My Dobie Has Bitten Someone - Help

Casky73

Jr Member
Hi everyone

My beautiful girl has turned 2 and for the last 2-3 months has been showing aggression towards me. I've been told she's trying it on coz she's a teenager so I've persevered with her. She has, on more than one occasion bared her teeth and growled at me. I have been advised via this site she's a working line breed. My brother has been looking after her whole I've been away for 3 days, today she did something wrong and he smacked her on her bottom, she grabbed him my the arm and bit him. He threw her outside. He's worried as am I that if she does that to the children or me we don't have the strength to get her off and she's a big girl. I'm devastated. Ive trained her since she was 8 weeks old and I love her to bits but can I afford to put her before the safety of my children. Please any suggestions. Since the aggressive side has come out she doesn't pay don't attention to me when we are out, she refuses to come back. It's like she's not had a day of training in her life which is very frustrating. I know when my partner finds out he will say get rid, if I keep her and she goes for the girls I will never forgive myself.
 
At 2 she is no teenager. She has fully matured and is now taking over so your training was not correct and did not establish a strong bond and pack order. Talk to your breeder - it is no excuse that she a working line breed. What titles and training did the sire and/or dam have to help evaluate temperament??? This starts with the breeder and ends with you. At this point you are headed for trouble if you have trained her and are still getting this reaction.

YOU NEVER HIT A DOG - period. That is a challenge and the bite was therefore provoked. When we loose control why should we be surprised that the dog lost it too!!! It is like two children fighting - once it escalates it is too late. Throwing her outside taught her nothing either.

At this point I would start with a talk with the breeder ... if they are breeding working lines then they should darn well have proven the line through training and titling. If not then this is how much of this stuff happens. People breeding what they have no true understanding of. If the breeder can't help you and even if they do, you need to find a good trainer (preferably a working dog trainer) to help you reestablish correct communication. The dog is clearly saying she does not respect you or trust you so there was a definite breakdown in your training program.

Loving these dogs is not enough to fulfill their true nature as a protective breed. Until you get help have her crated when the kids are around for sure - I would never want to see a child hurt for any reason. Check out the NILIF (nothing in life is free training) but again you need more help than just this - hopefully there is a trainer in your area who can help you evaluate and train the dog.
A working dog is frustrated if they do not work it is one of the biggest reasoning the working lines are not for the novice dog owner.
 
I have tried to contact the breeder he never responds to calls or texts so I gave up on that one. I took her training and stopped correcting her with smacking and did it by sounds and body language. I know the mistakes are mine, I've never owned a Doberman before and I've done the best I can. She hasn't growled at me for awhile, when she has I put her in a separate room and ignore her as she doesn't like being away from me. I was snout to start new training after my holiday. I told my brother u can't be aggressive towards her as she responds in the same way. Everyone is saying I've humanised her, mainly my family. I allowed her on the couch and we loved cuddle time. My partner doesn't like her on the couch and we have recently moved house and there has been a lot of changes not sure if this would make a difference. She never barked in our old house, in the new house she parades around the fence area barking and launching herself at the fence and she won't stop when told. It's like she's a completely different dog. There has been an immense amount of stress in the house too from me as I'm going though a very hard time at the moment and I'm absolutely convinced she understands that. When I have been upset she cuddles into me and rubs her face on mine. Maybe my emotional state isn't helping but right now I can't help that until my situation is resolved
 
Doberman's are super sensitive and in tune with their owners. Stress begets stress. May I ask who is the breeder??? What training or titling had he done? People need to know when someone does not try to help out their clients. Putting her in a separate room will not resolve the problem. It is still festering and will bubble over at some point. If someone in the house does not like her then PROBLEM and tension in the house - They are dogs they are not humans.

If I read this correctly your method of discipline is to smack her - glad to hear you have changed from that for sure as that is definitely part of your problem. You need to enroll both of you in a training class as you need outside help.

Having said that I sleep with my guys and there has never ever been a problem but I know how to train and handle a dog. But I also clearly understand who pays the bills so who is the leader. Calm - confident - self-assured creates a happy well balanced dog. But if I tell them to get down I expect them to do just that or they will be shocked at my response and follow through BUT never ever do I raise my hand to them.
 
Yes dogs can pick up on your emotional state and your stress so you need to be in a totally relaxed and confidant state of mind before you work with them (any breed). I also agree that swatting them or any kind of negative training can make them insecure and defensive so I'd try to find a good trainer who uses positive reinforcement and try starting from square one.

Good luck and let us know how it goes.
 
