• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?

If we fail to prove they're not cruel, exclusions will come along, and rightly so.

But if they are not cruel when done correctly then why should it rightly be so??? You can't defend a wrong by saying it was inadaquately defended. I can't paint a horrible picture of my puppies playing and running around right after ear crop - that is much harder to believe than the lie which is always about botched jobs and tear jerking commericals of horrible things. Why punish the good in hopes of stopping one bad person. I don't bnuy that reasoning just I don't buy 2 wrongs make a right.

If cropping and docking is cruel then so is spay/neuter which causes far more pain. Just let them have puppies willy nilly.
 
It's heartbreaking when young Dobermans are dying from genetic diseases....who cares what ears shape they have.
I never opposed c/d being completely pro-choice person... but I don't understand why it's so important for the breed.
Health and temperament problems make our lives miserable. What is wrong with the natural ears?
They are way too cute to crop :blush:
 
But if they are not cruel when done correctly then why should it rightly be so??? You can't defend a wrong by saying it was inadaquately defended. I can't paint a horrible picture of my puppies playing and running around right after ear crop - that is much harder to believe than the lie which is always about botched jobs and tear jerking commericals of horrible things. Why punish the good in hopes of stopping one bad person. I don't bnuy that reasoning just I don't buy 2 wrongs make a right.

If cropping and docking is cruel then so is spay/neuter which causes far more pain. Just let them have puppies willy nilly.

If c/d is not cruel when done properly, but it can be cruel when done improperly, then this is one of those things where it's extremely important to document the humane and right way to do things as a best practice, and make sure that you support animal welfare laws that allow improper docking & cropping procedures to be prosecuted as animal cruelty.

For example, is a breeder (or vet) who is cheap & backward enough to figure anesthesia isn't required for cropping because a puppy is "just an animal (and yes, there are still some morons who don't believe animals experience pain)" and they can "shake it off" guilty of animal cruelty in the eyes of the law? If not, they are not only committing animal cruelty, but they are giving cropping a bad name. When it comes time to enact laws to protect animals, if pro-crop people aren't taking a leading role in stopping barbaric bad medicine in the interest of animal welfare, the bad medicine won't be what's banned...all cropping is what's going to be lumped together and banned. Or put yet another way, we can be very active and aggressive in defining what is cruel and fight it, or risk having someone else who doesn't understand that there are right and wrong ways to perform cropping or docking define it for us. Am I making that point clearly?

Make no mistake that the only conceivable "wrong" we're talking about here is animal cruelty. Elective, cosmetic surgeries are a privilege. If we want to keep these privileges, they have to be defended on how they're relatively harmless.

I also happen to not be a big believer in spay/neuter surgeries. They're elective, have a certain level of risk, and have long-term health implications since they're removing major parts the animal's endocrine system. However, popping out puppies is a social ill (in terms of the cost of dealing with pet overpopulation) and also has health implications, so at least there are pragmatic reasons for sterilization. There are no positive health or social benefits from c/d, it's purely cosmetic and not quite in the same league. That said, with all procedures that carry health risks and cause discomfort to our animals, there is room for improvement until all those things are safe and painless.
 
I have a question.
Does anyone or has anyone done ear cropping with a laser? I understand laser tech to be clean,quick,and "seals" up the wound somewhat like a burn.
Just thought I would ask as I don't know?
 
I have a question.
Does anyone or has anyone done ear cropping with a laser? I understand laser tech to be clean,quick,and "seals" up the wound somewhat like a burn.
Just thought I would ask as I don't know?

I do believe laser cropping is getting to be pretty popular. But don't quote me on that. I could be entirely wrong.
 
THX Dobes4Ever for the Welcome:)I am very excited going to Memphis.
I am not known in the Doberman World, i only have had one Litter and i am not so much out there for Shows or Sports (due to severe Backproblems)........but if i would breed "Amy" once more in the US i would love to keep one Pup, and that more should be done this Time.
Of course i would need Help,but i believe that would be possible to get.
 
