Schutzhund - I am getting confused...

DreamValley

Well-Known Member
Today we visited another club. They told me a working dog should not be a pet at home. Dogs should be locked in the crate for the most time to develop a good drive and focus on a handler.
So they asked me if I were ready.... I am not sure.
Jess I thought your dogs spend most time at fireplace :) and they are happy pets home.
Have I missed something?

Also they told Asha did not look confident and protection may not be for her.
She look at me before biting a tug waiting for my directions... sure she has been trained to follow my directions.

My dogs were sleeping in the car.. other dogs were barking crazy. I am not sure I want my dogs become so crazy. We travel a lot.

Now I am more confused....
 
That is a very common rule for working dogs. I don't believe in it. My dogs are first and foremost my companions, then working dogs. We train for schutzhund and all sorts of other venues. The drive depends on the dog, and I believe at least for dobermans, locking them away in severely detrimental to their mental health. And my dogs LOVE to work WITH me, whatever game I set them on. I think that if you are dealing with a dog that has a lack of drive, that may help to bring it up just due to the frustration. But I would quit schutzhund if it meant I had to kennel my dogs. I may never have world competitor dogs because I won't lock them up, but I have a part of the family and my dogs LOVE SCHUTZHUND!!!!!!! Dobes NEED to be with their owners.
Just my 2 cents!
 
I'm not an expert by any means but in my limited experience with Schutzhund in my club I see there are both types of owners, those who treat their dog as a true working dog and are ultra serious and view their dogs as 'stock' and then there are the majority such as myself who are doing this to see what their dogs are capable of and to give the dogs a sport or activity they really enjoy, owners who live with their dogs in the house, on the bed (sometimes on a Sunday morning) and who do other more social things besides Schutzhund such as walking nice scenic areas and meeting other people.

I'd of also thought that it would need more than just one session to judge a dogs working aptitude (unless of course it becomes a cowering wreck just being there). Confidence comes with time and practice especially if a dog has not done this kind of work before, perhaps it's previously been corrected for jumping up, biting or trying to bite another person playfully (or not), now I would have thought that this dog would be conflicted surely and it would take time to bring the dog around to know it's OK to get physical with a human when the situation demands it such as participating in Schutzhund.

As I said there are others more experienced than me in these matters and I've no doubt they will give you better answers than me...
 
This mentality works very well for GSD. They are wired different. The problem is not that they live with people but thet the poeple are so darn PETA driven they think the dogs must have 24 hour attention and that leads to a neruotic co-dependent dog, meaning the dog cant function because they are so worried (that is how they were taught) about what the handler is doing Every little scrap is a major thing. The dogs get no alone time to learn self confidence. The best way I know to relate it is to people who smother their children , frantic that every little fever is fatal, can't stand the thought of them being away from them in case they get hurt etc.

If you are confident and give your dogs free time to be dogs then it works. If you can't do that then it won't work. Dogs like children gain their confidence from us. We either teach them to be strong and independent or we train them that disaster is always just around the corner and we make them nervous and have separation anxiety.

I agree that crating a Doberman most of the time is not good for them but it certianly does not kill them. In fact based on the dogs I have seen raised both ways I would lean toward more time away from the owner than a co-dependent dog. They quickly adapt to the idea that work is work and play is play. As long as they get both they are going to be happy and better at work. I personally think it is the mentality tha they are human and we are there to provide their every need that is the problem. It has gone way beyond provide for, train and be responsibltiy for y9ur dogs well being Co-dependent dogs are not able to adapt to any situation.
 
I would never call Asha a co-dependent dog. Also she doesn't lack confidence. Is not it normal to look for directions from me? That's what I have been teaching her for 8 months in OB.
Why should not she look at me when a stranger waving a tug? He didn't look frightening ... she was not scared....she gave a look and then started to bite a tug.
She doesn't bark... yes... she was taught not to bark. Her frustration barrier is very high. If the sport is built on frustration she won't succeed. She is not a nervous dog either.
I saw few dogs being really nervous there. It's not a pretty picture.

They made it clear I have to crate her.

Another club did not see her as co-dependent dog. A training director told me she had good personalities and I had to free her energy up... she went through too much compulsive training.
I agree with that.

I was so happy to get invitation from the city club. It's only 20 min drive... but it seems they have requirements I can not meet.

Now I don't know if I should continue with involving Asha in Sch :(
 
I would never call Asha a co-dependent dog. Also she doesn't lack confidence. Is not it normal to look for directions from me? That's what I have been teaching her for 8 months in OB.
Why should not she look at me when a stranger waving a tug? He didn't look frightening ... she was not scared....she gave a look and then started to bite a tug.
She doesn't bark... yes... she was taught not to bark. Her frustration barrier is very high. If the sport is built on frustration she won't succeed. She is not a nervous dog either.
I saw few dogs being really nervous there. It's not a pretty picture.

