• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Training the e-collar

If Justice is with you, then he is learning things from you. If you see a porcupine and focus on killing it, he will too. I never heard of porcupine quills loosing their sticking ability after the porcupine is dead.

I'm aware of the e-collar training you've been doing with Justice from the posts I've read here and it doesn't sound like you've done your homework. It doesn't sound like you have taken the time to teach Justice what the "shock" means. It doesn't sound like you've done the foundation work with a collar and long-line to teach Justice to associate the stim with a correction. Without the foundation work that builds up to using the e-collar, the stim just seems random to a dog and possibly even elevates the dog's drive to chase and get prey.

Agreed with Ingrid, like I mentioned, it's very important to have the physical reminder too so he knows what the stim means. For example, I set Java up with a couple of weeks of foundation work before I relied on the collar alone.
 
If Justice is with you, then he is learning things from you. If you see a porcupine and focus on killing it, he will too. I never heard of porcupine quills loosing their sticking ability after the porcupine is dead.

I'm aware of the e-collar training you've been doing with Justice from the posts I've read here and it doesn't sound like you've done your homework. It doesn't sound like you have taken the time to teach Justice what the "shock" means. It doesn't sound like you've done the foundation work with a collar and long-line to teach Justice to associate the stim with a correction. Without the foundation work that builds up to using the e-collar, the stim just seems random to a dog and possibly even elevates the dog's drive to chase and get prey.


O.K I'll let him wear it for a few weeks before I start again. The instructions say nothing of letting him wear it for weeks.......... I'm just going to see if a trainer in the area is trained in E-collars so I don't screw this up.
 
O.K I'll let him wear it for a few weeks before I start again. The instructions say nothing of letting him wear it for weeks.......... I'm just going to see if a trainer in the area is trained in E-collars so I don't screw this up.
I've made a lot of critical posts regarding your management of Justice and have felt bad about my wording of my posts and you not taking my suggestions very well, but I can't stay silent about this e-collar thing. The instructions that came with your collar most likely suck. Finding a trainer is a good idea!

I've used the e-collar as a last resort type of prey drive interuption, and it is not pretty. Even after proper recall training and graduation to an e-collar, dogs will be dogs when faced with a temptation that exceeds its will to obey training. When that happens, I have pushed the "continuous" button. It stops the dog from chasing deer and possibly getting hit by a car or lost in a strange place, but the dog screams in pain. It's an ugly last resort to a possibly preventable situation. I learned my lesson on this with Ladybug. I was taking her to work with me every day in a place where deer were bedding down at night, and when I got to work with her they were just getting up. I let Ladybug just jump out of the truck when I arrived, and she would find the deer and set off chasing them. I shocked her to the point where she would stop which also happened to be the point where she was screaming in pain. It was then that I realized that it wasn't worth tempting her with the ability to chase deer and put a leash on her before even letting her out of the truck. I don't have the stomach for that sort of use of an e-collar, and I doubt you do either. We don't want to hurt our doggy friends. I'd rather give my dog a hard shock than have her hit by a truck and die, but given the choice I'd rather avoid the situation entirely. I was stupid to let Ladybug loose and she wound up paying the price. That doesn't happen any more.
 
I've made a lot of critical posts regarding your management of Justice and have felt bad about my wording of my posts and you not taking my suggestions very well, but I can't stay silent about this e-collar thing. The instructions that came with your collar most likely suck. Finding a trainer is a good idea!