I didn't smack her from the beginning, I used to just make a shush sound from when she was 8 weeks old and that seemed to be enough. I didn't need to smack her I just rewarded her good behaviour. I took her to a local trainer and they told me I was telling her off to much and it was during that training that she started to bite me and the kids. I told the trainer and they told me to tie her to a lamp post and walk away and tell her she was unlucky. I said there had to be some other way to stop this behaviour as if she bites another child and hurts them it will be definitely unlucky as she will be put down. I went to another trainer where we did clicker training and at the weekend I have started to reinforce that. I have also gone back over the training we did together prior to us moving and she seems very settled. I was confident with her from a young age but I have had a lot of different people telling me I am not disciplining her enough, she is too humanised, she needs a strong arm, I tell her off too much, I shouldn't have her on the couch, I don't know whether I am coming or going, no wonder she is confused.

I did a lot of mental training with her to tire her out as you guys gave me great advice on this as it is very difficult tire her out just through exercise and she was pacing back and forward after a 2 hour run. Yesterday we all went for a bike ride and took her on her lead for a run with the bikes, she was fantastic. I did more re-enforced training and she was good. I have tried to explain to my new partner (of 8 months), that Calah was the one thing that has kept me strong and kept me going over the last 2 years. Just sitting and stroking her and getting that affection from her de-stresses me and she enjoys it too. My partner and my brother have told me that because I have her on the couch at the same time as my partner, I'm putting the dog before him, which seems ridiculous to me. So that routine of us training and then sitting on the couch for a cuddle has pretty much stopped.

I spoke to my mum and she said the dog has gone through a lot of changes and perhaps I am listening to everyone else too much.

Just seems I can't get anything right at the moment. My partner has said how much work do I want to put in to her and effort or chances with the other stresses I am going through. In my head as much as possible because she is my baby, am I wrong. Sorry guys but hopefully you can see why both Calah and myself are very confused. It makes me angry so why would she feel any different. There is a trainer near me I have found out about, I will be calling him to get some feedback.
 
I took her to a local trainer and they told me I was telling her off to much and it was during that training that she started to bite me and the kids. I told the trainer and they told me to tie her to a lamp post and walk away and tell her she was unlucky.
:eek::shakinghead::shakinghead: If someone told me that I'd be tying HIM to a tree! LOL Stupid advice. :shakinghead:

It sounds like you may have 'humanized' her a bit and in doing that she has taken over the Pack Leader role. I'd go back to basics with Nothing In Life Is Free. http://k9deb.com/nilif.htm Regain your Leader status and her the follower. She's a smart dog and should catch on quickly if you pull rank. And mean it.

You can still coddle and pet your dog........but only when she is calm and obedient.
 
Since the aggressive side has come out she doesn't pay don't attention to me when we are out, she refuses to come back.

That right there shows she's dissing you as Pack Leader. NILF will put her back in her rightful place but you must follow through.
 
Thanks everyone. I definitely don't reward her by cuddles if she has been naughty, she has to stay in her bed. I have started the training again yesterday and we had a really enjoyable run. I ran her around the lake and then I let her off, threw the stick into the water and told her to fetch, I told her to touch (she responds better to that than come) and then I clicked and rewarded her, we did that 5 more times and each time she came back, I clicked and rewarded. She ran off round the corner and I must admit I thought shit here we go another 2 hours to get her back. But she didn't she came back straight away, I clicked and rewarded her. So all in all it was a good day. The girls went to play in the park, so I continued doing training with her, told her close, she stays close to my side, click and reward, turn, sit, down, lie down (she plays dead), each time clicking and rewarding. I really enjoyed it. I took her over to play with some dogs, she has an awful habit of constantly barking in their face to get them to play. When she did I pulled her lead with a quick snap and said no. I made her sit and wait then rewarded her by letting her play, I repeated this until she stopped barking. She learns very quickly. Not sure how to stop her barking in the garden coz I can't get near her to check her as she runs out of the way.
 
She has, on more than one occasion bared her teeth and growled at me.
This too. Doing that to other people is one thing. But when a dog does this to its own owner, IMO the dog has no respect for you. You love her, I know, but she is seeing you as weak. You need to show her you are a strong confident owner and its done without yelling, hitting or tying to a tree. It comes from within. I always like to use this as an example: When you are in a store, looking for a sales clerk to help you with a difficult problem, don't you look around and sort of 'weed out' a few clerks before you finally see one that you think "looks" like they know what they are talking about?? That's because, even without talking to them, you can see leadership, confidence oozing from them. :D That's what your dog needs to see from you. :)


Not sure how to stop her barking in the garden coz I can't get near her to check her as she runs out of the way.
She should be training on leash so she doesn't get away with stuff like this.

Read this:
http://doberman-chat.com/community/threads/how-to-teach-you-dog-not-to-come.4089/

You will see some of the mistakes we all tend to make. :)
 
I've done all of them eek!! I bought a long line, so each time she goes in the garden I will put her long line on until she gets it. I am confident when I start training her then other people tell me their opinions and it makes me doubt what I m doing. New lesson, only follow those that know what they are doing. Keep doing the training I was doing that worked and listen to you guys. Thanks :)
 
I know it can be confusing when you have so many people telling you different things, but they are not Doberman owners and most likely don't understand the breed so they shouldn't be giving you advice. I can tell you're trying to do the right thing but conflicting advice makes it very hard to know which direction to go and stick with it.

