• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Training the e-collar

If you google the name of mine "dogtra 200NCP gold" , you will still find it for sale. Some places have it way cheaper than I bought it. I think sears has it for like 160.00?

Check this one out for small dogs...this is the one I'm looking into now.
http://www.google.com/products/catalog?hl=en&q=dogtra small dog&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.,cf.osb&biw=1366&bih=665&um=1&ie=UTF-8&tbm=shop&cid=6044031881707064562&sa=X&ei=7JWiT4HlD6aw2QX--533CA&ved=0CLUBEPMCMAM
Yes! The IQ is the one suggested to me too. (Ingrid? I'm sorry, I forgot who told me! :down:)

I'm gonna see which one my neighbor bought. Maybe it was the 'gold'. :ty:
 
Quee,

If you were interested in trying the e-collar again...I would tell you to go to the link I posted a little while ago for Stephen. It works. The catch is you have to start it right and you have to be educated yourself before you rely on "the all powerful and magical fix everything" e-collar. If you can't read your dog and you haven't gotten basic training already in place...then yes it will fail. If your dog isn't trained (basic and to the e-collar) correctly, then yes, if you give the vibrate or shock correction (at any level) the dog is going to try and "move away" from the stimulus. Bad part of that is....that also means moving away from you and in the direction of the thing you were trying to avoid. If your dog doesn't look at you as leader and master then you are going to have problems in every aspect of training, be it house training, leash pulling, being destructive, and yes....not coming when called THE 1st TIME you call.
The e-collar is in NO way a magic pill. But when used correctly it is the best tool in dog training 2nd to knowledge of a great mentor!
 
Great points pawpads. The hardest thing with the ecollar, and as with most dog training, is there is no textbook way to go about it. It's almost like with horsemanship...you have to learn and know how to approach the situation according to the individual dog. That's why so many are hesitant about attempting to explain it over the internet, points can be missed very easily! Just take your time is my biggest advice. Read read read all you can and figure out how you are going to go about it in your head first.

MB, I think as time goes on and technology advances, they make newer models and update them with different numbers. Just read into the features each one has and choose which one you like... it really mostly divides down into high output/low output, then the rest of the features are what you think you need. I have the Dogtra Surestim 1900 NCP...but it is now called the Dogtra Surestim H Plus. New name, probably some different things inside...but still the same collar. And, yep. Be sure to google what one you like, I received mine for $80 cheaper than the listed price, at gundogsupply I think it was. I think the IQ would work great for Kali, it's a lot smaller than the others so you shouldn't have to worry about the weight. Although, the weight of the regular sized ones is about 8oz...so half a pound including the strap and receiver.
 
I know for me, this would be a given. But like I told Stephen earlier, some things that we may think is a 'given' may get forgotten in translation to the other person. But this working with your dog in a low profile situation first, is most important and where I would start. I don't know if that is where you started with Pippi but him running so far away (egads!) seems to suggest it was not low profile. He seems to be a very sensitive dog and it will take a very long time to work that out of him. Poor guy, I feel for him!!

I agree. Well said.
 
Rits you're right. As a horse owner I can say that it is similar. Knowledge is Key. Whenever I find someone looking into e-collars for the first time I tell them to go to Leerburg. It can't be explained any easier or clearer than he does it. The facts to back it up are there. Seeing is believing, I always say.

Your local dog trainers are just like us...people. They have preferences and their own ideas of why the dog does this or that.....and God forbid....what it is that is wrong with your dog. They will have large differences in what works and what evil (e-collars) with ever trainer you go to. Don't stop at just one opinion....gain all the info you can before ultimately making your own choice.
 
MyBuddy said:
Oh my! LOL!! This is what makes them so confusing. lol So many names and features! Was it you that suggested the IQ for Kali? It seems to be the one to go with. I am gonna start looking (and reading) on them in the stores too. I think because most people are looking for them for a larger dog, I thought the smaller ones wouldn't be as available, but who knows? It's like anything, you have to do the research, right? lol I remember when I was looking for a horse trailer and I was very confused as to what to buy, how big, gooseneck or bumper pull....wow. My son told me to start looking, READ, read reviews, research and it will all start to make sense and you will get a feel for what you want. I didn't jump on the first one (thank God) and I got what I wanted and am happy with it! :D Man, I hate when the kids are smarter that me! :tap:You guys have been very helpful!

