• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?


  • Total voters
    16
This is a great video of very sharp dogs being used in military and police applications. This is a training exercise with an eastern european anti terrorist unit. watch this dog work but watch at around 44 seconds and you will see exactly what we have been talking about.

Coming from someone new to the sport and still ever learning here is my take on this video.

That dog looks confused amist all the chaos as to who is friend and who is foe. So attacks the handler accordingly. Not desirable in my eyes.
A dog like that could easily kill a military/police member that was not experienced in situations such as the one you posted.

It looks extremely dangerous, and something I think that needs to be extremely well monitored if incorporated into a working dog breeding program.
 
Coming from someone new to the sport and still ever learning here is my take on this video.

That dog looks confused amist all the chaos as to who is friend and who is foe. So attacks the handler accordingly. Not desirable in my eyes.
A dog like that could easily kill a military/police member that was not experienced in situations such as the one you posted.

It looks extremely dangerous, and something I think that needs to be extremely well monitored if incorporated into a working dog breeding program.
It is not that the dog is confused, the dog knows what it is supposed to do, but with these dogs they go into a state of overdrive, they are in the moment, they are in the highest of fight drives and thus when being corrected or controlled by the handler they will sometimes attempt to take that control or threat away as their entire pure instinctual need, is their fight drive. Can you really look at that video and watch that dog working and say that there is no place for such a dog?? That is exactly the place for a dog like that, and did you not see at the end the dog lying in a down between the handlers legs, perfectly content??

There is a lot more to reading and understanding a dog, than just watching the wag of the tail.
 
It is not that the dog is confused, the dog knows what it is supposed to do, but with these dogs they go into a state of overdrive, they are in the moment, they are in the highest of fight drives and thus when being corrected or controlled by the handler they will sometimes attempt to take that control or threat away as their entire pure instinctual need, is their fight drive. Can you really look at that video and watch that dog working and say that there is no place for such a dog?? That is exactly the place for a dog like that, and did you not see at the end the dog lying in a down between the handlers legs, perfectly content??

There is a lot more to reading and understanding a dog, than just watching the wag of the tail.

I know it's hard to read tone over the Internet so I'm going to add this before you read my response. As I respect what you do. My purpose in this is not to be argumentative, but I find that in Schutzhund there are many extreme gray areas that are never addressed.
Coming from a new person to the sport all this is fresh unbiased feedback, and I mean it with the upmost respect.

"they are in the highest of fight drives and thus when being corrected or controlled by the handler they will sometimes attempt to take that control or threat away as their entire pure instinctual need"

To me this sounds like different wording for a confused dog when it is in the highest of fight drives. If you look at human psychology people react the poorest in extremely stressful situation, and a lot of times make poor decisions while trying to intently focus on a developing chaotic situation. Are you suggesting dogs have more rational thought than humans in chaos? if so why would we need handlers to direct them? People get "confused" as to what's the right thing to do. This looks exactly like what's happening to this dog. IMHO a dog should never even think about taking control over their handler if properly trained. Since these are expert trainers that goes back to genetics as you say their "instinctual need". I'm not watching his tail. I am watching how he is so intensely focused that the dog can not make any sort of rational thinking. This dog in my eyes is driven well over the need that any one person should want, and should never be added to a breeding program unless in situations like Suzan mentioned.

I'm going to give you two situations which I directly received from my best friend whom is a retired marine. I need you to see how these dogs can cause more harm than good at that level of drive.

1. You are in a combat zone. You are the k-9 handler and you set the dog free to attack. The dog attacks and kills, so you go to release the dog whom is now in "overdrive". The dog turns on you making you let your guard down and you are shot and killed. If this dog was not confused as to who was friend and who was foe you may have had time to react accordingly.

Now if you take a dog that does not have this ridiculous overdrive, and is focused on his task, and who is handler is, your life could still be saved since you do not have to worry about the dog you train/handle attempting to kill you in rage.

2. You are a police officer K-9 unit. Most of the ones I see are a single man and his dog. So we will use that for this situation. Gunman opens fire and runs you release the dog to attack. The dog pins him while biting and his gun falls. You come to release the dog and he turns on you. Giving the criminal the opportunity to pick up his gun and shoot you and the dog. Killing you both.

My point of all this being is that I can absolutely say that a dog like the one in the video you have shown has no place in today's world. A properly trained well balanced intelligent dog has a place in these situations.

The only good use I see for these dogs is incorporating them in to breeding programs that have very low drive. Even then I believe that has to be incredibly monitored so we don't purposely aim for dogs like this.

Again I mean no sarcasm or aggressive tone. This is my honest unbiased opinion.
 