They made it clear I have to crate her.

Another club did not see her as co-dependent dog. A training director told me she had good personalities and I had to free her energy up... she went through too much compulsive training.
I agree with that.

I was so happy to get invitation from the city club. It's only 20 min drive... but it seems they have requirements I can not meet.

Now I don't know if I should continue with involving Asha in Sch :(
It sound to me like the first club was better suited for you. I know it's a long drive and you have to weigh whether not not you want to go that far. I would not go to the last club. It does not sound like they would suit you and that they are looking at each individual dog and home situation. I don't know why they can't fit to suit. Why is it not OK to just want to work your dog and do something fun with them? Why does it always have to be competitive and all the way? I don't agree with that.

The breeder of my girls have all the dogs in the house. None of them are crated and they have a boy who is Schutzhund III. It can be done also when you are at the highest competitive level.
 
I've heard about this attitude and it is WRONG! Any good trainer/club will tell you that a Schutzhund dog is supposed to be the most well rounded dog on earth. The best Schutzhund dogs can tear it up on the field and come right off to love on their people. Gary Patterson, who quite literally wrote the book (well one of the major books), tells a story about traveling back from one of the DVG nationals with his SCHIII dog. They had the dog in a down in the airport lobby and he was just chilling there with all the activity going on. A Chinese family was behind them in line and had 4 kids, the parents asked if the kids could pet the dog. They spent the next several minutes loving and petting all over this dog who just hours before had been doing protection. That is the true nature of a Schutzhund dog. I have a photo of Spock, fresh off the field, giving our club's main helper kisses.
So do me a favor, RUN from this club. They obviously have a false understanding of what it takes to make a good Schutzhund dog. As for her looking to you, without being there to see in person what she did we can't evaluate if she was in fact looking for direction, showing hesitation because of fear, or something else. One session can give a very experienced person an idea of what the dog has in them but that's it. What happened to the first club? I thought they were a good fit?
As for whether or not Schutzhund is for you, you are the only one who can make that decision.
 
I've heard about this attitude and it is WRONG! Any good trainer/club will tell you that a Schutzhund dog is supposed to be the most well rounded dog on earth. The best Schutzhund dogs can tear it up on the field and come right off to love on their people. Gary Patterson, who quite literally wrote the book (well one of the major books), tells a story about traveling back from one of the DVG nationals with his SCHIII dog. They had the dog in a down in the airport lobby and he was just chilling there with all the activity going on. A Chinese family was behind them in line and had 4 kids, the parents asked if the kids could pet the dog. They spent the next several minutes loving and petting all over this dog who just hours before had been doing protection. That is the true nature of a Schutzhund dog. I have a photo of Spock, fresh off the field, giving our club's main helper kisses.
So do me a favor, RUN from this club. They obviously have a false understanding of what it takes to make a good Schutzhund dog. As for her looking to you, without being there to see in person what she did we can't evaluate if she was in fact looking for direction, showing hesitation because of fear, or something else. One session can give a very experienced person an idea of what the dog has in them but that's it. What happened to the first club? I thought they were a good fit?
As for whether or not Schutzhund is for you, you are the only one who can make that decision.
GREAT reply Jess. :)
 
The training director in the first club told me he could not estimate at this point if my dog will be good for protection. He also advised me to lock her in the crate and don't let her play with Gino and don't take her hiking and work hard towards her success in the field. They all do it. Geezzzz.... I did not realize the sport was so demanding!

I know my dog she didn't have any hesitation or fears. She was biting a tug hard after all.

It seems more reasonable for us at this point to continue with CKC OB or train her for BH or tracking only. I can not pay so high price for the sleeve work.
 
It isn't that uncommon of a viewpoint, especially with those who are focused only on gaining titles, usually for breeding purposes, rather than the benefits that can come with the training. He probably wanted you to separate them so she could work on bonding more with you than with Gino. You have admitted that Gino is your "favorite" and that you are bonded more to him. In order to really succeed in the training you need to get that same level of bond with Asha. Did you explain to the club what your goals are from the training? Schutzhund is demanding, it is serious, and it does require sacrifices. You have to find a club that matches your goals and will help you achieve what you want rather than just shove you into what they want. If you cannot commit don't. There is nothing wrong with doing something else with your dogs. The sport is not for everyone and that is fine. But if you want to do it and you choose to you need to jump in with both feet and quit looking back. Did you ask the club if you can train in tracking and OB only if the sleeve work seems like too much? Some are okay with that.
 