Surgery is surgery and I have heard a lot about the magic of laser cropping and about all I can see is it saves having to stitch them up and then remove stitches. I have seen a couple dogs done with laser and when it is all done they look the same as mine. The most important thing is the style of crop and the artistic skill of the vet.

For example, is a breeder (or vet) who is cheap & backward enough to figure anesthesia isn't required for cropping because a puppy is "just an animal (and yes, there are still some morons who don't believe animals experience pain)" and they can "shake it off" guilty of animal cruelty in the eyes of the law?

Kaloric that is already against the law - so because it might happen in some back woods area you would prefer to see the breed loose breed type??? This is what so many do not understand because they just want a purebred dog for one reason or the other but have no understanding of the history and development of the breed or what the breed standard does. But that is exactly who so many push AKC registration and not CKC(Continential Kennel Club, WWR, NKC, APRI etc because you don't know what you will get for sure as they have very weak standards for reg if anyat all..

It's heartbreaking when young Dobermans are dying from genetic diseases....who cares what ears shape they have.

DV someone has really sold you a bill of goods on dogs dropping dead left and right. If that were true we should have dogs on here dropping dead daily. Who cares about the ears??? - Good breeders care as they are described in the standard - What is your solution to solve genetic disease at this time???

1. Stop all breeding
2. Stop ear cropping ROFLOL
3. Sit and cry all day about genetic disease and how horrible it is
4. Try to keep the breed gene pool healthy and hope science finds magical cures for things that have been around in both animals and humans since the garden

1 2 3 or 4 Which makes more sense? Why should it be a good thing to loose the right to crop and dock and still have the genetic problems???

You can't just sit and fcous on one thing to the exclusion of all others. If you don't have a solution then you need to do what the rest of us are doing. Do the best you can and hope the find the magic bullet.
 
I have a question.
Does anyone or has anyone done ear cropping with a laser? I understand laser tech to be clean,quick,and "seals" up the wound somewhat like a burn.
Just thought I would ask as I don't know?
Spock's were done that way and I really didn't see a lot of benefit over the regular kind. But then again I don't really have anything to compare it to since River came to us fully healed.
 
I don't "think" ours were laser cropped, but all of ours have been fixed using laser. I have heard that it's a nice clean line when they crop using laser so I'm sure it's a great option when it's available.


sorry Jans I must have got mixed up, I though you once talked about laser and just assumed it was the ears
 
Kaloric that is already against the law - so because it might happen in some back woods area you would prefer to see the breed loose breed type???

It's an extreme example of bad practice, I'm just saying there has to be a best practice that is backed by good evidence, the safest and most painless technology, and aftercare techniques that provide results and minimize the chance of infection. That stringing to post ears is apparently still an acceptable practice makes me question what people are thinking, what kind of other bad practices are still occurring. It should make everyone who supports the privilege of cropping worry for the future of being able to do so..

DV someone has really sold you a bill of goods on dogs dropping dead left and right. If that were true we should have dogs on here dropping dead daily.

If the talk of the progeny from a certain Serbian kennel routinely dropping dead at or before 6 years of age is accurate, that situation is downright outrageous. The average natural lifespan for a medium-sized dog like a Dobe seems like it should be somewhere around 11 years, why does it seem that it's towards the extreme upper end of the lifespan and dogs that live over 10 qualify for the Longevity title?

Who cares about the ears??? - Good breeders care as they are described in the standard - What is your solution to solve genetic disease at this time???

There doesn't seem to be anything in the standard about avoiding congenital health problems, and it would seem that a lot of "good breeders" care more about conformation, competition, and other things than they worry about DCM, vWD, z-factor, and other congenital health issues, which is why they continue to be problems. These things have historically not been problems until reasonably recently in purebred dogs, since they're mostly due to extreme linebreeding on the part of focused breeding programs.