These are all great analogies and great questions. First let me address what you said in the beginning, Thank you for your kind words, and please understand that I respect anyone who wants to learn the sport of SchH or even wants to take the time to train their dog and give their dog an outlet for their natural needs. Now I am going to address a few things you said by putting my comments in red next to yours so what I am saying makes more sense.

I know it's hard to read tone over the Internet so I'm going to add this before you read my response. As I respect what you do. My purpose in this is not to be argumentative, but I find that in Schutzhund there are many extreme gray areas that are never addressed.
Coming from a new person to the sport all this is fresh unbiased feedback, and I mean it with the upmost respect.(this video is not sport, this is not SchH or any other working "sport" it is real world anti terrorism work, featuring a K9 and an Anti Terrorism team.)

"they are in the highest of fight drives and thus when being corrected or controlled by the handler they will sometimes attempt to take that control or threat away as their entire pure instinctual need"

To me this sounds like different wording for a confused dog when it is in the highest of fight drives. If you look at human psychology people react the poorest in extremely stressful situation, and a lot of times make poor decisions while trying to intently focus on a developing chaotic situation. Are you suggesting dogs have more rational thought than humans in chaos?( No I am saying dogs are very instinctual animals who have particular drives that come in out in certain situations.) if so why would we need handlers to direct them? People get "confused" as to what's the right thing to do. This looks exactly like what's happening to this dog. IMHO a dog should never even think about taking control over their handler if properly trained.( The dog isnt really thinking, he is reacting while he is in "drive") Since these are expert trainers that goes back to genetics as you say their "instinctual need". I'm not watching his tail. I am watching how he is so intensely focused that the dog can not make any sort of rational thinking.( the dog is not thinking rationally, he is instead using his drive in the situation, and the training he has received, helps to shape what his reactions are in the situation) This dog in my eyes is driven well over the need that any one person should want, and should never be added to a breeding program unless in situations like Suzan mentioned.(as we have said, this type of dog is not in a pet home breeding program, they are in a working dog breeding program that breeds dogs for particular work, such as Law enforcement and military applications.)

I'm going to give you two situations which I directly received from my best friend whom is a retired marine. I need you to see how these dogs can cause more harm than good at that level of drive.

1. You are in a combat zone. You are the k-9 handler and you set the dog free to attack. The dog attacks and kills, so you go to release the dog whom is now in "overdrive". The dog turns on you making you let your guard down and you are shot and killed. If this dog was not confused as to who was friend and who was foe you may have had time to react accordingly( dogs are not used to attack and Kill, they are used to takedown and subdue a person until the handler and team can get into the situation to take control of the person or person., IE the Seal Team 6 Raid that killed Osama Bin Laden, a working K9 similar to the one you saw on that video was used, that dog went in first, the dog was equipped with a camera on its vest and a protective vest and goggles. This is to allow for the operators to see what the dog sees in that room before they enter, as well as to protect the dog and allow him to get to the person to takedown and subdue or to distract long enough for the handler and other Tier 1 Operators to get to the person and either capture or kill the them.)

Now if you take a dog that does not have this ridiculous overdrive, and is focused on his task, and who is handler is, your life could still be saved since you do not have to worry about the dog you train/handle attempting to kill you in rage.

2. You are a police officer K-9 unit. Most of the ones I see are a single man and his dog. So we will use that for this situation. Gunman opens fire and runs you release the dog to attack. The dog pins him while biting and his gun falls. You come to release the dog and he turns on you. Giving the criminal the opportunity to pick up his gun and shoot you and the dog. Killing you both.(same situation as before, the dog is to subdue or takedown the person, the suspect is usually down and not an actual threat when the dog is outed. I personally know of several situations where a police K9 has been released on a suspect and has nipped or bit the handler or bitten another officer who was as it is called "in the line of fire" this does happen in the real world.)

My point of all this being is that I can absolutely say that a dog like the one in the video you have shown has no place in today's world. A properly trained well balanced intelligent dog has a place in these situations.(if you think that you should again think back to the K9 that was used in the takedown of Osama Bin Laden, this was and is, exactly the type of dog you saw on that video.)

The only good use I see for these dogs is incorporating them in to breeding programs that have very low drive. Even then I believe that has to be incredibly monitored so we don't purposely aim for dogs like this.

Again I mean no sarcasm or aggressive tone. This is my honest unbiased opinion.

I hope this helps to answer some of your questions and sheds some light on the use of sharp dogs in real world applications.

Thanks for asking and giving your thoughts, its very much appreciated.
 
