• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Two Fold Food Question

Caloni

Active Member
1. Do you all use puppy food for your puppies, or do you use Large Breed Adult food and supplement with extra calories?

2. Do you think that Nutro is a good food to use if you are on a budget? I am trying to stay within a $50 a month budget for food and currently my dogs eat about 40 -50 lbs a month.

Right now they are on Diamond large breed puppy and Purina One Naturals. The places where I can get pet food here are: Tractor Supply, Grocery Store, and Petsmart.
 
How about Taste of the Wild?


It's a 4.5 star rated food, and is only 45$ for a 30 pound bag.

I try to stick with all life stages food. TOTW is one of those.


Don't know anything about nutro though.
 
Do you have access to a Costco? I think the most reasonably priced food that is good quality is Nature's Domain, but you can only get it at Costco.

You might find better prices online - check Petflow.com or Chewy.com. Free shipping and the quality foods are less expensive than in stores.
 
You really need to stick with a food that has the appropriate calcium/phosphorus levels. The very vast majority of puppy foods, including the large breed puppy foods, have way too much calcium or an improper balance. Because of this, you generally want to feed a food that's been approved for all life stages, but even then you have to be careful about what you feed. Feeding the wrong levels can cause your pup to have various musculoskeletal problems, like pano and hip dysplasia.

For a great list of appropriate foods for large breed puppies, follow this link. It's a forum discussion, and I think the most current version of the list is on page 15 -- of course, there's a lot of great information in the other pages too.

Topic: Large and Giant Breed Puppy Nutrition
 
I did not feed Della a puppy food and acclimated her over to an "all life stages" formula shortly after she came home, which she did very well on. Albert did get a large breed puppy formula at the request of the breeder and we fed Fromm Gold large breed puppy, again with good results.

As for Nutro, no... Boris was on it when we first got him and I did not care for it at all so we gradually switched him to a better food as well.
 
Daisy was on Nutro when she was a pup,the puppy formula.Trouble began when we switched to the adult Nutro.For the life of me I can't recall the formula.
Went to Blue lamb/rice after trying some "budget" brands.Stay away from Beniful!!!!!!
We also experimented with a Costco lamb/rice formula.It didnt wirk for us either.The label claimed no corn in it,I'm thinking that claim is BS.
 
we don't do separate puppy foods for long. Generally it's just long enough to transition the dog to better quality food.

The name doesn't matter; the ingredient list does. Some brands have different formulas for what would seem to be closely related product lines. Nature's domain in Costco is really a food store level dog food. 2 of the top 4 ingredients are potatoes and #1 is Salmon meal, not salmon. I do not like to see "meal" as the #1 and ideally not at all. It makes it way too easy to slip in cheap fillers like corn and chicken beaks when the main ingredient is a meal or powder. That much potato is just using potato to replace corn as a big starch filler.

Costco/kirkland dog foods are all made by Diamond unless they've changed suppliers. I know some rescue friends who have dipped down into the Kirkland lamb and rice lines when needed. Many dogs did ok with it, not great. A few dogs definitely didn't do well. Still one of the better temporary choices if you are really strapped for dog food money.

I sort of laugh at the Beneful lines. Their ingredient list is scary :eek: (Ground yellow corn, chicken by-product meal, corn gluten meal, whole wheat flour) - all 4 of the top ingredients are on my "NO it's junk" list! The closest thing in there to what dogs should eat is the chicken beaks they use as chicken by product meal. I have to give points for them at least showing corn in the pictures on the bags. Usually there's some low grade "meal" as the main ingredient but they show pictures of big, fat wild Salmon or huge steaks on the bag.

The best way I find to save $$$ is to buy the top quality best foods I can get when they are on the biggest sales or clearance. Storing them in the big vacuum cube bags really keeps them fresh much longer than just sitting in the regular bag. Good quality foods keep the vet bills to a minimum in my experience. It ultimately saves you more money than cheaper foods with junk type fillers. You are also way less likely to start adding all kinds of supplements to make up for their food if it's top grade to start.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joz
I sort of laugh at the Beneful lines. Their ingredient list is scary :eek: (Ground yellow corn, chicken by-product meal, corn gluten meal, whole wheat flour) - all 4 of the top ingredients are on my "NO it's junk" list! The closest thing in there to what dogs should eat is the chicken beaks they use as chicken by product meal. I have to give points for them at least showing corn in the pictures on the bags. Usually there's some low grade "meal" as the main ingredient but they show pictures of big, fat wild Salmon or huge steaks on the bag.