Oh, and nope, I don't buy it when folks try to pin these genetic problems on BYBs or the less serious breeders who aren't obsessed with titles, glory, and breed standards. You don't often get homozygous congenital defects from haphazard, random, or convenient breeding, you get it from focused inbreeding in pursuit of some specific trait, hoping that the more you flounder around in a tiny, fouled gene pool, the better chance you might have that something will rise out of it that might attain the glory of its notable ancestors or be "pretty". True, there might be some of those amateur breeders who are just too lazy to screen for genetic disorders who contribute to the problem due to their apathy, but they're just not a major contributor and let's make no mistake about where the congenital diseases came from in the first place. There was a time when a tiny gene pool was necessary to make a consistent, definable breed, but that's in the distant past & it's a great time to clean some of the filth out of the gene pool.

There's obviously nothing that precludes a breeder from breeding for genetic health and longevity in addition to upholding a breed standard, but seriously, if good kennels put as much effort into removing lines plagued by genetic diseases out of their programs as they do into defending the superficial stuff in the breed standard, well maybe it wouldn't seem so much like polishing the bell on a sinking ship. That's all cosmetic surgery on ears is to me, and I'm not jumping the Doberman ship over the glint on the bell, only if I can't trust the integrity of the hull, of which health is a key component. I'm probably taking that metaphor too far...
 
I have a question.
Does anyone or has anyone done ear cropping with a laser? I understand laser tech to be clean,quick,and "seals" up the wound somewhat like a burn.
Just thought I would ask as I don't know?

As other folks have mentioned, yes, lasers cauterize the incision a bit, they make a clean cut, but the light beam also doesn't offer a surface that can potentially introduce bacteria. Even a scalpel that was just sterilized in an autoclave is possibly going to get a few pathogens on as soon as it's exposed to the air, which then get carried down into whatever tissues it is then used to cut. It's usually not too big of a problem, but it seems like it would reduce the risk of an infection somewhat.
 
I'm just saying there has to be a best practice that is backed by good evidence, the safest and most painless technology, and aftercare techniques that provide results and minimize the chance of infection.

I think the problem is getting anyone to agree on what is best practice. Certainly the puppy should be put to sleep and given antibiotics following surgery. But for someone else to try to tell a vet what is the best way to do it would be like asking 10 breeders to agree on every little item. But we should all agree on certain standards and if anyone feels vets do not use care then what is your solution to getting them cropped to suit everyone??? In fact is vets are not using care then we should stop seeing vets period.

There doesn't seem to be anything in the standard about avoiding congenital health problems, and it would seem that a lot of "good breeders" care more about conformation, competition, and other things than they worry about DCM, vWD, z-factor, and other congenital health issues, which is why they continue to be problems. These things have historically not been problems until reasonably recently in purebred dogs, since they're mostly due to extreme linebreeding on the part of focused breeding programs.

Thats because the standard is about the dog not health it is about SHOWING and competiting. That is for the medical profession and those breeding to strive to maintain health. But I can guarantee you no one in their right minds sets out to breed unhealthy dogs. Have you read Ilena and the 7 sires??? Do you understand that by the very nature of the purbred dog it is a closed gene pool??? How exactly do you foul a closed gene pool?? The problems that were bred in were bred in from the beginning and it did not happen recently - it is just now we are a health crazed world. Every other commercial on TV is trying to sell you some drug to solve a problem you didn't know existed. Doctors will create a problem so they can legally sell you a drug.

Are you saying we should do away with purebred dogs to eliminate the health issues or should we use them to study and come up with test that actually prevent something from occuring??? Can't have it both ways and once a gene pool is closed what you have is what you have. Dogs have been dying from the beginning, but people did not even know about health - they took life as it came and the world has survived.

