• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Is a Martingale Safe?

Caloni

Active Member
I have trained many different breeds before including large and small breeds. But never a doberman puppy. I have heard that their necks can be very delicate and I wanted to ask this before just jumping in and damaging him.

Is a martingale collar safe for a 4 month old puppy or should I stick with the buckle collar?
 
i would say that it would be safe, just be very consistent with it and don't pull when leash training and well almost all training, you want to do fast pops on the leash, and always have lots of praise when they are doing good.

i think i used a martingale even before 4 months with Watson, but waited and used a prong collar after 5 months.
 
A martingale collar is safe for your training but don't use it when he plays with other dogs. We had a terrifying experience when Gino's martingale collar became tangled in Asha's jaws. She was trying to release herself and was chocking Gino. We managed to keep dogs calm before the collar was cut off.... it was very scary!
 
Thanks all for your help. I will get one then. I will be sure to treat it just like a chain collar with my obedience guys with respect to training.

I agree...collars should be off for training and play no matter what.
 
I agree that they should be as safe as any other flat collar as long as you're not popping it or letting him pull, which I'm sure you don't.
We had a terrifying experience when Gino's martingale collar became tangled in Asha's jaws. She was trying to release herself and was chocking Gino. We managed to keep dogs calm before the collar was cut off.... it was very scary!

I remember that and how scary indeed!
 
I have only heard of the chain (choke) collar doing damage to the neck. Flat, martingales and prongs all distribute the pressure equally around due to the wider width. I love the martingale for beginning training because the dog can't ever slip out of it and learn that trick. BUT it also means if they get hung up as DV said it can be dangerous so I would not leave it on when you are not there supervising or the dog is with other dogs.

I don't use the martingale anymore because I teach my dogs form the beginning to never slip a collar but it means I have to use it correctly so they don't manage to get out of it. I use a very loose flat collar that if allowed they can slip out of for safety reasons they could so it is all about timing. I did get an older dog once who had never worn a collar because she could slip it faster than you could blink your eye and it took over a year wearing a martingale for her to stop trying to slip her collar.

Regardless of the collar as Jan said it is the pulling and jerking on the lead that can cause neck problems regardless of the collar you use with the exception of the chain which can cause damage regardless. The martingale just teaches the dog they can't escape the flat collar and the prong teaches them to respect pressure on the lead and to yield to it not fight it.
 

Back
Top