It was me, a few times. It's ok...I forgive you. I'm excited to hear your updates with the little whipper snapper, Kali.:D​
​
​
 
I'm moving Quee's last 2 replies from the other thread here since we were all working at the same time and I don't want them to be left out. :)

Pippi is very sight/sound sensitive. We had an incident with dogs two weeks ago where a knucklehead let his dogs out of his SUV in a car park, without having them leashed and they were not well controlled. Pippi and I were in the park next to Lake Michigan, about a mile and a half away. As soon as she laid eyes on the dogs getting out of the SUV (we were training but she was getting tired and not focusing on me as much), she started instantly barking and lunging, and the dogs made a beeline in about a minute over that mile and a half to get to Pippi. I had to break out the mace - fortunately Pippi's snarling and my kicking at them stopped them in their tracks until their lazy-a$$ed owner ambled over (about 5 minutes later) to get the two miscreant dogs out of our face.

She goes from 0 to 100 miles per hour in about 2 milliseconds. There is no 'ramping up' to her aggressive state - she's either mellow or in Cujo mode instantly - there's no in between. And when she hears or sees trains it's even worse - she's in the zone instantly, and if she's not already restrained she really doesn't have the ability to hear, smell, taste or anything else once she's triggered - shemust get to that train or dog in her mind. When restrained I've tried giving her her favorite treats that she begs for - but she turns her face away so that she can keep her eyes on the train. I've tried covering her eyes - she will fight like a mad creature to be able to retain sight of her target (train or dog), no amount of commands, food, or redirection will stop her - short of physically draggin her to a place where there is no prospect of seeing or hearing her target.

She's an extreme case - but only in these specific situations - she's otherwise very sweet and pretty mellow - she loves people, and likes dogs (spends many days during the week at day care with dozens of dogs). She's come a long way on a lot of other issues very quickly, but I've been working with her on these issue for the last 8 months since I adopted her, and she's really dug in her heels and hasn't changed a bit in her level of reactiveness to these things.

Thank you Pawpads. I'm hesitant to try again - not only because of our failure, but also because our trainer in assessing her has suggested that it probably won't work even if she or one of the other trainers were to work with her using that tool. Her case seems to be very unique according to our trainers - in the case of trains we believe she was hit by one before she was rescued, which is why she is so white-hot in the zone when she hears or sees them, and the e-collar or any other attempts at redirecting her fail when she's in the presence of trains. Her problem with trains occurs regardless of who is handling her.

Because she has a similar (but less extreme) problem with dogs, and that problem seems to be related to me specifically (she's over-protective with me when dogs are around, where with trains she simply wants to attack them and it has nothing to do with protection of me) we're working on that first since it seems the easier of the two problems, and it may set the stage for addressing her train issues.

The trainer said that with the e-collar seeming to egg her on instead of stopping her from what she's doing, it's not going to be a usable tool to address her chasing issue.
 
Quee,

I suggest getting another trainer to evaluate her. I'm not saying your trainer is bad/wrong. I'm just saying seek other help before deciding "Ok, this is what's wrong with my dog". Don't take it as gospel just bc one trainer says so. I have no doubt that if used correctly the e-collar would fix both issues. I also would NOT allow your current trainer to work your dog with the e-collar if she has already stated that she is against using them. The dog aggression problem won't change with you unless you yourself change. She feeds off you. Sounds crazy, I know, but it's true.
As far as getting hit by a train....I seriously doubt that. I think it's something that makes her fearful and stressed BUT it moves "away" quickly, which makes her want to "go after" it in an effort to try an control the situation that makes her so fearful/uncomfortable.

I was told about and have seen people mention a guy named Cesar on here. I finally saw a few of his shows and I have to tell you that guy knows his stuff. The few shows I have seen were great! I have been using the techniques he uses forever!Those people on his show had to contact him somehow....maybe you should give him a call! :D

Dogs will live in the Right Now if you let them....they only hang on to stuff if we do.

