Other Breeds' Trainability

Gretchen_Red

Hot Topics Subscriber
MOD NOTE: A few posts may not make sense as they have been moved from another thread about energy levels of Dobermans

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If a dobe is too much I would suggest staying away from bull mastiffs. They are VERY powerful dogs and socialization isn't their strong suit. We had an Italian mastiff and if she ever truly wanted to break line she could! She weighed almost as much as me and was MUCH more powerful (and I'm a fitness instructor and consider myself pretty darn sting for a woman). Also, when a dobe attacks they can be called off when a mastiff attacks it's to kill. If you want something intimidating i would consider a rottie. Intimidating, strong, not super huge and they don't drool! Believe me the drooling and the "slinging of drool" everywhere is disgusting. I hope to never own another mastiff again! Even though my b/f wants a neopolitan after his French mastiff passes.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
:welcome: To DCF from Denver!

I personally think all Dobes are high energy, perhaps working lines a bit more but I can't speak to that since I've only owned from conformation lines.

If a dobe is too much I would suggest staying away from bull mastiffs. They are VERY powerful dogs and socialization isn't their strong suit. We had an Italian mastiff and if she ever truly wanted to break line she could! She weighed almost as much as me and was MUCH more powerful (and I'm a fitness instructor and consider myself pretty darn sting for a woman). Also, when a dobe attacks they can be called off when a mastiff attacks it's to kill. If you want something intimidating i would consider a rottie. Intimidating, strong, not super huge and they don't drool! Believe me the drooling and the "slinging of drool" everywhere is disgusting. I hope to never own another mastiff again! Even though my b/f wants a neopolitan after his French mastiff passes.
Lol rotties may not be tall but they are huge. They are extremely powerful. Also the second most dangerous dog breed. We have a rottie German import in my Schutzhund class and he is easily the scariest dog I have ever seen and he's two ! He's about 130 pounds of muscle and jaws.

My golden was sweet boy he had energy but not to the level of my dobie. I loved that dog and no drool.
 
That is on the very high side of the standard, females are much smaller ours was 80lbs We've never had an issue with our rot ties, as I have personally owned one and my neighbor did as well. One male one female and zero aggression. They are also highly trainable. Seen any bull mastiffs in your club? No? Do you know why? No off switch they attack to kill. There are many dogs I would allow in my house a bull mastiff isn't one of them, just my opinion.

When looking at an article about dangerous breeds it's also important to note the popularity of the breed. Many articles only go by attacks and don't take into account percentages.
 
My friend has a bull mastiff female she's very sweet wouldn't hurt a fly. But she got hers from a good breeder. I thinks that's a big part of it.
 
:welcome: To DCF from Denver!

I personally think all Dobes are high energy, perhaps working lines a bit more but I can't speak to that since I've only owned from conformation lines.

If a dobe is too much I would suggest staying away from bull mastiffs. They are VERY powerful dogs and socialization isn't their strong suit. We had an Italian mastiff and if she ever truly wanted to break line she could! She weighed almost as much as me and was MUCH more powerful (and I'm a fitness instructor and consider myself pretty darn sting for a woman). Also, when a dobe attacks they can be called off when a mastiff attacks it's to kill. If you want something intimidating i would consider a rottie. Intimidating, strong, not super huge and they don't drool! Believe me the drooling and the "slinging of drool" everywhere is disgusting. I hope to never own another mastiff again! Even though my b/f wants a neopolitan after his French mastiff passes.
How sure are you of that? What you wrote about Mastiffs when they attack? From what I've read, Bullmastiffs were actually bred to not bite, rather to knock down and hold the assailant. And, I haven't heard a lot about Mastiffs (I always think of English Mastiff when it's just called "Mastiff" as opposed to another specific kind) being aggressive.

I'd say also that Bullmastiffs aren't supposed to be a lot larger than Rotties as far as I know. You're not thinking of the English Mastif are you?

Could be said for any breed honestly :/
I sometimes say you never know what an animal is going to do. Same with humans.

SEPARATE POST BELOW:

Has anyone got a theory on the size of a young pup and its effect on the pup's temperament? I know on paper the answer is going to probably be there's no correlation, but it seems to me the smaller pups could be more scrappy. Maybe they're smaller because they burn more calories with their higher activity level? Two brothers of my pup were smaller and they were the ones that were the more aggressive/assertive ones.

With my first Dobe, I had pick of the litter (again, he was not from a reputable breeder). I chose the largest male pup who also happened to be the least energetic of the litter during my visit. He had a lot of energy like any Doberman will, but he really calmed down very well in the house (also a trait I think a lot of Dobes have, and I love).
 