I've used the e-collar as a last resort type of prey drive interuption, and it is not pretty. Even after proper recall training and graduation to an e-collar, dogs will be dogs when faced with a temptation that exceeds its will to obey training. When that happens, I have pushed the "continuous" button. It stops the dog from chasing deer and possibly getting hit by a car or lost in a strange place, but the dog screams in pain. It's an ugly last resort to a possibly preventable situation. I learned my lesson on this with Ladybug. I was taking her to work with me every day in a place where deer were bedding down at night, and when I got to work with her they were just getting up. I let Ladybug just jump out of the truck when I arrived, and she would find the deer and set off chasing them. I shocked her to the point where she would stop which also happened to be the point where she was screaming in pain. It was then that I realized that it wasn't worth tempting her with the ability to chase deer and put a leash on her before even letting her out of the truck. I don't have the stomach for that sort of use of an e-collar, and I doubt you do either. We don't want to hurt our doggy friends. I'd rather give my dog a hard shock than have her hit by a truck and die, but given the choice I'd rather avoid the situation entirely. I was stupid to let Ladybug loose and she wound up paying the price. That doesn't happen any more.


Well as to not listening, I don't listen to authority type comments so if that's your aggressive pattern we mine as well never speak again. I'll blow you off and call you names till I'm blue in the face. But we all know where that get's us " NOWHERE ". I'm the guy that admits when I'm wrong, and yes I'm wrong, but I do learn from mistakes ( Mostly ). To scold me, yell at me ( online ) doesn't get anywhere with me. Just tell me what it is you think is best.

Hell I'm not sure exactly what I've done with my dog that upsets you or worry's you to a point of a lecture or holding back as you say. If you don't like me or my way of raising him that's certainly your opinion, but keep it yours and don't bother me again. I'd delete this account if I'd get upset enough, but I'm not exactly sure where the delete button is ? ( I've looked )

Funny how no one else chimed in on advice about letting him sit with the collar on for weeks prior to use. I'd love nothing more than to throw the damn thing away at this point ! But all in all it's best as you so say, and many other's, so I LISTENED, Bought the best kind a guy can get, and let it sit in a box until it was really necessary. Well now it necessary in my mind, and so I'm willing to LISTEN to reason.
 
Well as to not listening, I don't listen to authority type comments so if that's your aggressive pattern we mine as well never speak again. I'll blow you off and call you names till I'm blue in the face. But we all know where that get's us " NOWHERE ". I'm the guy that admits when I'm wrong, and yes I'm wrong, but I do learn from mistakes ( Mostly ). To scold me, yell at me ( online ) doesn't get anywhere with me. Just tell me what it is you think is best.

Hell I'm not sure exactly what I've done with my dog that upsets you or worry's you to a point of a lecture or holding back as you say. If you don't like me or my way of raising him that's certainly your opinion, but keep it yours and don't bother me again. I'd delete this account if I'd get upset enough, but I'm not exactly sure where the delete button is ? ( I've looked )

Funny how no one else chimed in on advice about letting him sit with the collar on for weeks prior to use. I'd love nothing more than to throw the damn thing away at this point ! But all in all it's best as you so say, and many other's, so I LISTENED, Bought the best kind a guy can get, and let it sit in a box until it was really necessary. Well now it necessary in my mind, and so I'm willing to LISTEN to reason.
You are correct about the tone my posts can have at times, and I have withdrawn quite a bit from posting since we have been butting heads. I don't intend to lecture but rather share experiences and answer questions. If you click my name, a box will pop up where you can choose to ignore me. I've never done it, but I think doing that would block all posts from me.

No one else chimed in on letting Justice acclimate to wearing the e-collar prior to zapping him because they recommended that you get training first. No one here can give you a step-by-step guide over the internet on how to train your dog on the e-collar.
 
Sorry Stephen, I thought you realized when I brought up the leash thing that even though you don't like it, that it's kind of a necessity to have a physical correction from the leash along with the stim so you set up him up correctly. I also mentioned leaving it on "10 minutes" or so before use and after. I may have skipped over some things but in reality, a trainer or someone in person is really the way to go to learn how to use one for you at this point, it is truly difficult to explain over the net unless you have a pretty good understanding of it already.
 
You are correct about the tone my posts can have at times, and I have withdrawn quite a bit from posting since we have been butting heads. I don't intend to lecture but rather share experiences and answer questions. If you click my name, a box will pop up where you can choose to ignore me. I've never done it, but I think doing that would block all posts from me.