I'm new to Dobermans, and only know what I've read about Schutzhund, I've never done it myself.

It seems to me, though, that you want a dog who will take direction. Looking to you instead of willy-nilly biting something should not, I don't think, necessarily put her nerve or drive in question. If you have dog that you are teaching to bite, you want a dog who will take direction. You want a happy, well socialized, well balanced dog that you can trust to be in control and sociable in your home, and on guard if necessary as well.

In my complete amateur opinion.
 
Today we visited another club. They told me a working dog should not be a pet at home. Dogs should be locked in the crate for the most time to develop a good drive and focus on a handler.
So they asked me if I were ready.... I am not sure.
Jess I thought your dogs spend most time at fireplace :) and they are happy pets home.
Have I missed something?

Also they told Asha did not look confident and protection may not be for her.
She look at me before biting a tug waiting for my directions... sure she has been trained to follow my directions.

My dogs were sleeping in the car.. other dogs were barking crazy. I am not sure I want my dogs become so crazy. We travel a lot.

Now I am more confused....[/quote
I wish to be very direct here! WHAT A LOAD OF CRAP!! If that's what it takes to make a working dog then forget it but I don't believe a word of it!:confused:
 
Does it make sense to work towards BH and tracking if I can not follow requirements for protection?

Jess I watched your videos. Asha's biting looks very similar to River's. She did not bark though.
I think our club's requirements are a bit different. Your dogs look more relaxed and happy.
Dogs I watched were very high drive.... some of them looked nervous and even aggressive.

Maybe Asha is too soft for the sport. I raised her in that way socializing and training in CKC OB classes.
 
The point of doing the OB and tracking was just if you wanted a way to continue in the sport. If you don't, don't worry. I don't know about CKC but AKC has their own tracking and OB events but they aren't to the same standard that Schutzhund is, sorry but that's just the facts of it.
As I told you in the other post, her barking is likely something that can be developed and even if it can't it isn't that big of a deal. Our club dogs are relaxed and happy because that is just how we do things. We aren't in it for the titles alone so if the dogs don't enjoy it there is no point in doing the sport. Those that don't know can often misunderstand high drive for nervy or aggressive (and there are many forms of aggression, not all "bad"). But no, not every dog has what it takes for the sport. The sport is meant to break dogs and handlers. That is just the facts of it, that is why it is so respected as a judgement for breeding. That is also why if you are going to do the sport you have to do certain things with the dogs as puppies. We were very lucky with Spock in that we did a lot of those things naturally without even knowing we were going to do the sport.
 
Lisa this is obviously just not your cup of tea, you are not enjoying doing this with Asha and if you don't enjoy it she won't either, the people you are going to seem very negative about Asha and it is getting to you as it would me , I have my two as my walking companions they are quite happy with this role as I am sure Gino and Asha are when they are out hiking with you, I could not have them crated all the time either , just pack it in and enjoy your two beautiful dogs you have given it a go but it seems you are not a happy bunny:2cents
 
Let me stop you right there. This is a common misconception, and probably not what you meant. All dogs know how to bite from the tiniest Chihuahua to the biggest Mastiff. We are teaching dogs to have judgement and control. If anything we are teaching them NOT to bite.

Allow me to rephrase: "If you are teaching your bite to open his or her mouth and get a deep grip on a human subject when deemed appropriate by the handler in a specific fixed situation."

I am fully aware that dogs know how to bite. Bitework is a term used, as pertaining to part of the protection portion of Schutzhund, yes? Forgive me for not spelling out what I meant explicitly.
 
Allow me to rephrase: "If you are teaching your bite to open his or her mouth and get a deep grip on a human subject when deemed appropriate by the handler in a specific fixed situation."

I am fully aware that dogs know how to bite. Bitework is a term used, as pertaining to part of the protection portion of Schutzhund, yes? Forgive me for not spelling out what I meant explicitly.
I didn't mean to upset you but that is a common misconception and one that can cause trouble for those in the sport so it is one that I cannot let go without a correction. I acknowledged it was probably not what you meant to say but as this is a public forum I don't want that misconception being spread further.
 
The sport is meant to break dogs and handlers.

Jess - I hope this is a typo and you meant MAKE a dog and handler. It is all about building the confidence of the dog and creating a positive bond with the handler. In the old old day Yes there were those who worked to either make or break a dog and they ruined many good dogs. We have come a long long way from that sad philosophy.

Today it is all about the postive relationship between dog and handler. Working with the dog over time through positive methods and training.

We are teaching dogs to have judgement and control. If anything we are teaching them NOT to bite.
We are teaching them judgment and WHEN to bite and HOW to bite.. Not to NOT bitye that would defeat the purpose of bitework.
 

Back
Top