I really hate to see the Bullmastiff's talked about poorly - the example of the negative experience one of you have had is definitely not characteristic of a well bred bullmastiff. However, it could be that in your region there are some poor quality examples, poor breeding, to which you have been an unfortunate witness. Tad is right, it isn't their modus operandi to maul and kill outright. That's not the way they go about things - not what they were originally bred to do. Anyway, sounds like you've been exposed to some poor examples, and I'm sorry about that. (FYI, I have learned that some lines have tighter lips and are less prone to drool issues - to the point that they really only drool after drinking or meals. Some, however, do have flappy dewlaps and the drool requires mopping.)
 
It's a known fact in dogs that mastiffs and pitbull Lack an "off" and it's the reason you don't see any in IPO/protection type sports. I haven't personally met someone who will work with one in IPO, they could be out there though. I wasn't talking ill, I was speaking facts. It's why I PERSONALLY wouldn't want one to step in front of me for protection, to each their own. My b/f loves mastiffs and my cousin has pits, all have been lovely dogs, still not ones I would personally want to own.

Also I didn't say you weren't you were weak, I was saying I'm in better shape than most and wouldn't want a dog that could over power me if it wanted.the same breed that lacks the off switch.

I'm actually around well bred dogs all the time, but thanks for judging, almost daily and on the weekends when I'm competing. I also have experience with a very well bred Italian mastiff and a not so well bred French mastiff. The French is a sweetie but their small build lacks intimidation to me due to her small size. The Italian was also very sweet but she wasn't a dog that was good around other dogs or people due to lack of socialization as a puppy.
 
How sure are you of that? What you wrote about Mastiffs when they attack? From what I've read, Bullmastiffs were actually bred to not bite, rather to knock down and hold the assailant. And, I haven't heard a lot about Mastiffs (I always think of English Mastiff when it's just called "Mastiff" as opposed to another specific kind) being aggressive.

I'd say also that Bullmastiffs aren't supposed to be a lot larger than Rotties as far as I know. You're not thinking of the English Mastif are you?


I sometimes say you never know what an animal is going to do. Same with humans.

SEPARATE POST BELOW:

Has anyone got a theory on the size of a young pup and its effect on the pup's temperament? I know on paper the answer is going to probably be there's no correlation, but it seems to me the smaller pups could be more scrappy. Maybe they're smaller because they burn more calories with their higher activity level? Two brothers of my pup were smaller and they were the ones that were the more aggressive/assertive ones.

With my first Dobe, I had pick of the litter (again, he was not from a reputable breeder). I chose the largest male pup who also happened to be the least energetic of the litter during my visit. He had a lot of energy like any Doberman will, but he really calmed down very well in the house (also a trait I think a lot of Dobes have, and I love).
Short mans syndrome ;)
 
It's sort of sad how often we can say something yet be misunderstood on a forum where all we can see is letters on the page. Ah well. The shortcomings of the internet.

Thanks folks.
 
It's a known fact in dogs that mastiffs and pitbull Lack an "off" and it's the reason you don't see any in IPO/protection type sports. I haven't personally met someone who will work with one in IPO, they could be out there though. I wasn't talking ill, I was speaking facts. It's why I PERSONALLY wouldn't want one to step in front of me for protection, to each their own. My b/f loves mastiffs and my cousin has pits, all have been lovely dogs, still not ones I would personally want to own.

Also I didn't say you weren't you were weak, I was saying I'm in better shape than most and wouldn't want a dog that could over power me if it wanted.the same breed that lacks the off switch.

I'm actually around well bred dogs all the time, but thanks for judging, almost daily and on the weekends when I'm competing. I also have experience with a very well bred Italian mastiff and a not so well bred French mastiff. The French is a sweetie but their small build lacks intimidation to me due to her small size. The Italian was also very sweet but she wasn't a dog that was good around other dogs or people due to lack of socialization as a puppy.
This is just interesting to me, that's all. I seek information. I didn't know that Mastiffs were considered to act the same as the Bully breeds. When it comes to Bully breeds (think Pit Bulls) I do believe that if they get engaged, they have the propensity to maul instead of just bite and disengage at some point. I know even that is a generalization, and some will disagree, but it's almost always Pits that you hear about mauling, and not just biting. Yes, I know there is a counter argument to that too regarding the media and statistics. But anyway, I think I agree with you about the "off switch" in Pits, generally speaking.

Now I do know that some Mastiffs have been guilty of mauling and killing humans in some nationally-known cases. I have heard of Canary Dogs (a type of Mastiff) doing it. I've heard other stories. But I guess I don't lump all Mastiffs, or Molosser-type dogs together. I consider most English Mastiffs quite docile and I don't have much "fear" of them. I also thought Bullmastiffs were not a real threat to maul. Again, generally speaking. But maybe some types of Mastiffs are more dangerous. I don't know much about most of them.

I have seen some Bully breeds in protection work and protection-oriented sports by the way.

What really concerns me is when you've got unsocialized Pits that escape their yards, and when you've got more than one together that get into a fight with another dog or a cat. Seems they get into a frenzy.

