Help! Please Help Me Show My Friend That She Is Doing Wrong By Her Doberman!

Linda A.

New Member
Hi Everyone,

I am sorry to appeal to everyone for help like this but I don't know what else to do to convince my friend that what she is doing to train her doberman not good for her puppy I have a friend who recently acquired a Doberman and she does things that I consider unacceptable in her training. I myself have a small dog who has some issues (separation anxiety and can be bratty) because I probably coddle him too much. Because of this she refuses to listen to anything I have to say about her methods, though I have read about dogs and dog psychology pretty extensively. I thought that if I appealed to a community of Doberman owners and got some feedback she would be more likely to listen to me. She says that it is essential to use fear in training your dog and she does things to scare her dog into submission (not physically harm him but scaring him in a way I consider unacceptable), I will list the problems I have with her methods below. She doesn't want to have her dog neutered and says that to weed out aggressive behaviors she will NEVER let her dog sniff/smell (she believes this makes him less obedient) and that she will NOT let him interact with other dogs (she believes this also makes him less obedient). I told her that socialization is essential for a dog's training, well-being and also happiness. They are social/pack animals and they need interaction with members of their own species. She is taking the dog to puppy class next weekend and I told her to talk to the dog trainer about it - I also hope that the trainer will tell her these methods are terrible. She responded that he was socialized (though it does not sound like he is and she he is only a few months old). To summarize:

* She scares her dog by filling a jar with pennies and hitting the jar of pennies on the dog's crate while he is in it to stop him from whimpering/crying/barking.
* She says that sniffing/letting the dog smell things makes him less compliant and that she will therefore not let him smell AT ALL when she takes him on walks. It is my impression that smelling/sniffing is how dogs take the world in and that it is important to make time to let them do it during a walk, that you don't have to let them do it the whole time but that they need SOME time to be allowed to smell things.
* She says socializing with other dogs increases his propensity to nip and takes focus off her as "the boss/the alpha" and she will therefore no longer allow him to socialize (I think she means for the duration of training, ie, months -I mean I hope she doesn't mean for the dog's lifetime because it seems to me that this would be cruel and insane).

Am I completely wrong? Are these acceptable things to do when training a dog? Please help!! She is a good person at heart and someone irresponsible dumped this dog on her - it wasn't her choice and she is doing the best she can, I know that she THINKS she is doing the right thing because she is quite easily swayed and one of her neighbors told her about these methods and told her that dogs are happier with a "firm" owner and "set" boundaries. PLEASE HELP ME SHOW HER THAT THIS IS NOT THE WAY TO GO!

I thank everyone for their time and their input.

Best,

Linda
 
Hi Everyone,

I am sorry to appeal to everyone for help like this but I don't know what else to do to convince my friend that what she is doing to train her doberman not good for her puppy I have a friend who recently acquired a Doberman and she does things that I consider unacceptable in her training. I myself have a small dog who has some issues (separation anxiety and can be bratty) because I probably coddle him too much. Because of this she refuses to listen to anything I have to say about her methods, though I have read about dogs and dog psychology pretty extensively. I thought that if I appealed to a community of Doberman owners and got some feedback she would be more likely to listen to me. She says that it is essential to use fear in training your dog and she does things to scare her dog into submission (not physically harm him but scaring him in a way I consider unacceptable), I will list the problems I have with her methods below. She doesn't want to have her dog neutered and says that to weed out aggressive behaviors she will NEVER let her dog sniff/smell (she believes this makes him less obedient) and that she will NOT let him interact with other dogs (she believes this also makes him less obedient). I told her that socialization is essential for a dog's training, well-being and also happiness. They are social/pack animals and they need interaction with members of their own species. She is taking the dog to puppy class next weekend and I told her to talk to the dog trainer about it - I also hope that the trainer will tell her these methods are terrible. She responded that he was socialized (though it does not sound like he is and she he is only a few months old). To summarize:

* She scares her dog by filling a jar with pennies and hitting the jar of pennies on the dog's crate while he is in it to stop him from whimpering/crying/barking.
* She says that sniffing/letting the dog smell things makes him less compliant and that she will therefore not let him smell AT ALL when she takes him on walks. It is my impression that smelling/sniffing is how dogs take the world in and that it is important to make time to let them do it during a walk, that you don't have to let them do it the whole time but that they need SOME time to be allowed to smell things.
* She says socializing with other dogs increases his propensity to nip and takes focus off her as "the boss/the alpha" and she will therefore no longer allow him to socialize (I think she means for the duration of training, ie, months -I mean I hope she doesn't mean for the dog's lifetime because it seems to me that this would be cruel and insane).