I agree...junk. My puppy is on Hill's I/D stomach formula food. I tried to tell the vet I think this food is crap, but she insists on it! He's been having loose stool and vomiting after being taken off some antibiotics. I am not sure if it is the food or if something else is going on.
 
Hills SD used to be decent food. So did royal canin. They're both JUNK now. Not unlike Milkbones or Beggin Strips. It's why I'm a broken record on checking the ingredient list. These companies change big ingredients without saying a word once they've built a customer base. Some may have a decent canned line and junk kibble or vice versa. You've just got to read everything.

Sorry about the sick pup. how long has it been since stopping abx? How long vomiting? Tried no food for a few hours, then a little pumpkin/chicken/rice?

If he was ok on the Hills before the abx I'd wait on changing foods until everything is more solid. Frustrating and you want to fix your boy asap but you know when you change more than one thing at a time you can't tell what works and what doesn't. Don't forget to use a store that lets you return things your dog doesn't like while you do your dog food search. It can save you a bundle while you work things out.
 
Hills SD used to be decent food. So did royal canin. They're both JUNK now. Not unlike Milkbones or Beggin Strips. It's why I'm a broken record on checking the ingredient list. These companies change big ingredients without saying a word once they've built a customer base. Some may have a decent canned line and junk kibble or vice versa. You've just got to read everything.

Sorry about the sick pup. how long has it been since stopping abx? How long vomiting? Tried no food for a few hours, then a little pumpkin/chicken/rice?

If he was ok on the Hills before the abx I'd wait on changing foods until everything is more solid. Frustrating and you want to fix your boy asap but you know when you change more than one thing at a time you can't tell what works and what doesn't. Don't forget to use a store that lets you return things your dog doesn't like while you do your dog food search. It can save you a bundle while you work things out.

He's been sick on and off....contracted it from a friend's pup when we didn't know she was sick (she got it from a vet's office of all places). He was on 2 different anti vomiting meds....they were stopped this week on tuesday and this morning he started vomiting again with some yellow colored loose stool. Went back in for more meds at the vet's today and they say to keep him on the script food with Hills. I just want him to get better...the waiting is the hard part, but at least he's not in ICU any more.
 
Yikes! Did they have any idea what it was? They did fecal exams? Same looking stools as before or is the yellowish stuff different?

I would try the pumpkin, chicken and rice mixed with a little of the Hills and see how it goes. Hope things improve asap!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Joz
I feed GO food available in Canada and made in British Columbia. I raised puppies on it and feed all my dogs this food. Love it. The company is Petcuran and can be found on facebook. I don't know if they sell in the USA.
 
They put him back on the pepcid, upped his dose of reglan, and also gave him something to firm upthe stool. The stool is back to normal after 12 hours of meds and so far no vomiting....but still watching him closely.
 
We also experimented with a Costco lamb/rice formula.It didnt wirk for us either.The label claimed no corn in it,I'm thinking that claim is BS.

Hi again - I'm trying to figure out what food I will be feeding the pup to be and I did look at Costco / Kirkland. Costco is one of the larger corps I generally trust. I saw the food said 'no grain' which I thought would be good. I expect the pup will be 8 to 9 weeks when I take her home. May I ask more specifics? I read somewhere else on here that Taste of the Wild is good. I THINK It was dhorner8 that posted that but I need to go find it. Thanks in advance.
 
I feed GO food available in Canada and made in British Columbia. I raised puppies on it and feed all my dogs this food. Love it. The company is Petcuran and can be found on facebook. I don't know if they sell in the USA.
I saw this in my local Hollistic store here! I thought of you!
 
Hi again - I'm trying to figure out what food I will be feeding the pup to be and I did look at Costco / Kirkland. Costco is one of the larger corps I generally trust. I saw the food said 'no grain' which I thought would be good. I expect the pup will be 8 to 9 weeks when I take her home. May I ask more specifics? I read somewhere else on here that Taste of the Wild is good. I THINK It was dhorner8 that posted that but I need to go find it. Thanks in advance.
Well,I suspect there is corn in it.
My dog is allergic to it.So when I started mixing the Costco brand into their current food she had the same kind of allergic reaction she did on Beniful that is loaded with corn.
 
I started mixing the Costco brand into their current food she had the same kind of allergic reaction she did on Beniful that is loaded with corn.

Thanks. May I ask what you feed your dog? It seems to be it may be some trial and error. I think the only thing of sure of is NO Grain and keep the calcium down for a puppy.
 

Back
Top