Prong aka Training collars

Snoops

Member
I might get roasted but wanted to share my experience.
Just wanted to say after alot of research and investigation and thousands of YouTube videos into these training collars I went ahead and purchased one.

For 7 months solid I tried to train my Dog to walk calmly on a lead. All good at home and near our house. Take the Dog to the park or any other place with lots of stimulation it was a nightmare.

On wet ground I have slipped a few times, and others with not enough strength can no longer take Bella out.

Ordered a Herm Springer from Leerberg.
When it arrived before it was going any where near my dog I tried it on me.

The prongs are rounded and blunt.
I then proceeded to put it on my arm, leg and neck and began to pull.
On a choke chain you can feel the pain, on this collar the pressure is evenly distributed and I felt no discomfort at all.

Left it on her, and gave her treats. She did not even know it was on.

Progressed to the streets where she pulls and it was a miracle. I did not even have to correct. The collar did that and then for the rest of the walk, the longest and fastest ever it was amazing.

Today took her to the park. To get to fields to run around usually took me 30mins and alot of bicep workout, hip yanks and slippery skids.
Today straight down in 10mins.
Took it off in the fields and viola an amazing And enjoyable time in the park.

I think these collars get a very bad rap as most times people may misus them or buy the wrong type.

1) make sure it's snug at top of head under ears.
2) don't skimp on quality. Herm Sprenger seems to be excellent quality and blunt, bent prongs.
3) no yanking. Only very gentle corrections or let the collar do it
4) for training , walking only. Not to be left out or while they play.

I will also continue training on a flat collar, just easier so I do t have to take collars on and off but right now I'm very very impressed.

Those that know me, will know I love my Dog and would never ever hurt it.

Got a lady at park that was not impressed with my choice and did not want to be educated or for me to demonstrate it on myself. However she did have to agree Bella walks very nicely.

I know these are used alot in the States but less common in the UK.

Do you find after a while, it's not needed anymore and the Dog walks to heel?
 
I was a 4H leader / dog trainer until last year. I started every 4H year giving a demo where I put the prong collar on my forearm and yanked on it very hard to prove it didn't injure the dog. We couldn't use prong collars in 4H, so I did the demonstration to dispel the idea that they were cruel (and hoped the kids and parents train with them at home off the 4H premises).

When dogs mature enough, I use a wide martingale or buckle collars for walks. I don't use choke collars because the dogs gasp for breath if they start pulling. Sometimes I keep the prong collar in my pocket for 'just in case' if I have a very active dog.

My only comment on your excellent post is for 3) make it no nagging. Sharp snaps when needed instead of constant pressure.

Me and my eight month old puppy AJ training with a prong collar.

RS_20181214_201641-AJAndMeAtGoldenRule.webp
 
I have used a prong collar for years on multiple dobies. I have found there is much less pulling compared to using a choke collar. I have never had a problem and to this day I still use a prong collar.
 
I might get roasted but wanted to share my experience.
Just wanted to say after alot of research and investigation and thousands of YouTube videos into these training collars I went ahead and purchased one.

For 7 months solid I tried to train my Dog to walk calmly on a lead. All good at home and near our house. Take the Dog to the park or any other place with lots of stimulation it was a nightmare.

On wet ground I have slipped a few times, and others with not enough strength can no longer take Bella out.

Ordered a Herm Springer from Leerberg.
When it arrived before it was going any where near my dog I tried it on me.

The prongs are rounded and blunt.
I then proceeded to put it on my arm, leg and neck and began to pull.
On a choke chain you can feel the pain, on this collar the pressure is evenly distributed and I felt no discomfort at all.

Left it on her, and gave her treats. She did not even know it was on.

Progressed to the streets where she pulls and it was a miracle. I did not even have to correct. The collar did that and then for the rest of the walk, the longest and fastest ever it was amazing.

Today took her to the park. To get to fields to run around usually took me 30mins and alot of bicep workout, hip yanks and slippery skids.
Today straight down in 10mins.
Took it off in the fields and viola an amazing And enjoyable time in the park.

I think these collars get a very bad rap as most times people may misus them or buy the wrong type.

1) make sure it's snug at top of head under ears.
2) don't skimp on quality. Herm Sprenger seems to be excellent quality and blunt, bent prongs.
3) no yanking. Only very gentle corrections or let the collar do it
4) for training , walking only. Not to be left out or while they play.

I will also continue training on a flat collar, just easier so I do t have to take collars on and off but right now I'm very very impressed.

Those that know me, will know I love my Dog and would never ever hurt it.

Got a lady at park that was not impressed with my choice and did not want to be educated or for me to demonstrate it on myself. However she did have to agree Bella walks very nicely.

I know these are used alot in the States but less common in the UK.

Do you find after a while, it's not needed anymore and the Dog walks to heel?
Be carful leaving on in the House. Ours has got hung on everything you can imagine. And yes they do work great.
 