Am I completely wrong? Are these acceptable things to do when training a dog? Please help!! She is a good person at heart and someone irresponsible dumped this dog on her - it wasn't her choice and she is doing the best she can, I know that she THINKS she is doing the right thing because she is quite easily swayed and one of her neighbors told her about these methods and told her that dogs are happier with a "firm" owner and "set" boundaries. PLEASE HELP ME SHOW HER THAT THIS IS NOT THE WAY TO GO!

I thank everyone for their time and their input.

Best,

Linda
Welcome Linda.What kind of previous experience does this person have with dogs or more specifically Dobermans?
How old is this dog?Or the person for for that matter?
If she won't listen to you what are the odds she even reads responses here?
Any chance you could convince her to join this forum herself?
 
That's a good idea, I might try and get her to join herself. She would probably be angry that I posted this although I am ready to accept that. We have been bickering about this dog training business and she knows I disagree with her. She loves dogs and often babysits neighborhood dogs free of charge but these are different because they are already well trained. This is her first experience with a puppy who is not trained - he is only 4 months old - and as I told her and she has come to understand, puppies are a lot of work.

As far as I know she has limited experience training a dog "from scratch" so to speak and I thought that she would be likely to take the advice of other doberman owners who have had success with their training because she took/received this advice from a neighbor who has an exceptionally well trained dog. I guess she is thinking that the results speak for themselves but I can't help but think that she must have misunderstood what the person said... How could you train a dog without socializing them? Is that even possible?
 
Your friend should relax. He's 4 months old so he is just a BABY. She needs to realize that structure is good but too much and she could totally shut him down from wanting to learn anything!! Right now she should be focusing on the positive. Reward good behaviors, ignore bad ones and redirect. Asserting dominance is not needed for all dogs ... especially not a puppy. I hope she understands that she could seriously ruin this dog if she is not careful. Dobermans are very smart and because of that can be sensitive to how you treat them compared to other breeds of dogs.
 
Hi and welcome! I agree that it doesn't sound like she's being fair to the pup and I totally agree with Rits on the positive reinforcement.


Right now she should be focusing on the positive. Reward good behaviors, ignore bad ones and redirect. Asserting dominance is not needed for all dogs ... especially not a puppy. I hope she understands that she could seriously ruin this dog if she is not careful. Dobermans are very smart and because of that can be sensitive to how you treat them compared to other breeds of dogs.
My thoughts exactly! You do have to let them know you're alpha so they won't walk on you, but like you said, I do not think her approach is right and it can make a pup less confident and harder to train in the long run.
I never believe in training by submission; but to take the time and consistency to to give them a job to do for us so it makes them feel confidant and satisfied as well, and looking up to us, rather than fearing us.
 
Linda - you are probably fighting a loosing battle. But since I compete with my dogs I can tell you I do not ever let them play with other dogs. They don't need that interaction unless you take them to dog parks which I am totally against.

While she does have a strange idea about now letting them ever sniff it is not cruel just kinda dumb since dogs olfactory is highly developed and it a big part of how they take in the world. You teach them when it is allowed and when it is not.

I don't agree with banging on a crate either. That is a place of calm and banging on the crate will set the dog up for anxiety and fear of the crate. Some folks are they own worst enemy
 
Find a puppy class for the dog! Hopefully they'll show her the right way to do it.

I learned dog training from an ex-Marine K9 cop who taught me force training. It worked for my first dog. It was a disaster for my second, which led me to find a trainer who used motivation training. That's far more productive and will lead to a happier relationship.

Good luck and please keep us informed.
 
