Any type of leash correction can be painful as well....prong, flat, choke....if used improperly. The same is true for the e-collar. Used correctly it is not painful, used incorrectly it can be very painful. But if my dog was running out in the street and not paying attention to my recall, I would use a strong shock to get his attention and save his life. The end would absolutely justify the means!
Positive training can only go so far, especially for the pet owner. I do not think positive training alone can be used to train off leash in the real world. A correction can save your dogs life, and stop many dangerous situations in their tracks. Positive training will not do that for the majority of pet owners.
Well, said,
@Dobie Wan Knobie
When I was growing up, my adoptive father used a razor strop on me. It did work, but it made me fearful and resentful. He might as well have used an electric collar.
I'm sorry that happened to you.

But the difference there is that was abuse, not raising a child with corrections. That's a beating, not teaching a child right from wrong. You can teach that without touching a child and still call it 'corrections'. I'm a firm believer in reprimanding for a wrong doing, but certainly not beating. I'm a grandmother of 4 and they all know I love them, and they love me. But I'm also known for being fair and calling them out for a wrong doing. They don't gets spoiled in the wrong way from me.

I dish out love and positive "training" all the time. But I believe in holding them responsible for wrongdoings too!

I don't even have to touch them. It's a 'look'

or a punishment. But if they were racing across a busy street, I just might be a bit harsher! Better than getting hit by a car!
An e-collar for most people who use it, is a last resort. Its the 'emergency brake' so to speak. Dogs must be trained
before using the e-collar or they are using it wrong. It's not for you to sit back and just press a button. They should have recall training down pat. The e-collar is for those times when off leash, they spot a deer, are racing across a busy road, etc and you need to stop them! It's a way to 'reach out and touch' them before they are hurt or killed. My dogs are 'collar trained', meaning they've learned that they have the e-collar on. Most people try not to do that and I did too but it didn't work. They were too smart. lol But that's ok. I use it to my advantage. Buddy rarely wears it and his recall is good. Plus he knows his property (we live on 10 acres and he's always off leash) But if I am working in the yard and not watching him every minute, I put that collar on and I know he will stick closer to me. I don't even turn it on.

Same with Kali. But I use it on her more. That little dog is like the wind! And she is really why I bought the collar. Again, all I have to do is put the collar on her and she knows. Most of the time, I don't even turn it on. And if I have to use it, the Vibe setting is all I use. Its nothing. Not painful. I've felt it. All it is, is a reminder that I am calling her when she is dissing me.
We get a lot of wildlife here and if that collar saves their life one day, it's well worth it.