No one else chimed in on letting Justice acclimate to wearing the e-collar prior to zapping him because they recommended that you get training first. No one here can give you a step-by-step guide over the internet on how to train your dog on the e-collar.


Ingrid,

( in response ) Nor should I have to hit the ignore button or want too. Again, I'm not sure what it is I exactly do that is so wrong when it comes to raising Justice, but I do care more than you know. Heck that's why I'm on here a few times a day, learning, sharing, and having fun. Sometimes things on here can get heated, serious, or over indulged, but it's all part of sharing opinions and experiences that is of great value to me.

I enjoy being on here, I enjoy learning ( not as much as the fun ), sharing, contests, etc. This is not like other sites where ridicule rules, which is one of many reasons I'm here now. There are other sites, much more harsh, much more political, showy, etc........ This is a great all around place for us to be.

Butt heads we may, not saying I didn't respect your opinion. If I didn't care what you thought, I wouldn't of followed up with the breeder recommendation you were kind enough to give me. You explained how it was a good fit, since I'm a ruleless doberman owner. Wait, that's too harsh, I'm not a " Ruleless Doberman Owner " in the least. Prey Drive is a hard thing to correct, and I think everyone will agree on that.

I'm not looking for a step by step instruction to raising my boy, or the new puppy on the way. I comment a lot on here, I start a lot of posts, so I'm much more subject to correction than the other's that don't post as much. I like to get it out there, share if you will, my experiences, in an honest sometimes blunt way.

For example: There are times when I think what I'm doing is correct, 30 of you will disagree. So I heed that advice ( sometimes ) and move on with that knowledge. Contradicting I know, sorry.........

The collar is a pain for me let's just get that out of the way. Justice has had a few set backs, but I had hoped he'd learn from them on his own. I was wrong, so now the one thing that I ask isn't step by step instructions, isn't a how to guide, but a kind response into what the correct procedure is. You say the instructions suck, well that maybe so, but I was also advised to read the instructions, and proceed. I DID !!!
 
Sorry Stephen, I thought you realized when I brought up the leash thing that even though you don't like it, that it's kind of a necessity to have a physical correction from the leash along with the stim so you set up him up correctly. I also mentioned leaving it on "10 minutes" or so before use and after. I may have skipped over some things but in reality, a trainer or someone in person is really the way to go to learn how to use one for you at this point, it is truly difficult to explain over the net unless you have a pretty good understanding of it already.


It's O.K Rits, it's not your responsibility to coddle me and always show me the light. Nor was that ANYTHING I was looking for out of you. People did say find a trainer, that's for sure.......There isn't one within reason unless I drive to the cities. Most of them are dog hunters I've found and work normal day jobs, vs teaching training sessions for a living. I take some sleeping pills at night ( mostly when I'm on ), so most times I forget what the conversation is even about the day after. So you may have told me, someone else may of told me, but it didn't stick. I am a busy guy, and have other issues to deal with during my normal day plans, so sometimes this forum and it's advice escapes me.
 
Sorry you're having such a hard time with this, Stephen. I find that sometimes when I try and explain or teach something to someone, that it's really hard to remember where the other person is coming from, that their mind is a blank on (whatever subject we are talking about) and that mine is full of information that I'm trying to get out in a timely, helpful manner. So sometimes I think things get overlooked because I might assume they know that part, when in reality, they didn't. And it might be a very important part! lol

I've been on DCF longer than you so of course, I've read a lot more on here too. And it seems e-collars have come up a lot. I think it was here where I first learned a bit about them! I never had an interest in them and never worked with them. So I was eager to learn. I posted somewhere here (I thought it was this thread but now can't find it! grr ) about a guy on here that posted the way he taught his dog and I was so impressed! It was similar to what a few people here mentioned.....he had let the dog wear it for maybe two weeks before he even pressed the button! He didn't want the dog associating the collar with the zap. And that was very important to me because one of the things that I always felt was 'wrong' with an e-collar was that folks just put it on and zap, zap, zap the dog, with no training or ease into the thing. I always felt there had to be some kind of training or something that helped the dog understand the connection between a given command and the zap. I mean, that made sense to me that you can't just throw on an electric collar and zap a dog and he's gonna know, Oh that means I have to come back to you.