Coming from a professional dog trainer.....I never let my puppy or dog I am training sniff, wander, or play with other dogs. I don't care if he is 8 weeks old or 8 months old. Training a dog for performance is a whole new ball game. I don't care if they sniff or play or wander in general, but NEVER during a training session. That's just how I do it. It has nothing to do with dominance at all, but rather focus. If she is trying to weed out or get rid of aggression she is going about it the wrong way. And if her puppy is that young and aggressive then there is something wrong, or maybe she got it from bad lines. With that bit of training information put out there, I do PLAY a LOT after each short training session. And this is ESSENTIAL to every dog I work with.

Dogs do not need to play with other dogs to be socialized and I will never let my dog play with any one else's dogs either. They do not need this for training, nor for development. Wolf packs do NOT associate themselves with other packs they come in contact with. In many cases, they will kill members of other packs they run into. My dog needs to act polite and obedient around other dogs, but no, he does not need to play with them. His pack is the people and dogs he lives with and it doesn't need to go further than that. I am not saying letting your dogs play with other dogs is wrong....it's just not how I do it. I do not train for pet homes, only competition and service dogs. Plus dog parks can be very dangerous so I make a point to stay away!

I also do not let my dog sniff on walks. We are there to walk, NOT sniff. If you have watched any of Cesar's videos he can explain why the constant forward motion (not stopping to sniff) is very beneficial to the dog. And I have to agree. By letting the dog sniff every couple of feet and marking all the time they are being your boss and telling you how to take their walk. That is NOT being a good pack leader on the human's part if they let their dog go everywhere and sniff. Part of being a good large dog owner is understanding and enforcing this. As per the crate, there are many different views on this, but personally when my dog whines or barks he gets a correction. Pennies in a jar would NOT work for my guy because he does not get bothered by loud noises....so he gets a leash correction. Crate time = quiet time in my house and I will enforce that every day :) So I see eye to eye on that with your friend.

I agree with no socialization of her dog to other dogs. Michael Ellis touches on this in his world rwide known lectures....and I think there is some info in the video's section on www.leerburg.com about this too. I agree that this is for the lifetime of your dog. Especially for dogs trained in performance type sports. She is protecting her pack structure and keeping her dog focused. This will in no way shape or form harm the dog or his social skills if she also does things like balance her training sessions with play. The dogs that we own in our home should only look to us for food, shelter, warmth, and affection. Why else would they ever need to go to any other pack to get these things? It is NOT cruel and or insane to keep the dogs you have in your pack solely in your pack. BUT I do disagree with her statement that it will prevent nipping. Although my dog has never been socialized with other dogs by play, he knows to keep his manners about him. And if I wanted I could let him go and play with no issues at all on his end. What I worry about more are the other dog's harming him. I protect my dog by not allowing him to play with others.

Honestly I think she is doing the right thing by training the dog this way. Doberman do need a strong and firm leader. Not abusive in any way shape or form, but strong and consistent. Having the dog in puppy training classes will most likely help, but she is well on her way to shaping this dog in a proper fashion....IMHO
 
Hi Everyone,

Thank you so much for reading my post and taking the time to respond in such a detailed way. I know everyone is busy and that it takes quite a bit of time to read all of this and to provide thoughtful detailed answers so I very much appreciate the feedback.

Just as a sidebar though - to the people who have said that socialization is not essential - does that still apply if there are no other dogs in the home? Is it ok for a dog's only contact to be with humans?

Also - how much exercise do dobermans need in terms of walking and or/ chasing a ball/play. I have heard that it is really important to get dogs and puppies tons of exercise and that people underestimate the amount of exercise time that dogs need... I know that this may be difficult to quantify but I would be curious to know what a good amount of time is on average.

By the way - this would be for a dog that is neither a show dog, a breeding dog or a competition dog - just a regular household pet that is also a doberman.

Thanks and Best,

Linda
 
Puppies still need socialization (socialization is more than just dog v dog). Experience with the outside world. However, that doesn't mean he needs doggy friends. He just needs to be okay other dogs, but to focus on her. The puppy class will probably help with that :) Dogs are perfectly fine and healthy being in a 1 dog only pack.