Oh, and nope, I don't buy it when folks try to pin these genetic problems on BYBs or the less serious breeders who aren't obsessed with titles, glory, and breed standards. You don't often get homozygous congenital defects from haphazard, random, or convenient breeding, you get it from focused inbreeding in pursuit of some specific trait, hoping that the more you flounder around in a tiny, fouled gene pool, the better chance you might have that something will rise out of it that might attain the glory of its notable ancestors or be "pretty".

WOW you really hate the purebred dog world - then why not go get a mutt. I have never tried to pin anything but disreputable practices on back yard breeders. In fact with the unreasonable expectation put on heath they may be the only ones left with Dobermans to breed in the end.

If the talk of the progeny from a certain Serbian kennel routinely dropping dead at or before 6 years of age is accurate, that situation is downright outrageous.

And finally the key word is IF IT IS ACCURATE- way too much is speculation and innuendos - I do try not to speculate in the rumor mill and grapevine. It is often far from the mark. If elephants could fly and if the Great Dane had never been bred into our gene pool of the Beauceron both of which supposedly have DCM probems well we would have a different converstion but we don't.

That was not done recently as you imply - that was done in the beginning and when the gene pool was closed that sealed in and or out however you want to look at it the things we see today.

It is daily shoved down peoples throats that the only dogs worth breeding are Champions and not just any old champion but it has to be an approved AKC ch - guess what the limits the gene pool and creates bottlenecks.

Then we turn around and say breeders are breeding sick sick dogs so my solution would be buy only from the BYB because at least they dont' have any ch in their pedigree to speak of.

Only breed to health tested dogs - why??? Won't tell you anything concrete except Vwd and Pdk4 status. Won't keep your dog from getting DCM but at least you can say you tested and that just gives some folks a real warm fuzzy feeling. Breeders don't gou out and say let's see if we can find a sickly dog to breed to. That is such a slap in the face of eveyrone and the dog show world espeically wo have done more to promote the pureberd dog than anyone.

Everytime some says this is not a healthy breed I wonder why they have one then. If you do not believe in them and think they are all sickly then find a healthy disease free breed and go have some fun.
 
Thats because the standard is about the dog not health it is about SHOWING and competiting. That is for the medical profession and those breeding to strive to maintain health. But I can guarantee you no one in their right minds sets out to breed unhealthy dogs. Have you read Ilena and the 7 sires??? Do you understand that by the very nature of the purbred dog it is a closed gene pool???

Nobody plans to fail, they just fail to plan. Or they just don't care, and willfully breed animals they know to carry defects because they're more concerned with money or their breeding program's legacy and rationalize that what they think are their successes outweigh their propagation of genetic diseases.

How exactly do you foul a closed gene pool?? The problems that were bred in were bred in from the beginning and it did not happen recently - it is just now we are a health crazed world.

Let's compare the Doberman gene pool to the Olympic-sized pool in a swimming club. Lots of water in there, with about the same concentration of chlorine and even if it gets a little fouled here and there, there's a lot of water to disperse through so nobody's likely to be too affected. Now take 1,000 gallons of that and channel it into the small tot pool. That's your breeding program and the most closely-related programs that draw on each other primarily. Now if water cycles freely between the bigger pool and the tot pool, chemical concentrations are going to stay fairly consistent, as will the filth concentration, but you're not going to differentiate or specialize, so you have the option to break circulation between the pools and not introduce much from the bigger pool, let's say you do. (By the way, this is the generic "you", of course)

Now any filth in your tot pool is going to be inescapable, but you're trying to keep it clean, even better than the big pool. Oh no, someone has discovered that bacterial levels in your tot pool have somehow climbed! What do you do? I don't know, you could dump all your water and start over with water from the big pool (nobody gives-up on a life's work that easily), you could treat your little pool with some chemical (which would be analogous to aggressive health testing to identify & stop breeding tainted stock), you could dump some of the water and replace it with the water from the bigger pool (dilute the line with fresh blood in hopes of losing some of the concentrated bad traits at the cost of losing some of the concentrated good traits), or...you could just pretend like nothing is wrong and that filth isn't so bad, and that your water is superior despite the filth.