Once the dog got acclimated to wearing it like any other collar, then he started the training. The long line is a big help for that just like it is when you are teaching a dog to come outside a house situation. Kali has been on a flexi leash or long line since I've had her and I had already thought to myself that that long line will be staying on with the e-collar! I realized it would be a great help in her learning that an ignored pull on the line (after a 'COME' command) will follow by a vibe or nick. That will be her 'association.'

And I've read several situations here where a dog was already in the red zone (ie barking at a dog or ready to fight) and the owner zapped him and pushed him over the edge because the zap was too late....he was already soooo agitated that 'electrocuting' him just set him off, maybe even made him feel it was the other dog biting. So I was already seeing that this e-collar business had a lot more to it. I've even read here on DCF a few times that the instruction manual was not all that good. So I guess DCF had armed me a bit with information that may have come in bits and bits and maybe we just didn't relay it all properly to you. I've been 'gathering' information on this for a long time, but only because it has peaked my interest, ya know? You probably, not so much.........and thats understandable! We all take from here the things that interest us, and sorta let others go by the wayside. But then when that part becomes a part of our lives, we gotta go back and 'pick it all back up' so to speak.

I think we have some threads on here about e-collars, but maybe we should group them.......even this thread should possible be pruned to another thread of it's own on e-collars. I'm sure we are not the only folks interested in learning about them.

And you see I still have not got the e-collar....lol...partly because I am still trying to learn by reading in DCF. But just last night I had a dream that Kali sneaked out TWO slightly open doors to the outside, even as I am screaming for her! And just like in a dream, I could not get dressed fast enough!!!! Everything was in slo mo...............ughhhhhhhhh, couldn't find my bra either! :groan: :bag:
 
Sorry you're having such a hard time with this, Stephen. I find that sometimes when I try and explain or teach something to someone, that it's really hard to remember where the other person is coming from, that their mind is a blank on (whatever subject we are talking about) and that mine is full of information that I'm trying to get out in a timely, helpful manner. So sometimes I think things get overlooked because I might assume they know that part, when in reality, they didn't. And it might be a very important part! lol

I've been on DCF longer than you so of course, I've read a lot more on here too. And it seems e-collars have come up a lot. I think it was here where I first learned a bit about them! I never had an interest in them and never worked with them. So I was eager to learn. I posted somewhere here (I thought it was this thread but now can't find it! grr ) about a guy on here that posted the way he taught his dog and I was so impressed! It was similar to what a few people here mentioned.....he had let the dog wear it for maybe two weeks before he even pressed the button! He didn't want the dog associating the collar with the zap. And that was very important to me because one of the things that I always felt was 'wrong' with an e-collar was that folks just put it on and zap, zap, zap the dog, with no training or ease into the thing. I always felt there had to be some kind of training or something that helped the dog understand the connection between a given command and the zap. I mean, that made sense to me that you can't just throw on an electric collar and zap a dog and he's gonna know, Oh that means I have to come back to you.

Once the dog got acclimated to wearing it like any other collar, then he started the training. The long line is a big help for that just like it is when you are teaching a dog to come outside a house situation. Kali has been on a flexi leash or long line since I've had her and I had already thought to myself that that long line will be staying on with the e-collar! I realized it would be a great help in her learning that an ignored pull on the line (after a 'COME' command) will follow by a vibe or nick. That will be her 'association.'

