• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?

As long as the dobermann stays a working breed, I don't care about the ears and tails... Looks are not important. I like both natural and c/d equally much. I oppose a ban.

That's because you don't understand that if we have to breed a softer look and the preception no longeer sees it as a serious working dog the temperament will follow and in that case you might as well have a hound - look is very similar. I guarantee you that is we loose one part of the standard then soon others will follow.

Calling that slop "food" is a stretch,dontcha think?

Gel please try to focus here - I was not discussing the quality of the food only that franchises have a "standard" so if you got get noodles in one mcDonalds it will be very similar in another.
Just as BYB don't breed to improve quality, heath or temperament McDonalds does not try to compete with Steak and Ale on quality of what they call food.

this argument is always one sided, and I have never been against you all having a choice , we don't and this law came in before I got back into Dobes, I am sure everyone will loose the right one day, for as much as you shout about it and want to keep your choice once the government makes it's mind up they will just walk all over everyone like they have done here and in the rest of Europe.

I agree with Gel - everyone loves Judith. You don't have to hate someone to have a difference of opinion. And the battle may be one sided but I am on the side of the Doberman not the government. Judith if it were in my power I would give you back the right to uphold the breed standard. I would give it to all Europe - It blows my mind that the very country who is responsible for giving us several of our top working breeds turned around and turn tail (no pun intended) and sold out.
 
I just wanted to add, living in the UK I am JEALOUS of all your lovely crops. Don't get me wrong, I love natural ears and tails, but if I had a choice that wouldn't be it. Alvin also has a natural tail and I frequently get asked if he is a staff (???)

Dobes are in the decline here for sure, I went to a fun dog event and saw three of them the whole day. Nobody where I.live seems to know what a dobe.looks.like. They congratulate me on my new rottie pup :/

Us in the UK have.to make the best of what we have. I know indi's breeder would have.c/d given the choice. It's. Shame for sure but I guess natural is the standard here now. I hope some places keep their right.too choose as I couldn't imagine never seeing a cropped dobe ever again.
 
My heart breaks for you and it breaks for this breed. Everywhere a c/d ban has been implemented reg has droppped drastically. One of the purposes of a standard is to preserve Breed type - In other words the dog should be immediately recognizable by anyone who sees it and is aware of the purebred dog.

If the #'s Marko sent are correct there were only approx 3,400 reg of Doberman in the UK that is barely above critical extincition level. So if we had to depend on the UK to bring this breed back from the brink of extinction we would all be in trouble. Some of the great breeders got out of breeding because they could not bear to see the dog disresepcted and their hard work thrown out the door and controled by government.
 
The European Union is the power behind most of these changes not just the UK government and the EU are a law unto themselves; they tried to bring this law in but the supermarkets took them to court, have you ever heard anything so ridiculous

European laws which insisted that cucumbers and bananas could not be excessively curved and had to be of a certain shape were ruled "unenforceable" by the High Court yesterday.
Reversing two decades of regulations regarded by many as an affront to common sense, Lord Justice Rose said that EU quality grading standards imposed since 1973 were "unknown to law".
The ruling stripped the Government of many of its powers for controlling the shape, quality and description of fruit and vegetables.
 
Seriously Judith? Wow you're right, I never have heard anything so ridiculous. :shakinghead: I better start tossing our delicious cukes if they have a curve in them. :D
 
Me either...
From my experience natural ears have no impact on Doberman health or drive. Poor breeding does...

I'm not saying a dog cannot work without being cropped and docked. What I am saying is, if you don't follow the standard and start dropping things off, what's next? Oversized dogs? Eventually you will be left with something nowhere near the Doberman we love and respect today. I always hear lines like this is it, or this is the last time. It won't end with banning c/d it will continue on to things that will eventually destroy the standard, and the breed.

I responded this to cliffdog as well....

Outlawing c/d is the beginning of a very progressive downward spiral. Just my honest opinion.
 