Unfortunately, the latter seems to be what most breeding programs do when confronted with genetic filth in their pool, and it's unethical. Even worse, they generally throw a tantrum and scream about the veterinary researchers who identified the problem and the breed organization that is branding the defect in a conspicuous way that even novices can recognize and avoid.

It's unlikely to find anything extremely good or extremely bad coming out of the breed's bigger gene pool, which is why focus can be good, but only if the focused breeding programs are managed exceedingly cautiously and ethically.

Not everything has been a problem since the beginning. Mutations happen and recombination can sometimes result in interesting things, not all of which are good. Some things were more-or-less present from the beginning, but they didn't become actual problems until a prolific progenitor that carried the trait was linebred, which led to that trait being more pronounced and prevalent.

WOW you really hate the purebred dog world - then why not go get a mutt. I have never tried to pin anything but disreputable practices on back yard breeders. In fact with the unreasonable expectation put on heath they may be the only ones left with Dobermans to breed in the end.

No, I do not "hate" purebreds. For the most part, cats excepted, most of my animals have been purebreds. I just loathe egotistical breeding programs that insist on dumping a steady stream of filth from their tot pools into the greater gene pool rather than cleaning-up their act when it proves to be tainted.

It is daily shoved down peoples throats that the only dogs worth breeding are Champions and not just any old champion but it has to be an approved AKC ch - guess what the limits the gene pool and creates bottlenecks.

Yes, this is a big part of the problem. And, well, it's why I try to avoid too many big fancy titles or famous ancestors in the preceding generation or two of my pedigreed animals.

Only breed to health tested dogs - why??? Won't tell you anything concrete except Vwd and Pdk4 status. Won't keep your dog from getting DCM but at least you can say you tested and that just gives some folks a real warm fuzzy feeling. Breeders don't gou out and say let's see if we can find a sickly dog to breed to. That is such a slap in the face of eveyrone and the dog show world espeically wo have done more to promote the pureberd dog than anyone.

Only health-tested dogs? No way. You're quite correct, health tests don't exist for everything. While it's important to blacklist animals with tested genetic defects from breeding, even though official sanctions almost never get handed-down, it's just as important to take old-fashioned notes on and see if a predisposition to a bad condition exists in a line, and if a strong predisposition is found, dump it.

If a line shows a strong disposition to hip dysplasia, don't keep breeding animals with hips that just barely pass certification, dump them from the program and use breeding stock that isn't close to the edge. There are breeds that are predisposed to epileptic seizures. Once a line is known to suffer those, dump it. Same with DCM and Wobbler's. Is it really that hard to identify a lineage that is predisposed because lots of progeny are being consistently diagnosed with the same health problem, and blacklist it?

Again, I don't think it's a matter of breeders going out of their way to breed diseased animals, but they sure throw fits when their specific disease is conclusively identified through a health or genetic test, and it's so serious that it gets branded or even sanctioned via limited registration. There's no excuse for breeding animals with identifiable genetic problems or diagnosed health problems for any reason. That behavior does make me want to slap those breeders across the face. I don't care how much they're (self-) promoting the breed, knowingly propagating a bad trait is just wrong.

Everytime some says this is not a healthy breed I wonder why they have one then. If you do not believe in them and think they are all sickly then find a healthy disease free breed and go have some fun.

As with my purebred AQHA reg. horses, I take my chances on getting the good while keeping my fingers crossed, with rolls of the dice against the bad. If I find myself losing my rolls consistently, I'm going to find another table. :D So far so good, I firmly believe it's possible to have one's cake and eat most of it, too. You're quite right that exclusive focus on health is going to ruin temperament and working ability, but the reverse is also the case.
 