I can show you countless videos of sharp dogs used in military and police work that during work or training they bite the handler, this is many times out of frustration or due to their fight drives being over the top, and so they grab the closest thing they can and that is their own handler. It happens all the time, but these same dogs can be seen being overly affectionate and loving to their handler once the work is over. It is just an aspect of working canines.
Interesting. Now you have me wondering. River does this to me sometimes on the protection field. I read it as she wants into the game so badly that when I hold her back she turns and nips at my hands in a "let me get him!" kind of way sometimes and other times it seems like she is so hyped up that she has to grab something and my hands are closest, literally. So what I'm wondering is do you think this kind of behavior is indicative of a sharp dog or one that any excited dog can display? I ask because I certainly wouldn't consider her sharp.
 
Very excellent points Dale. Helps put this into perspective a little more. From someone new to getting into bite work, the lingo is just as difficult to understand as conformation shows.

Now the curiosity bug has hit me. How long do these handlers have to train for before they are ready to undertake a dog like this?
Is this something our military trains our K9 teams effectively on?
 
Interesting. Now you have me wondering. River does this to me sometimes on the protection field. I read it as she wants into the game so badly that when I hold her back she turns and nips at my hands in a "let me get him!" kind of way sometimes and other times it seems like she is so hyped up that she has to grab something and my hands are closest, literally. So what I'm wondering is do you think this kind of behavior is indicative of a sharp dog or one that any excited dog can display? I ask because I certainly wouldn't consider her sharp.
I would agree with Susan in that she is highly frustrated for the game. Her drives are up and she wants in so badly she has to nip or push to get her way or to simply let some of that frustration out. It is normal in higher drive dogs and is not indicitive of sharpness.
 
Fair point.
Jess, I will give you a perfect example of what susan said being true. Susan stated "A sharp dog does not nip they come at you to eat you alive!!! Big difference".
and she is absolutely right.
I had matrix for about 6 months when this happened and its a great example of what myself and Susan have been saying.......... I was sitting in my computer chair just as I am doing now and was on the computer, matrix was in the room with me, I was not paying him any attention and he kept trying to force his dominance on me and pushing my arm and the computer keyboard so that I would pet him and pay attention to him rather than ignore him. He pushed my arm with his nose and I looked at him and with a normal command voice said no, go lay down, and I pointed my finger towards him. Suddenly he came up and at my face full on attack mode, Not growling not barking but for a full on bite, and I fortunately was able to quickly catch him mid strike by the throat with my hand and then grab him on the back on the neck with my other. I had to force this dog onto the grown and basically choke him out until his eyes rolled back in his head before he would submit, and even then he didnt. He still wanted to fight. This is a good example of a sharp dog who is dominant aggressive suddenly being forced to feel like he is not in control and feeling threatened and reacting.
fortunately we have not had an incident in over a year or so now, other than the occassional hackles up tail up and rigid body tense moments that I can quickly gain control of and redirect much easier now. He is a very different dog, but still shows his ability if not under control to quickly become sharp and on the offensive.

Where a dog like river would be my GSD, she has insanely high drives and gets so excited that during work or when I am playing ball with her she will get frustrated and nip my chest or leg or hand, but its out of frustration, not an attempt to bite.
 
Where a dog like river would be my GSD, she has insanely high drives and gets so excited that during work or when I am playing ball with her she will get frustrated and nip my chest or leg or hand, but its out of frustration, not an attempt to bite.
Thank you very much for clarifying. I understand what you mean much better now. I didn't think River was sharp, that is why I felt a need to ask for clarification.
 
My point of all this being is that I can absolutely say that a dog like the one in the video you have shown has no place in today's world

I will say this - They are taking our guns - are you going to follow in the AR mind set and take our true working dogs as well???? If you support guns then we better darn well support our working dogs. You are not seeing the difference - you are thinking from a pet mindset not a true working mindset. This is all new to you. Training, showing and Dobermans are new to you. You are learning and don't stop asking the questions etc but one of the biggest reason we have so much misunderstanding about our dogs is the irreoneous opinons people form without true understanding while watching a video which never shows the whole picture and you have nothing to base it on.

This is part of the reason our working dogs are labeled dangerous etc. People do not understand these dogs so they label them vicious and claim they should be put down. Please open your mind and see the magnificent power, beauty and teamwork that goes into producing a dog like this. Of course the military and police have trainers who work with these dogs on a dailly basis otherwise they would not be working dogs at all. You can't go into one of those situations with a dog that is going to turn tail and run. You must know absolutely that only a bullet will stop these most impressive working dogs - all heart, courage, fearless, confident, powerful truly a beautiful thing to behold.. Definitely not for pet minded people true - and that is why breeders who do not work their dogs do not understand and so place a powerful puppy in the wrong hands. Then someone is going to get hurt and the public is going to scream DANGEROUS DOG and the AR groups shout for joy - another nail in the coffin.
 