CKC allows natural ears and it has not destroyed the standard.
BYBs breed oversized dogs. You don't need to ban c/d to achieve it.

Why aren't you concerned about poorly bred out of standard cropped/docked Dobermans with many health issues?
Why aren't you concerned about the beauty contest (dog shows) where judges care more about handlers than dogs?
Why aren't you concerned that health testing is not required for breeding?....

There are so many challenges for our breed to survive... and you focus on cosmetic surgeries.
 
CKC allows natural ears and it has not destroyed the standard.
BYBs breed oversized dogs. You don't need to ban c/d to achieve it.

Why aren't you concerned about poorly bred out of standard cropped/docked Dobermans with many health issues?
Why aren't you concerned about the beauty contest (dog shows) where judges care more about handlers than dogs?
Why aren't you concerned that health testing is not required for breeding?....

There are so many challenges for our breed to survive... and you focus on cosmetic surgeries.

I am concerned about poorly bred dobermans.
I am concerned about the politics behind showing conformation.
I am concerned that health testing is not required for breeding.

We cannot change people, that is a hard truth. But we DO have the ability to vote and fight the government to get unnecessary intrusions out of our lives.

C/d goes hand in hand with things like oversized dobes. What happens when the standard tries to get changed because people like the bigger dogs. I mean its already been substantially changed once, right? Like I said this is a downward cycle.

Your last sentence could not be more accurate. Which is exactly why fighting to maintain the standard is so important. With as few Dobermans you see already this will be a devastating blow, as it has proved to be in Europe. We loose the standard, eventually we loose the dog. That's the plain simple ad hard truth.

I don't want this post to seem aggressive dv. That is not my intention, and I hope you don't take it that way.
The problem with this debate is that each side is equally as passionate, and it makes for heated debates.
 
That's because you don't understand that if we have to breed a softer look and the preception no longeer sees it as a serious working dog the temperament will follow and in that case you might as well have a hound - look is very similar. I guarantee you that is we loose one part of the standard then soon others will follow.

Temperament is going to be whatever temperament the breeders select for. As I recall, there was a pretty bad stretch where thug-bred, loose-cannon vicious Dobermans were a problem, much like thug-bred pit bulls are a problem today. There has to be a balance between too aggressive and too docile, and ears & tail should have nothing to do with it. After all, Rottweilers have natural ears and are viewed as toughies. Beaucerons and the original schutzhund GSDs both have natural tails and they are working protection dogs, so the point about docking having something to do with working/protection cred seems a bit tenuous.

Now while breed popularity has declined in Europe since the c/d exclusions, it should be easy enough to see if there has been a percentage decline in the Dobermans who earn their ScH titles, as compared to the overall Doberman population. Without knowing the actual numbers, my hypothesis would be that there has actually been an increase in the percentage of Dobermans earning ScH titles in the parts of Europe with the exclusions, since the people who were involved with the breed only for the "hard" image have left for other breeds, leaving a core of breeders and owners who are committed to the foundational Doberman temperament.

As I've probably noted before, if c/d cosmetic surgeries are going to inflict inordinate suffering on dogs, either prolonged discomfort due to the surgery itself, due to the method of posting (cf. that stringing thread), or due to overly frequent complications such as infections, such things should be considered cruel and the government should put an end to them. This is no different than the government telling people they can't engage their animals in any other cruel activities such as bloodsports. If the breed community can effectively deal with the bad actors who do not follow the best humane practices, then there should be no need for the government to get involved. Sell the case that neither docking or cropping causes excessive or prolonged discomfort to the dogs, these traditions will remain. If we fail to prove they're not cruel, exclusions will come along, and rightly so.

Anyway, I'm strongly partial to docked tails and reasonably partial to natural ears. Cropped ears do look nice if the cut is nice and have the proper aftercare, but I really have trouble believing they're worth the trouble, the discomfort to the dog, or the risk of how odd the results of a botched crop is probably going to look. Natural ears will never look as bad as a botched crop, regardless of what caused the failure.
 