My dogs are always in training mode. They have what is expected of them from day to day, we have training sessions and we have release times. I give many releases where they are rewarded to sniff, play, etc for doing good. There is a command for the release so they know when they are okay'd to "be a dog." Restricting releases completely is not healthy, IMO. If we come across other dogs, they aren't allowed to sniff, cause frankly in most cases the other dog doesn't behave. However, my dogs are adult dogs, not puppies...so they are well past their point of being socialized.

My point being earlier, since this is her first puppy, I think she should just relax a little more and not be so focused on being "the alpha/asserting her dominance" thing. The way you worded it came across that she felt like this dog is challenging her all the time. It's good that she wants to set up structure. I firmly believe all dogs need structure. That is why I practice NILIF. http://doberman-chat.com/community/threads/nilif-nothing-in-life-is-free.1088/

In the crate it's best to ignore his whining. That is why I mention for puppies it's best to reward the good behavior and ignore the bad. When they are older and have a firm understanding of what's good, that is where constructive discipline can come into place. If a puppy doesn't know what is expected of him, he won't understand the discipline either. Cover the crate with a sheet and give a food stuff kong or frozen bone to keep him busy. If he's still learning his crate, exercise him before putting him away so that he will most likely sleep the time he is in there.

As far as exercise, it depends entirely on the dog. A good determining factor would be knowing what the breeder does with the parents? Do they compete in show, agility, or personal protection? A good dog is a tired dog. Is he getting into more trouble than seems usual? Then work his mind and body with mental and physical exercise. It'll be entirely dependent on his genetics but I find a good rule of thumb is around no less than ~2hrs a day of physical and mental exercise.
 
I've only had one Doberman, but I can't imagine using fear to control/dominate one. The Doberman is usually eager to please, bonds easily with its owner and so intelligent that it can figure out what to do for positive reinforcement (making it perfect for marker training). I would think that using fear could result in a dog that is not bonded to the owner and could lash out when mature and sick of taking shit especially if not neutered.

I too don't have a problem with not playing with strange dogs. If it's a multi-dog household, they all have to respect each other, but there's no need for strange dog interactions. It's OK for a dog to just have human interaction, but it should be able to see other dogs without going nuts.

The exercise question depends on the Doberman. Some are high energy and some less so... Most just want to be underfoot all the time, but some need a serious romp every day or they get destructive in the home.
 
only competition and service dogs. Plus dog parks can be very dangerous so I make a point to stay away!

I also do not let my dog sniff on walks. We are there to walk, NOT sniff. If you have watched any of Cesar's videos he can explain why the constant forward motion (not stopping to sniff) is very beneficial to the dog. And I have to agree. By letting the dog sniff every couple of feet and marking all the time they are being your boss and telling you how to take their walk. That is NOT being a good pack leader on the human's part if they let their dog go everywhere and sniff. Part of being a good large dog owner is understanding and enforcing this. As per the crate, there are many different views on this, but personally when my dog whines or barks he gets a correction. Pennies in a jar would NOT work for my guy because he does not get bothered by loud noises....so he gets a leash correction. Crate time = quiet time in my house and I will enforce that every day :) So I see eye to eye on that with your friend.

Hi Caloni,

Thanks for your detailed response, I certainly appreciate the input. I would like to clarify a few things about the circumstances to see if this makes a different. The pennies in a can is being used to scare the dog - but he is scared because she has taken the can and SLAMMED it on the crate while the puppy was in the crate. Now the puppy associates the rattling of the pennies with that scary experience - hence his fear of it. I didn't mind the idea of using pennies in a can to distract the puppy from whatever he was doing but I thought it was terrible to hit his crate with penny can (with quite a bit of force right above the puppy's head). He is terrified of the can rattling now... This seemed very cruel to me.

Also, this dog is neither a service or a competition/show dog, he's just a household pet who lives in a home that has no other dogs - just one person. If the dog has no contact at all with other dogs is that still ok?

I should also mention the pup only gets about 40 minutes of walking time (total per day) and 10 minutes of play (total per day). It seems to me that this could also be the cause of the dog's nipping. I own a Yorkshire Terrier and he requires at least two hours of exercise per day before he becomes very calm/tired/compliant so I thought that Dobermans with their athletic physique might need a lot more exercise if they spend most of their time in a crate...