As other folks have mentioned, yes, lasers cauterize the incision a bit, they make a clean cut, but the light beam also doesn't offer a surface that can potentially introduce bacteria. Even a scalpel that was just sterilized in an autoclave is possibly going to get a few pathogens on as soon as it's exposed to the air, which then get carried down into whatever tissues it is then used to cut. It's usually not too big of a problem, but it seems like it would reduce the risk of an infection somewhat.
This was my thought too about the scalpel and other tools used.I would imagine it to cost more,but then I would think extra cost wouldn't be an issue(for me anyway) if germs and chance of infection were reduced.
Our Dobe is docked,but natural ears.Our next Dobe(coming soon I hope) we will be doing full c/d.
 
Holy shit kaloric,you sound just like one of the bosses at work.I hear him say this to many people there...."failing to plan is planning to fail":DThere is some truth to that.!!
 
Unfortunately, the latter seems to be what most breeding programs do when confronted with genetic filth in their pool, and it's unethical. Even worse, they generally throw a tantrum and scream about the veterinary researchers who identified the problem and the breed organization that is branding the defect in a conspicuous way that even novices can recognize and avoid.

I don't understand when you say breeders throw a tantrum and scream about vet researchers who identified a problem - I know DPCA jumped thorugh hoops when Dr. Meurs announced her DNA test for PDK4 and got her a plane ticket and a scheduled webinar for the Natls on a very short time frame. Why because for the MOST part breeders support heatth testing but it would be foolish to only depend on health testing that is still so up in the air. There are many many things that go into a decision on breeding and I have found that when someone sits on the outside they don't always have all the correct info.

While I agree you have to do some research to find breeders that do more outcrossing they are out there and not all line breeding is bad either.

But I tell you what does bother me - when someone bad mouths something without any concrete proof. There are too many examples of dogs may have had a problem yet did not pass it on and most of the things are things that unfortunately don't show up til later.

While it's important to blacklist animals with tested genetic defects from breeding, even though official sanctions almost never get handed-down, it's just as important to take old-fashioned notes on and see if a predisposition to a bad condition exists in a line, and if a strong predisposition is found, dump it.
Do you not know anyone who has had to do this??? Because I do and they did.

I take my chances on getting the good while keeping my fingers crossed, with rolls of the dice against the bad.

And that in a nut shell is how breeding works. So much is on blind luck of the draw and without concrete proof of everything you refer to it is a crap shoot. That is why we say breeding is not for the faint of heart because a very wise breeder once told me if you breed long enough you will get a little bit of everything. Sometimes things crop up that go way back but I also fear that way too many buy in to the very thing you stated here IF WHAT I HEARD IS ACCURATE. Fact is too many things we don't know so how do you crucify someone for the unknown on whims and innuendos. That has done far more to good breeding than al the health issues ever. Some have tried to make themselves superior by throwing out these erroneous statements and throwing mud at all this supposition.

I know many breeders who jumped on the band wagon and tested their dogs for the PDK4 - boy talk about rumors flying and name calling and slandering breeders only to find out the test was not the end all end all, but it didnot stop them from smearing breeders.
 
I don't understand when you say breeders throw a tantrum and scream about vet researchers who identified a problem - I know DPCA jumped thorugh hoops when Dr. Meurs announced her DNA test for PDK4 and got her a plane ticket and a scheduled webinar for the Natls on a very short time frame. Why because for the MOST part breeders support heatth testing but it would be foolish to only depend on health testing that is still so up in the air. There are many many things that go into a decision on breeding and I have found that when someone sits on the outside they don't always have all the correct info.

That would be an example of handling things in a really ethical way.