All of our dogs wear print collars if we are taking them out in public. Blaze usually just wears his ecollar and leather collar when we go out but I can take him out on just his leather collar, he knows what happens if his leash ever gets tight. He also knows he must stay by my side unless I give him a command to roam around but still must maintain a loose leash.
 
Great thread! I totally agree with all above, but we really need an education here in Australia. You can buy choke chains in endless variations, but it is illegal to import a prong collar. As far as I know it is not illegal to use one, but you will attract some pretty nasty comments from people who don't know how it works, (and aren't real interested often), so I have started to use a neck gaiter to cover it when walking in public places. And lets face it, that is when you really need it! @Tropicalbri's gave me this brilliant idea, many thanks to her. :thumbsup:

Really annoying is the fact that I did manage to buy a prong collar online and, gladly, it somehow dodged the regulations, but now I would like to buy a herm sprenger microprong. Found the one I would like online and find that they can't ship to Australia. Bugger! (This is an Australian term for things that displease!) :banghead::banghead::banghead:
 
The dog trainer we use is vehemently against prong collars (in class, we still use one on Rubie when we're out and about) but our friends with a Dobe puppy who's almost a year just told me that they're not getting anywhere with leash walking training and are going to try the prong. I feel bad that she was almost embarrassed to say that because it's just another training tool. I hate that people think you're a lazy dog owner if you've 'resorted' to using a prong collar :rolleyes:
 
The dog trainer we use is vehemently against prong collars (in class, we still use one on Rubie when we're out and about) but our friends with a Dobe puppy who's almost a year just told me that they're not getting anywhere with leash walking training and are going to try the prong. I feel bad that she was almost embarrassed to say that because it's just another training tool. I hate that people think you're a lazy dog owner if you've 'resorted' to using a prong collar :rolleyes:
Without the Prong collar and using just a choke collar our dog pulls hard enough to choke himself. I would much rather use a Prong collar and eliminate the choking.
 
There happens to be another current thread also on this topic right now.

This has always made me shake my head – the notion that prong collars are cruel or hurt a dog. It's a totally fact-free, emotional response to the appearance of the collar. At the same time, it's so weird, because I see prong collars used VERY commonly on all sorts of dogs in all sort of average, every day situations. Walk down the street and see your typical Labs and Doodles with prongs on. Go to the farmers' market and see tons of them on. The brewery taproom, the pet supply store: See plenty of dogs with prongs on. So it's just a weird thing.

Heck, as a part-time dog walker, the majority of the clients I have had use prongs. This has ranged from short, squat English Bulldogs to a 14 year old Labrador. Honestly, I do feel embarrassed walking a dog with a prong collar as their primary, everyday collar. It is a training tool and not just the collar you slap on your dog every time you leave the house. But I do as my clients wish.

I would be lying, by the way, if I said I did not feel that using a prong collar out in public is admitting to the world that I have a problem and cannot solve it without this tool. But then, I am very prideful when it comes to my Dobe and my training.
 
Many years ago I bought a prong collar to use on my German Shepherd. I didn’t know then that it was a knock-off and inferior to the German Herm Sprenger (HS) prong collar. The prong ends were sharp as if cut with bolt cutters. I now have a female Dobermann who is strong and a puller. I used the small HS on her as a puppy then upgraded to a large. That was a mistake as the large is only for big dogs over 55kg like Great Danes, etc. I purchased a medium and it is just right for her. I was a fan of choke chains but this girl pulls hard until she chokes herself and cuts off her air supply. I’ve given up on slip collars, choke chains, and shoulder harnesses. Prong collars are less brutal on a dog and work a treat. People who think that they are inhumane and cruel have little knowledge of training tools. I also have a flat collar that is a quick release military attack collar but wow does she pull when that one is on her. It does more damage to her (trachea) than a prong collar ever will; I like it because it has a grab handle to hold her back. However, my regular daily use collar is a prong collar. Just make sure you buy a genuine German collar and not a Chinese copy.

If you are in Australia and looking to buy a large Herm Sprenger prong collar suitable for big dogs then look in Gumtree
 
I previously posted about using the prong collar on my Dobies. Re-reading this thread made me remember training my fourteen pound Sheltie who is incredibly light. I found no way to effectively train her except with a prong collar.

She has a very thick double coat, so a smack on the flank will have no effect other than moving her position. The receiver for my e-collars is at least half the size of her head - plus I don't have a collar that will fit the receiver and I don't know if the electrodes will penetrate that coat. If I use a choke collar, even a mild snap will move her position in the direction of the snap, and with her thick double coat, she doesn't notice anything less. She's so tiny and delicate, there's little I can do physically.

She's a very willing worker, so after I used a tiny prong collar for several months, she got the idea that when I speak, I mean it, so we went back to training on a buckle collar.

An aside - I always had Dobermans and I had no idea how much I didn't know about dog training until I trained a very different dog in a very different sport.
 

Back
Top