I am not trying to contradict the points you made, I am only trying to see if you still think the same way given these clarifications...

Thanks again for your time, it is much appreciated. At the end of the day I just want to be able to have a more informed perspective and to be able to provide the best available information so that she and the pups can be happy and safe.

Thanks so much!

Best,

Linda
 
I agree and disagree primarily because it is dependent on the situation and the dog. Tasha is a high drive poorly bred Doberman, the way I train her is completely different than I train Boris on so many different levels. When Tash is out her nose is to the ground and I had to train her to heal and pay attention to me, Boris loves to prance and heals just fine but he wants to play with every thing that moves, Tasha doesn't even notice other dogs so it is the dogs strengths and weaknesses that determine how you establish boundaries.

Many people don't understand the dangers the public presents to our dogs as a whole. I come from San Antonio/Austin area. There is a no tolerance for aggressive breeds, which our dogs are, so if another dog approaches, is aggressive, our dogs get put down regardless the aggressor. Last year at one of our dog parks a dog that was off leash jumped into the back of a guys truck where his two Pitts were on leashes as he was preparing to leave the park and the court judged to put the Pitts down, both of them ,though they did nothing but protect themselves from this dog. We don't socialize our dogs with other dogs we don't know period. Other parts of the world may be different but we don't

The pennies on the crate seems goofy but I am thinking someone gave her the advice and she will find it is futile, the best thing to quiet a dog down is to cover the kennel until he quiets down and then let him out after a bit of time, eventually he will discover settling down is a good thing eventually loving his kennel as his night night time. I am a firm believer in not using the kennel for time outs or punishment.

The rest of the examples you used are just techniques and depending on the dog and what you want the dog to do they are perfectly fine. He is her dog she has to learn what works for her and what doesn't. My husband and I have different techniques when they are with us individually. They are not a set computer they are animals and they have personalities that respond differently to different people so my suggestion is to give her suggestions when she asks but I have found having confidence in someones ability to try and learn gets you a lot further than critique and criticism -
 
All I want to say on this matter is that I think the penny can is BS. :)

Seriously though. If you make a dog skiddish and fearful and it spends it's life that way, your looking at a dog who is likely to bite out of fear and be perceived as aggressive and dangerous.

The goal in training is to form a happy bond with you and your dog. As stated, Dobermans are eager to please and are very intelligent. If she can form a bond with her dog, he will be eager to please her and can be trained easily for the household basic manners.

Good luck getting through to her
 
Ok,
Dobs4ever Caloni Ingrid H

I'm a bit confused?

In all 3 examples you're talking about training a dog for performance,what about just a family pet?
No interaction with other dogs?No sniffing butts?
Claims that if they interacted with another dog they would keep their manners?How would you know that if you don't let them interact with others?
I don't let ours sniff or mark while on leash walking,but off leash while we roam the hills I see no problem with it?
We don't do the dog park we do "out in the wild".
I'd be the first to admit we've had a couple of incidents that turned bad in an instant.In those cases it was the other dogs desire to not sniff butts(the doggy handshake) and they chose to go straight to fight mode,Daisy was more than willing to return the sentiment.
She has a genuine willingness to meet and play with others.Recall my thread of a few months back of the experience that went bad.She put herself into a down as the little dog approached her,in an effort to not seem threatening.Once the little dog growled....ugly time.

Not one instance where the other dog reciprocated the sniff was there an issue.Even the 2 GSD's and Daisy all off leash and we just happened upon each other.The potential was there but did not escalate.
Daisy's only experience with a pitbull,also a female and her elder,butt sniffing,then ran around playing like pack mates...it was a beautiful experience.

Just trying to figure out the responses,it was very much not what I expected to read.
There will almost always be a time when they,for one reason or another have to be in close quarters with another dog.Without any experience would they not be a little lost of exactly how to handle it?
Rocky,he's had next to no contact with others.Now we're in a situation where any other dog he see's he wants to eat,or at least be aggressive.I perceive this as stemming from his lack of socialization with others.Am I wrong?
I'm not saying I disagree with you guys,I just don't understand.This is where I'm all ears as I know you all have WAY more experience than I.
 