And I've read several situations here where a dog was already in the red zone (ie barking at a dog or ready to fight) and the owner zapped him and pushed him over the edge because the zap was too late....he was already soooo agitated that 'electrocuting' him just set him off, maybe even made him feel it was the other dog biting. So I was already seeing that this e-collar business had a lot more to it. I've even read here on DCF a few times that the instruction manual was not all that good. So I guess DCF had armed me a bit with information that may have come in bits and bits and maybe we just didn't relay it all properly to you. I've been 'gathering' information on this for a long time, but only because it has peaked my interest, ya know? You probably, not so much.........and thats understandable! We all take from here the things that interest us, and sorta let others go by the wayside. But then when that part becomes a part of our lives, we gotta go back and 'pick it all back up' so to speak.

I think we have some threads on here about e-collars, but maybe we should group them.......even this thread should possible be pruned to another thread of it's own on e-collars. I'm sure we are not the only folks interested in learning about them.

And you see I still have not got the e-collar....lol...partly because I am still trying to learn by reading in DCF. But just last night I had a dream that Kali sneaked out TWO slightly open doors to the outside, even as I am screaming for her! And just like in a dream, I could not get dressed fast enough!!!! Everything was in slo mo...............ughhhhhhhhh, couldn't find my bra either! :groan: :bag:


Now that's a detailed response ! LOL

Each and everyone of us here need to learn something. I'm usually a hands on guy, I typically throw instructions away and just go with it. This E-Collar seems to be a controversial subject, and some deep emotions get expanded on it. I translate info differently than most, I cut thru the blah, blah, blah and get to the point quickly. Such as Step 1...... Wear E-Collar 2 weeks, Step-2........ Wear leash with collar for 2 weeks, etc.

20 different people giving 20 different opinions can confuse issues and cause mistakes to happen. Prime example was me recently. I don't blame anyone except myself for allowing this mistake to happen. No harm has been done, he's not going to be ruined.


So long and short, Justice will wear his collar for another 2 weeks before we start training. Long lunge lines will not work out here for us, it's too much of a pain to get hung up in trees so I'll have to use a shorter leash. I did find a nice video explained how to work with the collars that highlights the good points of training in a rather easy form for me to pick up on. Again, well be fine. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.......
 
Long lunge lines will not work out here for us, it's too much of a pain to get hung up in trees so I'll have to use a shorter leash.
As I was just out with Kali on her long line while I tended horses, this thought did pop up again in my head....I have to admit that a larger dog on a long line is sometimes a bit more PITA that a dog like Kali. It would work well out in the open, like I have seen in many pictures on here with folks in a park or airfield. But I certainly feel for you in a wooded situation! I get frustrated when Kali gets caught on a stupid high peak of grass! I've got 45 feet of clothesline and believe me, it gets me like this at times :complain: LOL So I understand you not wanting to deal with that in your woods. I hope something else works for you. Maybe even working some commands and e-collar work in the house or a smaller fenced in area.

Now, ya wanna share what video you found that you liked??? :wub:
 
Stephen,
I'm just checking back in with this thread....since it was posted or shortly there after. I will tell you I am a huge fan of the e-collar training and I DON"T CARE what anyone else's opinion of them is. I know they work. I know they are an amazing tool. When the training is set in place correctly, there is no need to ZAP your dog to the point of pain and crying out....well, let me correct that and say there might come a day that it happens but it would have to be an extreme situation and could possible be over adjusting on the human part. You learn your dog's stimulus threshold. And in a situation when more is needed you will know that you only have to step it up a notch....not jack it up to the max. You work with your dog with the e-collar BEFORE they are placed in a high excitement situation! Then you learn how much is needed for your individual dog. Justice is your dog and more than that, I can tell he's your best friend and family....that's a plus for you (and him) bc that means you can read him. You can read his body and know when he is in a prey drive mind set and when he is getting more focused on a sent, sound, or sight. At that time you can go ahead and snap him out of it.......verbal first then leash if he's wearing one, if not, the e-collar if need be. There are many different collars for a reason....small dog, high drive, mild mannered, collars with vibrate only. I am posting a link here. It's really good. You can also find Leerburg on FB. He post short training videos of all kinds often. Just check it out before you spend what I'm sure will be a lot of money on a trainer. You seem like a very smart and driven guy to me.....I'm sure you can find the answers you need here and benefit from the products they offer.