But what about how z-factor was handled? I didn't have Dobermans at the time, but from what it sounds like, there were epic tantrums thrown. I'm betting that putting those "z" designations on papers of Shebah's progeny met with much resistance. At least that's what happened with the HyPP crisis that hit the AQHA in the 90s when I was most concerned and involved with the breed and the organization (I dropped my membership out of disgust for the way they handled the matter). Horses did start dropping dead left and right. Mendelian genetics fingered a particular prolific sire, and a genetic test was made for the disease's genetic marker. Since the risk factor and genetic test are so conclusive, and the disease is so serious, you'd think it was a slam-dunk for everyone who loves the breed and the defect would've been eliminated from breeding programs within a single generation. Not so. People hollered over having the risk factor (descent from the sire "Impressive") identified conspicuously on their foals' registrations, so that action was debated for years. An exclusion was adopted only for homozygous positive horses. Carriers are still permitted to be registered and bred, and numerous halter class (this is essentially conformation showing for those not familiar with horsey things) breeding programs continue to breed verified carriers because the organization just won't crack-down on them. An appropriate response would not be to exclude all carriers, but to only grant them limited registrations so they can't have their progeny registered. Is that really too much to ask?

It's unbelievable to me that anyone would even consider, for a second, breeding an HyPP carrier, and from what I've read about albinism in Dobermans, why would anyone consider breeding a z-factor? Also, it seems that there are plenty of Dobermans that do not get diagnosed with DCM, so it should be entirely possible to minimize that defect through conscientious breeding, but that's obviously a bit more complicated due to how and when it's diagnosed, regardless of how it got into the breed.

(On identifying and isolating bad health traits the old-fashioned way) Do you not know anyone who has had to do this??? Because I do and they did.

I would definitely not claim that all (or even most) breeders are delusional and reckless. :D Those who are this conscientious are truly reputable and quality breeders. But it often seems to be the exception than the rule, or maybe the unethical breeders are just the most vocal when it comes to being told that they're wrong. I suppose it's like politicians-- the breeders who are most "successful" at fielding popular sires and dams and gaining fame and fortune for their programs are the most morally-bankrupt and shameless when it comes to doing the right thing even when it's a bitter pill and not expedient for them or their ambitions.

Sometimes things crop up that go way back but I also fear that way too many buy in to the very thing you stated here IF WHAT I HEARD IS ACCURATE. Fact is too many things we don't know so how do you crucify someone for the unknown on whims and innuendos. That has done far more to good breeding than al the health issues ever. Some have tried to make themselves superior by throwing out these erroneous statements and throwing mud at all this supposition.

It's a difficult situation, since it's hard for anyone to compare notes and determine if there's a problem without theorizing and trying to put together data points that aren't all that easy to find. Now here is an area where I'll admit that I'm bad. Of my two deceased horses, I returned neither of their registration certificates for cancellation, including the one who died young. Without folks all reporting back to the breed organizations when their animals die, and not providing causes of death if the death was premature, it's pretty difficult to determine if there's a trend. You're mostly going to hear from the folks who are mad that their animal died prematurely of natural causes such as a congenital defect, but not about the ones who didn't die horribly or prematurely. There's most definitely cause for concern if an inordinate number of people are having their dogs die prematurely.

Well, back on topic, I'm obviously with DV here-- shrugging off a trivial part of a breed standard isn't as detrimental to the breed we care about as knowingly propagating congenital defects. I wouldn't even say it's moral relativism, because there are no moral downsides from not cropping or docking. Opting-out of the cosmetic surgery is a personal choice with no ramifications beyond the individual dogs, which many folks won't even identify as Dobermans. Knowingly propagating diseases may not be against a breed standard, but it hurts us all.
 
I'm just going to make my quick entry and exit:

YES, dogs are dropping dead left and right in certain parts of the world. When I was looking through a bunch of pedigrees (meaning A LOT) from the European lines while trying to decide on which ones I wanted (and definitely didn't want) in my next pup, it was not uncommon to encounter lines with grandparents, great-grandparents and parents dropping dead at age 4-6. In all three generations. And yet people keep breeding these dogs because they want a beautiful dog first and foremost, who cares if it's only around for 5 or so years. It makes me sick.

From what I've read, the US situation isn't that bad, and I know it isn't in Australia after going through the database and looking at lifespans. Just putting that out there, now I'll leave you all to continue the C&D debate.
 

Back
Top