Consistency and time is your best method and she needs to respect you, but there's no reason you can't snuggle with her on the couch either. If our dogs start questioning me no matter where they are (on the couch or working) I'll let them know it's not acceptable. Once you have her total respect and understanding it will all come together and things will get easier. :)
 
Some advise from a fellow Doberman owner. Never hit your dog, it's just not a good training method. Dog fighters hit their dogs to make them more aggressive. I'm guessing a more aggressive dog is not your goal. Your dog needs to want to work for you. You need to encourage this behaviour. Meaning every time the dog does something you like = praise also EVERY time they do something you don't like discipline. Since your dog sounds pretty headstrong you may need to yell very loudly and strongly to get their attention (at first) to let them know that they've done something wrong. Over time taper the yelling down if you do it right eventually all you'll need to do is stand up and just stare at the dog and they'll instantly know you're upset.
 
Dogs are not deaf - yelling creates a problem as in dog language it mean you are excited - in high gear and out of control which will only make the dog follow suit. All commands and corrections should be in a normal tone of voice. It is why yelling at your kids does not work. They don't listen til you yell which shows you have not control. Speak softly and carry a big stick!!! I did not say use the stick just carry it. It represents authority and would allow you to block a dog that tried to bite.

A dog should be taught to obey on the first command not the 5th or the loudest command. THE FIRST time you ask enforce it. Stay with them til the comply - Don't just keep asking - Teach them that the faster they respond the faster they get their treat. Make it positive. DO NOT YELL and DO NOT HIT a dog ever. You loose all respect
 
Yelling (or maybe a better word is shouting) can be a very effective training tool to gain instant attention. Especially with a dog that has never really seen discipline. This is why all branches of the military use it to train new recruits.

If this dog is attacking it's owner there is a leadership issue happening. The dog does not view the owner as a person they should follow or respect.

Yelling or shouting "NO" and following through with the command is what this dog is looking for. Over time the over the top Yelling should be stopped. The yelling is just done to quickly gain the dogs attention in a way they've never seen before. Once the dog respects their owner you will not longer need to yell or use your voice sharply. The dog will want to work for you and will instantly read your body movements.

While I agree things like clicker training or giving treats can be effective. In this case the dogs owner needs to reestablish themselves as the leader. One this occurs more standard types of training can be implemented.
 
Just remember that your dog goes off of your emotions so if you tense up or stress out every time she is around someone it could lead to her feeling like she needs to do the same thing. In the case of her nipping/biting you or family members were they around something that she feels is her possession? If that is the case you could try and take those away and only give them back to her when you decide she should have them. This show that you are in charge of she has. It appears to me that you are doing a lot of different things to help her out just remember don't give up on her because it could cause her to continue that behavior or get more aggressive which will result in her being put down. You drive the relationship and if you reinforce that she will come around :) Keep up new training regimen and excerising her on a daily basis and it should help with these issues:thumbsup:
 
She doesn't have any toys she is possessive about and sits and waits for her food and will wait until I tell her she can take it. If I tell her to get in her bed I now only have to click my fingers and point and she gets in her bed, if she tries it on by getting out, I get up and as soon as I do she lies in her bed and settles. She hasn't been aggressive towards me for a about a month, the only issue I have with her now is her bolting if the door is open and if she is let off lead she decides she hasn't had long enough and won't come back. So I'm keeping her on the lead and doing training with her until she is obedient. She is very clever though, she comes back every time when she is on the lead, as soon as she is off she's gone!! My issue with my brother is that he provoked her, he had something to prove which was that he is great with dogs and he came off worse. I told him you can't show aggression towards her because she will respond the same. For him to ignore that and do it anyway was losing mine and Calah's trust. I won't ask him to look after her again!

She has always been very possessive of my time and affection. If I am cuddling the girls she comes over and joins in or sticks her nose in between us, if we ignore her she starts to bark and then nips my bum, not hard just enough to say "mum I'm here you know". When we came back from holiday, I fused her and then the girls and I were cuddling and she started to bark, so I ignored her, she got louder and I just put my finger in the air and she stopped. After looking at the NILF I should have just kept ignoring her, I will do this from now on.
 
Sounds like she is a very clever girl! Kunnar is very needy when it comes to my affections and he does the same things so I know what you are going thru on that aspect of it! I am glad she isn't being aggressive towards you anymore! I am glad she is responding to your training and that you didn't give up on her! That is what makes a wonderful Doberman owner!!! Can't wait to hear more about what she is up to!
 
I haven't had time to read through all the posts....so please forgive me if this has been asked and answered already. But have you considered boarding her at a facility where they do training and address behavior issues. I know we have an excellent one here called Richardson K-9 in Ohio. Very inexpensive and the boarding fee includes lessons that he will give you too. You can board there for as little or as long as you like. I can try to help you find something like this in your area if you message me.
 

Back
Top