s/n I use the Dogtra e-collars only....but that's my personal choice after using a few other makes. Also keep in mind that when the dog is introduced to the collar the right way, they don't associate the "correction" with the collar.....they think of it as an extension of you or something that occurred due to what ever action they just preformed. So knowing that....a dog might give a verbal response in the beginning phases of e-collar training....but it's not ALWAYS bc of a pain factor. Sometimes a dog gives a verbal response due to mental stimulus. If your dog in highly fixated on something and you give a "touch" (even the light snap of the leash) to bring them back to earth....that too can cause a verbal yip or squeal from the mind snapping out of the fixation. Much like when a dog is close to an object of it's fixation but can't quite get to it...the dog whines or make and high pitch cry.
Now this is not to say that this is the case if you have the remote jacked up to the highest setting (or way higher than ur dogs normal tolerance). Of course that can bring about a cry of pain.....but this is way it's important to educate yourself with the use and training of the e-collar first.
I'm not in any way judging you or anyone. We are all individuals and I for one can respect that. This was just my 2 cents worth and I hope that you find the link helpful. Also you can find me on FB (seems like I live there) and if you need more help along the way, I'm willing to help in anyway I can or even connect you with some Sport Dog trainers that I know.
~Charity Maxwell~

http://leerburg.com/318.htm
 
Stephen,
I'm just checking back in with this thread....since it was posted or shortly there after. I will tell you I am a huge fan of the e-collar training and I DON"T CARE what anyone else's opinion of them is. I know they work. I know they are an amazing tool. When the training is set in place correctly, there is no need to ZAP your dog to the point of pain and crying out....well, let me correct that and say there might come a day that it happens but it would have to be an extreme situation and could possible be over adjusting on the human part. You learn your dog's stimulus threshold. And in a situation when more is needed you will know that you only have to step it up a notch....not jack it up to the max. You work with your dog with the e-collar BEFORE they are placed in a high excitement situation! Then you learn how much is needed for your individual dog. Justice is your dog and more than that, I can tell he's your best friend and family....that's a plus for you (and him) bc that means you can read him. You can read his body and know when he is in a prey drive mind set and when he is getting more focused on a sent, sound, or sight. At that time you can go ahead and snap him out of it.......verbal first then leash if he's wearing one, if not, the e-collar if need be. There are many different collars for a reason....small dog, high drive, mild mannered, collars with vibrate only. I am posting a link here. It's really good. You can also find Leerburg on FB. He post short training videos of all kinds often. Just check it out before you spend what I'm sure will be a lot of money on a trainer. You seem like a very smart and driven guy to me.....I'm sure you can find the answers you need here and benefit from the products they offer.

s/n I use the Dogtra e-collars only....but that's my personal choice after using a few other makes. Also keep in mind that when the dog is introduced to the collar the right way, they don't associate the "correction" with the collar.....they think of it as an extension of you or something that occurred due to what ever action they just preformed. So knowing that....a dog might give a verbal response in the beginning phases of e-collar training....but it's not ALWAYS bc of a pain factor. Sometimes a dog gives a verbal response due to mental stimulus. If your dog in highly fixated on something and you give a "touch" (even the light snap of the leash) to bring them back to earth....that too can cause a verbal yip or squeal from the mind snapping out of the fixation. Much like when a dog is close to an object of it's fixation but can't quite get to it...the dog whines or make and high pitch cry.
Now this is not to say that this is the case if you have the remote jacked up to the highest setting (or way higher than ur dogs normal tolerance). Of course that can bring about a cry of pain.....but this is way it's important to educate yourself with the use and training of the e-collar first.
I'm not in any way judging you or anyone. We are all individuals and I for one can respect that. This was just my 2 cents worth and I hope that you find the link helpful. Also you can find me on FB (seems like I live there) and if you need more help along the way, I'm willing to help in anyway I can or even connect you with some Sport Dog trainers that I know.
~Charity Maxwell~

http://leerburg.com/318.htm


Well thank you ! Very kind of you.........
 