Ok,
Dobs4ever Caloni Ingrid H

I'm a bit confused?

In all 3 examples you're talking about training a dog for performance,what about just a family pet?
No interaction with other dogs?No sniffing butts?
Claims that if they interacted with another dog they would keep their manners?How would you know that if you don't let them interact with others?
I don't let ours sniff or mark while on leash walking,but off leash while we roam the hills I see no problem with it?
We don't do the dog park we do "out in the wild".
I'd be the first to admit we've had a couple of incidents that turned bad in an instant.In those cases it was the other dogs desire to not sniff butts(the doggy handshake) and they chose to go straight to fight mode,Daisy was more than willing to return the sentiment.
She has a genuine willingness to meet and play with others.Recall my thread of a few months back of the experience that went bad.She put herself into a down as the little dog approached her,in an effort to not seem threatening.Once the little dog growled....ugly time.

Not one instance where the other dog reciprocated the sniff was there an issue.Even the 2 GSD's and Daisy all off leash and we just happened upon each other.The potential was there but did not escalate.
Daisy's only experience with a pitbull,also a female and her elder,butt sniffing,then ran around playing like pack mates...it was a beautiful experience.

Just trying to figure out the responses,it was very much not what I expected to read.
There will almost always be a time when they,for one reason or another have to be in close quarters with another dog.Without any experience would they not be a little lost of exactly how to handle it?
Rocky,he's had next to no contact with others.Now we're in a situation where any other dog he see's he wants to eat,or at least be aggressive.I perceive this as stemming from his lack of socialization with others.Am I wrong?
I'm not saying I disagree with you guys,I just don't understand.This is where I'm all ears as I know you all have WAY more experience than I.
Gel the lady that did the OP said she did this while training, I think what they were talking about is while they are training.
 
Gel the lady that did the OP said she did this while training, I think what they were talking about is while they are training.
I perceived it as the ops assumption?


her methods below. She doesn't want to have her dog neutered and says that to weed out aggressive behaviors she will NEVER let her dog sniff/smell (she believes this makes him less obedient) and that she will NOT let him interact with other dogs (she believes this also makes him less obedient)
 
Ok,
Dobs4ever Caloni Ingrid H

IJust trying to figure out the responses,it was very much not what I expected to read.
There will almost always be a time when they,for one reason or another have to be in close quarters with another dog.Without any experience would they not be a little lost of exactly how to handle it?
Rocky,he's had next to no contact with others.Now we're in a situation where any other dog he see's he wants to eat,or at least be aggressive.I perceive this as stemming from his lack of socialization with others.Am I wrong?
I'm not saying I disagree with you guys,I just don't understand.This is where I'm all ears as I know you all have WAY more experience than I.

You know Gel Boris has been super socialized and he still wants to be the tough guy, the only thing that has worked for me is training him to obey me, come, sit and leave it, when on walks he has to sit when we pass a dog and stay focused on me. We are at 18 months now, he does it wonderfully and never gets into altercations but if I don't give him the commands he raises his hair and bow wows, so I don't know there is an answer other than not allowing him to be the aggressor, now we have the occasional idiot that thinks their little purse dog is cute and approaches anyways and I politely tell them I will release him if they don't walk around. They always do :)

We have family and friends that have dogs and he is great with them and my grand pup Libby is his BUD! they roll and play and love when they get to visit but outside the circle we just don't do. Maybe here in Minnesota with more area that is not full of rattlers and dangerous areas maybe we will do more of the exploring off leas stuff.
 
Regardless of my reading comprehension skills,lol.
Linda A.

These folks giving their info are very experienced people.You've come to a great place to learn and I'm learning right along with you.
I encourage you to try (in a positive manner) to get your friend to visit the site.
 
I perceived it as the ops assumption?


her methods below. She doesn't want to have her dog neutered and says that to weed out aggressive behaviors she will NEVER let her dog sniff/smell (she believes this makes him less obedient) and that she will NOT let him interact with other dogs (she believes this also makes him less obedient)
Your right I was skimming didn't read that :( We are having a neutering party :)
 

Back
Top