Advice? Dog Fights!!

  • Thread starter Thread starter FredC
  • Start date Start date

This is a tough call and it looks like you have received some
really good answers here, although some are not what you
want to hear. I have never been in your shoes.

I am sorry you are going through this and I PRAY FOR ALL OF YOU.
 
Von you might not need to throw in the towel just yet :)

I had worse with my last dobe and the breeder managed to "fix" the issue just as they said they would.

You need to find someone with the experience to help - I'd love to help but in my case it would be more like a hit'n miss affair - these people do exist but getting hold of them is the hardest part. But from what I've seen it's well worth it :)
 
I cannot imagine that type of situation you must be dealing with, for that I'm sorry for you and your troubles with Kali. I'm sure with all the experience on here and knowledge you'll get the results you need. I too would put your GF in charge of more things, especially with Kali so that respect is earned, I.E feeding, correction with your supervision, and of course play time, and leaving the " Hot Spots " off limits such as the sofa, etc.

Seriously good luck in this, I worry about that with my two becoming enemies, but so far it's the furthest thing possible. But yah never know as I'm sure you never thought this would turn out this way.
 
My first thought is that she may be in pain. Have you had her thoroughly checked by a vet? As Lisa said, if they are sick or not feeling well they can lash out. Maybe something hurt when Demi laid on her and when she ran to the door. It is something I would rule out for sure.
 
Wow, this is my worst nightmare. I constantly worry with Nexus and her dominance that she will tear the crap out of poor Bella. Bella is so laid back and calm most of the time but she does like to goad Nexus into action. she wants her to play but Nexus on occasion gets crabby. Or if Nexus is barking at something outside the little stinker Bella nips her hind legs. The only point in my favor right now is that both back off on their own and they both also respect my husband and myself. I am terrified of them actually fighting.

I hope both your girls are ok, and that this problem gets fixed!
 
I'm going to give you bad news too. You need to separate them. I have three Dobermans. Two females one male. Echo and Juno are both females and two years old. Echo is deaf and was raised with Juno but is very submissive so it works in the house. Aslan our male is a big four year old boy and Juno is the dominant one in the house. I no longer run the three of them together because Juno becomes excited and I can see the dominance in her eyes. I have not had a dog fight for 15 years and never want one again! Horrible thing and not only do you feel helpless you end up getting hurt trying to separate them.
In my house everybody had there place and routine is so important here. I don't feed dogs together and I have a gate in our house and when my husband is away Juno or Aslan takes turns on the couch with me. Echo our deaf girl gets along with both of them. My sister that Does not have dogs doesn't understand that I separate dogs and tells me to watch Cesar Milan on tv! Lol! I have had at least three Dobermans in my house now for over twenty years and I've seen a lot of different personalitys but dominance kicks in when you have a pack of dogs. I tend to ramble and go off subject frequently but in my house it works and everybody gets love and attention and have not had a dog fight for fifteen years. It's interesting with dogs if you watch their eyes. I can see what there thinking just by the way they are looking at the other dogs. I hope that makes sense. I don't think it's a bandaid at my house and it works for us.
 
Demi has a good cut but just needs to keep it clean.. Kali wound up with a K9 to the inside of her mouth between the teeth and gums. I didnt notice this when i inspected her wounds, but it was the cause of her extreme discomfort yesterday, She is 100% today.. The vet visit lasted all of 3 minutes.

Keeping them separate has been tough on Kali she wants to play and this is going to take a lot of adjustments from all of us herself included.. Its sad and brings back some bad memories but it is what it is and we will all adjust to the new routine sooner or later
 
I'm glad it wasn't worse, and glad to hear they're on the mend as well. If it's any consolation, I can tell you that our dogs go from angels to monsters the minute Hubby walks into the house, and it's not like he doesn't work with them, but they just know how to get around some things with him, and we all know how smart Dobe's are. ;)

We always kept Dodie separated from our other dogs, and it was mostly because she was the bitch in the group and tried to cause the trouble, even though she was small. It will all work out in the end. :)
 
Thanks for the update and glad they are okay phsyically. Sometimes it is what it is and you are doing a good thing doing what is best for them even though we may not like it. I'm sorry they have to be separated. Can Kali still play with Mars at least or is she full on dog aggressive now and not just same sex aggressive?
 
They got along for years with no issues, and then it started small, a few growls and then small fights, and now they want to kill each other whenever they see each other.
I was talking to my sister yesterday and we talked about dog fights, which she has had experience with, and it was her opinion that once it starts, it usually only gets worse. :( It's very hard to control without 'crate and rotate'. Especially with your GF being the weaker link. Keeping the excitement level down is important. In the case of your GF letting them out of their crates and allowing them all to run to the door, that surely would create a problem.
 
Just my 2 cents, I am not experienced with dogs fighting in my home, but I would definately find a good trainer with experience in this behaviour..in the meantime I would get a muzzle (which USUALLY creates submission) and using lots of praise and treats start putting it on and off of Kali until she fully doesnt mind it, then I would start using it and start working on the two dogs together and then bring in the GF and make her work with the two of them. With Kali in a submissive state, their should be less of a threat to Demi.
I would be using the muzzle when ever they are to be together or when the GF needs to look after them and then seperate untl you find a qualified trainer..one with years of experience, not someone just out of school. Use your judgement when finding one...if they don't seem to understand whats going on or you don't like their training techniques, find another.