Oh...I forgot! If nothing else make sure to scroll all the way through that link and read what they have to say...the page isn't a long one. I've used the system. I can tell you first hand that it's all true.
 
You work with your dog with the e-collar BEFORE they are placed in a high excitement situation! Then you learn how much is needed for your individual dog. Justice is your dog and more than that, I can tell he's your best friend and family....that's a plus for you (and him) bc that means you can read him. You can read his body and know when he is in a prey drive mind set and when he is getting more focused on a sent, sound, or sight. At that time you can go ahead and snap him out of it.......verbal first then leash if he's wearing one, if not, the e-collar if need be.
​
Perfectly said! Thank you!

Also keep in mind that when the dog is introduced to the collar the right way, they don't associate the "correction" with the collar.....they think of it as an extension of you or something that occurred due to what ever action they just preformed. So knowing that....a dog might give a verbal response in the beginning phases of e-collar training....but it's not ALWAYS bc of a pain factor. Sometimes a dog gives a verbal response due to mental stimulus. If your dog in highly fixated on something and you give a "touch" (even the light snap of the leash) to bring them back to earth....that too can cause a verbal yip or squeal from the mind snapping out of the fixation.
​
Exactly! That is why you often hear the 'yip' with Cesar when he does his little 'kick' or 'bite'! They are simply surprised and their attention on him now. :D

Well said Pawpads.........and Dogtra is one that I was looking at too. It seems there are so many though!
http://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&channel=s&hl=en-US&source=hp&biw=&bih=&q=Dogtra IQ&btnG=Google Search&oq=&aq=&aqi=&aql=&gs_l=#q=Dogtra IQ&hl=en&client=firefox-a&sa=G&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:official&channel=s&prmd=imvns&source=univ&tbm=shop&tbo=u&ei=-eKfT7neOYGN6QHNiKyhAg&ved=0CHwQrQQ&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.,cf.osb&fp=9ab423965db2f3bd&biw=1920&bih=874
Surprisingly, they are just as expensive for a little dog as for a large one! :eek:
 
That's true....but here's a tip. If you find the collar you think fits your needs....google the name of the collar. You will find it cheaper than buying it directly from www.dogtrastore.com or dogtra.factoryoutletstore.com.

This is the one I use, The dogtra 200NCP Gold. It has a rechargeable battery. The cord comes with a v split so you can charge the remote and unit at the same time but they do hold a charge for a long while....days. My first set of batteries last a few years!!! And the batteries are fairly cheap on the dogtra website. Plus it you lose or damage any part of them (pretty much) you can order a replace part as well.

Falkor is a high drive dog and this collar (though not stated for high drive dogs) works fine on him! I never have to put the nick option higher than about a 30....and that's just on nick.
 
Thanks! Interestingly enough, Leerburg doesn't even have yours anymore http://leerburg.com/200ncp.htm But my neighbor bought a Dogtra at Menards! I think it was $150.00. I don't know the exact name, ie NCP Gold and what have you. I think this is whats holding me back more than anything, is choosing! Of course, I have also not been out in the stores looking too much yet either. Just reading up on here, google, and reading reviews. lol So many things to consider and sometimes I'm tempting to get one for both dogs! Then it gets into more $$. Right now, Kali is the one I trust the least and she also hard to see cause she's small. But I also wonder how heavy that thing is to be wearing around her neck?
 
Ingrid,

( in response ) Nor should I have to hit the ignore button or want too. Again, I'm not sure what it is I exactly do that is so wrong when it comes to raising Justice, but I do care more than you know. Heck that's why I'm on here a few times a day, learning, sharing, and having fun. Sometimes things on here can get heated, serious, or over indulged, but it's all part of sharing opinions and experiences that is of great value to me.