Thanks Marko - Sorry I copied a post by CRD out of Dale's post so that is why it showed Pitts.

This is a very heated subject to working folks. We saw DPCA push AKC to drop working sports from their venue and with the cost and low turn out it was dropped. Instead of embrasing the image of our dogs as a working breed the pushed to eliminate the sport and water down the dogs. Then about 5 years ago we got them to reinstate it for a short 3 year trial due to the support of UDC, Ray Carlisle and a couple others but it did not continue on. DPCA show breeders did not want to see dog bite work at all as they felt it showed our dogs a vicious again a HUGE misunderstand about what you are seeing and what is happening. You are 10 X more likely to get bit by that couch potato than a trained working dog.

It is very hard trying to walk the fence - I believe in conformation and the role it plays in dogs - I believe just as strongly a working dog should first and foremost be able to work. I started in conformation and I have a deep love for it as far as it goes, but once you stand on the end of a leash of a dog that says bring it on it will humble you right down to your toes at how truly awesome these dogs are. We need more folks in our sport - it is dying heck today even conformation is dying while agility is blowing the roof off. Why - a lot less work and money involved.

Good breeders have said these dogs are not for everyone and then some have tried to breed them down to make them more like goldens so they can be for everyone. JMHO

Our working dogs are not trained to BITE - they already know how to do that = The training shapes the bite to specific times and commands but alas the AR folks have screamed about how cruel training a dog is, how scarey these dogs are and just like they stole our right to just go buy a gun over an incident in CT they are after our dogs as well. They want you to believe you can live in a world where nothing bad ever happens if you just eliminate everything. Not gonna work. JMHO
 
Even Golden Retrievers can and will bite 1:05 seconds :)


Doesn't contribute to the thread but I haven't seen a Golden do that before lol
 
You are too funny and that had to be one in a million GR ... Heck do you remember when Pitts posted on the PINK POODLE Sch dog!!! I bet that was a sight to see. Occassionally you will see a brred perform in an unusual manner for the breed but it is far more rare than common. But at some point all dogs that survive nature must have very strong survival instincts. Now there is a whole new facet to consider.

to add: if it is true ony the strong survive you can be darn well sure they were SHARP!!!
 
I will say this - They are taking our guns - are you going to follow in the AR mind set and take our true working dogs as well???? If you support guns then we better darn well support our working dogs. You are not seeing the difference - you are thinking from a pet mindset not a true working mindset. This is all new to you. Training, showing and Dobermans are new to you. You are learning and don't stop asking the questions etc but one of the biggest reason we have so much misunderstanding about our dogs is the irreoneous opinons people form without true understanding while watching a video which never shows the whole picture and you have nothing to base it on.

This is part of the reason our working dogs are labeled dangerous etc. People do not understand these dogs so they label them vicious and claim they should be put down. Please open your mind and see the magnificent power, beauty and teamwork that goes into producing a dog like this. Of course the military and police have trainers who work with these dogs on a dailly basis otherwise they would not be working dogs at all. You can't go into one of those situations with a dog that is going to turn tail and run. You must know absolutely that only a bullet will stop these most impressive working dogs - all heart, courage, fearless, confident, powerful truly a beautiful thing to behold.. Definitely not for pet minded people true - and that is why breeders who do not work their dogs do not understand and so place a powerful puppy in the wrong hands. Then someone is going to get hurt and the public is going to scream DANGEROUS DOG and the AR groups shout for joy - another nail in the coffin.

I'm sorry but this is not something I will budge on.

If any dog is aggressive to his handler then that is extremely undesirable. No matter the circumstances. I'm not talking about confused reactive nips. I'm talking about dogs who bite and attack.

So by your definition of a "sharp" dog I personally feel there is no need for this type of dog in any situation.

That dog bit his handler and would not let go. It's unacceptable. No other way to put it.

I also don't see why this has anything to
Do with AR groups at all. Please don't associate me with them, you know I am completely against that thought process, and I am a little offended you would even make that association to me. I also don't see how my constitutional right to own a gun has anything to do with a dog that is handler aggressive.

This has to do with the advocating with out of control dogs, and it's disgusting to be honest.

If anything promoting these dogs just gives more fuel to an already blazing AR fire. Because to any average person watching that video it is considered unacceptable no matter what adjective we use for what's happening.

I feel there is more to a sharp dog than handler aggression, and i personally believe that has nothing to do with a sharp dog, and if it does that word needs to be abolished from the bite sport dictionary.

That's my stance, and I'm not budging. But believe me, if there were a realistic setting where these dog were appropriate I would be all for it. The simple fact is that this is not the case. I have no biased opinion towards the sport and this is just my feedback. Take it or leave it.
 

Back
Top