Good luck and I'm glad the dogs are going to be ok.
 
I'm a new Dobe owner, but I've had dogs and many times adult same sex dogs don't work well together. The bad news is that they may need to be separated. You provided clues when you talked Kali being dog aggressive. It's not an issue until the dogs get older and the true struggle for dominance begins. Dog aggression is an inherited trait, if you don't want to see it don't breed it. These dogs are for home protection and aggression can get out of hand quickly. Don't put yourself or your lovely dogs in harms way. I had an adult male pitbull named Deebo that was the most loving dog and we kept him with his sister. Never any aggression towards family, friends, or sister, but the moment he saw other dogs he went ballistic. I used to love going to the dog park, but I had to accept he would just have to live at home. I feel your pain.
 
W0w I just am so sorry hearing this! Having always had two males and two intact males by the way I just don't know how to help except to concur with Suzan and Pitts! I wish I had a better answer.. I am glad mine have always gotten along and I would hate to ever have to seperate them! I wish we could perhaps have a little Cesar imput here. You might have a good case that he would be interested enough in to help! That would be so cool and it seems to be a case that would be right up his alley! Why not try it couldn't hurt right??;)
 
Just my 2 cents, I am not experienced with dogs fighting in my home, but I would definately find a good trainer with experience in this behaviour..in the meantime I would get a muzzle (which USUALLY creates submission) and using lots of praise and treats start putting it on and off of Kali until she fully doesnt mind it, then I would start using it and start working on the two dogs together and then bring in the GF and make her work with the two of them. With Kali in a submissive state, their should be less of a threat to Demi.
I would be using the muzzle when ever they are to be together or when the GF needs to look after them and then seperate untl you find a qualified trainer..one with years of experience, not someone just out of school. Use your judgement when finding one...if they don't seem to understand whats going on or you don't like their training techniques, find another.

Good luck and I'm glad the dogs are going to be ok.

Axel,
Not meaning to contradict you at all.
But as a trainer myself who specializes in protection breed dogs, and aggressive dogs, I can tell you that a muzzle does not in any way create submission, as a matter of fact, we use muzzle work to heighten a dogs aggression when going after a bad guy, this creates frustration in the dog as they cant get ahold of what they are trying to and that frustration transfers over to aggression. Muzzles are only good for making it safer to handle a dog, not to create submission.
And as for training this out of the dogs, That is an almost impossibility. I have two myself this way, and know of many other trainers who have the same issue, and everyone will tell you the same thing..... Once it starts, it only gets worse and you will have to crate and rotate, and keep theme seperated.
 
Glad to hear your vet visit went well and I'm sorry about the troubles with your dogs. I would hate to hear that separation is the only option, but if it keeps everyone safe. I've seen dog/dog aggression, but it was usually same sex aggression. Could Kali's attacks on Mars just be frustration if she can't get to Demi? I may be way off base, but parrots are known for attacking their favorite people when they can't get to the spouse or person they are jealous of. (and yes I know this is a doberman forum, not bird talk :))Just my 2 cents. We've been lucky with our 2 females, Soph is pretty dominant and Daisy, even though she is a shepherd/chow mix, has always been submissive even with our super dominant previous Dob, Pansi, so no problems. Wish you the best of luck Von.
 
I honestly don't think it is an inherited thing since Kali is Albert's mom and he's about as placid as you could ever imagine. Granted we have 2 opposite sex dogs, but he's been loose out in the yard with other intact males on break time in class and there wasn't a single issue or sign of aggression. Von stated that with Kai it started young, and Albert is now 15 months old and I can even take away a high value item without an ounce of resistance.
With Boris, we did worry some, even though he was neutered, and he would go into the "red zone" from time to time because he came from a bad breeder and was insecure, but that's definitely not the case with Albert.
 
Axel,
Not meaning to contradict you at all.
But as a trainer myself who specializes in protection breed dogs, and aggressive dogs, I can tell you that a muzzle does not in any way create submission, as a matter of fact, we use muzzle work to heighten a dogs aggression when going after a bad guy, this creates frustration in the dog as they cant get ahold of what they are trying to and that frustration transfers over to aggression. Muzzles are only good for making it safer to handle a dog, not to create submission.
And as for training this out of the dogs, That is an almost impossibility. I have two myself this way, and know of many other trainers who have the same issue, and everyone will tell you the same thing..... Once it starts, it only gets worse and you will have to crate and rotate, and keep theme seperated.

Hey Dale I'm all for information...I just know we use muzzles in grooming, but like I hope I said that it usually works, not 'does' work all the time. And I've seen Cesar do this :) a lot to bring down the heightened agressor, for safety, and to bring back trust.

Didnt realize the muzzle was used to bring out the agreesion..WOW! Though I can see it happening as we groomers know all too well, that the muzzle can bring out the worst in a scared or agressive dog, and you just can't use one on them.

Good to know. Thanks. And it's a lousy way to live with your dogs if you have to crate and seperate. I myself would not put up with that...not for life anyway of my pets...I don't think it is fair to any part of the family, dog or human. Dogs like to be with the pack and if having another dog as part of this pack means trouble, then I believe it is only fair that the agressor should go to a home where he/she is the only dog and can have that pack existance calmly. This is just MY opinion, not trying to get anyone upset, it just seems like an awfully tense way to live, and the joy of having 2 or more dogs in the family is gone.

So you are saying thats it? No dogs can be retrained out of this behaviour?
 

Back
Top