I enjoy being on here, I enjoy learning ( not as much as the fun ), sharing, contests, etc. This is not like other sites where ridicule rules, which is one of many reasons I'm here now. There are other sites, much more harsh, much more political, showy, etc........ This is a great all around place for us to be.

Butt heads we may, not saying I didn't respect your opinion. If I didn't care what you thought, I wouldn't of followed up with the breeder recommendation you were kind enough to give me. You explained how it was a good fit, since I'm a ruleless doberman owner. Wait, that's too harsh, I'm not a " Ruleless Doberman Owner " in the least. Prey Drive is a hard thing to correct, and I think everyone will agree on that.

I'm not looking for a step by step instruction to raising my boy, or the new puppy on the way. I comment a lot on here, I start a lot of posts, so I'm much more subject to correction than the other's that don't post as much. I like to get it out there, share if you will, my experiences, in an honest sometimes blunt way.

For example: There are times when I think what I'm doing is correct, 30 of you will disagree. So I heed that advice ( sometimes ) and move on with that knowledge. Contradicting I know, sorry.........

The collar is a pain for me let's just get that out of the way. Justice has had a few set backs, but I had hoped he'd learn from them on his own. I was wrong, so now the one thing that I ask isn't step by step instructions, isn't a how to guide, but a kind response into what the correct procedure is. You say the instructions suck, well that maybe so, but I was also advised to read the instructions, and proceed. I DID !!!

I've been watching this thread, and where the e-collar is concerned I'm probably in the same place that you are with Justice with my Pippi. I've tried it as she has a high prey drive in a very dangerous situation (around trains), but the results were so poor that I gave up using it very quickly. Instead of stopping her at all, it seemed to spur her on. She would yelp loudly, but keep going and going until she was out of range (and then she kept going some more). She's actually worse on the e-collar than without it, as I can sometimes get her to listen after chasing after her for awhile without it, but she ran for about two miles before I could catch up to her (in a car) when I used the e-collar on her.

It's not an easy thing to train on and it depends as much on what you're trying to train them to do with the e-collar and the experience of the owner with the e-collar. I had never used it before so that probably didn't help, but I also have a dog who is is very reactive and uncontrollable in a few situations (aronud trains, around other dogs). My approach has been to take a step back and focus on specific training with a trainer on each issue. We're working on curbing her reactivity around other dogs (only when she's with me) first, since that's her less reactive issue we're working on that first. Once we've made progress with that issue, we plan to work on her train reactivity which is a much tougher issue. The trainer I'm working with is not a fan of e-collars so we may not use it then either.

All of this to say, unless you're working with the dog directly, any suggestions that are provided by us on this forum are pure guess work and we really shouldn't throw stones at peoplpe who are looking for help and guidance in an extremely difficult situation. I'd challenge anyone to try to break my Pippi of her train chasing with an e-collar - her reaction is unique and unusual, and timing of applying the shock/buzz doesn't make one bit of difference. She has a severe reactive behavioral issue that my trainer and me need to develop a unique solution for - store-bought solutions are not a solution in this case, and it sounds like Justice may have a similar type of issue.
 
Quee I'm no expert on e-collars, as you know, I'm still learning myself. But I think Pawpads but it best when she said this:
You work with your dog with the e-collar BEFORE they are placed in a high excitement situation! Then you learn how much is needed for your individual dog. Justice is your dog and more than that, I can tell he's your best friend and family....that's a plus for you (and him) bc that means you can read him. You can read his body and know when he is in a prey drive mind set and when he is getting more focused on a sent, sound, or sight. At that time you can go ahead and snap him out of it.......verbal first then leash if he's wearing one, if not, the e-collar if need be.
I know for me, this would be a given. But like I told Stephen earlier, some things that we may think is a 'given' may get forgotten in translation to the other person. But this working with your dog in a low profile situation first, is most important and where I would start. I don't know if that is where you started with Pippi but him running so far away (egads!) seems to suggest it was not low profile. He seems to be a very sensitive dog and it will take a very long time to work that out of him. Poor guy, I feel for him!!
 

Back
Top