinking it's okay because they will get their reward next time when they do it right. I believe you get much better results when there are consequences for bad behavior. I have never had to seriously correct my dogs because they understand what is expected. IMHO, based on what I have seen, when a dog is "over corrected" and doesn't understand what is expected and the handler gets frustrated. For me, it's time to go back to basics, not get mad and take it out on the dog.
 
Any type of leash correction can be painful as well....prong, flat, choke....if used improperly. The same is true for the e-collar. Used correctly it is not painful, used incorrectly it can be very painful. But if my dog was running out in the street and not paying attention to my recall, I would use a strong shock to get his attention and save his life. The end would absolutely justify the means!

Positive training can only go so far, especially for the pet owner. I do not think positive training alone can be used to train off leash in the real world. A correction can save your dogs life, and stop many dangerous situations in their tracks. Positive training will not do that for the majority of pet owners.
Well, said, @Dobie Wan Knobie
When I was growing up, my adoptive father used a razor strop on me. It did work, but it made me fearful and resentful. He might as well have used an electric collar.
I'm sorry that happened to you. :( But the difference there is that was abuse, not raising a child with corrections. That's a beating, not teaching a child right from wrong. You can teach that without touching a child and still call it 'corrections'. I'm a firm believer in reprimanding for a wrong doing, but certainly not beating. I'm a grandmother of 4 and they all know I love them, and they love me. But I'm also known for being fair and calling them out for a wrong doing. They don't gets spoiled in the wrong way from me. :) I dish out love and positive "training" all the time. But I believe in holding them responsible for wrongdoings too! :nono: I don't even have to touch them. It's a 'look' :tap: or a punishment. But if they were racing across a busy street, I just might be a bit harsher! Better than getting hit by a car!

An e-collar for most people who use it, is a last resort. Its the 'emergency brake' so to speak. Dogs must be trained before using the e-collar or they are using it wrong. It's not for you to sit back and just press a button. They should have recall training down pat. The e-collar is for those times when off leash, they spot a deer, are racing across a busy road, etc and you need to stop them! It's a way to 'reach out and touch' them before they are hurt or killed. My dogs are 'collar trained', meaning they've learned that they have the e-collar on. Most people try not to do that and I did too but it didn't work. They were too smart. lol But that's ok. I use it to my advantage. Buddy rarely wears it and his recall is good. Plus he knows his property (we live on 10 acres and he's always off leash) But if I am working in the yard and not watching him every minute, I put that collar on and I know he will stick closer to me. I don't even turn it on. ;) Same with Kali. But I use it on her more. That little dog is like the wind! And she is really why I bought the collar. Again, all I have to do is put the collar on her and she knows. Most of the time, I don't even turn it on. And if I have to use it, the Vibe setting is all I use. Its nothing. Not painful. I've felt it. All it is, is a reminder that I am calling her when she is dissing me.

We get a lot of wildlife here and if that collar saves their life one day, it's well worth it.
 
The comparison of using an ecollar to the Star Trek show when he was being shocked into submission (same with Planet of the Apes) is ludicrous. If you were to just start commanding a dog, and then shocking it as punishment, the dog would shut down. It would cower and be in such a state of fear it would not know what to do. You do not "shock" your dog into submission, just like you don't beat your dog into submission for wrong doing. You can tell when someone does not know how to train their dog, as they always walk around in a fearful cowering submissive, tail between the legs, position. Bad dog training happens with or without an ecollar.

As a trainer you have to have the skill sets to train with an ecollar, just like you have to have dog training skills to train any other style. No skill sets in training, no matter what style, and you will have a poorly trained dog, and that is a situation when people get frustrated and then make training mistakes that end up causing problems for you and the dog. The difference here is in Training Knowledge vs just slapping on a training devise and pushing buttons to get a reaction.

Study, learn, and then begin to train. But it is well established by all the professional trainers that I admire, that positive training alone is not satisfactory in a complete training program. But, that is just my 2 cents.
 
I missed the original thread. These are my 2 cents. We used just positive training and that only worked up to a point. Then we moved to a choke and a prong. But that caused other issues. Now we use the ecollar to reinforce what was we taught him. Nowadays I use it in bark mode and for off leash recall.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Any type of leash correction can be painful as well....prong, flat, choke....if used improperly. The same is true for the e-collar. Used correctly it is not painful, used incorrectly it can be very painful. But if my dog was running out in the street and not paying attention to my recall, I would use a strong shock to get his attention and save his life. The end would absolutely justify the means!

Positive training can only go so far, especially for the pet owner. I do not think positive training alone can be used to train off leash in the real world. A correction can save your dogs life, and stop many dangerous situations in their tracks. Positive training will not do that for the majority of pet owners.
Well said
 

Back
Top