I wonder if Cesar has is show on DVD? I think I might like to see more of them. :ot:
 
The trainer said that with the e-collar seeming to egg her on instead of stopping her from what she's doing, it's not going to be a usable tool to address her chasing issue.

It most definitely WOULD be a tool to use for this behavior. The problem is the ground work was not laid down before trying to use it at her highest level of fixation. It's all in the foundation of the training! You can't just slap the e-collar on a dog and the take them into a situation that causes their highest level of frustration and excitement and think you can hit a vibrate or shock button and the dog is going to magically turn into Lassie. NOT GOING TO HAPPEN. The only thing that is going to happen at that point is that the e-collar correction is going to push them even farther into a excited state....it wouldn't matter at that point what level you set the remote on. If you really want to help you dog and ease the stress on yourself then all you have to do is a little research. If it was my dog I wouldn't hesitate to talk to people, read or try anything. You're dog has a deadly obsession, period!
No one person has the answers.....but I can tell you that the e-collar works. I just can't stress enough that it's a tool and it has to be used properly to work! I mean you wouldn't try to drive in a screw with the handle of the screw driver would you?

Quee,
Try this link. Get another professional opinion.

http://leerburg.com/qaelectric.htm#7
 
Thanks Jan....I haven't seen a lot of his shows but I really do like him. He thinks like a dog....which is VERY helpful when trying to alter a behavior. I found it funny how shocked the people were when he made them realize that THEY were the problem in almost all the issues and not their dog. Thanks for the website!
 
Quee,

I suggest getting another trainer to evaluate her. I'm not saying your trainer is bad/wrong. I'm just saying seek other help before deciding "Ok, this is what's wrong with my dog". Don't take it as gospel just bc one trainer says so. I have no doubt that if used correctly the e-collar would fix both issues. I also would NOT allow your current trainer to work your dog with the e-collar if she has already stated that she is against using them. The dog aggression problem won't change with you unless you yourself change. She feeds off you. Sounds crazy, I know, but it's true.
As far as getting hit by a train....I seriously doubt that. I think it's something that makes her fearful and stressed BUT it moves "away" quickly, which makes her want to "go after" it in an effort to try an control the situation that makes her so fearful/uncomfortable.

I was told about and have seen people mention a guy named Cesar on here. I finally saw a few of his shows and I have to tell you that guy knows his stuff. The few shows I have seen were great! I have been using the techniques he uses forever!Those people on his show had to contact him somehow....maybe you should give him a call! :D

Dogs will live in the Right Now if you let them....they only hang on to stuff if we do.

I wonder if Cesar has is show on DVD? I think I might like to see more of them. :ot:

Thank you Pawpads. I think I've watched most episodes of the Dog Whisperer (Cesar Millan) and have many of them 'Tivo'ed' for playback. Some of his training methods are a bit strange (like kicking your dog) and I avoid using those, but have used others. I've seen how he works with extreme cases too, and occasionally tried some of those methods.

In a few weeks we're going lure coursing at a Doberman rescue charity event (where your dog can chase lures) and I'm also going to see what some of the folks there think. Many of them have seen it all pretty much as they are trainers or fosters or have just had Dobes all their lives.

Based on feedback from other trainers and dog owners, Pippi's situation really does seem unique. The train thing is not just a visual trigger - if she hears them or feels them (because they're in close proximity at home, sometimes we can feel their rumble before we even hear them), she's off like a shot if she's not restrained.

After going through our set of trainng sessions the next few weeks specifially on her dog-aggressiveness, I will get her evaluated by another trainer specifically on the train issue. I have friend who is a dog trainer who does great obedience training with large dogs, and he's going to come over and evaluate her in the specific situation with trains, to see what he recommends as a training plan for her based on that specific situation.
 
Pippi's situation really does seem unique. The train thing is not just a visual trigger - if she hears them or feels them (because they're in close proximity at home, sometimes we can feel their rumble before we even hear them), she's off like a shot if she's not restrained.