I wish my natural Dobermans would have softer look :)
Gino and Asha are real toughies. It is an effort for me to make people feel comfortable around my dogs.
My dogs are very protective and watch every stranger approaching me. They are serious dogs.
Ears shape? LOL... it has nothing to do with a dog temperament.
 
I am concerned about poorly bred dobermans.
I am concerned about the politics behind showing conformation.
I am concerned that health testing is not required for breeding.

We cannot change people, that is a hard truth. But we DO have the ability to vote and fight the government to get unnecessary intrusions out of our lives.
I bet your concerned about keeping your rights to be Free as well.Some folks just don't get that.
 
I know the image of a Doberman...the image that you could recognize even from it's silhouette... is of a Doberman with the cropped and docked look. That is what is you see in the media and that is what your average person is going to have in their head when they hear "Doberman" or see one. Dobermans are what, the only personal protection breed? They are naturally protective. I know most doberman owners here do not want to have their doberman have to go so far as to bite to protect because with this day and age, even if your dog was protecting you on your own property, you can easily be the one in trouble...not the other way around!

So, that image is so very important as first defense, as it protects you and your doberman... because most people would stop dead in their tracks a mile away just from the image of a Doberman. There are few breeds that can do that. A doberman is a doberman deep down inside but you have to understand/see how crop+dock has an effect on the breed. Like I said, with how times are now and how things aren't the way they used to be, if your dog bites someone on your property, even if for just cause...your dog's life can easily be at risk. I know I personally would rather have a stranger stop a mile away than for them to get within range of a bite because they didn't recognize that Doberman image.

If it hasn't been clear before, I am pro choice on c/d but I prefer the c/d look.
 
CKC allows natural ears and it has not destroyed the standard.
BYBs breed oversized dogs. You don't need to ban c/d to achieve it.

Why aren't you concerned about poorly bred out of standard cropped/docked Dobermans with many health issues?
Why aren't you concerned about the beauty contest (dog shows) where judges care more about handlers than dogs?
Why aren't you concerned that health testing is not required for breeding?....

DV first Canada just recently lost the right so it has not been long enough to evaluate and trend up or down. You should understand that. It can take years for a ban to make its impact known and by then it can be too late.

Why do you equate the fight to preserve c/d as we don't care about health, judges caring more about handlers. That is a whole different discussion - Why do you think if one supports c/d they are not for the other things?

I will try to help you understand - the judges don't impact the standard in a lasting way, health as we know it today is not a part of the standard but it does call for an entergetic, alert dog which would be a indication of the health as good as anything else we have today.

I don't believe health testing should be required for breeding. WHY because it will not save a breed at this point as there is not enough known to make solid decisions on. I believe we test to gain info in the HOPES it will give us some guidance for the future but it is not the breeding god and we are not even sure how it plays out. Are you saying people should just jump off the deep end at every little whim??? Or should we proceeed with caution until we have better answers??
 
Sometimes I think that with all the bylaws which we're seeing, D4E's blanket attitude of "don't touch the standard" is actually a much better defense than any other rational response.

Looks aside, the US dobe will have issues defending its C/D status because firstly you can't argue that the crop makes it harder for an intruder to catch its ears due to the length of the crop, and if the UK/Canada laws are to be implemented then you better hope that your Dobe has a long fat tail so that the intruder can grab hold and hurt your dog - otherwise your Dobe might retaliate and then be put to sleep :cold:

And that's before some "experts" tell us that C&D brings pain which has NEVER been substantiated. But they can go on and on about how 5 year old Jenny couldn't sleep because she saw an infection (which generally can be cured by one part bleach 10 parts water in 2 days ;))

We want the US Dobe to look like it always had - but I think that D4E's "uphold the breed standard" shizzle is the only way one can go forward to avoid the disintegration of the breed :(
 

Back
Top