I forgot to say anything about the American Bulldog and the three main types of that breed. I really admire that breed – especially the hybrid, or sport type. The one that looks most like that traditional bulldog head, though, but are still that taller, larger athletic build, I have a fear of them. I understand they are really tough.

I've mentioned we fostered an American Bulldog / Pitt Bull female. She was pretty large with a nice big head. Picture a Pitt head with a bit of an underbite. Very sweet girl and actually lost a fight to a small male Husky while we had her. I guess she really didn't turn it on.

I also know she struggled with me trimming her nails, and on a few occasions actually made contact with my hands with her teeth. That was unnerving. But she didn't go mano or anything.
 
Personally I think any breed dog can be trained to 'turn off'. Even Pitbulls that were once fighting dogs can be rehabilitated. I think 49 of 50 of the pitbulls found in the Micheal Vick case were rehabilitated.
I'm sure it would be difficult to IPO train a Mastiff but I believe mostly because of the size. It would have to probably take 2+ people to hold a Mastiff back on an agitation harness. It would have to take a very large and brave person to hold a bite sleeve with a Mastiff charging full speed at you. Not sure how they would handle the A-Frame but can't imagine they can do any of the jumps. Many places won't even train Rottweilers.
I think there are more pits in IPO than one might imagine. Seems everybody has a pit or pit mix these days, at least where I live. Well not 'everybody' but ya know.
Here's a pit going for IPO2

What really concerns me is when you've got unsocialized Pits that escape their yards, and when you've got more than one together that get into a fight with another dog or a cat. Seems they get into a frenzy.
I'd be concerned with many breeds of unsocialized that escape their yards. I think the more than one together goes for dogs in general. I know at the dog park I go to when 2 dogs are playing rough and one is obviously loosing, often other dogs of various breeds join in and 'pick on' the one that is already loosing. Unless if the loosing dog has one of its pack members (lives in same house) at the park, then I've noticed that dog will often jump in to protect the one loosing.
Wouldn't it be great if we knew what they are thinking? Is it just a survival of the fittest instinct thing?
 
I think a larger type of Mastiff like the English would not do well at IPO. Think of all that running. Speed and agility is prized as well, hence the smaller size of the Dobermans that excel in the sport. It just doesn't seem in the nature of a big English Mastiff to do all that athletic work. Maybe a small one.

It's hard to picture something like a Neopolitan Mastiff charging around the Schutzhund field making hard turns to check the blinds. :rofl: Then there'd be the waiting around for the dog to reach the handler on the long bite. :whoop:
 
I'm sure it would be difficult to IPO train a Mastiff but I believe mostly because of the size. It would have to probably take 2+ people to hold a Mastiff back on an agitation harness. It would have to take a very large and brave person to hold a bite sleeve with a Mastiff charging full speed at you. Not sure how they would handle the A-Frame but can't imagine they can do any of the jumps.
Difficult but not impossible.I recall a video posted here on one of the K-9 Brawl events our own @Silent Dobe posted and attended one of the gals at the event was working a Neo Mastiff in IPO.Looked like that dog was doing just fine.Maybe she see's this and comments?


Here you go,pretty sure she said that black dog with the gal with longer dark hair was a Neo?
And hey,an excuse to watch the awesomeness that is Silence and Jerry Lee doing their job for mama.
 
Difficult but not impossible.I recall a video posted here on one of the K-9 Brawl events our own @Silent Dobe posted and attended one of the gals at the event was working a Neo Mastiff in IPO.Looked like that dog was doing just fine.Maybe she see's this and comments?


Here you go,pretty sure she said that black dog with the gal with longer dark hair was a Neo?
And hey,an excuse to watch the awesomeness that is Silence and Jerry Lee doing their job for mama.
That was fun! Awesome. Hmmm. If that was a Neo it was a lot less profuse in the jowel department than that for which the breed is known. Could that have been a Corso?
 
That was fun! Awesome. Hmmm. If that was a Neo it was a lot less profuse in the jowel department than that for which the breed is known. Could that have been a Corso?
Crap.I think you are correct.My mistake.
 
That is Angie's dog Dozer. Had pizza with her and Waine last night. Dozer is a Cane Corso. It helps that Angie's trainer and boyfriend is Waine Singleton who we are here to train with this weekend.
You don't see the mastiffs and bigger breeds in the sport mainly because the sport is based on speed. You lose points if your dog doesn't do the exercises quickly. Catching a larger breed dog is much easier than a Mal or Dobe coming full speed.



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Here are some pictures of Dozer .
0437a80f5ba202f0fb7cc4901b6ff4c8.jpg

f26328d36eb4407d4e2f5823b7910e42.jpg

90ba40ca47f6a1c95d1b5be41c3654d0.jpg

6bf5d2eb9d5f1da83299da629f9a0a70.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Back
Top