She is NOT unique....I wish I could make you see that. She associates the sounds, the feelings, even smells of certain types, to the Train....which has become her fixation. If the train by your house comes at the same time everyday, I wouldn't even be surprise if you said, "Everyday a 3pm she get anxious and growls and paces the floor". She knows that they are linked. Just like people who feed their dogs canned food can just turn on the can opener and the dog comes running!Does the dog do it because of the can opener itself because that dog it unique...NO! It does this because it has associated the sound of the can opener with it's food!

Some of his training methods are a bit strange (like kicking your dog) and I avoid using those

I have seen him do what you are describing....but he is NOT kicking the dog. He is delivering a touch to the flank area on the dog (much like riding horses). It is an area that when touched quickly with medium pressure can make the dog drop focus on whatever else is going on around him...kind of a "hey, snap out of it and come back down to earth!" It is very effective......try it. If you're sitting on the couch (let's say for this example anyway) and ur dog is fixated on something....give her a quick touch to the flank area with your finger tips. You can even add a "hey" in a firm tone to add more power to your touch....or do that weird "sshhhhh-ing" noise that he uses! Use the same amount of pressure that you would use to toss someone the keys to your car if the were across the room. It works....and it gives you a window of a few seconds to redirect her behavior in a way that you want.
The reason Cesar uses his foot (in a side kicking action) is because he has his hands tied up with a leash or other dog or something and isn't able to take the time to readjust his body to make the touch by hand. That touch correction has to be given at a certain time....you have to address a dog's action at the exact moment it's happening and right before it starts to escalate. If a dog is at a certain level or gets to those levels very fast (like your dog), then pulling on the leash, collar, choke chain, prong collar, and yelling or saying NO! over and over again, or even using the dogs name....is not going to mean anything! It's not going to have an affect on your dog. That's why you have seen him use a touch to the flank area....

Have you ever been around a bitch and her puppies? Have you seen the bitch correct the puppies? If so I can't see where you would have any concern about giving a touch to correct your dog. I'm not saying pick up a baseball bat by any means.....I'm not saying hit your dog or kick him to the ground. But if you are afraid or too timid to correct this dog you have then all I can say is, GOOD LUCK.
 
He is delivering a touch to the flank area on the dog (much like riding horses). It is an area that when touched quickly with medium pressure can make the dog drop focus on whatever else is going on around him...kind of a "hey, snap out of it and come back down to earth!" It is very effective......try it.​
​
Holy cow that's interesting and I do know that about horses, but I tried just a little tap (with the back of my fingers) to Albert's flank area when he has his issue with Della going out with Dad and it immediately made him refocus on me and stop with his fussing about Della leaving. Ya learn something new every day! :thumbsup:
I have seen how so many take it way overboard about Cesar "kicking" the dogs (I don't mean you Quee :)) and I've always said that there's no way he's really kicking them when he's doing it from behind as he's leading them and there's no way it could be more than a tap to refocus them from that angle.
 
I have to give credit to my dad for all of my knowledge about dogs. My dad taught me that touch method before I was a teenager (MANY years ago!) . I saw 2 more Cesar shows today....it's amazing! It's like he and my dad went to the same "secret" dog training school! :rolleyes: My grandpa said daddy was training dogs since he was 5! About the only difference is dad always said "Hey!" were Cesar does that "Shhhh" thing.
When I first started training GSD I would ask his advice about bringing a certain behavior out of a dog....if I came back and told him it didn't work he would say, "Well, think about it for a bit then come tell me what it is that YOU"RE doing wrong". We never realize the magical effect that a good mentor has on us until their unavailable. I would give anything to be able to take another training lesson from dad!


This was a little mutt dad worked with when he first joined the Navy. The dog was a little stray and soon became the base mascot! This was in Palau.
daddog.webp
 
For those who want to train on a long-line but have too many trees, bushes, rocks, etc at home, I recommend taking the dog to a field such as a baseball or soccer field. A bonus to using a field away from home is that there are new scents for the dog to investigate. The new scents are particularly useful in recall training because they are powerful enough to take the dog's mind off the training at hand. When training recall with a combination of a long-line and e-collar, the dog can tend to stick to the handler and offer no opportunity for correction during the training session, so having powerful enough distractions for the dog makes the training session much more productive.
 

Back
Top