Educator (formerly Einstein) Remote Training Collars

Ingrid H

Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
If I can't get my old Dogtra training collar working again (hopefully just a $20 battery for the receiver), I'm considering one of these models:
http://leerburg.com/electric_einstein.htm

Some models have a tone and some have what they call "tap" which I guess is only slightly different from a vibrate mode. All models have a nick or continuous stimulation.

I already use a verbal warning before giving a correction, so I'm thinking an audible tone might be good coming from a collar. This "tap" thing might also be a good attention getter

Does anyone have experience with tone vs. vibrate on an e-collar?
 
I don't have personal experience but I have a friend up in Colorado that has one with the vibrate feature.
His Rottie is deaf and they live on a fairly large fenced and wooded parcel of land.It works great for him to get the boys attention to look for a sign command.Sometimes he can be a half acre away,one little blip and he's looking towards the house for someone to sign him.

I should add,I'm not sure of the brand?
 
The vibration must be a god-send for the owner of a deaf dog! I could see it used for marking correct behavior or as an attention getter.

The Einstien/Educator brand is fairly new on the market, but I totally trust Leerburg's endorsement of the product.
 
The vibration must be a god-send for the owner of a deaf dog! I could see it used for marking correct behavior or as an attention getter.

The Einstien/Educator brand is fairly new on the market, but I totally trust Leerburg's endorsement of the product.
Absolutely.
It's a little off topic.That dog had gone through a few owners.Everyone claimed he didn't mind and was unruly.He heard about the dog through a friend who knew they were Rottie fans and told them he was going to go to a shelter.So they went and got him from the owner.
Sure enough the dog wouldn't mind,paid no attention to verbal command.Took him and his wife a few days to figure it out.He wasn't disobedient he couldn't hear..anything.
Once they figured it out his wife went online and started learning sign language and sign command.
He (the dog ) responded instantly when being taught and improved every hour.
Their only issue was when he was outdoors.That collar saved the day there!
 
Absolutely.
It's a little off topic.That dog had gone through a few owners.Everyone claimed he didn't mind and was unruly.He heard about the dog through a friend who knew they were Rottie fans and told them he was going to go to a shelter.So they went and got him from the owner.
Sure enough the dog wouldn't mind,paid no attention to verbal command.Took him and his wife a few days to figure it out.He wasn't disobedient he couldn't hear..anything.
Once they figured it out his wife went online and started learning sign language and sign command.
He (the dog ) responded instantly when being taught and improved every hour.
Their only issue was when he was outdoors.That collar saved the day there!
That's awesome! I bet the dog was really happy when somebody finally communicated in a way he could relate to and respond to.
 
I just bought the sport dog 850. it has the tone, vibrate, and then static if you need it. Absolutely love it. Hardly ever have to use the static, unless theres a squirel or rabbit that runs by us.
 
I like their range of functions, but the collars are super bulky and so are the receivers. They are hard to hold, nick at the right time and at the right level. I wouldn't use this brand because of that difficulty. But to each their own. Try it out, it may be for you. I have smaller hands, and with some of my disability things going on I would tend to drop something like this a lot.
 
I like their range of functions, but the collars are super bulky and so are the receivers. They are hard to hold, nick at the right time and at the right level. I wouldn't use this brand because of that difficulty. But to each their own. Try it out, it may be for you. I have smaller hands, and with some of my disability things going on I would tend to drop something like this a lot.

Are you referring to the Educator/Einstein brand?
 
I've never heard of it, but just the pics I was looking at, I don't get the remote. Of course I'm guessing the top has different buttons like we have on the front with the Dogtra.

I bet all you need is a battery for the Dogtra, and I bet if that doesn't do it they'd replace it for you.
 
I've never heard of it, but just the pics I was looking at, I don't get the remote. Of course I'm guessing the top has different buttons like we have on the front with the Dogtra.

I bet all you need is a battery for the Dogtra, and I bet if that doesn't do it they'd replace it for you.
The Educator/Einstein's hand-held remote is supposed to be designed like a stopwatch. I'm only barely old enough to have used a real stopwatch before they went digital, so I don't know how they expect people under 50 years old to relate to the design. But there is a feature on the Einstein that my Dogtra doesn't have. It's gives tone or vibration (depending on the model) followed by a nick in a set amount of time. A feature like that would fit right in with my current training style. I currently give a verbal warning before a nick, but that's only good if my dogs are in sight and sound. That feature could work the same way when they are out of sight and sound as a warning to hightail it back to me.
 
I have an Einstein 400 and I love it. When you place it in your hand it is really easy to hit the button that you want. Who do not have to worry to much about hitting the wrong one like some of the others that you have to slide your finger. I know the 400 is very small. I like the vibrate. I wanted something complete different then a sound. From what I know (very little) most people who do the sound are for hunting dogs. I know most Ob people use the vibrate option.

PS I am under 50 and I have used a stop watch and I can relate to the design.
 
I have an Einstein 400 and I love it. When you place it in your hand it is really easy to hit the button that you want. Who do not have to worry to much about hitting the wrong one like some of the others that you have to slide your finger. I know the 400 is very small. I like the vibrate. I wanted something complete different then a sound. From what I know (very little) most people who do the sound are for hunting dogs. I know most Ob people use the vibrate option.

PS I am under 50 and I have used a stop watch and I can relate to the design.
That's interesting about the hunting dog people liking the tone because Einstein's model for hunting dogs has tone rather than vibrate. What do you use vibrate mode for with your dog?
 
It is a warning for me. My female is not the most stable dog and I do not see on her being anything else without a ton of conflict. I also got it because I needed some control of her off leash without the fear of being bitten. I have heard of people using it as a re enforcer just do not know of any in person. My female comes running to me when ever she gets vibrated from day one. So that helps a lot with her their.

I do not see a place where I do not think my dog could not hear me and the collar will reach. In that case I will stick with the vibrate over the tone because I can always use my voice in my mind and having another tool is always nice.
 
It is a warning for me. My female is not the most stable dog and I do not see on her being anything else without a ton of conflict. I also got it because I needed some control of her off leash without the fear of being bitten. I have heard of people using it as a re enforcer just do not know of any in person. My female comes running to me when ever she gets vibrated from day one. So that helps a lot with her their.

I do not see a place where I do not think my dog could not hear me and the collar will reach. In that case I will stick with the vibrate over the tone because I can always use my voice in my mind and having another tool is always nice.
That's a good point you have about your voice being just as good as a tone if the dog is in ear-shot. I too have heard of vibrate being used as a sort of positive marker, but I'd probably use it as a warning like you do too.
 

Back
Top